Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Channel crossings

338 replies

Tevion28 · 18/11/2021 16:29

Whats your thoughts on this are these people really desperate fleeing worn torn countries do you feel sorry for them etc

OP posts:
wightwine · 26/11/2021 16:33

@woodhill, why are you allowed to be here? your dgps were foreigners. you have the nerve to say a multicultural society has been forced on 'us'. are you 'us'?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/11/2021 16:26

I can't answer for the government, thereisonlyoneofme, but remember once going for an interview at a local "law centre" - who incidentally were lying about being a service for everyone in order to get the funding, but were actually only taking asylum cases

At one point I asked how they approach claims of nationality, past hideous experiences and so on, only to be met with bemusement because they simply couldn't countenance the idea that everything might not be exactly as it was presented

Imagine my embarrassment when they offered me the job ... Hmm

popapoppadum · 26/11/2021 16:26

This thread makes me desperately sad. I am very close to a large number of asylum seekers through my circumstances and their stories are horrific. You can't begin to imagine what these people have been through.

By sheer luck of the draw we have been born in Britain and I don't think many realise just how lucky they are. I'm not diving into the politics but just want to ask that if people feel strongly either way about this issue, get out and talk to these people before finalising your judgements. Listen to the lives of the people most affected by these politics.

thereisonlyoneofme · 26/11/2021 16:19

As many destroy their IDs how does the Government decide if they are genuine asylum seekers if they dont know where they are from ? Do they just take their word for it ?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/11/2021 15:57

I agree there may not have been amnesties from Jan '20 to June '21, Zotter, though there are still plenty of other ways dishonest governments can (and do) fudge the figures over the years

However I understand there's currently pressure for another one, and along with too many who they lose all track of, I'd be surprised if anyone has a definitive idea of just how many are actually in the country, far less who they all actually are since many destroy their ID

Zotter · 26/11/2021 15:41

[quote Puzzledandpissedoff]Concerning the % whose claims are successful, it's worth remembering the number may include the many thousands who've been granted an "amnesty" in one of the periodic attempts to fiddle the figures clear backlogs. The link below is from 2011, but it would be interesting to know what that figure is now:

www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/jun/02/160000-asylum-seekers-granted-amnesty[/quote]
I have read now your post above. I have now read in full the Refugee Council report too released last week. As said, Refugee Council say it is likely 61% of those coming over on small boats will be granted asylum and 50% of those who appeal after being refused initially are granted asylum, so around 80% in total.

The refugee council say they got this figure by examining the data for the grant rates at initial decision stage for decisions made in the period Jan 2020 – June 2021. I think it’s unlikely there has been any amnesty measures during that period.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/11/2021 14:09

In fact, rates of people refused leave to stay have been falling even further since those figures (they understandably dropped like a stone when no-one was travelling due to covid of course).

mustlovegin · 26/11/2021 14:08

France is a safe country.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/11/2021 14:08

@Zotter

We can't deport them because there is nowhere to send them that will accept them.

If they are refused asylum some are deported back to their home country if you look at govt reports. Those U.K. can’t send back to third countries are those who come through other countries as we have few bilateral agreements, nor is it supposed to happen according to international law.

We have a pretty low rate of repatriation or deportation - this is from Migration Watch, but it's from Home Office Officially Published figures -

On average, over 60% of those who were refused asylum or some other form of international protection after having applied for it during the period 2004-2017 did not leave the country. This amounts to nearly 120,000 failed asylum seekers remaining here over the entire period, or 8,500 people per year (a number have been granted amnesty by stealth – in 2011 it was revealed that the government had given settlement to over 160,000 people as part of what was called a ‘backlog clearance’ exercise, including failed asylum seekers).

Zotter · 26/11/2021 13:20

especially by the hardly-disinterested Refugee Council

The govt don’t give the full story either.

Zotter · 26/11/2021 13:18

We can't deport them because there is nowhere to send them that will accept them.

If they are refused asylum some are deported back to their home country if you look at govt reports. Those U.K. can’t send back to third countries are those who come through other countries as we have few bilateral agreements, nor is it supposed to happen according to international law.

Zotter · 26/11/2021 13:14

@Puzzledandpissedoff, thanks will read.

vast majority of the remaining 39% will never leave the UK anyway.

It’s not 39% as half win on appeal.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/11/2021 13:00

@Puzzledandpissedoff

A report by the Refugee Council released on Monday using Home Office data and requests under freedom of information laws has concluded that 61% of migrants who travel by boat are likely to be allowed to stay after claiming asylum

I already mentioned this upthread, but the % figure who are allowed to stay will also reflect the amnesties brought in over the years to relieve pressure on the immigration authorities and massage the numbers in order to appear to be "dealing with the situation - I posted a Guardian link last Friday at 20.46 if you want to read it

As so often, what's presented - especially by the hardly-disinterested Refugee Council - and what's the real case can differ

It doesn't actually make a lot of difference anyway - the vast majority of the remaining 39% will never leave the UK anyway. We can't deport them because there is nowhere to send them that will accept them. That's part of the pull factor - a bit like the old adage about possession being 9/10ths - once they are here, the vast majority aren't going anywhere else, whether or not they are granted asylum.
Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/11/2021 09:06

A report by the Refugee Council released on Monday using Home Office data and requests under freedom of information laws has concluded that 61% of migrants who travel by boat are likely to be allowed to stay after claiming asylum

I already mentioned this upthread, but the % figure who are allowed to stay will also reflect the amnesties brought in over the years to relieve pressure on the immigration authorities and massage the numbers in order to appear to be "dealing with the situation - I posted a Guardian link last Friday at 20.46 if you want to read it

As so often, what's presented - especially by the hardly-disinterested Refugee Council - and what's the real case can differ

pinknikes · 26/11/2021 08:23

It's all very well to have empathy for the genuine refugees (or even, for example, the many economic migrants from countries such as Pakistan who are told by the smugglers to chuck away their documents and say they're Syrian) for having the misfortune of being born in a 2nd/3rd world country.

