Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Channel crossings

338 replies

Tevion28 · 18/11/2021 16:29

Whats your thoughts on this are these people really desperate fleeing worn torn countries do you feel sorry for them etc

OP posts:
clarepetal · 25/11/2021 18:39

@JunoMcDuff

I feel extremely sorry for them and feel we should do everything to support them.
This a thousand times. How bad must a country be for someone to take the risks to get here. Especially after yesterday's news of 27 deaths. I would happily help them.
woodhill · 25/11/2021 18:37

@Allycott

And when shall we close them? When we have doubled our population? When the infrastructure collapses? When a civil war breaks out? When the UK becomes too shit to live in that ITS residents seek asylum elsewhere?
I really think that's how it will end up eventually and it won't be a lovely safe place for anyone
Allycott · 25/11/2021 18:35

And when shall we close them? When we have doubled our population? When the infrastructure collapses? When a civil war breaks out? When the UK becomes too shit to live in that ITS residents seek asylum elsewhere?

User135644 · 25/11/2021 18:35

@Tevion28

From what I hear most asylum cases are unsuccessful in the uk so in some respects they never move on with thier life here because they are stuck in the asylum system for years with no decision surviving on £37 a week then end up working illegally.
The claim might be unsuccessful but they still stay here anyway. Look at the guy last week in Liverpool. His asylum case was rejected 6 years ago yet he was still here.
LittleMG · 25/11/2021 18:32

I can’t understand what makes people think they are entitled to a lovely safe life and others aren’t. Through accident of birth.

LittleMG · 25/11/2021 18:27

Glad you agree!

woodhill · 25/11/2021 17:46

Over 1000s of years I mean

woodhill · 25/11/2021 17:46

But this has happened only thousands of years not in the amount of the last 50 years'

pinknikes · 25/11/2021 17:02

@LittleMG

I think people forget that we all have immigrant blood in us. Who is 100% can trace all ancestry back to say, the Saxons? No one.
Absolutely. Open the borders for this reason alone tbh.
itsgettingwierd · 25/11/2021 16:53

@thepinknecklace

We can’t take everyone who tries to cross the channel.
But then neither than the first countries all these refugees arrive at.

We need a better system.

But these people must have money because they pay a fortune for a crossing. So they must have qualifications or a trade.

Which makes me think they must be desperate to pay all their savings to make a dangerous crossing to arrive in the UK to live in a container on £37 a week fully supervised whilst hoping for asylum.

lonelyapple · 25/11/2021 16:46

@CorrBlimeyGG

Before anyone says they're here to claim benefits, they get £37 a week. If they were doing it solely for the money, other European countries are far more generous.
Plus free housing, free dental treatment, free nhs care, free schooling if they have children etc. The equivalent of a lot more than just £37 per week.
LittleMG · 25/11/2021 16:45

I think people forget that we all have immigrant blood in us. Who is 100% can trace all ancestry back to say, the Saxons? No one.

MidnightMeltdown · 25/11/2021 16:24

27 people died yesterday trying to cross the channel, but I suppose that's fine with all those who think it's ok to encourage them to keep coming.

MidnightMeltdown · 25/11/2021 16:22

@Sam020

The UK is known as a tolerant country only inside the uk. Please trust me when I say this. Most people outside the UK think we are bigoted idiots. Just read their papers to find out what they think of us and our famously misplaced sense of exceptionalism.

And what about the French who are openly racist, far worse than Britain? I know this because I have French family and spend a lot of time there.

And the Australians? They have plenty of land and are wealthier than us. How many refugees do you see them taking?

Britain has done more than it's fair share, and is far more tolerant, than many other countries.

RavingAnnie · 20/11/2021 17:17

@EileenGC

My dad snuck into what later became my home country, through the mountains, in winter and in the middle of the night. He was a strong and healthy 22 year old.

Yes, these people are desperate. They’re putting themselves through this because it’s a better, safer option than staying in their own countries.

Why pass so many safe countries on the way to the UK? I don’t know, variety of reasons. My dad left many ‘good’ countries behind on the way to his final destination. He was going there because he had some acquaintances who had already settled there and he hoped they’d be able to help him. The language was easier. The residency application process and general admin fees were lower. There was more need for workers in his job. He had an actual visa for some of the countries on his route but chose not to stay there, legally.

This

Think about what you would do if leaving the country you had grown up in and roots in due to a horrific situation there, losing everything and going to another country to try to start again with nothing.

You would want to go to a country where you perhaps spoke the language already, or knew family/friends or there was a community that already lived there, where there was a good chance of you being able to secure work and housing, and where you felt your children would have a future.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 20/11/2021 13:41

@Tevion28

I know income in these countries can be extremely low so families can't be provided for. Do you think these men think come here to try and get jobs
In some cases, yes. I know several fathers at my school who were Syrian refugees and are who are now working, supporting their families and whose children are, without exception, absolute delights, despite the horrors we know they have lived through.
woodhill · 20/11/2021 13:16

[quote Parker231]@woodhill - similar situation a couple of years ago. Some colleagues and I were working in Cheshire and staying at a local hotel. My colleagues, all British but whose families came from Kenya and India, were the only non white people at the hotel. They were made to feel very uncomfortable by some of the staff and other guests[/quote]
Yes that's not nice

PlanDeRaccordement · 20/11/2021 13:09

What is English “indigenous” culture?
There is a distinct English culture. You may not know because you’ve always lived in England so to you, it is just the way things are and the way people are supposed to act. But if you lived abroad, you’d notice the differences in culture.

