Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to get this car on PCP?

114 replies

Yummyy · 18/11/2021 12:58

It costs £17000… we have a deposit of around £5000 and pcp payments would be around £200 per month for 4 years. Then £5000 to pay if we want to keep it. We are very likely to be in a better financial position in 4 years time (due to not having to pay childcare anymore and potential pay rises) and will probably just go for a different car.

What are the pros and cons of PCP?

OP posts:
safariboot · 18/11/2021 15:14

If you plan on keeping the car PCP probably isn't the best option. And if it does work out cheapest, be sure to set aside the money for the balloon payment.

There is no guarantee a new car will be trouble-free or that the repairs will be paid for! The only time I've been stuck on the side of the motorway was in a family member's new on-finance German luxury car, and the dealership blamed them for the fault and they had to pay for the repair. Never had any trouble with my own old Japanese city car.

SusieBob · 18/11/2021 15:03

I've just searched for cars on autotrader within 100 miles of where I am, and actually 5k really doesn't get you very much apart from little city cars with >60k on the clock or just complete bangers.

I'll say it again -> used car prices are MENTAL at the moment. If I go on WBAC I am being offered 8k for a 5 year old astra with 40k on the clock.

Which, frankly, is extremely tempting.

coatofmanycolors · 18/11/2021 15:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the request of the user.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 18/11/2021 15:01

Depends what you mean by respectable for 5k
I’ve just looked on the AA website and for that price your looking at a car that’s about 8 years old and has done about 70k miles
Obviously there’s some outliers but unless you know loads about cars that kind of car is a risk to buy. You could easily spend that 5k and then in a years time the car completely clap out and you have to buy a new one.

nancywhitehead · 18/11/2021 14:54

@TotallySuper

The naysayers seem to be those who still think £2000 will get you an amazing solid and reliable car that will run for years. Even £10k won't get you that at the moment.
£5000 can get you something respectable and you would not spend £12,000 on repairs for it over a four year period unless you were extremely unlucky. Therefore that would be the better decision financially.

If people want shiny new cars they can't afford because it makes them happy, there's nothing wrong with that, but don't pretend it's a good financial decision because it's simply not.

Motherhubbardscupboard · 18/11/2021 14:51

@inmyslippers that's the whole point of a PCP. You don't suffer the depreciation because you hand it back at the end having only paid what you would have lost in depreciation anyway (on a new car). What doesn't make sense here is why the deposit is so high, there are much better deals to be had.

SpeckledlyHen · 18/11/2021 14:51

Up until a few years ago I shuddered at the thought of PCP and always purchased my cars outright for cash. I had been in a lot of debt when much younger (irresponsible with store and credit cards) and vowed never to get into any debt ever again apart from my mortgage.

However, I started a new job about 4 years ago with a large commute and not able to be done by public transport. My old car was now coming up to 10 years old and the bills were getting higher and higher every time it went in for a service and major things were starting to go wrong with it. I talked to a friend at the time and they explained it as renting the depreciation of a new car.

I added up the purchase value of my old car I paid cash for, then added in every repair (but not servicing and tyres as you pay those regardless of own versus pcp) I had spent over the years I had the car. One was a new clutch after 12mths of owning it which cost 2k. Then I divided it by the months I owned the car, the total value was about the same as the monthly PCP. For that I had a brand new car every 3 years or the ability to buy it or hand it back. It was a no brainer for me and whilst I am still financially able to and working it is the way forward for me.

I actually ended up being very fortunate, when mine last pcp was due to go back after 3 years (this year) they were gagging for second hand cars and paid me well over the odds of the remaining balance.

SusieBob · 18/11/2021 14:51

"If you can't afford it, get something cheaper."

Which is great and all, but 2nd hand cars are silly money at the moment, meaning that when things settle down again there depreciation is going to bite people in the arse even on 2-3 year old cars.

With a bit of shopping around PCP/leasing makes a great deal of financial sense at the moment.

TotallySuper · 18/11/2021 14:49

The naysayers seem to be those who still think £2000 will get you an amazing solid and reliable car that will run for years. Even £10k won't get you that at the moment.

nancywhitehead · 18/11/2021 14:48

If you have £5000 now, you can get a perfectly decent car without taking out any loan whatsoever.

If you did this, and saved the money you would otherwise have used on this car, in four years time you will have £12,000 in the bank. Yes some of it will go on repairs, but it won't be £12,000.

Sorry but I think you are bonkers to consider what you are proposing over this.

TotallySuper · 18/11/2021 14:48

@inmyslippers

It's debt on an item that will depreciate in value. If I can't afford it in cash, then I can't afford it. No such thing as good debt
So you've never had a mortgage? Or used 0% finance and kept your money in savings therefore actually earning money on the debt? There's loads of ways to use debt in a "good" way.
cookiemonster2468 · 18/11/2021 14:45

@inmyslippers

It's debt on an item that will depreciate in value. If I can't afford it in cash, then I can't afford it. No such thing as good debt
This.

I wouldn't do it.

No one needs a £17,000 car. If you can't afford it, get something cheaper.

Franklin12 · 18/11/2021 14:41

I have had both PCP and Personal Lease and I have to say getting a new car every 3 years is fab. I do about 12-15,000 miles per year but do look after my cars. I had company cars for years and also in the old days much older cars. I love the fact that you dont need to worry about them.

I think the people who say they have a 20 year old car, nothing wrong with it etc are often handy around any repairs or know people who can patch them up cheaply. I agree with others. The cost of second hand cars is shocking and you dont have the comfort of knowing its band new.

