Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RidingMyBike · 01/12/2021 09:40

We've lost awareness of the realities of BFing in the rush to promote the 'positives' - that a certain number of babies will need to be supplemented, that milk gets delayed, that not everyone can produce enough milk, that not all babies can latch and suck effectively.

Instead of talking openly about this and how to supplement safely, how to combi feed etc, we just get endless stuff about the benefits of BFing.

Don't forget, in the past, even if a baby survived they may not have got enough milk to reach their potential - stunted growth (common in developing countries now with high EBFing rates), lack of brain development from not enough calories.

RidingMyBike · 01/12/2021 09:34

It's quite possibly true that a lot of women who've said they didn't produce milk, didn't have any milk [initially]. I wonder if those women had severe milk delay - mine didn't come in until 8 weeks, I have one friend whose milk didn't come in until 6 weeks after a planned, straightforward CS. I've seen women in combi feeding groups whose milk comes in around the 4-6 week mark after a difficult birth.

I only knew to keep going with BFing because of my friend's experience of severe delay. Otherwise, why would you keep doing something that apparently produces no milk? The BFing promotion makes no mention of milk being delayed, even though it's incredibly common (anything over 72 hours is termed late onset).

Glassofshloer · 30/11/2021 07:19

Also the fact premature/earlier babies, who find it harder to bf, are now much more likely to survive. There are a lot of slightly wary inductions as well (37-38 weeks), which although only a few weeks early, makes a big difference to the baby’s sucking reflex.

Cameleongirl · 30/11/2021 03:47

@Radziwill

What the fuck is happening to our species? Why are women losing the ability to produce breastmilk? And why aren't scientists doing more to find out why this is happening? It's extremely concerning.
I think low milk supply is an oversimplification of breastfeeding problems, though. I had plenty of milk and could pump bottles of it with an electric pump. Grin It was my DD who couldn't suck properly and had to have a special feeding bottle to drink my expressed milk. She did eventually improve.

Still have no idea what caused a 9 1/2 lbs full-term baby to have this problem, despite having a lactation consultant

Sleeplessem · 29/11/2021 20:35

@Radziwill

Not all mothers could breastfeed, but historically most of them must have been able to. Otherwise the infant mortality rate would have been much higher than 15%. Think about all the advances in medicine, hygiene, and general standards of living in the last 100 hundred years. If a significant percentage of babies couldn't even be fed, once you add in all the ones who would have died of now-treatable conditions, there wouldn't be many left.

Look how many women on this thread say their milk never even came in. Clearly, something very serious is happening, and the scientific community is doing fuck all about it. If a male body part mysteriously stopped working across the population, we'd never hear the end of it! Researching it would absolutely be a priority for scientists.

Wet nurses and milk sharing in general? Far more common and socially acceptable historically speaking.

I recall reading an article on a breastfeeding page about the first bottle and what mums used to feed babies back in the day that couldn’t breastfeed, i feel like they used to latch them to goats?

Either way, it’s not a direct comparison historically speaking. Babies wouldn’t have been weighed at birth, at day 5, day 10 and 14 to check that they are thriving. A baby can be feeding enough to live but not enough to thrive by todays standards but historically speaking surviving would have been enough. A lot of women give up breastfeeding due to their baby not thriving early doors, whereas ‘back then’ they just wouldn’t have known.
Additionally, medications that impinge on breast milk production weren’t around. Neither were breast implants (that can sometimes interfere with milk production) or surgeries like mastectomy.

Glassofshloer · 29/11/2021 20:22

@Radziwill

Please forgive me if this is offensive, but my grandmother’s personal theory is that it is down to obesity & chemicals disrupting our finely balanced hormones. She said she thinks fat tissue in the breast stops the milk production Confused not sure if it’s true, just throwing it out there.

Radziwill · 29/11/2021 20:17

Not all mothers could breastfeed, but historically most of them must have been able to. Otherwise the infant mortality rate would have been much higher than 15%. Think about all the advances in medicine, hygiene, and general standards of living in the last 100 hundred years. If a significant percentage of babies couldn't even be fed, once you add in all the ones who would have died of now-treatable conditions, there wouldn't be many left.

Look how many women on this thread say their milk never even came in. Clearly, something very serious is happening, and the scientific community is doing fuck all about it. If a male body part mysteriously stopped working across the population, we'd never hear the end of it! Researching it would absolutely be a priority for scientists.

RidingMyBike · 28/11/2021 18:05

It's never been the case all women can produce enough milk to fully feed a baby. There's evidence for it going back centuries. Enough babies survived for humans to continue but many more didn't survive. Even 100 years ago the infant mortality rate was 15%.

Plus now there are a lot of women having babies and trying to BF who once wouldn't have done - whether thru infertility, having medical conditions that would once have killed them before they could even have got pregnant, or who would have died or been seriously injured by the birth, or whose baby didn't survive the birth. Having a CS or a haemorrhage was once a death sentence, now they're risk factors for milk delay and low supply.

Radziwill · 28/11/2021 16:07

What the fuck is happening to our species? Why are women losing the ability to produce breastmilk? And why aren't scientists doing more to find out why this is happening? It's extremely concerning.