The addition of a new culture doesn’t erase the existing culture.
But it can. Historical examples are everywhere of how incoming colonists culture can in the span of a few generations become the new dominant culture in a country. The entire continents of North America, South America and Australia for example...

PlanDeRaccordement · 20/11/2021 13:04

@tttigress
Exactly, they have passed through, safer, richer, and larger countries with more room/housing and infrastructure than the U.K.

FruitFeatures · 20/11/2021 13:04

[quote chillicrackers]@Sam020 Turkey gives nothing close to what we give immigrants and they give with an aim to stop them coming entirely, rather then give them advantages over their local poorer people, if locals are unhappy they're allowed to say something. That's the thing, if all the countries had to give a percentage of the wages for that place, a specific standard of living attributed to illegal immigrants that might be fair, but when one country gives more than others it does become unfair.
It's actually particularly uneven across Europe itself.

@FruitFeatures it may be the case that people slate the British abroad but at the same time most people know of the stereotyping around the French or Germans for example. Most stereotyping shows up ignorance. We seem to have gotten to a point where if you dare say you are proud to be British because of a long line of your own heritage and things to be proud of (I had a few relatives who gained medals in the bot WW1&WW2 for example) this is also unfair. What space gets carved out for the indigenous people? Why is it so wrong that the indigenous people want to preserve their own culture. Just because some don't agree with the culture or they think it's funny or rubbish, doesn't mean indigenous British people should have their culture taken away from them or have to move entire areas to preserve it.

My dad went to where he was born and all the road signs had been changed into Punjabi with the Punjabi characters so you have no chance of reading them. He was well and truly hurt when he found everything he grew up with wiped out by a completely mono cultural change. He got stared at the whole time as the only white man walking around, he went to see his childhood home in east London. He's not racist. He didn't want his own culture to disappear in the way it had done there. Many elements of most cultures have bad points is it ok to wipe them out as a result?! [/quote]
What is English “indigenous” culture? My family is pretty much entirely English going back generations and I couldn’t tell you a thing that points to an English culture, unless you count working yourself into an early grave, going to the pub and being repressed.

Also, I didn’t say Brits are slated abroad, I said people think we’re intolerant, which we are and your post is an example of that. Why should we preserve road signs for nostalgia reasons rather than making it easier for the people who actually live in an area to get around? The addition of a new culture doesn’t erase the existing culture. Road signs are not culture. Your father can still do English things like go to the pub and be repressed even though his old road now has a sign that’s in Punjabi. He’s also still part of the dominant culture, as are you. His way of life is not under threat.

tttigress · 20/11/2021 12:57

The problem is they have already passed through a number of safe countries including France.

Parker231 · 20/11/2021 12:41

@woodhill - similar situation a couple of years ago. Some colleagues and I were working in Cheshire and staying at a local hotel. My colleagues, all British but whose families came from Kenya and India, were the only non white people at the hotel. They were made to feel very uncomfortable by some of the staff and other guests

woodhill · 20/11/2021 12:18

@chillicrackers - that sounds awful for your dad, unfortunately a lot of the London suburbs seem to be going that way, Southall is one example

gogohm · 20/11/2021 08:42

There's refugees and asylum seekers in every European country, Germany takes the most

chillicrackers · 20/11/2021 08:14

@Sam020 Turkey gives nothing close to what we give immigrants and they give with an aim to stop them coming entirely, rather then give them advantages over their local poorer people, if locals are unhappy they're allowed to say something. That's the thing, if all the countries had to give a percentage of the wages for that place, a specific standard of living attributed to illegal immigrants that might be fair, but when one country gives more than others it does become unfair.
It's actually particularly uneven across Europe itself.

@FruitFeatures it may be the case that people slate the British abroad but at the same time most people know of the stereotyping around the French or Germans for example. Most stereotyping shows up ignorance. We seem to have gotten to a point where if you dare say you are proud to be British because of a long line of your own heritage and things to be proud of (I had a few relatives who gained medals in the bot WW1&WW2 for example) this is also unfair. What space gets carved out for the indigenous people? Why is it so wrong that the indigenous people want to preserve their own culture. Just because some don't agree with the culture or they think it's funny or rubbish, doesn't mean indigenous British people should have their culture taken away from them or have to move entire areas to preserve it.

My dad went to where he was born and all the road signs had been changed into Punjabi with the Punjabi characters so you have no chance of reading them. He was well and truly hurt when he found everything he grew up with wiped out by a completely mono cultural change. He got stared at the whole time as the only white man walking around, he went to see his childhood home in east London. He's not racist. He didn't want his own culture to disappear in the way it had done there. Many elements of most cultures have bad points is it ok to wipe them out as a result?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread