Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 20:56

@mishmased

I’m sorry that sounds very stressful and in your case it does sound like a sort of intervention.

But surely using this phrase on a blanket basis to cover any scenario in which a woman feeds formula is pretty inflammatory.

We are talking about a safe, legal, approved product which has been used safely by probably hundreds of millions of women.

Yes there are clearly advantages to breastfeeding but positing formula as a kind or last resort for when all else has failed makes it sound like napalm.

Language is important. Yes people should be able to state facts that demonstrate why breast is optimal - as it undoubtedly is. But people coming on here, wide-eyed, and insisting they only want to help, just stating facts and then referring to formula as an “intervention”… can you seriously not understand how this will land for a woman struggling with guilt for basically feeding her own child?

JadeTrinket · 19/11/2021 20:48

I agree with @AliasGrape that I don’t recognise the worldview where you in which you’re ‘not allowed’ to discuss the benefits of breastfeeding. As I said up the thread, I was upset for a long time that my supply never came in at all despite advice, tests etc, and it often felt as though literally everyone was either telling me about how I should be bfing, or criticising my ffing, often complete strangers, who clearly felt confident enough in the tightness of their views to express them to a total stranger. I literally had a man sit down on a park bench and ask me why I wasn’t ‘feeding my baby properly’.

mishmased · 19/11/2021 20:48

@thepeopleversuswork for me it was an intervention. My baby had lost 11% of birthweight and he wasn't even 7 pounds at birth. They intervened, sat me down in hospital told me it wasn't working to feed formula. I cried but knew that was best. What we didn't know until age 1 was he had a posterior tongue tie. He was fed until 2.5 because they refused to snip after 1 year and at that stage all the associated challenges had been encountered. For us an intervention was needed.

thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 20:47

@AliasGrape

I also loathe all that “breastfeeding mamas you are amazing” stuff. Cringeworthy and insufferably smug.

Sometimeswinning · 19/11/2021 20:41

Breastfed one. Ff the other 2 because it suited me. Sorry it made zero difference. All fine. Ff is petty much on a par with ff. Breastfeeding is convenient and cheap. Ff is convenient for dad helping.

mishmased · 19/11/2021 20:39

@Kendodd post emcs my first child lost 11% of his body weight on day 3 and he was fed 10ml formula while I expressed and a midwife showed me how to bf lying down. There is no way on earth I would doggedly refuse to supplement and risk my baby going hungry. As it turned out the small amount of formula triggered a dairy allergy and eczema.Said baby bf until 2.5 years with undiagnosed tt, reflux and eczema. I had people saying why not give formula ehh he will literally die. Age 8 and he still cannot drink cow's milk.

I have said it before I don't get why people take facts as criticism.

AliasGrape · 19/11/2021 20:30

The problem is that the kind of person you're replying to won't often acknowledge that FF babies sleep better or that FF makes life easier for some (most) mums

I do remember getting confused because I was trying so hard to be a gentle, attachment type parent but it was made very clear I didn’t fit that mould (I’m thinking particularly of the gentle sleep book Sarah ockwell smith which was just one long exercise in feeling even more terrible about myself than I already did) because I couldn’t breastfeed.

But anyway, lots and lots of talk about how of course FF don’t sleep better that’s nonsense and you shouldn’t listen to it. But also you can’t cosleep if you’re formula feeding because formula fed babies sleep so deeply and can’t be woken. I do remember thinking you can’t have it both ways.

I genuinely don’t recognise this worldview where you’re not allowed to talk about the benefits of breastfeeding and particularly not on social media. EVERY parenting/ motherhood type account I followed in the early days was all ‘breastfeeding mamas you are amazing, you are doing the absolute best thing for your child who will probably live forever on account of your magical unicorn tears boobie milk’ then somewhere further down the comments ‘yeah formula is fine too if you have to’. I don’t even criticise them for that (I just unfollow because it still hugely upsets me) but in my corner of the world/ internet it’s just not true that you can’t discuss the benefits.

Kendodd · 19/11/2021 19:55

Should I have just let my son die

Are we really getting that ridiculous? FFS the only people giving you a hard time for not breastfeeding is yourself.

SmellyOldOwls · 19/11/2021 19:39

'But this spectacularly misses the point that by far the largest group of people who don't breastfeed are not feckless types who can't be arsed or desperately ignorant people who don't know. They are people who have tried and failed.

It's not a simple binary thing of people either being uninformed (and needing more information) or being too selfish.

Telling someone who has struggled for weeks and months with pain, discomfort, sleeplessness, massive challenges in adapting to any semblance of normal life that they are doing the "bare minimum" for their baby is just really really shitty.

This is what "fed is best" is about. It doesn't literally mean that any kind of food is preferable to breastfeeding. Any fool knows formula isn't better than breast. It's a way to get people to get things into perspective and support those of us who struggled with massively and allow ourselves not to have to beat ourselves up over it for the rest of our lives.'

