Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you shouldn't be claiming benefits if you've just bought a house outright?

115 replies

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 12:39

I've posted about this before- ex paid noting in CM for years then about £140ish per month for a couple of years and has them about 3 nights per fortnight but buys them NOTHING. Two dc.

He recently inherited enough to buy a £200k house in cash. There may well be more money, I don't know though it couldn't be that much more don't think. I have to pay him £10k as marriage equity in about 10 years.

I just got a letter to say his CM contributions will now be nil as he's on benefits??? I just can't believe it. I feel sick. I don't rely on the money but how much of a kick in the teeth can it be? and surely he shouldn't be able to claim benefits with that money?

I've rung CM and because he's on benefits and has them at least 52 nights per year there's nothing they can do. He has arrears too which he could have paid.

Can I report him somewhere? He's ignoring my messages. I want to email him mum or something. I'm off work with stress and this has tipped me over.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 18/11/2021 18:02

@Minceandonions

Yes that's really unfair. I don't know how benefits work, but know someone who has done the same - been on benefits for a decade or more whilst doing a degree and writing a book. Noone in the house works. But they've just bought a house outright, paying cash from inheritance, and are renting it out to private tenants. Is this allowed, or is there a scam going on?
The house they own should be regarded as capital because they don't live in it and, as it will almost certainly be over £16k in value, would disqualify them from means-tested benefits.

However, if the inheritance was placed in a discretionary trust by the testator, the property bought with the inheritance may also be legally held by the trust and then it will not count as capital. The income deriving from it may not count as income for benefit purposes if the rental income goes back to the trust before being disbursed by the trustees.

Hont1986 · 18/11/2021 17:55

If you think the alternative to him being a carer is him getting a full-time job, then I suppose. I'm not sure that is the realistic alternative though.

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 17:54

Well, as I said, I see no reason why he wouldn't tell me about it if he was as I was accusing him of benefit fraud/not supporting the dc. If he had said he was having to claim for a disability that would have shut me down and he would have enjoyed that - any maybe that would have been fair enough.

Also have clicked on the link for PIP and I really don't think it describes him. but shall we just agree that if he is claiming it I am UR maybe? I mean, no one here knows that he is, do they? And I do think if he is and his condition has deteriorated so much he should tell me. Lack of communication is a nightmare when co-parenting.

OP posts:
DrCoconut · 18/11/2021 17:53

If you separate out the issue of maintenance and buying a house it is not unreasonable to claim benefits to which you are properly entitled after buying a house. For example in the case of an inheritance but not being in a well paid job. You are actually claiming less as no rent element is then payable and you will not need housing paid for in your old age. The maintenance is a different issue and seems all too common regardless of house buying status.

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 17:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 17:41

@Hont1986

If his sister receives PIP, and he lives with her (or did?), then I expect he's getting Carer's Allowance, which is not means-tested.

It would also exempt him from having to look for work if he claimed UC, regardless of his capability to do so.

That's interesting to know. So he can effectively decide to care for his sister instead of supporting his dc? Obviously, I don't know that he has done this but it makes me wonder if that's what's going on.
OP posts:
Hont1986 · 18/11/2021 17:38

Why should the government / tax payer pay for this though? We would all love a bit of free money I'm sure!

Do you seriously think that someone shouldn't be able to claim benefits if they have a house and a car?

What if they even have, God forbid, a flat-screen TV?!

Hont1986 · 18/11/2021 17:35

If his sister receives PIP, and he lives with her (or did?), then I expect he's getting Carer's Allowance, which is not means-tested.

It would also exempt him from having to look for work if he claimed UC, regardless of his capability to do so.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 17:12

Why should the government / tax payer pay for this though? We would all love a bit of free money I'm sure!

Free free to claim UC and love this "free money".
It is so much more than money going into your account... it is worrying about it being stopped at any time, worrying about the intrusive assessments to claim it, scared to sell anything of value for extra cash in case someone reports you, having to declare a penny over £6k because someone gifted you money, not being able to save anything decent for things like vet bills, a car, holidays etc.
It is fucking miserable.

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 17:06

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

daffodils123 · 18/11/2021 17:01

@Hont1986

Ok, so let’s say you had a windfall, eg winning the Lottery. You buy a great house, a Range Rover, have a few holidays and then have less than £16k left over. Do you really think you should be able to claim benefits?

