Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect SIL spends a similar amount of our kids as we do on hers, even though we have 3?!

86 replies

Schooldilemma2345 · 18/11/2021 16:59

I probably could have worded that a bit better! Essentially I’m asking whether it’s acceptable for my sister in law to expect us to spend £40 on her only child and then only spend £15 on each of our children? I’m wondering if it’s because we have 3!
For context: we asked SIL what her child would like for Xmas and the suggested Amazon link costs £40. She rarely asks what our children would like and the presents they receive are always pretty inexpensive or something she’s picked up at the school fair. On one occasion is was a knitted teddy type thing each which couldn’t have cost more then a fiver. Recently she sent us a message asking us to buy a particular item of clothing for her child that cost around £25 as a birthday present. She didn’t mention my son’s birthday which is a few days before her child’s. We obliged and then as an after thought she transferred £15 into our account as a birthday present for my son. She didn’t send a card or wish him happy birthday or anything. Last year for Xmas she said she would like to buy the present from us to her child. We had a family gathering at our house just before xmas and she dumped a bag of stuff on me to urgently wrap while I was hosting. She then told me what I owed her which was £30. The presents she gave my children would not have cost anything like that amount.
For the record I don’t begrudge spending £40 on her child but I do feel it’s somewhat more than the average amount that side of the family spend on each other and it feels a little greedy given what her budget is!
She is very focused on her child but she will almost always forget my children’s and my husbands birthdays. She never asks what they want.
For the record she is very well off financially, think several holidays a year- annual ski trip is a human right! We, by comparison are much less well off, we are self employed and our business has been hit very hard by the pandemic. I genuinely don’t feel remotely jealous btw- I just feel we are a bit less materialistic as a family generally. I wanted to make the distinction before people say perhaps she can’t afford to spend more.
I don’t expect everything to be even to the penny and I know my kids don’t need her to spend a fortune on them. They’re very lucky and are grateful for what they receive.
It’s just the disparity in budget and also attitude that I’m finding a bit odd but perhaps it’s me who is wrong here.
So, AIBU- yes- a budget should be total per family, split between how ever many siblings are in the family.
Not unreasonable- each child should receive a gift of roughly the same value even if one is an only child and there are 3 kids in other family.

OP posts:
foxgoosefinch · 18/11/2021 17:55

I know what you mean, OP.

The expected amount normally spent in my family is £25 each on niblings. Both of my siblings have 3 children and I have one.

One sibling buys my DD something worth £25 while I spend £75 on her three kids. She thinks this is fair and right.

The other sibling spends around £75 on my DD because I spend £75 on his three kids. He thinks this is fair and right (obvs I agree here 🤣)

Sibling 1 thinks DD is being favoured over the other kids; sibling 2 thinks it’s unfair that I am always spending three times the amount on the other families than they spend in return. (FWIW I am the middle income and Generous Sibling is better off than Less Generous Sibling 🤣)

I can see both views. But if we all stick to the allotted amount I will always end up paying more than the other siblings just because I couldn’t have more children, which does seem pretty unfair tbh.

I tend to favour an option which is something like: DD gets a bit more spent on her, but not three times as much - but sibling 1 will not have this at all. It’s got to be not even a penny over £25.

merryhouse · 18/11/2021 17:49

I'm one of six siblings, four of whom had children.

Every one of us has a different budget for nibling presents, and they've never been discussed. Present suggestions, where they happen, always involve a range of prices.

Buy what you want to buy, spending what you want to spend. Hand the present to the child, and concentrate on them.

Totally separately, if your SIL takes no interest in her niblings, that's her loss.

occa · 18/11/2021 17:48

My sister has one DC and I have 2. I expect to spend roughly double on hers what she spends on each of mine so it all works out about the same.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/11/2021 17:48

Was going to say yabu just on the calculations you posted, but when I read how rude she is I thought differently!

Voucher for the amount you’d actually like to spend?

DinoWoman · 18/11/2021 17:47

Why don't you just transfer the money you're happy to give?

bananaboats · 18/11/2021 17:47

She sounds very rude i agree with pp's just stop buying for them!

KeyboardWorriers · 18/11/2021 17:46

Presents are meant to be a voluntary thing. It all sounds more like a transaction here! I have never insisted someone spend a particular amount on my children, I can't imagine the mindset. Both of you are being unreasonable.

