Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Channel crossings

338 replies

Tevion28 · 18/11/2021 16:29

Whats your thoughts on this are these people really desperate fleeing worn torn countries do you feel sorry for them etc

OP posts:
Blueuggboots · 19/11/2021 09:13

The NHS is on it's knees because of chronic underfunding for many years.

That's the GOVERNMENT's fault, not illegal immigrants.

The government are spending billions and billions of pounds on a trainline that isn't required, destroying countryside in the process.

They have the money, they just choose not to spend it in this area.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 19/11/2021 08:11

If you’re concerned about infrastructure and resources, these few channel crossing refugees are the least of your worries.

You need to be campaigning for population reduction by :

a) Introducing an age for mandatory euthanasia of the elderly / this will take massive strain off the NHS and social care

b) Introduce mandatory sterilisation of women on a postcode lottery basis - this will lower population growth and require less infrastructure

c) One child limit for those permitted to breed

Does this sound awful ? Yes it does doesn’t it. If you don’t support these awful measures - things which will actually move the needle on your infrastructure and resources concerns - then don’t waste your energy pursuing the tiny number desperate families risking this crossing for a better life.

Tabbacus · 19/11/2021 08:10

@TheFuckingDogs

Goodness this thread is depressing- we really are becoming an increasingly backward nasty little racist isolationist country.

I come from a pretty shit northern town. You really have to be desperate and in fear for yours and your kids life to end up in the worst parts of this shithole to feel safer and like your life will improve.

Those of you saying women and kids fine etc the young men will often just be a few years older than our boys. Everyone was someone’s baby once

Most people are saying they welcome refugees, just not those that travel over on dinghies funding people smugglers, our government should be doing more. And yes that's true, but women and children are often subject to more risk back home, they are not equal to men.
TheFuckingDogs · 19/11/2021 07:55

And completely agree with FrenchFancy - our language is the international global language, this is also because we were the worst (best?) in terms of going round colonising the world so actually our ancestors are to blame to a large extent

TheFuckingDogs · 19/11/2021 07:31

Goodness this thread is depressing- we really are becoming an increasingly backward nasty little racist isolationist country.

I come from a pretty shit northern town. You really have to be desperate and in fear for yours and your kids life to end up in the worst parts of this shithole to feel safer and like your life will improve.

Those of you saying women and kids fine etc the young men will often just be a few years older than our boys. Everyone was someone’s baby once

Frenchfancy · 19/11/2021 06:22

There is a lot of French bashing on this thread.

France welcomes many migrants, but the ones that stay are overwhelmingly from francophone Africa because they speak the language.

The camps are horrific which is why the gendarmes regularly break them up and ship the migrants to asylum centres where their claims are processed and they get help to settle.

The people at Calais and Dunkirk are only there because it is the closest point of Europe to the UK, that is not France's fault.

My DH works with many migrants, some of them were at the jungle and tried to cross to the UK. They had no idea they could get help in France because they read the same press reports as you do. They are now apprentices, have bosses that support them and when asked if they would try to get to the UK now they say no way. Many of the bosses that take on the apprentices prefer migrants because they work harder, so much for being racist.

One of the apprentices he has was a translator in Afghanistan. He speaks 6 languages fluently but not French. He says that French is the hardest language he has ever learnt. That is why migrants want to get to the UK. It is the downside of your language being the international language for communication.

workwoes123 · 19/11/2021 06:17

I am baffled as to why so many do not like France/French people.
They’re risking their lives to cross the channel to get to a more crowded, colder, and poorer country.

But it’s also one that is largely tolerant, which to celebrate multiculturalism and is by and large accepting of different cultures and ways of living. France is the opposite: assimilationist in its approach to incomers. you are expected to put your own beliefs and cultural practices to the side in order to become “french”. There is nothing here like, for example, the Notting Hill carnival: french people would see nothing to celebrate in this respect.

The UK is messy and chaotic and lax in how it enforce laws - and that attracts people willing to exist in the shadows for a while. No I D cards, free at the point of care / no questions asked health care. In France you don’t generally get past the secretary unless you have your carte vitale and ID - and you don’t get the former until you have proved that you are contributing to the system. Or you have to show you have the means to pay for your care.

And yes, the french police have a reputation for racist brutality.

Dazedandconfused28 · 19/11/2021 05:28

@Biker47

*I worked in the camps in Dunkirk - you are very much mistaken - the majority I met were skilled workers & professionals.

Why would you assume otherwise?*

Learning the French language and applying to stay there should be a walk in the park for professionals then, we teach children French from Primary school age here, I'm pretty sure adults who've already managed to forge skilled and professional careers can manage then.

Happy to DM photos of the camps where children are living in France? No sane parent or person would willingly live there. They are horrific
chillicrackers · 19/11/2021 03:13

The benefits actually went up for asylum seekers last year. I think it's crazy that in a country where the infrastructure is stretched to its capacity we are allowing more and more people in. I resent having my taxes put up when their benefits also go up. I'd much rather the welfare system was improved for citizens of the U.K. who have contributed to it.
Article in the times today shows how wait times in a&e are literally ending up with people dying as a result. I can't register with a dentist. My GP won't see me face to face and getting through just to ask is an absolute nightmare. You can't get a school place because they're so full and the non English speaking asylum dc (due to their numbers) attending schools do put strain on already limited resources.
Where do we stop with how many people can come in?

