Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect SIL spends a similar amount of our kids as we do on hers, even though we have 3?!

86 replies

Schooldilemma2345 · 18/11/2021 16:59

I probably could have worded that a bit better! Essentially I’m asking whether it’s acceptable for my sister in law to expect us to spend £40 on her only child and then only spend £15 on each of our children? I’m wondering if it’s because we have 3!
For context: we asked SIL what her child would like for Xmas and the suggested Amazon link costs £40. She rarely asks what our children would like and the presents they receive are always pretty inexpensive or something she’s picked up at the school fair. On one occasion is was a knitted teddy type thing each which couldn’t have cost more then a fiver. Recently she sent us a message asking us to buy a particular item of clothing for her child that cost around £25 as a birthday present. She didn’t mention my son’s birthday which is a few days before her child’s. We obliged and then as an after thought she transferred £15 into our account as a birthday present for my son. She didn’t send a card or wish him happy birthday or anything. Last year for Xmas she said she would like to buy the present from us to her child. We had a family gathering at our house just before xmas and she dumped a bag of stuff on me to urgently wrap while I was hosting. She then told me what I owed her which was £30. The presents she gave my children would not have cost anything like that amount.
For the record I don’t begrudge spending £40 on her child but I do feel it’s somewhat more than the average amount that side of the family spend on each other and it feels a little greedy given what her budget is!
She is very focused on her child but she will almost always forget my children’s and my husbands birthdays. She never asks what they want.
For the record she is very well off financially, think several holidays a year- annual ski trip is a human right! We, by comparison are much less well off, we are self employed and our business has been hit very hard by the pandemic. I genuinely don’t feel remotely jealous btw- I just feel we are a bit less materialistic as a family generally. I wanted to make the distinction before people say perhaps she can’t afford to spend more.
I don’t expect everything to be even to the penny and I know my kids don’t need her to spend a fortune on them. They’re very lucky and are grateful for what they receive.
It’s just the disparity in budget and also attitude that I’m finding a bit odd but perhaps it’s me who is wrong here.
So, AIBU- yes- a budget should be total per family, split between how ever many siblings are in the family.
Not unreasonable- each child should receive a gift of roughly the same value even if one is an only child and there are 3 kids in other family.

OP posts:
Hesma · 18/11/2021 21:55

She is spending £45, you are spending 40… similar amounts to me. I think YABU to expect her to spend £120 on your DC

Naughtynovembertree · 18/11/2021 21:28

Op.
Is she struggling? A single parent, has less then you?
Can you afford to spend a something on her dc? If yes, then just do it and ask for money in a card for your dc, something she can afford.

If your both even, she doesn't have 100s to buy t for. more.. Equal money etc then just put an end to it all.
Give her child a tenner in a card and say nothing for your dc.

Buying gifts should be a pleasure never ever a chore.

Undertheoldlindentree · 18/11/2021 20:54

I am staggered by all this calculation and comparison. We have several sets of siblings and one solo child in the extended family. We all gave each other's children gifts to the approximate value of £10 (when they were tiny) to £20-25 (inflation and grown to teens). The DC are all cousins and if they're all opening gifts at the grandparents on Boxing Day, there's no way anyone wants one child receiving gifts three times the value of the others, just because they don't have siblings. That would be valuing money than the individual children we all love. The whole thing is for the shared experience of the children, not souring it by some sort of tit -for-tat balancing act by parents. If the disparity thing really bothers you, drop the budget to £10 for everyone so it's not a big issue. Or if you must even things out somehow, treat tge children equally but take a nice bottle of liqueur/box of luxury truffles along for the parents of the smaller family.

Rubadubdub21 · 18/11/2021 19:57

You want your sil to spend £40 on each of your 3 kids because you've spent £40 on hers?
Sorry if I've read that wrong but if I haven't, that's £120 on your kids. That isn't right. £15x 3 = £45 is even.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 18/11/2021 19:56

I think you posed the question strangely so are getting mixed responses.

Yanbu to chose whatever you want to gift.
I wouldn't let her dictate or ask what she wants. If you do explain its "ideas for £20 max"
She sounds tone deaf/unaware as well as entitled and rude.

Buy what you like and next time she tells you to ebay it and give her the money tell her to ebay it herself.

Cheeky cow!!!

ThinWomansBrain · 18/11/2021 19:51

just tell her that you need to cut back, and stop the gift merry go round

DeepaBeesKit · 18/11/2021 19:42

My sibling has more children than I. The amount we spend is fixed per child and that's fine by me. Its not her children's fault they have more siblings.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 18/11/2021 19:34

You can't really expect her to spend 3 x the amount on your family that you spend on her family, I certainly wouldn't.