RidingMyBike · 27/11/2021 19:45

Exactly. I was told antenatally it was vital to follow the golden rules for BFing - BF on demand, BF as soon after birth as possible, baby would want to BF frequently, do lots of skin to skin. I did all that and the result was no milk.

Admitted to SCBU with baby severely dehydrated we were put on a schedule (having been told antenatally this was the worst thing you could do!) involving BF, top up and express for 30 mins every 3 hours to try and force my milk to come in. That also didn't work, although the top ups meant my baby was no longer in danger.

Then the stuff about it being vital to feed at night for supply. Nope, my milk didn't even come in until I was getting 8 hour blocks of sleep.

Too much of the BFing promotion treats us like we're factory products all set to work the same rather than individual women with different bodies, health needs etc.

Italiandreams · 27/11/2021 17:53

Advice is so confusing which doesn’t help! I remember hearing about not introducing a bottle too early, but my milk didn’t come in straight away and I wasn’t allowed home due to being losing weight until she was taking a substantial amount of milk which obviously had to be through a bottle. I don’t understand what else I could do in the situation. When you are sleep deprived, hormonal and desperate to do the right thing for your baby but being given completely conflicting advice it’s really hard to know what to do.
In the past I guess many people had family around to support while establishing breast feeding but it’s much harder when you are on your own with a baby and older toddlers etc

RidingMyBike · 27/11/2021 09:06

Eg what I mean by balanced info which allows families to make choices:
At the moment the msg is a blanket 'do not introduce a bottle before at least 6-8 weeks because nipple confusion'.

This leads to fear from those who have had to introduce a bottle early because of delay/low supply because they think they've ruined BFing, people struggling with their MH carrying on when they could get a break, people who will need their baby to take a bottle because of their personal circs end up with a bottle refuser.

It would be far better to say:
There is no evidence for nipple confusion. Some babies will need to have a bottle from early on in cases where milk is delayed or low supply (these are the risk factors to look out for and what you can do about it...).
If you choose to introduce a bottle early you may run more risk of bottle preference. If you delay introducing a bottle you may run more risk of having a bottle refusing baby. Would you like to talk about your priorities as a family (eg around returning to work, sharing feeds) so you can make an informed choice?

RidingMyBike · 27/11/2021 08:53

And I'm amused that people think Fed is Best is a terrible source (it's actually thoroughly evidence-based and balanced but seems to be loathed in EBFing circles - it's the only place I found support for combi-feeding after various MWs, HVs etc couldn't offer me any) but will happily recommend the likes of Kellymom (which is funded by BFing advertising, run by someone who makes a living from BFing and is heavily biased) and La Leche League which is also very unbalanced and cherry picks evidence without critiquing it.

RidingMyBike · 27/11/2021 08:48

If someone wants to support BFing, they'd do more good finding out what practical support they can offer a new family than posting stuff on SM about the positives of BFing. In our case I was getting it rammed down my throat by the NHS, all HCPs I cam across and social media, was given a copy of the Womanly art of BFing for my birthday whilst pregnant and a sub to a 'natural parenting' magazine for Christmas when I had a tiny newborn. All of those just made me feel terrible and heightened the pressure, whilst being no actual help with BFing (milk failed to come in leading to seriously ill baby readmitted with dehydration).

What no one did was offer us meals, offer to take the baby so we could sleep, offer us lifts, do the shopping. There was precisely zero practical support.

LJAKS · 26/11/2021 20:20

Any time I speak to the midwife she mentions the benefits of BF so there's no way expectant mothers are oblivious to this. But equally I had a complete nightmare with my first for a plethora of reasons. As much as yes I intend to BF this one, if it doesn't work out I'm not going to beat myself up about it. It just doesn't work for everyone and knowing all the benefits you are "depriving" your child of isn't helpful for anyone.

Radziwill · 26/11/2021 20:00

If formula is almost as good as breast milk, why does the NHS recommend that even smokers breastfeed? Surely if the two substances are just about equal, it's better to give babies the one that isn't laced with nicotine? The NHS isn't exactly pro-smoking, so why would they lie?

Sam020 · 25/11/2021 04:40

[quote Silverclasp]@MollieMaeve maybe if ppl knew the benefits it could help them with their decision?[/quote]
As far as I know the majority of mums start breastfeeding but then breastfeeding rates gradually reduce with the age of babies. This seems to indicate that most mums do know the benefits And want to breastfeed but stop because there are issues with breastfeeding. Breastfeeding is bloody hard and in some cases just doesn't work. What we need is more support to help mums to breastfeed. Having said that with all the support I got my milk supply was just too low and I had to give my dc formula. Initially I cried every time I read another article about how great breastfeeding is but now I know I made the right decision. Sometimes it just doesn't work.

So to answer your question yes of course you can post anything you find interesting but my hunch is it will not actually help many mums.

3cats4poniesandababy · 24/11/2021 20:55

@ChocolateQuiltedShitpig I and other posters aren't offended by breastfeeding. I am offended by the 'if I was told the benefits I would have breastfed' message/attitude somepeople have. I bloody well know the benefits and desperately wanted to breastfeed.

