Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Channel crossings

338 replies

Tevion28 · 18/11/2021 16:29

Whats your thoughts on this are these people really desperate fleeing worn torn countries do you feel sorry for them etc

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 28/11/2021 10:20

@mustlovegin

You’d be bonkers to think there wouldn’t be a huge amount of opposition

On what grounds will they 'oppose'? We are a sovereign state and they will have to accept it

Is that you Boris?
thereisonlyoneofme · 28/11/2021 10:19

redirect where

mustlovegin · 28/11/2021 09:19

You’d be bonkers to think there wouldn’t be a huge amount of opposition

On what grounds will they 'oppose'? We are a sovereign state and they will have to accept it

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 28/11/2021 09:06

@mustlovegin

I reckon it would only take redirecting two or three vessels to somewhere other than the British Isles (so never allowing them to set foot here illegally) to stop this madness once and for all. No drama, no loss of lives and no wailing from human rights 'organisations'. Publicise this new hard stance to death in all possible media and the attempted crossings will stop once the penny drops they will not be allowed in. It just requires authorities to grow a back bone. Stop talking to France as they don't seem to be interested, quite the opposite.

You wouldn't be allowed to board a plane to travel anywhere in the world without the proper visas and paperwork, this should be no different.

No drama or wailing? Are you serious? Look at the outcry when Australia tried a similar tactic. You’d be bonkers to think there wouldn’t be a huge amount of opposition.
Quincythequince · 28/11/2021 09:05

@ExtraOnion

… if we want to stop illegal migration, maybe we should stop selling weapons to totalitarian regimes, that terrorise their own citizens, and the citizens of neighbouring countries. ..want to stop asylum, let’s start taking a stronger stand on human rights , and stop doing business with countries who abuse women, kill political dissidents, and punish the LGBTQ community …want to stop human traffickers, and people coming over on boats.. have a properly managed scheme, where we take a fair share on displaced people.

This country makes billions trading with the regimes that these people are fleeing, we accept misery so we make our money. If it comes back and bites us on the arse, it’s all our own fault.

Couldn’t agree more!
Quincythequince · 28/11/2021 09:03

Last post didn’t quite Juno’s saying more tax is paid by incoming AS/economic migrants etc than millionaires.

Also your post re we have room, NHS can cope etc… simply not true, as it currently stands!

Quincythequince · 28/11/2021 09:02

This is categorically not true Juno.
And you simply don’t understand our system of taxation if you think it is.
You do yourself, and this cause no favours by promulgating false narratives around the state of British infrastructure either.

The NHS is in a bad way, we do have a shortage of housing, school spots, care services etc!

Should it be this way in one of the richest countries in the world? No.

But it is, and until we change how we run this country and spend our taxpayers money, we have a problem with how to try and care for these people.

And I’m all for supporting genuine AS as well and think we can, and should do more. But it requires top down change.

logsonlogsoff · 28/11/2021 09:00

Of course I feel sorry for people so desperate that they’d risk drowning in the freezing Channel. How could you not? You can still wonder why they’re taking that final risk while
Feeling sorry for them.
The
Conditions in the French camps are appalling according to every report I’ve read.

mustlovegin · 28/11/2021 08:57

I reckon it would only take redirecting two or three vessels to somewhere other than the British Isles (so never allowing them to set foot here illegally) to stop this madness once and for all. No drama, no loss of lives and no wailing from human rights 'organisations'. Publicise this new hard stance to death in all possible media and the attempted crossings will stop once the penny drops they will not be allowed in. It just requires authorities to grow a back bone. Stop talking to France as they don't seem to be interested, quite the opposite.

You wouldn't be allowed to board a plane to travel anywhere in the world without the proper visas and paperwork, this should be no different.

Xenia · 28/11/2021 08:17

I am not sure. I believe the people we airlifted from Afghanistan were put in hotels for 3 weeks due to covid and they were not required the £3k a family a British person who had been away and had to quarantine from a red country at that time had to pay which felt a bit annoying as some of them were fairly rich journalists and lawyers.

