Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Channel crossings

338 replies

Tevion28 · 18/11/2021 16:29

Whats your thoughts on this are these people really desperate fleeing worn torn countries do you feel sorry for them etc

OP posts:
Sam020 · 20/11/2021 00:57

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@Sam020
Immigrants are not kept. They work and pay taxes (mostly without being able to access public funds).

Asylum seekers do not have the automatic right to work in the U.K. you are mixing up legal immigrants with asylum seekers.
“Those who claim asylum in the UK are not normally allowed to work whilst their claim is being considered. They are instead provided with accommodation and support to meet their essential living needs if they would otherwise be destitute. The policy outlining when permission to work will be granted to those who claim asylum is set out in the Immigration Rules. This outlines that the Home Office may grant permission to work to asylum seekers whose claim has been outstanding for more than 12 months through no fault of their own. Under this policy, those who are allowed to work are restricted to jobs on the shortage occupation list published by the Home Office. Any permission to work granted will come to an end if their claim is refused and any appeals rights are exhausted because at that point they are expected to leave the UK. Those who are granted leave have unrestricted access to the labour market.”
www.gov.uk/government/publications/handling-applications-for-permission-to-take-employment-instruction/permission-to-work-and-volunteering-for-asylum-seekers-accessible-version[/quote]
I'm not the one confusing immigrant's with asylum seekers.

PlanDeRaccordement · 20/11/2021 00:19

@Sam020
Immigrants are not kept. They work and pay taxes (mostly without being able to access public funds).

Asylum seekers do not have the automatic right to work in the U.K. you are mixing up legal immigrants with asylum seekers.
“Those who claim asylum in the UK are not normally allowed to work whilst their claim is being considered. They are instead provided with accommodation and support to meet their essential living needs if they would otherwise be destitute. The policy outlining when permission to work will be granted to those who claim asylum is set out in the Immigration Rules. This outlines that the Home Office may grant permission to work to asylum seekers whose claim has been outstanding for more than 12 months through no fault of their own. Under this policy, those who are allowed to work are restricted to jobs on the shortage occupation list published by the Home Office. Any permission to work granted will come to an end if their claim is refused and any appeals rights are exhausted because at that point they are expected to leave the UK. Those who are granted leave have unrestricted access to the labour market.”
www.gov.uk/government/publications/handling-applications-for-permission-to-take-employment-instruction/permission-to-work-and-volunteering-for-asylum-seekers-accessible-version

PlanDeRaccordement · 20/11/2021 00:14

@Sam020
Because the refugees crossing the channel are not French. Why do you think the channel refugees are somehow special cases and not part of a larger problem? They are part of the 26m global refugee population. Which is only going to get bigger from climate change. And there are clear migration routes these refugees are following...one of which goes directly to the U.K. like a yellow brick road to OZ.

PlanDeRaccordement · 20/11/2021 00:11

@Sam020
No, of course all 26 million will not be going to U.K.
But the point is that it is not just this year’s total of 100,000 applicants and U.K. is done, there will continue to be more, and more every year.
And I’ve said nothing about refugees robbing anyone. I am descended from refugees myself, so there is no question about how nice they might be as people. It’s simply a question of a small island with one of the highest population densities in the world, so there has to be a point where you have no more room.

I don’t think “richness” matters as much as room to settle refugees.
Turkey is three times bigger than the U.K. and has a much lower population density of 108 people per sq km, compared to the U.K. population density of 280 people per sq km.

China, for example has a population density of 150 people per sq km
USA has a population density of only 34 people per sq km.

Sam020 · 20/11/2021 00:01

@Doodar

my point is we're creating ghettos of immigrants, shipped out of expensive areas, mainly to the north of England. I don't think turkey keeps immigrants in the same way we do.
Immigrants are not kept. They work and pay taxes (mostly without being able to access public funds).
FruitFeatures · 19/11/2021 23:55

In this thread: a load of intolerant people get their knickers in a twist when it’s pointed out that the UK is intolerant and that is how the world sees us.

She’s right, you know. Ask anyone from overseas (if you’re not scared to talk to them) what they think of Brits and they’ll tell you we’re arrogant, intolerant, two faced and we’ve lived on an island for too long.