Why couldn't I? Because 6 doctors failed to diagnosis my son with CMPA and finally masked the symptoms using medicine rather than actually diagnosing him. By the to they had done that my milk supply was fucked and I was stressed mother with a baby who had only gained 1lb from his birth weight at 3 months old. Knowing the benefits wasn't going to change the absolutely substandard medical care my son received.

There are pages and pages of posts here telling you why women didn't breastfeed and none of them are saying it was because they didn't know the benefits.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 24/11/2021 20:30

I just don't get why this is the topic that is so contentious. Whether one uses one type of milk... or another.

Because women are judged. Simple as that.

When you try and educate women who are already committed but struggling to do it, you're showing that you CBA to understand the actual problem. That sets the scene for the judgement.

Silverclasp · 24/11/2021 13:04

@ChocolateQuiltedShitpig there are literally 28 pages of comments on this thread most of which are ppl saying that they are offended and telling me not to post the article Hmm

OP posts:
ChocolateQuiltedShitpig · 24/11/2021 13:00

I only ever see posts like this, never actually see evidence of what you've said.

If anything, formula feeders get a very rough ride. Breastfeed your baby, no one is offended

Silverclasp · 24/11/2021 12:23

@LemonDrizzles I appreciate your points and do agree to most and this is a little off topic but isn't propping a bottle up for a baby to self feed not incredibly dangerous?

www.healthline.com/health/baby/bottle-propping

OP posts:
LemonDrizzles · 24/11/2021 07:28

@Silverclasp I agree with you that you would get flamed if you post anything that is pro-bf. Maybe pre-requisite with "you do what is right for you (including bottle feeding!) but here is an interesting article about a recent study re bf'ing. "
The challenge with posting anything at any time is it could represent our biases. There are benefits to bottle feeding. Formula is a bit more filling and so formula fed may likely sleep through the night earlier. Anyone can make formula at any time so if your child wants an extra feed and there isn't breastmilk pumped, you can just mix up a bottle. You can just mix up a bottle, prop up in a car seat, at leave the child to self feed. It's a question if the undertone is that there are only benefits to BF and none for bottle feeding

I have two DC. First DC I b/f until 18 months. I did a mix in the beginning because I wasn't producing enough milk and had to top up. Then we went away for a week and the bottles were becoming too much for me so from about 2 or 3 months, I was EBF'ing. I really didn't like pumping as a result. Epidural birth as well even though I was like 9 cm !

DC2 - I'm still BF'ing - she is almost 2! I keep being told "she's too old for BF'ing." I think we will keep going until she has a few more teeth (she is 3 shy from a full set - but starting getting teeth 6 months later than DC1.) She was a QUICK birth, under 3 hours. I think all that adrenaline may have helped with the BF oversupply. I had every intention of donating Bmilk to the local Bmilk bank but lockdown :(

I think both conversations need to happen. My best friend and her sister are different. My best friend has deduced most of her health problems stem from not being b/f as her sister was b/f and has none. Bmilk is specific to your child so whatever your child needs would be in it. DC2 is in nursery with many bugs and I love being able to give her Bmilk. however, what I think would be great is during national BF week is that we remind any BF mummies that they can donate Bmilk to local banks.

To the best of my knowledge, the Bmilk banks are mostly used for NICU and early-pre-term babies. I could be wrong.

It would be great if we could offer more Bmilk to bottle fed babies in early months.

I am imagining it is hard for any mother to imagine their child drinking someone else's milk though. We are quite connected, as a collective, to specific ideas and ideals on our children. I'm sure there is a protective element but perhaps we have to let go a little bit at this.

I went to a wedding when DC1 was about 3 or 4 months. The bride (who was really just renewing her vows, was in her 40s and had more than 4 children with her husband) grabbed by DC1 and I did not see him for a while. I explained to my DH that this is normal - people like showing off babies. I sat back (back to baby!) and enjoyed my meal and had to make a strong effort to not be worried - but that is normal to feel worried!

As a collective we just need to be more supportive to whatever it is we end up doing. There are likely more long-term healthy benefits to the baby who is BF (even short term - such as passing on immunity). But there are also benefits to bottle feeding.

Wishing everyone the best on their life journeys.

Teacupsandtrainers · 22/11/2021 20:39

But in the grand scheme of things, I just can't believe this is where we draw the line on sensitive topics. Sometimes as adults we do have to be resilient: by all means debate if one wants, but it's like some people just don't want to hear it whatsoever

Yeah I completely get where you’re coming from. I honestly wouldn’t want debate shut down because it ‘hurt my feelings’ but I definitely understand why it’s such a highly emotive subject for many women.

emmylou24 · 22/11/2021 19:36

I had strangers demanding to know if I was breastfeeding my new baby. No idea why they felt the need to but as she was 9 months old when she arrived and I had no biological link my body hadn't produced milk. I went with the medicated formula the Foster carer gave me. If I was ever able to gave baby's myself I would have loved to do it for bonding and to give the child some benefits but wasn't possible