I feel sorry for the individual people and don't blame them for trying but I also believe either we have a society that works or we allow the whole world to come through our doors and trash our society, culturally, financially, and otherwise. I completely blame this government and do wonder if there's more to it because I can't see why something successful to in the very least deport those that have already been refused hasn't occurred yet.

videovixen · 19/11/2021 01:16

@FuckingPissedOff

I see my comment on the first page has been deleted. I'd like to know why please MN, as there was nothing offensive in it. Saying that resources are finite is a fact.
Hmm
videovixen · 18/11/2021 23:37

This is such a 'get out my country go back to where you came from' type of thread. Embarrassing

videovixen · 18/11/2021 23:37

@HappyToPayForAdultSocialCare

I'm just going to leave this here:
🙌🙌
pinknikes · 18/11/2021 23:32

@Tabbacus

If the government supported the vulnerable in our society, and we, as one of the wealthiest countries in the world didn't have children skipping meals because their parents can't afford to feed them, women fleeing abuse weren't holed up in tiny bedsits for long periods, people waiting on social housing lists for literally decades, areas with few opportunities, families plunged into poverty if one of them becomes unable to work through illness or disability etc, people could access timely and appropriate healthcare I'm sure people would be more welcoming. There are areas hugely affected by high levels of economic migrants, it's faux nativity and disingenuous to say otherwise.

I'd rather see a fairer and safer route for actual refugees- including women and children (it's all very well to say men send money home, but many women and children are in great physical danger in these countries; also these young men don't all have families), rather than boatloads of people who can afford thousands to make the journey.

This
KingofQueens · 18/11/2021 23:18

@DroopyClematis

Just watching the news.

Only five immigrants have been removed this year , back to France.

To be fair, Kent has suffered the brunt of the influx. The human traffickers are making huge amounts out of these vulnerable people.

As long as we accept these people then the traffickers will continue to ply their filthy trade.

Dover is almost pitiful now.

If that figure of 5 is true why do you think that might be? Maybe because we are no longer part of the EU agreement on resettling asylum seekers?
traka · 18/11/2021 23:16

They pass through multiple safe countries on the way but want to come to soft touch UK

KingofQueens · 18/11/2021 23:15

People lap up the rhetoric of the right-wing press and right-wing government and don't see they are being played and led to believe absolute lies.
We are not "full," we don't take more refugees than other countries - very far from it. In terms of percentages of populations the countries in the top ten in terms of the highest numbers of refugees include Lebanon, Jordan, Turkey, Sudan, Liberia, and Uganda. The one, just one, European country in the top ten is Sweden.

In terms of pure numbers Germany is the only European country in the top ten - Turkey receives the highest number, followed by Lebanon, Jordan, Pakistan, and Sudan. Germany is at number 6.

We don't feature in the top 25.
Germany has 10 times more asylum claims than we do.

Look up Napier Barracks, look up Yarlswood, look up "no recourse to public funds".

I'm ashamed of how little we are doing, particularly when other less affluent countries are doing so much more.

Biker47 · 18/11/2021 23:11

*I worked in the camps in Dunkirk - you are very much mistaken - the majority I met were skilled workers & professionals.

Why would you assume otherwise?*

Learning the French language and applying to stay there should be a walk in the park for professionals then, we teach children French from Primary school age here, I'm pretty sure adults who've already managed to forge skilled and professional careers can manage then.

BluebelllsRosesDaffodills · 18/11/2021 23:10

@Lineofconcepcion

''that working people are vastly impoverished compared to our parents generation''

Really! My parents like most of their generation and class, rented their property. It had no heating only coal fires and a back burner, which was great but we couldn't always afford coal. We had frost on the inside of the windows when we woke up in the morning. Luckily we had an indoor bathroom. My grandmother didn't, she had an outside privy. Both my parents worked to pay the rent and buy food. I had no clothes, other than one second hand dress and a hand me down school uniform and it wasn't unusual for kids to go to school with no shoes. Can't say I've noticed any of that recently.

Which country and decade was this that kids commonly had no shoes??
DroopyClematis · 18/11/2021 22:56

There is literally no answer to this issue.

DroopyClematis · 18/11/2021 22:54

Just watching the news.

Only five immigrants have been removed this year , back to France.

To be fair, Kent has suffered the brunt of the influx. The human traffickers are making huge amounts out of these vulnerable people.

As long as we accept these people then the traffickers will continue to ply their filthy trade.

Dover is almost pitiful now.

PlanDeRaccordement · 18/11/2021 22:52

“Tow the party line”
What they pull on it with ropes? Isn’t it “toe the party line”?

JustAnotherPoster00 · 18/11/2021 22:50

Mumsnet is starting to resemble Parler with pearls

JunoMcDuff · 18/11/2021 22:49

@LittleDandelionClock

Hiding the thread now!
Why? Because you can't manage rigourous debate?
JunoMcDuff · 18/11/2021 22:48

[quote LittleDandelionClock]@JunoMcDuff

You're wrong.

They are Teachers, nurses, skilled tradesmen. Even lawyers and Drs. They need to jump through hoop after hoop to get registration here, but they are skilled non the less.

No, YOU are wrong. As IF the people coming to the UK (illegally - on the boats across the channel,) are doctors, teachers, lawyers, and skilled trade men and nurses.

Pull the other one, it's got bells on![/quote]
You've clearly no idea have you!

Why do you think refuges and asylum seekers are driven from their homes? It's because they don't tow the party line - usually a strictly religious party line. Who are the least likely people to tow a discriminatory party line that is enforced by fear, misinformation and withdrawal of rights? Educated people. People who have the ability to know the truth because they have access to information, can read, usually read English, internet access.

LittleDandelionClock · 18/11/2021 22:33

Hiding the thread now!