Schooldilemma2345 · 18/11/2021 17:46

For the record, I have no expectations of what she ‘should’ spend collectively on my children! But equally I think her expectations of what I should spend on her child is quite a lot. I would like to spend about £25- I feel comfortable with that. I don’t mind what she spends but if she is planning to spend £5 on each of my kids I don’t think she should suggest a present that costs £40 for her child.
I guess opinions are quite divided here. Interesting the person who said I was expecting her to take all the mental load by not providing links to suggestions for my kids. I would happily do that but I feel it’s rude to ask for something specific unless that person asks you to suggest something.
I think next year I’ll just give a voucher- that can’t be ‘wrong’ and hopefully won’t be given back!

OP posts:
HelebethH · 18/11/2021 17:45

The year she returned the present and suggested itwas sold on ebay would have been the last year I went to the time or trouble of buying one. How rude!!

billy1966 · 18/11/2021 17:44

@Dontjudgeme101

I would stop buying presents if l was you.
This.

Just stop.

MrsAvocet · 18/11/2021 17:43

Another vote for stopping buying presents here.
We did this a few years ago with one of my DH's siblings. They have a large family who we don't even see very often. We were spending a fortune on gifts and they were doing similar, albeit for a smaller number of our children. It was pointless really. We had a conversation and just said spend what you would have spent on our children on your own, and we will do the same. Nobody minded and it saved a lot of hassle.

Icantrememberthenameoftheartis · 18/11/2021 17:43

I was going to say YABU as she has one child and you have three so her ‘budget’ is divided between the three by the sounds of it. But,reading your whole post I’ve changed my mind. She sounds very grabby. If she is spending roughly £15 per child then why don’t you spend the same? If it becomes an issue and she feels her one child is entitled to have more money spent because she spends more because you have three children then I would stop exchanging presents. Exchanging presents is meant to be something you want to do, a pleasure, not a chore and it receiving a present isn’t something anyone is entitled to.

PlanDeRaccordement · 18/11/2021 17:43

I don’t keep score on how much this or that is worth vs what this and that cost when it’s within the family. Generally though, we do share wish lists with items of a range of costs so people can pick what suits their budget at the time. Most important thing is to send something they want.

LethargicActress · 18/11/2021 17:42

Yabu to expect her to spend the same each on three children that you spend on one, but it does sound like she’s taking the piss.

Get her dd the £40 present, and follow her example and send her ideas of £15 gifts for each of your children that they would actually like.

BurntO · 18/11/2021 17:38

Tbh it’s common sense IMO. I wouldn’t expect someone to fork out £££ because I decided to have several children.

Capferret · 18/11/2021 17:36

@Schooldilemma2345

For people saying why do I ask what we should buy her child, I do now because a couple of times I’ve just chosen something I thought she’d like (always around the £25 mark) and she’s never been impressed with the present! She makes comments like, next time maybe get x or my child isn’t really into this sort or thing. On one occasion she actually gave me back to present and suggested I sold it on eBay and gave her child the money instead.
I hope you told her no.
Dontjudgeme101 · 18/11/2021 17:32

I would stop buying presents if l was you.

Plutonium7000 · 18/11/2021 17:31

OMG the drama. Just buy her daughter whatever you want.

Pinkstegosaurus · 18/11/2021 17:30

One of SIL’s and I have been discussing a secret Santa idea for the kids next year with a capped budget as we have lots of nieces and nephews…it’s becoming too much and I’d rather put more thought into one or two gifts as opposed to the 5 generic book vouchers I do every year.

DontBeADodo · 18/11/2021 17:28

Sorry @Schooldilemma2345
Christmas is for giving - not what you get back!! Seriously give your head a wobble and stop teaching your kids this mean way of thinking!!!

Just spend £15 on their 'one' child if you still think you are hard done by!!!

clpsmum · 18/11/2021 17:28

Why should she spend three times the amount you do?

Chocolatewheatos · 18/11/2021 17:27

You could see it the other way. She does all the mental load for your gifts for DN but you then expect her to also do the mental load for your kids. It's fairer to pick a strategy for both sides.
Therefore, send her a link to gifts for your kids. But I don't think you can expect her to spend 120 quid to your 40. Maybe 20 quid each for yours and 40 for hers, she's still spending more but 20 quid is a decent present.

settleforme · 18/11/2021 17:27

Just saw your last message. If she is that rude about it @Schooldilemma2345 then I would just tell her to stuff it!!

Whywonttheyhelpme · 18/11/2021 17:26

People like this are usually very well off because they are tight. If it pisses you off then stop doing it.
Your choices are:

  1. say to SIL that you don't want to do gifts at all
  2. ask SIL what child wants but tell her the budget is £ (insert amount she normally spends)

Otherwise accept she budgets per family and keep grumbling Grin

settleforme · 18/11/2021 17:26

Don't ask for ideas.
If she gives you links/suggestions etc then respond with "thank you but I'm already sorted for this Christmas/birthday" and then but what you want to buy within your budget