Allycott · 27/11/2021 23:48

Does anyone know if asylum seekers are subject to covid checks? Just thinking about the new variant. Actually even before this - do the isolate?

ExtraOnion · 26/11/2021 22:55

… if we want to stop illegal migration, maybe we should stop selling weapons to totalitarian regimes, that terrorise their own citizens, and the citizens of neighbouring countries.
..want to stop asylum, let’s start taking a stronger stand on human rights , and stop doing business with countries who abuse women, kill political dissidents, and punish the LGBTQ community
…want to stop human traffickers, and people coming over on boats.. have a properly managed scheme, where we take a fair share on displaced people.

This country makes billions trading with the regimes that these people are fleeing, we accept misery so we make our money. If it comes back and bites us on the arse, it’s all our own fault.

Fomofo · 26/11/2021 21:54

Poppapopadoms, completely agree and Miss minutes 24, no-one is suggesting 'taking entire populations'

Xenia · 26/11/2021 21:09

In the UK and internationally we need to look again at the various rules as they are not working for many countries and for people.

Lineofconcepcion · 26/11/2021 20:01

@popapoppadum I agree, I worked at a legal aid immigration solicitors. Although I didn't do immigration law myself I did a lot of work on the periphery and what happened to men and women and children in some of these countries is sometimes too horrendous to contemplate. The human rights record in some of the countries they are fleeing is pitiful. We have to give people fleeing persecution a safe haven for as long as they need.

popapoppadum · 26/11/2021 19:15

@daimbarsatemydogsbone I agree. I also have many concerns about the processes of asylum claims but I despair at people's ability to seemingly turn off their humanity when discussing it. What is the point of those politics if not to improve humanity? I'm just asking people to keep emotion and compassion in the mix when deciding what is the best course of action.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 26/11/2021 17:23

It’s so depressing that the “they must claim asylum in the first safe country they reach” zombie fact continues to circulate

This is not true

fullfact.org/immigration/refugees-first-safe-country/

JustAnotherPoster00 · 26/11/2021 17:16

They are meant to stop in the first safe country.

Says who?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/11/2021 17:06

@popapoppadum

This thread makes me desperately sad. I am very close to a large number of asylum seekers through my circumstances and their stories are horrific. You can't begin to imagine what these people have been through.

By sheer luck of the draw we have been born in Britain and I don't think many realise just how lucky they are. I'm not diving into the politics but just want to ask that if people feel strongly either way about this issue, get out and talk to these people before finalising your judgements. Listen to the lives of the people most affected by these politics.

Recognising our many blessings and having empathy for others don't preclude the ability to also have some concerns about who we share our island with and what the processes should look like. Having a view about a policy isn't automatic personal hatred, or racism or xenophobia (and I know you didn't level that accusation but it is a common one).
wightwine · 26/11/2021 16:46

@woodhill are you a part of the indigenous population?

woodhill · 26/11/2021 16:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

NeverForgetYourDreams · 26/11/2021 16:40

@kaztastic

Is France war torn?
This

They are meant to stop in the first safe country.

woodhill · 26/11/2021 16:39

The other side of the family have been here for generations.

MissMinutes24 · 26/11/2021 16:38

@popapoppadum

This thread makes me desperately sad. I am very close to a large number of asylum seekers through my circumstances and their stories are horrific. You can't begin to imagine what these people have been through.

By sheer luck of the draw we have been born in Britain and I don't think many realise just how lucky they are. I'm not diving into the politics but just want to ask that if people feel strongly either way about this issue, get out and talk to these people before finalising your judgements. Listen to the lives of the people most affected by these politics.

But I don't understand this argument.

Yes it's luck of the draw just as its luck of the draw not being born to a heroin addict or being born to a prince.

But what are Western countries expected to do? Take the entire populations of Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Somalia, Libya etc? If you agree that's an unreasonable stance how is it fair only to take a handful? (Who are probably the strongest, smartest, most capable already).

woodhill · 26/11/2021 16:37

I was born hereConfused

How rude