This all makes so much sense. The problem is that the kind of person you're replying to won't often acknowledge that FF babies sleep better or that FF makes life easier for some (most) mums. 'Breastfeeding is so easy, just whip out your boob! Formula fed babies don't sleep for longer!' That'll be why 81% of mums start off breastfeeding and only 17% are EBF at 3 months Hmm

Onairjunkie · 19/11/2021 19:38

@IWouldntHavetoWorkatAll

Should I have just let my son die of malnutrition then? As I just didn't produce milk properly and he was losing more and more weight.

Absolutely no one is saying anything like that. What some of us are saying is that formula is something to be used under advice of a healthcare professional in exactly the situation you describe. Not as a “lifestyle choice”. It’s an intervention. That said of course hcps will support women whatever their feeding choices.

I’m really sad that you seem to liken formula to something like methadone or anotejr controlled substance.

You viewpoint seems to imply that women should be forced to attempt breastfeeding, regardless of their own mental and physical health and wishes, and that only once a health professional deems it absolutely necessary, could they be prescribed formula.

You’re more batshit that I thought if you think that’s the way to increase the prevalence of breastfeeding. Confused

NerrSnerr · 19/11/2021 19:34

What some of us are saying is that formula is something to be used under advice of a healthcare professional in exactly the situation you describe. Not as a “lifestyle choice”. It’s an intervention.

@IWouldntHavetoWorkatAll do you think the above paragraph would make people who formula fed realise they made the wrong decision and declare how they got it wrong or encourage people to breastfeed? Do you feel spouting stuff like that is going to help at all.

Who else is included in the 'some of us'?

heliosunburg · 19/11/2021 19:34

*Applaud complete strangers for how they're choosing to feed their babies?

Too weird to even contemplate.
*
...

@WorraLiberty

No, but thanks for showing us you lack comprehension. Pp said breastfeeding is harder. I said, often it isn't or at least not in my experience. My point was even if it was harder, that's more reason to support and big up breastfeeding.

I'm sorry nobody supported your feeding choices. Encouraging breastfeeding mothers isn't weird at all.

AveryGoodlay · 19/11/2021 19:30

JunoMcDuff Thank you for reminding me of the word cockamamie! Let's bring it back!

thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 19:28

@IWouldntHavetoWorkatAll

Should I have just let my son die of malnutrition then? As I just didn't produce milk properly and he was losing more and more weight.

Absolutely no one is saying anything like that. What some of us are saying is that formula is something to be used under advice of a healthcare professional in exactly the situation you describe. Not as a “lifestyle choice”. It’s an intervention. That said of course hcps will support women whatever their feeding choices.

No one is saying formula is a "lifestyle choice". And saying it needs to be used under advice of a healthcare professional and calling it, God forbid, an "intervention" implies that its some sort of controlled substance or something dangerous.

The language around FF is so sanctimonious and loaded. The clear implication is that its something to be used as an absolute last resort.

When in fact millions of women and their babies use it perfectly healthily. And at a population level in developed countries there is very little evidence that FF disadvantages children over the long term.

Can you not see how it makes women who have struggled massively with their mental health and watched their babies fail to thrive because they can't breastfeed if you describe something totally normal as an "intervention"?

IWouldntHavetoWorkatAll · 19/11/2021 19:16

Should I have just let my son die of malnutrition then? As I just didn't produce milk properly and he was losing more and more weight.

Absolutely no one is saying anything like that. What some of us are saying is that formula is something to be used under advice of a healthcare professional in exactly the situation you describe. Not as a “lifestyle choice”. It’s an intervention. That said of course hcps will support women whatever their feeding choices.

candlelightsatdawn · 19/11/2021 19:08

This thread is depressing.

The breastfeeding folk seem to be arguing with the formula feeding folk trying to educate them on where they went wrong and getting pretty nasty and it's leaving the formula feeding mums feeding a extra added lump of guilt on what many have described a traumatic time.

Problem is that a lot of advice isn't actually asked for. If my pal posts on social media "if you ever need help with breast feeding give me a shout " absolutely spot on no problem.

If that same pal posted the benefits of breast feeding on IQ of children vs formula , your posting it to educate people bit ICK but ok it's facts aren't attacks but I have to ask has it ever crossed peoples mind to think "if they wanted to know that I assume they would ask ? Or done their own research"

I say this as a breastfeeding mum. Celebrate your journey, absolutely fine but don't come along and offer unsolicited advice to women who clearly have been failed by the system, not because they didn't want to.

thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 19:08

@Tonyschoco

This thread has become a sad divide between the band of ‘telling it like it is, ball-breaker breastfeeders’ for whom breast is vehemently best, and those women desperately trying to ‘defend’ themselves for using formula (or the ‘bare minimum’ as one absolute peach twat described it) for whom BF didn’t come easy, at all, or at a huge personal cost.

And that, right there, is the saddest thing.

Yep.

which is why I struggle to believe anyone posting something "highlighting the positives of breastfeeding" genuinely did so as an act of disinterested public spiritness.

I've said it a million times and I'll say it again. If we really want to increase breastfeeding rates we need to provide proper support for women who find it hard rather than telling them for the millionth time something they already know full well and already feel shit about.