LoveComesQuickly · 18/11/2021 19:17

I started off thinking YABU (I have three DC, my brother has one, I would expect him to spend less on mine per child) but on reading your later comment she sounds awful. Stopping asking what her DC would like and getting a £25 voucher sounds like a good plan.

woodhill · 18/11/2021 19:13

@FreeBritnee

I received a present back that I’d bought for my nephew as apparently it wasnt good enough. It honestly is the height of rudeness. Personally I’d decide what you actually want to spend and give her the amount on an Amazon gift card or similar. Then she can choose but you can decide the amount.
Then I wouldn't bother any more, how rude of him
FreeBritnee · 18/11/2021 19:09

I received a present back that I’d bought for my nephew as apparently it wasnt good enough. It honestly is the height of rudeness. Personally I’d decide what you actually want to spend and give her the amount on an Amazon gift card or similar. Then she can choose but you can decide the amount.

lanthanum · 18/11/2021 19:05

If it's not being done as people going out and choosing presents for the nieces and nephews, maybe the simplest thing would be for each parent to put the same amount into the kitty, and then spend the same amount on each child. Okay, so that means that effectively the parent-of-more is contributing to their own kids' aunt&uncle presents, but it does keep the spending and receiving equitable.

Spiceup · 18/11/2021 19:04

I don't know how she gets to "expect" you spend a certain amount, but generally yes, I think it's correct that she spends roughly the same sum on her brother's family as he spends on hers.

Personally though it depends on what people want/need and how flush I feel at the time and no one keeps count.

Chloemol · 18/11/2021 19:02

YABU. You have 3 she has 1. Why should she spend £120 on three presents to your one £40

Her spending £15 on each sounds fine to £40 for hers

However if you are that concerned why dont you say let’s stop buying presents for everyone

woodhill · 18/11/2021 18:49

@Schooldilemma2345

For people saying why do I ask what we should buy her child, I do now because a couple of times I’ve just chosen something I thought she’d like (always around the £25 mark) and she’s never been impressed with the present! She makes comments like, next time maybe get x or my child isn’t really into this sort or thing. On one occasion she actually gave me back to present and suggested I sold it on eBay and gave her child the money instead.
I think she's rude and grabby and I wouldn't like someone asking me wrap something and transfer money to her account - how mercenary
Gliderx · 18/11/2021 18:45

Just exchange token gifts (£5-10 per child) and spend what you save on your own children.

I think each child should have the same value spent on them but the issue is in the inflated expectations of what that amount is. If you were just buying a book or small gift per child, the discrepancy wouldn't matter as much.

Beautiful3 · 18/11/2021 18:38

I think yabu, sorry. If you spend on one child £40, then it's fair they spend a similar amount on your family. Otherwise its unfair to expect they spend £120, when you've spent far less. If it's stressing you out, why not suggest to end all presents. That's what we did, best thing we ever did.

Poonique · 18/11/2021 18:19

My brother was always similar, giving us a list etc
The last time he messaged to suggest a certain gift (despite being notoriously difficult to get hold of/commit to any plans he was always rather proactive when it came to dictating gifts in plenty of advance) I just said thanks for the suggestion but this year the kids wanted to be more involved in the gift giving side of things and choose his gifts, wrap them up etc which I think is a lovely gesture from them to their cousin.

jackstini · 18/11/2021 18:18

Just say, please buy your dd whatever she would like and I'll give you a tag to put on it

I will do same for my kids

No money changes hands, you both spend what you are comfortable with

I would say fair to spend similar amounts overall

ZenNudist · 18/11/2021 18:14

Just agree not to do gifts this year. £40 for a nephew or neice is ridiculous

2018SoFarSoGreat · 18/11/2021 18:12

for larger families I do one present, spend 50 or so, and get one more expensive thing they can enjoy together. Why don't you propose that to her? then you're stopping cheap tat, and getting something better for your DC.

supremelybaffled · 18/11/2021 18:10

We were in the opposite situation to you, with DH's two siblings having two and three kids respectively. We would buy five presents every time, and get two back. I know it's the thought that counts, but if you are buying a present for each of theirs, the least they could have done was think 'oh they spend three times as much on ours so we'd better spend a bit more than a tenner on their one'.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 18/11/2021 18:10

@Schooldilemma2345

For people saying why do I ask what we should buy her child, I do now because a couple of times I’ve just chosen something I thought she’d like (always around the £25 mark) and she’s never been impressed with the present! She makes comments like, next time maybe get x or my child isn’t really into this sort or thing. On one occasion she actually gave me back to present and suggested I sold it on eBay and gave her child the money instead.
Buy what you want. and when she comments, comment back with ' I was similarly unimpressed with yours', or 'same for what you picked out for mine'
Wildrobin · 18/11/2021 18:04

We have a family secret Santa of £10/ person but where one family has more dc it can be a bit lower if wanted , I’m doing them all the same. Your SIL sounds a bit thoughtless though so I think this is more the issue than value of gift

Tumbleweed101 · 18/11/2021 18:00

Tbh I would expect the budget to stretch over as many children as I had against the number someone else had. So if I have four and they had two my children's gifts would be less per child but same spend overall. That is assuming similar financial circumstances.