Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Channel crossings

338 replies

Tevion28 · 18/11/2021 16:29

Whats your thoughts on this are these people really desperate fleeing worn torn countries do you feel sorry for them etc

OP posts:
woodhill · 18/11/2021 19:55

Why is Poland allowed to sure up its borders but we aren't

I think it is dangerous for the UK that so many young men are arriving here. It feels like an invasion

AllesAusLiebe · 18/11/2021 19:53

I'd rather see a fairer and safer route for actual refugees- including women and children

Exactly. Until this happens, the only winners are the people smugglers.

Also, this way it would be possible to check who these people actually are.

Branleuse · 18/11/2021 19:50

@Chloemol

France is not war torn. The agreement is asylum seekers seek asylum in the first safe country they come to

I don’t believe these are asylum seekers but economic migrants pushing their luck

They are Frances problem and should be sent back to them

How fucking unfair to the countries bordering is that attitude. UK is more than happy to go to war but as soon as its helping the civilians fleeing, somehow not our problem
LakieLady · 18/11/2021 19:49

@Tevion28

I really don't think alot are getting what people think they get they are usually not entitled to benefits unless they regulise thier stay which can be very difficult in this country.
Asylum seekers are not entitled to benefits. They become entitled to benefits only when they are granted refugee status and have leave to remain in the UK.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/11/2021 19:49

@Chloemol

France is not war torn. The agreement is asylum seekers seek asylum in the first safe country they come to

I don’t believe these are asylum seekers but economic migrants pushing their luck

They are Frances problem and should be sent back to them

Even if this was true - France won’t take back people who have made it here so that won’t work.
Tabbacus · 18/11/2021 19:48

If the government supported the vulnerable in our society, and we, as one of the wealthiest countries in the world didn't have children skipping meals because their parents can't afford to feed them, women fleeing abuse weren't holed up in tiny bedsits for long periods, people waiting on social housing lists for literally decades, areas with few opportunities, families plunged into poverty if one of them becomes unable to work through illness or disability etc, people could access timely and appropriate healthcare I'm sure people would be more welcoming. There are areas hugely affected by high levels of economic migrants, it's faux nativity and disingenuous to say otherwise.

I'd rather see a fairer and safer route for actual refugees- including women and children (it's all very well to say men send money home, but many women and children are in great physical danger in these countries; also these young men don't all have families), rather than boatloads of people who can afford thousands to make the journey.

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 19:47

@Chloemol

France is not war torn. The agreement is asylum seekers seek asylum in the first safe country they come to

I don’t believe these are asylum seekers but economic migrants pushing their luck

They are Frances problem and should be sent back to them

That's an EU agreement and post-Brexit it doesn't apply to the UK.
LakieLady · 18/11/2021 19:46

@Tevion28

Are those places supervised though
I have a friend who came here as an asylum seeker, and on the basis of her experience, I'd say not.

When she was in the asylum seeker hostel, she was raped, assaulted, racially abused and utterly traumatised. And all that after being imprisoned and tortured for 3 weeks by the government of her country of origin.

(She succeeded first time with her asylum application and has had fantastic help from some refugee support organisations. Since being in the UK she has got a degree, a good job, extensive therapy for her PTSD and has been working for 3 years.)

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/11/2021 19:45

@DGRossetti

That does leave a significant minority who are not and who will mostly remain here.

I though the new normal was to ignore anything less than 52% ?

Good grief.
Chloemol · 18/11/2021 19:45

France is not war torn. The agreement is asylum seekers seek asylum in the first safe country they come to

I don’t believe these are asylum seekers but economic migrants pushing their luck

They are Frances problem and should be sent back to them

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 19:39

@Tevion28

From what I hear most asylum cases are unsuccessful in the uk so in some respects they never move on with thier life here because they are stuck in the asylum system for years with no decision surviving on £37 a week then end up working illegally.
48% are unsuccessful, around a third of them (16%) appeal.

Of that 16%, around a third (so just over 5% of total applications) succeed at appeal.

So slightly more than half of asylum applications are successful.

Source: commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn01403/

I feel really sorry for them. How desperate must people be to take a notoriously dangerous crossing in a small boat?

DGRossetti · 18/11/2021 19:23

That does leave a significant minority who are not and who will mostly remain here.

I though the new normal was to ignore anything less than 52% ?

FuckingPissedOff · 18/11/2021 19:17

@RuggerHug Because in the past Britons 'migrating' by choice (not seeking asylum or fleeing anything awful)never resulted in war or any issues.

Not sure I quite see the relevance. We all know about colonisation etc. There is one ever so small difference though - the population levels and density of the land. Where people from the British Isles colonised in the past, as in loads of people settled elsewhere, they did so in lands that were not in use by agricultural peoples - Australia, New Zealand, America. It is slightly different when Britain is already full.