AliasGrape · 19/11/2021 19:01

@Tonyschoco

This thread has become a sad divide between the band of ‘telling it like it is, ball-breaker breastfeeders’ for whom breast is vehemently best, and those women desperately trying to ‘defend’ themselves for using formula (or the ‘bare minimum’ as one absolute peach twat described it) for whom BF didn’t come easy, at all, or at a huge personal cost.

And that, right there, is the saddest thing.

Absolutely this.
user14943608381 · 19/11/2021 18:59

@Ozanj

* Should I have just let my son die of malnutrition then? As I just didn't produce milk properly and he was losing more and more weight.*

I was told this too. That I was killing baby as he was losing weight and I should pay for formula; so after paying £150 for a lactation consultant in a last ditch attempt, who happened to be a big name midwife, I found out he had a tongue tie. The NHS clearly didn’t give a shit about my DS as the policy isn’t even to check for it but because a private mw spotted it, it was fixed. He began gaining substantial weight exactly 4 weeks after it was fixed. I do think one of the reasons why there is a wealth gap for breast feeders vs formula feeders is exactly this reason; you have to pay and be really dogged about anything related to bf.

^ this right here!
Tonyschoco · 19/11/2021 18:56

This thread has become a sad divide between the band of ‘telling it like it is, ball-breaker breastfeeders’ for whom breast is vehemently best, and those women desperately trying to ‘defend’ themselves for using formula (or the ‘bare minimum’ as one absolute peach twat described it) for whom BF didn’t come easy, at all, or at a huge personal cost.

And that, right there, is the saddest thing.

Tabbacus · 19/11/2021 18:40

@Ozanj

* Should I have just let my son die of malnutrition then? As I just didn't produce milk properly and he was losing more and more weight.*

I was told this too. That I was killing baby as he was losing weight and I should pay for formula; so after paying £150 for a lactation consultant in a last ditch attempt, who happened to be a big name midwife, I found out he had a tongue tie. The NHS clearly didn’t give a shit about my DS as the policy isn’t even to check for it but because a private mw spotted it, it was fixed. He began gaining substantial weight exactly 4 weeks after it was fixed. I do think one of the reasons why there is a wealth gap for breast feeders vs formula feeders is exactly this reason; you have to pay and be really dogged about anything related to bf.

It is baffling that they don't check for tongue tie as part of the newborn checks, obviously would be up to parents to make an informed choice about how to proceed if they did have tongue tie. I know why it's because they don't have enough resources, but so many people have to fight to get anywhere with having it checked and sorted out its shocking.
Ozanj · 19/11/2021 18:35

* Should I have just let my son die of malnutrition then? As I just didn't produce milk properly and he was losing more and more weight.*

I was told this too. That I was killing baby as he was losing weight and I should pay for formula; so after paying £150 for a lactation consultant in a last ditch attempt, who happened to be a big name midwife, I found out he had a tongue tie. The NHS clearly didn’t give a shit about my DS as the policy isn’t even to check for it but because a private mw spotted it, it was fixed. He began gaining substantial weight exactly 4 weeks after it was fixed. I do think one of the reasons why there is a wealth gap for breast feeders vs formula feeders is exactly this reason; you have to pay and be really dogged about anything related to bf.

Bumblenums1234 · 19/11/2021 18:10

@Willyoujustbequiet

I do think the pendulum has swung a bit too far the other way. In attempt to ensure formula isn't shamed, I see a lot of people downplaying the benefits of breastfeeding on social media. The only militant perspective I've seen is from people who've chosen to formula feed without even trying breastfeeding.

I hate the whole 'fed is best' mantra. No it's not, it's the bare minimum.

Should I have just let my son die of malnutrition then? As I just didn't produce milk properly and he was losing more and more weight.
mishmased · 19/11/2021 18:10

But no one is berating anyone that uses formula. They are merely stating the facts. There is no need to take other people's comments to heart. Breastfed babies get coughs and cold fact, breast milk is the biological food for human baby's fact, formula is also suitable for babies fact.

@Babdoc with all due respect I have found med personnel to not be very clued on breastfeeding. Have had instances of doctors saying there's no benefit to breastfeeding after 6 months which isn't true. I don't listen to doctors when it comes to breastfeeding unless said doctor is a lactation consultant. And I don't expect doctors to be experts in breastfeeding especially when they have never breastfed.

AngelDelight28 · 19/11/2021 17:59

@Willyoujustbequiet Very apt username. You should follow that advice yourself.

Starvation is what would have happened to my baby if I didn't use formula. She had to be admitted to hospital with severe weight loss and jaundice, all because I was so determined she wouldn't have formula, which was all down to the "breast is best" brainwashing. At one point I was on the edge of breakdown with triple feeding and being practically a prisoner in my own home. The moment we switched to formula, the whole family started thriving. Formula absolutely was best for us.
Fed is best is a saying that hits back at the "breast is best" mantra, which has been hugely damaging to many new mothers' mental health and piles on the guilt by implying they don't want the best for their baby if they use formula. Why do people not grasp this and insist on being snide with the whole "fed is the bare minimum". It's like the people who say "all lives matter", thinking they're being really clever.