Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to get this car on PCP?

114 replies

Yummyy · 18/11/2021 12:58

It costs £17000… we have a deposit of around £5000 and pcp payments would be around £200 per month for 4 years. Then £5000 to pay if we want to keep it. We are very likely to be in a better financial position in 4 years time (due to not having to pay childcare anymore and potential pay rises) and will probably just go for a different car.

What are the pros and cons of PCP?

OP posts:
Welshiefluff · 18/11/2021 22:36

Wow. I am amazed so many people have answers for you. There is nowhere near enough information supplied in your post.

If you earn £50k a year, have few outgoings and drive 15k miles a year then it sounds fine.

If you earn £15k a year, have other expenses and drive the shops and back once a week, then probably not.

noworklifebalance · 18/11/2021 22:36

What is the advantage of owning a car outright? Genuine question.

We can afford to pay the full price for a car but I’d rather keep the £25k in the bank for unexpected major expenses and hand over £300/month from our salary for 3 years.
I appreciate it’s different if you don’t have that security, in which case that is bad debt.

addictedtotheflats · 18/11/2021 22:33

I've had a number of cars on PCP. All brand new (apart from my current which was 18 months old). I view it as a lease, I don't plan to keep them at the end, ive never put a deposit down as it makes hardly any difference to payments and all been 0% interest. I don't have to worry about MOTs, services have all been with no advisories and I've got peace of mind. I've always had around 2K equity which I transfer to the next car, so kind of a deposit actually. You just need to be careful with damage to the car as if you did plan to hand it back once you have paid 50% of the loan you could be hit with repair charges.

noworklifebalance · 18/11/2021 22:29

@oknowimscared - I think we see agreeing with each other! I am just saying that PCP can be used to buy second-hand so it’s not necessarily bad for the environment if you switch cars after 3 years.

TotallySuper · 18/11/2021 22:26

@StillPerplexed

People saying second hand car prices are crazy are overblowing it. I've just been on auto trader now and there are plenty of cars for less than £1k that would run fine. Just do your research and pick a reliable model. Why pay thousands (with interest!) for no reason?

Everything now is payment plans, debts and subscriptions and it's just a way of bleeding yourselves by a thousand cuts. Better to own outright than sign up for future financial insecurity.

I'd love to see an example of what you've found for 1k 🤣
ulez · 18/11/2021 22:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

StillPerplexed · 18/11/2021 22:21

@SusieBob Sure, I can see the argument for paying more for something reliable definitely, but I don't see the argument for getting into debt over it.

SusieBob · 18/11/2021 22:16

@StillPerplexed

People saying second hand car prices are crazy are overblowing it. I've just been on auto trader now and there are plenty of cars for less than £1k that would run fine. Just do your research and pick a reliable model. Why pay thousands (with interest!) for no reason?

Everything now is payment plans, debts and subscriptions and it's just a way of bleeding yourselves by a thousand cuts. Better to own outright than sign up for future financial insecurity.

There is a huge difference for most people between a car which "runs fine" and something they can happily rely on. 1k round here buys you an absolute shitheap.
StillPerplexed · 18/11/2021 22:15

People saying second hand car prices are crazy are overblowing it. I've just been on auto trader now and there are plenty of cars for less than £1k that would run fine. Just do your research and pick a reliable model. Why pay thousands (with interest!) for no reason?

Everything now is payment plans, debts and subscriptions and it's just a way of bleeding yourselves by a thousand cuts. Better to own outright than sign up for future financial insecurity.

oknowimscared · 18/11/2021 22:13

@oknowimscared

I’ve always bought second hand before this car. And never thought I’d go near PCP. But it’s working out really well for me. Obviously it depends on individual circumstances, like most things in life. If you can get a 0% deal and save the balloon payment up, I see no problem with it.
That was meant to be a reply to @noworklifebalance (I’m hopeless at this!)
oknowimscared · 18/11/2021 22:11

I’ve always bought second hand before this car. And never thought I’d go near PCP. But it’s working out really well for me. Obviously it depends on individual circumstances, like most things in life. If you can get a 0% deal and save the balloon payment up, I see no problem with it.

SusieBob · 18/11/2021 22:07

Just to illustrate how mad used car prices are at the moment, I've had my current car 2 years, and paid just under 10k for it. 2 years later with 25k miles done, I have a quote from a dealer for 8.8k as I'm considering moving to an electric car.

To only lose 1k on a car over that period of time is utterly crazy. The problem is, of course, that lead times on new cars can be anything up to a year and so demand for used cars has increased massively.

3luckystars · 18/11/2021 21:59

Sorry I posted too soon, I should have said pcp is a trap if your income is in any way shaky. You will be left with nothing.

noworklifebalance · 18/11/2021 21:58

@oknowimscared

I’ve always been sceptical about PCP, but have done it with my new car. Because I love it and am confident I’ll still love it at the end of the 0% finance deal. (I’m hoping to pay it off early, which is fine, because 0%, but have set up a monthly transfer to a savings account to cover the end payment, to make sure) (one of the things I don’t like about PCP is it encourages us to change cars every 2-3 years. Which is really bad for the environment. So I won’t be a part of that)
You don’t have to buy a new car, you could buy second hand and someone can buy yours, which will obviously be second-hand, too, so not necessarily detrimental to the environment. Clearly, if you are happy with your car then there is no need.
GroggyLegs · 18/11/2021 21:55

@TotallySuper

The naysayers seem to be those who still think £2000 will get you an amazing solid and reliable car that will run for years. Even £10k won't get you that at the moment.
This. Honestly, we've been considering a banger but for 10k you get a shitload of potential hassle and a deeply mediocre 14 plate car which will still depreciate.