Doodar · 19/11/2021 23:55

my point is we're creating ghettos of immigrants, shipped out of expensive areas, mainly to the north of England. I don't think turkey keeps immigrants in the same way we do.

Sam020 · 19/11/2021 23:48

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@Sam020
You have been overstating the size and wealth of the U.K. while understating the worlds refugee problem and the UKs own overpopulation problem. Why can’t you look at this issue more objectively?[/quote]
Why are you talking about global refugees? What's that got to do with channel crossings?

Sam020 · 19/11/2021 23:44

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@Sam020
I’m not being sarcastic. You are clearly only listing the number of pending asylum applications with the U.K.

This does not represent the full number of refugees currently seeking asylum. Which is currently 26 million people according to Amnesty International. And what I was referring to. You clearly do not understand the scale of what is happening.
www.amnesty.org/en/what-we-do/refugees-asylum-seekers-and-migrants/global-refugee-crisis-statistics-and-facts/[/quote]
The link you posted clearly states that there are 26 million globally. Globally. Do you think they are all knocking on the door of the UK?

Are we talking about different topics? Of course there are millions of asylum seekers Globally. A fraction of these try to come to the UK. A fraction that is not going to rob us blind.

Turkey takes millions of refugees by the way. I don't think they are considered to be very rich.

PlanDeRaccordement · 19/11/2021 23:41

@Sam020
You have been overstating the size and wealth of the U.K. while understating the worlds refugee problem and the UKs own overpopulation problem. Why can’t you look at this issue more objectively?

PlanDeRaccordement · 19/11/2021 23:36

@Sam020
I’m not being sarcastic. You are clearly only listing the number of pending asylum applications with the U.K.

This does not represent the full number of refugees currently seeking asylum. Which is currently 26 million people according to Amnesty International. And what I was referring to. You clearly do not understand the scale of what is happening.
www.amnesty.org/en/what-we-do/refugees-asylum-seekers-and-migrants/global-refugee-crisis-statistics-and-facts/

Sam020 · 19/11/2021 23:35

@Doodar

how about all the northern towns filled with male asylum seekers/refugees? they'll never work or marry and have kids as they're muslim and will never integrate.
And some people still genuinely think that the UK is one of the most tolerant countries in the world...you just need to allow this thread to know that's not the case.
Sam020 · 19/11/2021 23:29

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@Sam020
This is not a small country. It could have been a rich country but it's completely mismanaged. I'm honestly tired of the rhetoric around asylum seekers. These are very few people. They are not going to rob us of our resources. That's the government's job

The U.K. is not a small country?! There are 77 countries which are larger than the U.K. You are roughly the same size as Guinea. New Zealand? bigger. Ecuador? Bigger. Phillipines? Bigger Morocco? Twice the size. Chile and Zambia? Three times the size! Ethiopia? Five times bigger!

And the asylum seekers are not “very few people” .....

You need to really look at an accurate map of the world which doesn’t Center London in the middle and draw the U.K. island as if it were as big as Greenland and read about the millions of refugees/displaced people currently looking for asylum.[/quote]
Millions of asylum seekers? Are you being sarcastic?

The number of pending asylum seekers is less than 100000 currently. Don't let facts get in the way of your prejudice though.

Doodar · 19/11/2021 23:13

how about all the northern towns filled with male asylum seekers/refugees? they'll never work or marry and have kids as they're muslim and will never integrate.

PlanDeRaccordement · 19/11/2021 23:10

@Sam020
This is not a small country. It could have been a rich country but it's completely mismanaged. I'm honestly tired of the rhetoric around asylum seekers. These are very few people. They are not going to rob us of our resources. That's the government's job

The U.K. is not a small country?! There are 77 countries which are larger than the U.K. You are roughly the same size as Guinea. New Zealand? bigger. Ecuador? Bigger. Phillipines? Bigger Morocco? Twice the size. Chile and Zambia? Three times the size! Ethiopia? Five times bigger!

And the asylum seekers are not “very few people” .....

You need to really look at an accurate map of the world which doesn’t Center London in the middle and draw the U.K. island as if it were as big as Greenland and read about the millions of refugees/displaced people currently looking for asylum.

