Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you shouldn't be claiming benefits if you've just bought a house outright?

115 replies

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 12:39

I've posted about this before- ex paid noting in CM for years then about £140ish per month for a couple of years and has them about 3 nights per fortnight but buys them NOTHING. Two dc.

He recently inherited enough to buy a £200k house in cash. There may well be more money, I don't know though it couldn't be that much more don't think. I have to pay him £10k as marriage equity in about 10 years.

I just got a letter to say his CM contributions will now be nil as he's on benefits??? I just can't believe it. I feel sick. I don't rely on the money but how much of a kick in the teeth can it be? and surely he shouldn't be able to claim benefits with that money?

I've rung CM and because he's on benefits and has them at least 52 nights per year there's nothing they can do. He has arrears too which he could have paid.

Can I report him somewhere? He's ignoring my messages. I want to email him mum or something. I'm off work with stress and this has tipped me over.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 18/11/2021 14:21

When you say “on benefits” I assume that due to his MS he gets PIP. That’s really hard to get and isn’t means tested so his inheritance means nothing in terms of that.

Playing a gig a week is entirely different to being able to hold down a full time job when you have MS.

But sure, report him if you must.

Ragruggers · 18/11/2021 14:20

Try to put this aside it will just make you unwell.He is a useless individual.Not giving anything for the children is so awful but don’t waste time thinking of his actions nothing will change.The children will see him for who he is and see you as their lovely Mum who did everything for them.He will be the loser,take care.

Justgorgeous · 18/11/2021 14:16

I think to skip over the fact he has MS so quickly is a bit harsh. My friend has had this for years and it’s an awful disease that some days getting out of bed is a huge effort. He should pay maintenance of course but he will be entitled to some benefits with MS.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 18/11/2021 14:14

Should someone be able to buy a house outright and then claim benefits to live? Yes. If, for eg, I inherited enough to buy a house I could do so and then 'save' the taxpayer £800 pcm in housing benefit. But I'd still need the rest of my UC to live on.

Of course that is dependent on actual amounts. Eg I inherited millions and bought a grand country house that was far bigger than I need it would be unfair. If I inherited enough to buy a suitable sized house but didn't have anything left after it would be a different matter.

Should NRPs get away with not paying any maintenance. No. The CMS is a fucking joke.

beigebrownblue · 18/11/2021 14:10

I think there is some kind of rule whereby if you receive money for the purpose of buying a house...

I'm so sorry you experiencing this.

It took me eight years to get even some of what I was entitled to from ex and even then...

Sounds like a brat that's true.

Pazuzu · 18/11/2021 14:09

Sucks for you personally OP but from the taxpayer perspective, being able to stop paying housing benefit is a massive long term saving.

The second it becomes his residence, it ceases to be an asset (as makes no sense to then have to house him when he has a residence).

What I would be doing is ensuring that he makes the children the sole beneficiaries of the will so that they get any something out of him somewhere down the line.

Merryoldgoat · 18/11/2021 14:05

I’ve said YABU.

Because you are expecting decent and reasonable behaviour from a proven irresponsible feckless man.

He is entirely at fault but your anger will eat you away if you don’t let it go.

Live your life, do the best you can for you and your DC and pretend you never met him.

He’s scum.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 18/11/2021 14:01

@PingedPotato

Don't email his mum. Don't message him about it. Go to CMS and explain the inheritance. Report him for potential benefit fraud if you have suspicions. Do it all through the proper channels and let them sort it.
This.
coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 14:00

Raisedby Pangolins

Your situation is entirely different and of course your benefits shouldn't stop just because your house has gone up in value. Tbh, I do get how it would be misguided to say that someone in a house they own outright should have to sell up or lose benefits as, apart from any other issues, like fairness, it would be more expensive for the state in the long run anyway. But my issue is him coming into a large sum and giving not a thought to his dc, spending it all on a house he could have got cheaper/doesn't needs (lives in another city with his sister when not seeing the dc) and then cuts CM to zero.

I'm sorry my title is clumsily worded though Flowers.

OP posts:
Thecathouse · 18/11/2021 13:59

Universal credit - if he was given inheritance money then used it to purchase a home then they will see this as him using income that should have been used in lieu of benefits. Once you have that money you use it for living expenses and stop claiming benefits until the money dries up, univers credit are very strict on this. If they find out he has done so they will treat it as if the money is still there and remove his entitlement to benefit anyway.

He would only be allowed to use the money to purchase property If he was on non means tested benefit (PIP / DLA/ contributions based job seekers, contributions based ESA) and not claiming any means tested benefits

Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/11/2021 13:58

Contact your MP. They have a history of being really helpful with CMS.

There isnt anything you can do about maintenance going forward because if he has no steady income then they wont calculate anything, but you can fight for the arrears.

Tell your MP how much he owes in arrears and how much he just inherited. Quote the CMS own powers to them. They can register an interest in the house, they can force the sale of a house to pay off arrears, they can remove his driving license, they can send him to prison.

They never do any of that because there isnt a push from a conservative government for them to use the powers but if you contact your MP and keep contacting them then you might get something.

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 13:54

Thanks for the responses.