And Britain is full, it is is one of the more densely populated countries in the world, and does not have the resources to feed all the people here. Land is over-farmed, soil qualities are falling and nutritional levels and production are falling. Distribution is an issue: but resources are finite.

JunoMcDuff · 18/11/2021 18:44

daimbarsatemydogsbone

As many as want to come if I'm honest.

But I don't believe we're "full". I don't believe our NHS is inadequate or our incapable of taking the extra. I don't believe there's not sufficient housing. I believe our government doesn't want to fund these things sufficiently, doesn't want to put the laws in place to prevent empty second homes and won't commit to build more school places.

I certainly don't think it's the fault of refugees (economic or other) and I don't think it's the fault of British born poor people either. I believe it's a failure of those in charge.

eightlivesdown · 18/11/2021 18:43

I understand why people want to better their situation, but it's not tenable to have worldwide open borders where anyone can live anywhere. The illegal route is also discriminatory, favouring those who are physically strong enough to travel and wealthy enough to pay people smugglers. Equally deserving people are left behind and people smugglers profit from human misery.

VladmirsPoutine · 18/11/2021 18:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

EnrouteNOTonroute · 18/11/2021 18:31

I think the people facilitating their arrival here are probably “selling” the U.K. to them as there’s simply so much money to be made from these vulnerable people. That, coupled with the U.K being relatively tolerant makes it a massive pull.
Some of these people smugglers charge many many thousands…they’re rubbing their hands together with glee at all this. Yes some die, but statistically, if you’re in a dinghy…you’re probably getting here and they know that.
Remember that truck full of Vietnamese migrants - they were sold the dream and they ended up dead.

Floundery · 18/11/2021 18:30

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/11/2021 18:25

@LittleLottieChaos

Some stats for those just making random assumptions about these refugees. I don’t think think the DM shares these kinds of figures.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/nov/17/most-people-who-risk-channel-boat-crossings-are-refugees-report

“The analysis contradicts the government’s narrative that people coming across the Channel are not refugees. The reality is that people who come to the UK by taking terrifying journeys in small boats across the Channel do so because they are desperately seeking safety having fled persecution, terror and oppression.”

Good points - 61% approx are refugees.

That does leave a significant minority who are not and who will mostly remain here.

Theunamedcat · 18/11/2021 18:22

At one point the French were supporting them to make applications to come to UK legally what happened to that?

AlbusDumbledore2234 · 18/11/2021 18:17

The UK is the land of milk and honey.

Lineofconcepcion · 18/11/2021 18:16

And I think many businesses would welcome anyone to come and join their businesses. We are desperately short of nurses, doctors, drivers, baristas, shopworkers etc etc. The reason these businesses are struggling to find employees is because of the hostile Brexit environment which has meant many of them have returned to their country of origin. Is that a good thing? Hardly.

LittleLottieChaos · 18/11/2021 18:14

Some stats for those just making random assumptions about these refugees. I don’t think think the DM shares these kinds of figures.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/nov/17/most-people-who-risk-channel-boat-crossings-are-refugees-report

“The analysis contradicts the government’s narrative that people coming across the Channel are not refugees. The reality is that people who come to the UK by taking terrifying journeys in small boats across the Channel do so because they are desperately seeking safety having fled persecution, terror and oppression.”

Lineofconcepcion · 18/11/2021 18:12

And I absolutely agree there is a major issue surrounding housing in this country, and that's because governments won't do anything about it. It is within their power to ensure when housing is built that a proportion is social housing that is needed in the immediate area, but I see local to me that is not happening.

The PRS are not at fault here, rents are increasing because this government has made being a landlord a hostile environment and many landlords are leaving the sector. Who will be housing people?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/11/2021 18:11

@WhittersE

What are the reasons for our poor housing options, homelessness etc ?

Off the top of my head, very quickly I would say: 'right to buy', non existent social housing, the fact that we build a small amount of 'affordable' rather than 'social' housing, the number of people with second homes, and the ridiculous renting/private landlord situation in this country, build to rent, short tenancies, affordability of rent, the number empty homes in this country. All of these probably have a much bigger impact on housing in this country than asylum seekers. (For example, the end of private tenancy is the leading reason for homelessness in England).

Speaking of homelessness, the on-the-street homeless people I work with all there because they can't get a place in a shelter/hostel (there usually are places, but they're not allowed in). There are for various reasons but the most common are being banned for drink/drug use, a history of violent/criminal/sexual behaviours which make them too risky to take again, mental health problems (ex-military with untreated ptsd etc). If there were adequate services to support these issues, homelessness in this country would look very different.

So agreed, these issues aren’t caused by having too many people from elsewhere coming here - but they are still issues that exist and cannot be quickly or easily solved so it’s hard to see how adding more people will help anyone (them or us) unless/until the issues are addressed? Or is your contention that adding more people is ok because even though we are short of housing it’s not their fault? Having trouble following the logic.