Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want another baby so that I can do it right?

31 replies

Donttakethecake · 18/11/2021 13:30

Let me try to explain. I don't actually want another baby. I'm late 30s, having a baby wouldn't be practical for so many reasons.

I need to try and reframe my thinking.

Whenever I hear of someone getting pregnant or having a baby in the perfect circumstances I get a pang of jealousy.

Both of my dc were born through less than great circumstances. Ds1s father became violent and treated me like absolute crap resulting in me having to flee a few days before giving birth. His father has never bothered with him. I've been a good mum to him, but still feel sad about how he was brought into the world. It was a lonely time.

Then with ds2 my now dh had a wobble early on in the pregnancy and again, treated me like crap, decided he didn't want a baby after all, then insisted on telling his parents before the scan against my wishes. Although he did come round and now absolutely dotes on ds I can't forget those early weeks and months. After ds was born I allowed way too many visitors some who were rude and far outstayed their welcome (think a neighbour sitting there for 4 hours).

I wish I'd been more assertive and put myself first because it ruined what should have been a happy time.

Both dc are older now, happy, healthy, wonderful little people, we are all settled. It's just that jealous, sad feeling I get whenever I see families doing everything the right way.

OP posts:
weegiemum · 18/11/2021 13:45

I agree with what the pps are saying, no one does it "right".

But I really get where you are coming from. I had severe PND with all 3 of my dc and to be honest my mental health was poor throughout their childhoods. I wasn't the best mum to them. They've had their own struggles because of my MH. Now they're about to all be adults (ddd2 is 18 in less than 2 weeks) and while I wouldn't want another baby (I'm 50!) if I could go back and do it all again with good MH then I would.

Wannakisstheteacher · 18/11/2021 13:45

DD was premature and I recall feeling desperate for another baby to almost redo it ‘properly’. Then I realised that another non premature baby wouldn’t make DD any less premature so it was an utterly pointless feeling. It was a very powerful feeling though so I do get it.

ICalledYouLastNightFromGlasgow · 18/11/2021 13:42

@MsAgnesDiPesto

There is no right way. You have no idea what goes on behind other people’s doors, so don’t let social media fool you and make you feel less.

If you want to do it right from here, then I would concentrate on making your existing children’s lives as good as they can possibly be. Starting again with a new baby feels dismissive of them and their childhoods, as if they’re somehow tainted or defective, and not fixable. They might not have had the ‘perfect’ start, but you can do everything in your power to make up for that now.

This.

Also, how would you be giving a baby a perfect start when you don't want a baby? I'm confused

PrudishCheese · 18/11/2021 13:39

Well you must remember OP that those families who are, what you say is, "doing it right" will have their own things going on.

No one has the Facebook perfect life they present in real life. You won't see the neighbours staying for 4 hours, or the nights of no sleep which cause the arguments the next day and so on...

No one necessarily "does it right". There are things I wish I'd done differently when mine were born but you can't live your life like that, there will be others who would look at me and wish they'd done what I did and on it goes.

We all just do, no one's way is better than someone else. There are all sorts of bumps in everyone's life that you likely won't always know about and the likelihood is it wouldn't be "perfect" even if you were to have another baby now.

TheEncouragingStranger · 18/11/2021 13:37

Nobody's doing it perfectly. Everybody would change something about how things went, or how they'd do things if given another chance etc.

I watched a friend have another baby soon after her 1st, because she wanted to try doing it better (the things she perceived as "bad" had been completely out of her control), and it was very much like she was replacing the first with a "better version" - wanting a better sleeper, a better feeder, a less fussy baby etc. Her eldest was totally normal for a baby, but she was convinced she could do better. It was very sad to see.

If you're in a good place now, with your older 2, and you don't actually want a baby for the baby itself, then I'd say don't do it. If something isn't perfect next time round, how many will you keep having? ;)

MsAgnesDiPesto · 18/11/2021 13:37

There is no right way. You have no idea what goes on behind other people’s doors, so don’t let social media fool you and make you feel less.

If you want to do it right from here, then I would concentrate on making your existing children’s lives as good as they can possibly be. Starting again with a new baby feels dismissive of them and their childhoods, as if they’re somehow tainted or defective, and not fixable. They might not have had the ‘perfect’ start, but you can do everything in your power to make up for that now.