Cordyceps I agree with almost all you say and have never questioned anyone's right to benefits before, but this has affect me personally so it's different (to me). Of course I see that there's lost of reasons why it would be wrong to say someone can't have benefits when they're in a house of their own but he came into that money knowing he owed arrears and bought a house not offering a penny to the dc. I think that's wrong.

He's just replied to me saying he has spent all but £1500 of the inheritance on the house and has done nothing wrong, which I suppose is correct legally, He also mentioned how he earns less than £10k per year and yet I take money he hasn't got. He just doesn't have a concept of supporting his children.

OP posts:
Wiredforsound · 18/11/2021 13:51

If he plays in a band does he get paid? If so I wonder if he’s paying tax on that…

NoBetterthanSheShouldBe · 18/11/2021 13:50

If he’s playing in a band every week he should be declaring the income from that, too.

dottiedodah · 18/11/2021 13:47

I find it incredible that men like this are so feckless! Yes he has MS ,but surely sick benefits are separate to any living costs /paying for DC.How on earth can this sort of thing happen FFS!

RaisedByPangolins · 18/11/2021 13:45

@CorrBlimeyGG

I think you're being unreasonable. Your ex should be paying CM, without question, but to suggest that no one should be allowed to claim benefits because they bought a house outright is completely unreasonable. Owning your own home provides security, and reduces the burden on the state in terms of benefits paid.

Separate the two issues. Your ex is a git. Your judgment of people on benefits is ignorant.

Agree with this entirely. I get tax credits because I’m on a low income. I work hard full time and support 3 DCs in our family home, which has a chunk of equity in it due to rising house prices. I can’t access that money without selling the house as I don’t earn enough to pay the extra on my mortgage if I released some equity.

My plan is to downsize to a smaller house that I can buy outright with my equity and then my outgoings will be reduced by £700 a month. At that point if I’m still on a low income and entitled to tax credits I will be better off, however as the kids grow up, and the lone parent benefits and child maintenance stop, I’ll be significantly worse off.

I don’t see why I should chip away at my equity, which will hopefully give me a security blanket into old age too, rather than claim the help to which I’m entitled.

Nobody pays my mortgage for me, whereas if I rented I’d get a housing element to my benefits to help pay for it, so by buying my own place I’m saving the government money on housing benefit.

I agree he should be paying maintenance even if only a small amount due to his circumstances but don’t tar all claimants with the same brush.

Yummymummy2020 · 18/11/2021 13:37

He hasn’t broken rules by the sounds of it as others have said but he sounds like an absolute brat. I can’t believe he won’t be contributing to the kids. Disgraceful. I hope he starts giving money again soon.

Hoptoit1 · 18/11/2021 13:36

I said yabu because I get disability benefits and in 10 years time I will have paid off my mortgage but still have to claim benefits because I still need to pay the bills and I can't work. You also don't know how his ms is affecting him presently.
However you are not being unreasonable about cm. My ex hasn't seen dc or paid any cm in 16 years, dc is 17 and cm wrote off the areas years ago, ex gave up his job so didn't have to pay. He's now working but I'm sure if I went after him he'd give up his job again and I can't be doing with the mental load for £7 a week. So I understand your frustration but the two shouldn't be linked, he needs a roof over his head for him and his dc so buying a house seems sensible and means the government won't have to help him with rent as his condition deteriorates. He still should morally be paying for his dc, however how far you push this is upto you. I had to put my mental health first and stop chasing ex.

Cordyceps · 18/11/2021 13:31

If you qualify for a benefit then you should receive it. Full stop. Trying to make value judgments about who deserves and doesn't deserve help only makes people less likely to apply for what they really need, and allows the government to make even more cuts, supported by the public who eat up all all this bullshit about deserving vs. undeserving benefits claimants.
People who report others or complain about others' benefits allowance are the absolute lowest of the low and are the reason that the welfare state will probably not exist anymore in our lifetime. People will starve to death on the streets because we would prefer that to the idea that SOMEONE might be getting a little bit more than we think they're entitled to and we'll clap our hands and say too right as the welfare state dwindles to nothing.
If you want to get het up about something, why don't you worry about the billionaires and corporations who receive more undeserved "benefits" every day than every benefit claimant in the UK together will see in a lifetime.

Dddccc · 18/11/2021 13:25

As long as saving below 16k he can claim benefits he has bought the house out right so would not be claiming housing benefit entitlement as he his in a paid off house unfortunately nothing you can do he has not broke any rules what so ever

MumYourBabyGrewUpToBeACowboy · 18/11/2021 13:20

I agree with @ClitorisAllsorts

DDivaStar · 18/11/2021 13:18

Of course he should be working and paying maintenance.

There is no law against buying a house with inheritance, what exactly would you be reporting him for ?

MartyHart · 18/11/2021 13:17

You can claim when you own a house if you live in it. If you own a house you rent out then the income/equity is taken into account.

You can't live on capital tied up in a house you live in.

Bluntness100 · 18/11/2021 13:13

To be honest if he spent the money on a house and has less than the required level in savings he is now allowed to claim benefits. Plenty of people claim benefits who own their own home.

RandomLondoner · 18/11/2021 13:10

Housing equity in your own house doesn't count, if a house you own is being rented out then the income would be counted.