TotallySuper · 18/11/2021 14:39

@Valeriane

Its debt and its not smart debt. By a second hand car outright.
You clearly haven't bought a car for quite a while

Car stocks are at an all time low due to brexit and covid hence putting the price of what's available (mostly old dogs!) Up massively. Therefore you'd end up spending way over your ideal budget for a car that's not really worth it, with limited warranty and all the costs involved in servicing, MOT etc on something that's likely to cost £££ in repairs etc going forward as it'll be a bit of an old over priced dog in the first place.

OP go for it.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 18/11/2021 14:37

We have just got a PCP car 7 months ago after previously using HP for my previous cars, it was silly to keep using HP as I never keep a car longer than the length of the HP do PCP worked out best for us. We have it on a low interest deal, set over the annual mileage I do and I have the security of knowing it is covered for warranty etc for the next year or so.

Fatgalslim · 18/11/2021 14:06

I'd never do it again, it wasn't my choice, it was my ex who got it but I took over the finance. I can hand it back in December without any penalties or I can settle the finance, I'm selling it and settling and will come out with around 3k according to various valuations. I've barely used it though, it's an 19 plate and only has 6400 miles on the clock, despite paying for 10k annually.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 18/11/2021 14:00

We always said we would never get a car on PCP and would never buy a brand new car.
We've just done both.

Our car was £18,000 new. Very similar figures to what you have provided, OP. An almost 3yr old car would have cost us £16,000. On top of the second hand cost would be new tyres, MOT costs etc so actually worked out more expensive than buying brand new. We were lucky enough to be able to find the exact car coming into the country a couple of weeks after we enquired. If we'd have had to wait the minimum 4mths advised, we might have gone second hand.

What we'd rather have done was get a loan, but the rates were ridiculous. Of course the day we signed the PCP agreement we got the nod for a cheaper loan than PCP, but it was too late by then.

VividGemini · 18/11/2021 13:47

It's not only debt - at that rate its about 7-8% interest.

Daddydog · 18/11/2021 13:46

Often with leasing you can beat the depreciation and don’t have to worry about it for the 3 years you have it. Secondhand cars always seem to mysteriously develop an issue the minute you decide you want to sell it. Usually that’s the reason why someone is selling in the first place! Then you have to deal with weeks of tire kickers and low ball offers until you give up and sell for less than you wanted. Unless you buy a car to run into the ground it doesn’t make sense to own these days.

Frazzledbutcalm · 18/11/2021 13:46

You can increase the annual mileage - check what your contract is and how many miles you need - increase BEFORE you sign your contract.

Dd gave her car back a few months early, no problems, no hassle - had to pay the remainder months balance but she knew that. Figures all added up, car collected without problems.

bingoitsadingo · 18/11/2021 13:44

Do the maths, add up the TOTAL figures, and see if it works for you.

We bought a 1 year car outright. Looked into all the finance deals, PCP etc, as everyone was swearing you get better deals, but when you add up the total amount paid over however many years it didn't work out cheaper.

Everyone always says the finance companies subsidise the purchase price as they make money off the finance... but who is paying the finance costs? The customer!

EatSleepRantRepeat · 18/11/2021 13:44

I've had both PCP and bought outright, and you have to be really careful to get the maximum value from it. The APRs can be ludicrous on PCP, mine was 12% APR but we didn't have a couple of grand sitting around at the time to buy a second hand one. At the end of the contract you literally own nothing from the money you have already spent, unless you have also saved for the bubble payment in that amount of time. As PPs have mentioned, any damage comes out of your pocket to get it to good as new, so to get a good deal this needs to be done before the hardback at a garage you choose, not by the car company. If you are stuck at home like in lockdown or on furlough, you're paying every month for something you can't use.

However, if you're using it very very often for activities where you're completely reliant on a car, it can be very reassuring to have one within warranty which is unlikely to break down or need a lot of garage time for repairs. I'd never buy a brand new car because the loss in value happens so quickly, but nearly-new can get some good deals, especially if you can wait a year or two.

Ignore that the servicing and MOT is sometimes included, as MOT charge is minimal and set by the government and servicing on a non-luxury car is rarely above £300 per year. Try and work out how much the overall cost is over the 3 years and get some comparison quotes, eg from carlow or autotrader.

inmyslippers · 18/11/2021 13:39

It's debt on an item that will depreciate in value. If I can't afford it in cash, then I can't afford it. No such thing as good debt

emmathedilemma · 18/11/2021 13:37

I've always bought new cars on 0% finance deals but last time i changed it there was none available so I looked into PCP but I couldn't get the figures to work for me, plus the uncertainty around the mileage restrictions felt too risky for me - my work can change location and my family are 200+ miles away so if anything happened with either of those it could drastically increase my annual mileage.
I bought mine with the old car as trade in, top up from savings and then took out a new credit card with 0% interest on new transactions for 12 months (with a plan to pay it off!) and a small car loan from Admiral which had very low interest rates. I also bought a pre-reg "ex demo" model which was technically second hand, thus saving 10% on the list price and it only had 13miles on the clock!

Mouseonmychair · 18/11/2021 13:36

It's horses for courses I don't like PCP but I run a 14 year old car worth less than your deposit even at today's expensive rates. The depreciation is nothing nearly and I will trade it in at 200 k maybe and repeat. If I wanted and could afford a new car each 3 years then a PCP might be the way to go. I certainly doubt it's cheaper long term as the finance companies have to make money.