Tabbacus · 19/11/2021 22:45

@Sam020

The UK is known as a tolerant country only inside the uk. Please trust me when I say this. Most people outside the UK think we are bigoted idiots. Just read their papers to find out what they think of us and our famously misplaced sense of exceptionalism.
What are they basing that on out of interest? We are far from perfect, of course, and there's plenty we could do as individuals, communities and a country to do better and we should; but where are these perfect utopias that are fully tolerant?
Sam020 · 19/11/2021 22:40

@stonebrambleboy

Sam020 'Most people outside the UK think we are bigoted idiots' So you talked to all these people then??
Like I said: try reading their papers
stonebrambleboy · 19/11/2021 22:22

Sam020 'Most people outside the UK think we are bigoted idiots'
So you talked to all these people then??

Sam020 · 19/11/2021 22:11

The UK is known as a tolerant country only inside the uk. Please trust me when I say this. Most people outside the UK think we are bigoted idiots. Just read their papers to find out what they think of us and our famously misplaced sense of exceptionalism.

Sam020 · 19/11/2021 22:05

@Tevion28

Whats your thoughts on this are these people really desperate fleeing worn torn countries do you feel sorry for them etc
Most of them. Yes.

This is not a small country. It could have been a rich country but it's completely mismanaged. I'm honestly tired of the rhetoric around asylum seekers. These are very few people. They are not going to rob us of our resources. That's the government's job ...

PlanDeRaccordement · 19/11/2021 21:58

Forgot my rich list link
www.worldatlas.com/articles/the-richest-countries-in-the-world.html

PlanDeRaccordement · 19/11/2021 21:57

No one is asking for the U.K. to help everyone but they don’t do their share as one of the richest countries in the world.

They don’t do their share? Please tell me, what is everyone’s “share” and why is it based on richness of a country, rather than, oh I don’t know how densely you are populated?

By the way, the U.K. is #24 on the rich list of countries. So, not really “one of the richest in the world” that phrase is often trotted out by people who have bought into the land of milk and honey, streets paved with gold mythology.

Allycott · 19/11/2021 21:48

@Xenia

The problem is the volume. We have 18m more people in the UK than when I was born. We have huge housing shortages, little NHS for many and we are paying a lot of money for those who come here illegally and do not seem able to remove over stayers at the rate we used to do.

Even if there are good reasons some people come here illegally (eg they are or become Christian or are gay and that means they have problems in their original country) the sheers numbers are just too many for us in the UK to be able to cope, given we have the highest tax burden for 70 years. Both Labour and Tory supporters largely feel the same. It is not that we have a problem with different people as long as they do not stop us showing our arms or disturb us - is the sheer weight of numbers particularly where newcomers outnumber the original people and thus a change is imposed which may not always be for the better without the original people agreeing.

This is not new. In 1066 the French came over, took our lands etc and before them we had Viking incursions and of course the Romans.

It is fine for those who are rich or who move via white flight to other areas but not for many ordinary people who don't have those privileged choices.

Exactly this. When you go to the UAE you abide by the laws and customs in place. I do not blame any asylum seekers but I do blame the government.
Xenia · 19/11/2021 21:10

The problem is the volume. We have 18m more people in the UK than when I was born. We have huge housing shortages, little NHS for many and we are paying a lot of money for those who come here illegally and do not seem able to remove over stayers at the rate we used to do.

Even if there are good reasons some people come here illegally (eg they are or become Christian or are gay and that means they have problems in their original country) the sheers numbers are just too many for us in the UK to be able to cope, given we have the highest tax burden for 70 years. Both Labour and Tory supporters largely feel the same. It is not that we have a problem with different people as long as they do not stop us showing our arms or disturb us - is the sheer weight of numbers particularly where newcomers outnumber the original people and thus a change is imposed which may not always be for the better without the original people agreeing.

This is not new. In 1066 the French came over, took our lands etc and before them we had Viking incursions and of course the Romans.

It is fine for those who are rich or who move via white flight to other areas but not for many ordinary people who don't have those privileged choices.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 19/11/2021 20:43

Concerning the % whose claims are successful, it's worth remembering the number may include the many thousands who've been granted an "amnesty" in one of the periodic attempts to fiddle the figures clear backlogs. The link below is from 2011, but it would be interesting to know what that figure is now:

www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/jun/02/160000-asylum-seekers-granted-amnesty

Swipe left for the next trending thread