We worked out my DH was paying 600 a month in loan (0%) fees, depreciation and servicing on his old car. I only pay 310 for the lease of a new SUV, add on service and insurance & you're still better off with a newer car under warranty.

Must admit, I'm very aware its not 'mine' though.

oknowimscared · 18/11/2021 21:54

I’ve always been sceptical about PCP, but have done it with my new car. Because I love it and am confident I’ll still love it at the end of the 0% finance deal. (I’m hoping to pay it off early, which is fine, because 0%, but have set up a monthly transfer to a savings account to cover the end payment, to make sure) (one of the things I don’t like about PCP is it encourages us to change cars every 2-3 years. Which is really bad for the environment. So I won’t be a part of that)

noworklifebalance · 18/11/2021 21:47

The low mileage bit didn’t make sense and I can’t remember why I brought mileage into it!

3luckystars · 18/11/2021 21:46

Don’t do it !

If at any stage, you don’t make a payment, the car may be take me off you. It’s not like a car loan where you own some of the car, everything will be gone.

Go to the credit union and get a car loan instead. Don’t do pcp it is a trap. Good luck.

noworklifebalance · 18/11/2021 21:45

We bought previous cars outright - what’s the point? Apart from the current weird situation where there is a huge demand, generally your standard car does not appreciate in value so there is nothing to be gained from buying outright, esp if your mileage is low, as ours is.

We just bought an electric car second hand on PCP: £270/month for 3 years with deposit of £2500.
By the end of the 3 years we would have paid about £13k for a £25k car and then we will upgrade.

We could afford to buy outright but we’d probably be worse off financially as a result.
The car is electric so we anticipate in 3 years there will be significant improvements so we don’t want to be stuck with a unsellable old tech.

We know several people who use a work salary sacrifice scheme i.e. you are taxed on your income after your PCP payment has been deducted from your monthly salary. However, you would need to consider the impact on pension contributions.

Headteacher412 · 18/11/2021 21:37

I've tended to do similar deals and had a nearly new car every three to four years.

You are sensible to be putting a decent deposit in, as you are unlikely to end up in negative equity (ie needing to sell the car but finding it is worth less than you owe).

What you must factor in is that in 4 years time, you will have nothing left. The car will be worth £5k and you will owe them £5k. You either need to put aside around £100 per month additional (to create a similar deposit for next time), or reduce the final balloon payment to say £2500 by setting a higher monthly figure.

Otherwise, in four years time, you'll be back to an old car as you won't have any deposit to put towards the next one.

Pootle40 · 18/11/2021 21:22

Only ever had a car on PCP. Works for me

scarpa · 18/11/2021 20:55

@MoonbeamSprinkles

Oh my god Scarpa that sounds utterly terrifying!!

And expensive.

It was the scariest driving experience I've ever had, and I regularly drive the M62 at rush hour haha 😅!

I think the car could sense my hatred of it though - when I bought it the central locking didn't work properly so I spent a lot of time calling it the Bastard Bus. I think it was trying to spite me...

MoonbeamSprinkles · 18/11/2021 20:30

Oh my god Scarpa that sounds utterly terrifying!!

And expensive.

scarpa · 18/11/2021 20:21

@MoonbeamSprinkles

Depends what you mean by respectable for 5k I’ve just looked on the AA website and for that price your looking at a car that’s about 8 years old and has done about 70k miles Obviously there’s some outliers but unless you know loads about cars that kind of car is a risk to buy. You could easily spend that 5k and then in a years time the car completely clap out and you have to buy a new one.
Precisely just what's happened to me. After my hire purchase car was written off in an accident a while ago, I decided to buy a 7 year old Citroen outright. 59k on the clock, £4900, thought I'd be able to run it into the ground and get a good 5 years out of it.

I expect to pay for e.g. new tyres and brakes, and the odd thing going wrong with a slightly older car.

But as well as new brake pads and 4 new tyres, it's had a radiator leak and has developed an oil leak, it needed a new clutch, a new timing belt(/chain?) and a new starter motor, and - my favourite - both front suspension springs went within 2 months of each other. The second one went while I was driving on a dual carriageway, pinging the spring deep into my tire. The force of my tyre being suddenly dragged at speed nearly made me crash at 60mph and broke the drive shaft. At that point - having spent a fortune getting the fucker repaired and constantly living in fear during my (only weekly but long-ish) commute because I didn't know what else was going to break that apparently isn't covered in an MOT - I was just absolutely done. Maybe my dad's right on both of his mantras (that I have some kind of motoring curse and that French cars are the devil's work) but it was just not worth the constant hassle and unpredictability.

I don't have a car now, I can get the train to work so I've just started doing that, but next time I will be going for nearly new or a new one on PCP. Worth the peace of mind.

Alarchbach · 18/11/2021 20:04

I’ve just put a deposit down on a brand new car on PCP. I always buy cars on finance, usually 3-4 year old and generally change them every 4 years.
I’ve never had a brand new car but this time around it was cheaper, I’m paying 0%APR. The fact I’ll never really own it doesn’t bother me as I change mine every few years anyway.

What I would say is check the mileage. I only do around 6000 miles a year (less during Covid) and my payments have only gone up about £3 a month to increase it. So it’s worth checking different options x