Demanding we fling open the gates, referencing the Jewish refugees of WWII, and flinging the racist label about doesn't make you a more enlightened or better person...than those of us who feel empathy but have the objectivity to see the reality of the situation.

pinknikes · 26/11/2021 08:16

My comment stating we should have open borders because "our ancestors were immigrants thousands of years ago" / "we deserve to be punished for colonialism committed by the wealthy elites of Old England" was a sarcastic one.

Zotter · 25/11/2021 20:02

Sorry I have not read through the thread. I feel compassion for these desperate people. To those asking why do they come to the U.K., it needs to be remembered France has four times as many asylum seekers as the UK, and Germany even more. The U.K. take in 1% of global refugees.

A report by the Refugee Council released on Monday using Home Office data and requests under freedom of information laws has concluded that 61% of migrants who travel by boat are likely to be allowed to stay after claiming asylum. Data also suggests half of those who appeal after losing at the initial decision stage approx win the right to asylum.

According to the report, 98% of those coming across on small boats apply for asylum. This is in contradiction to Pritti Patel who told the House of Lords last month: “All the data and evidence has shown this – that in the last 12 months alone, 70% of the individuals who have come to our country illegally via small boats are single men, who are effectively economic migrants. They are not genuine asylum seekers.”

More crossings are by small boat now and not lorry as security at the Port of Calais in France - where UK border controls are - has been tightened, CoVid has also played a role.

Charities say that asylum seekers in northern France hoping to reach the UK to claim asylum should be able to register their claim with UK officials and then be placed on ferries to be brought to the UK while their claim is processed. If such a scheme was adopted it would achieve what the government has repeatedly promised to do: smash the the business model of the people smugglers.

The U.K. should also allow more refugees to come via resettlement schemes, refugee resettlement is only offered to a very small number of people fleeing conflict. Despite the promise of more safe routes, the number of people resettled under the government’s UK resettlement scheme was 1,171 in the 12 months to September 2021, down by about 45% year on year. Operation Pitting airlifted 15,000 people out of Afghanistan this year and the UK government resettled around 5,000 Syrians a year following the Syrian conflict. Refugee charities are calling for these schemes to be expanded.

Finally, efforts to end global conflicts should continue to be pursued. Apparently the UK’s Department for International Development (DfID) did a great deal of work aimed at this before it was axed as a standalone department and merged with the Foreign and Commonwealth Office in 2020. DfID worked to strengthen the infrastructures of fragile countries in the hope of increasing stability there.

Allycott · 25/11/2021 19:17

@clarepetal

You CAN help them! You could donate £37 weekly if there's a charity set up for it. But don't stop there - sponsor a family of four! After all the money for this needs to come from somewhere.

User135644 · 25/11/2021 19:12

@Parker231

Refugees don’t have to apply to the first country. Turkey has taken 3.7m refugees from Syria. What has the U.K. done - taken 20,000. The U.K. is pathetic!
How many has Russia taken, or Japan? Why is the onus on a little overpopulated island thousands of miles away?
woodhill · 25/11/2021 18:59

But who is going to pay for this?

How about the government sorting out its own population's needs first e.g. affordable housing

Youcunnyfunt · 25/11/2021 18:57

Do I feel sorry for them?

It feels condescending to say I feel sorry for people I have never met. I wish everyone had access to the same privileges and opportunities. It makes me sad that many people struggle so badly in war torn countries.

It is almost always the case that the males in the family start a new life elsewhere, and then bring the rest of the family over when it is safe, and home and work are secured. That’s nothing new. The government should have been fully anticipating this and putting measures into place.

Youcunnyfunt · 25/11/2021 18:50

Ah Russia, that well known charitable country.

Grin
User135644 · 25/11/2021 18:43

It's not fair to expect an island to take in so many people all the time. Why aren't Russia doing more? Or other countries with vast space.

FreshFreesias · 25/11/2021 18:41

It’s mostly healthy young men making the dangerous crossing and they make it less likely that genuine refugees get a chance. Survival of the fittest I guess but the gov is failing to keep our borders safe.

User135644 · 25/11/2021 18:39

@Allycott

And when shall we close them? When we have doubled our population? When the infrastructure collapses? When a civil war breaks out? When the UK becomes too shit to live in that ITS residents seek asylum elsewhere?
We made this mistake 20 years ago. A huge influx of people but without the infrastructure improvements to match. Now we have a housing crisis and public services stretched to virtual ruin.

How many people can our island really sustain?

Swipe left for the next trending thread