I do. I genuinely do. I don't want a system where people are expected to sell their family homes before they can receive any help, or penalised because they went on holiday when times were good. Are they supposed to eat the memories?

Why should the government / tax payer pay for this though? We would all love a bit of free money I'm sure!

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 16:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 16:58

I don't know if his sister gets PIP but I would imagine she does.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 18/11/2021 16:58

@DottyHarmer

Ok, so let’s say you had a windfall, eg winning the Lottery. You buy a great house, a Range Rover, have a few holidays and then have less than £16k left over. Do you really think you should be able to claim benefits?

Apparently on the MoneySavingExpert one of the most asked questions is how can people continue to claim benefits after getting an inheritance.

Someone who wins the lottery and only has 16k left after a house, car and holiday (and you wouldn’t be allowed to have multiple) isn’t winning multi million pounds.

A friend of DH’s inherited 150k. She’s disabled and had claimed housing benefit her entire adult life. Her condition id degenerative. She was allowed to buy a house, that was easily adaptable for her as she worsens. She no longer claims £1600 a month in housing benefit. She also won’t need help with social housing once she degenerates to a level that her private rental won’t accommodate.
Why is that not a sensible option rather than taking away all benefits and then in

Hont1986 · 18/11/2021 16:53

Does his sister get PIP?

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 16:52

He doesn't get Pip! I have known the man for 20 odd years and he throws every sob story known to man at me to justify not paying. If his MS was preventing him from working and/or he was claiming PIP or DLA he would 100% have replied to my messages this morning telling me I'm a heartless cow and what do I expect him to do when he's disabled etc etc. And maybe he would have point if that was what was happening, Obviously we don't keep abreast of each other's news, but what reason would he have not to tell me this if I'm asking him why his CM payments have stopped?

I also know two other people with MS - one has to use a wheelchair 2 years after her diagnosis and the other is in the same job as me, has had it for 20 odd years and, while she has days with a lot of fatigue, most people would not know she had any sort of condition. Both work. It's an unpredictable disease that's different for different people and at different times, but I do know that he is able to work at the moment in the line of work he does. It doesn't make me a wannabe PIP assessor but I don't think he gets a free pass because of his condition. And housing benefit isn't being saved as he has a place with his sister.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 16:50

@DottyHarmer

Ok, so let’s say you had a windfall, eg winning the Lottery. You buy a great house, a Range Rover, have a few holidays and then have less than £16k left over. Do you really think you should be able to claim benefits?

Apparently on the MoneySavingExpert one of the most asked questions is how can people continue to claim benefits after getting an inheritance.

Benefits would not cover the upkeep/bills for a great house and Range Rover.
Hont1986 · 18/11/2021 16:49

Ok, so let’s say you had a windfall, eg winning the Lottery. You buy a great house, a Range Rover, have a few holidays and then have less than £16k left over. Do you really think you should be able to claim benefits?

I do. I genuinely do. I don't want a system where people are expected to sell their family homes before they can receive any help, or penalised because they went on holiday when times were good. Are they supposed to eat the memories?

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 16:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DottyHarmer · 18/11/2021 16:41

Ok, so let’s say you had a windfall, eg winning the Lottery. You buy a great house, a Range Rover, have a few holidays and then have less than £16k left over. Do you really think you should be able to claim benefits?

Apparently on the MoneySavingExpert one of the most asked questions is how can people continue to claim benefits after getting an inheritance.

LampLighter414 · 18/11/2021 16:30

Don't hate the player, hate the game.

Presumably no rules have been broken and no fraud has taken place (innocent until proven guilty).

If you care that strongly join or set up a campaign group or lobby your MP for changes.

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 16:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PingedPotato · 18/11/2021 16:24

@Hont1986

He can work. I'm not being harsh, but I know he can work. And the gig is quite demanding physically - he plays sax, which is a heavy instrument that takes a lot of energy.

OP, you have a bright future as a PIP assessor.

Hehe so true.

OP if you think his benefits are falsely claimed then challenge them but it is haaaard to get PIP so if it's that be prepared that it might be a legitimate claim. He doesn't have to keep you updated on his health.

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 16:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Hont1986 · 18/11/2021 16:21

He can work. I'm not being harsh, but I know he can work. And the gig is quite demanding physically - he plays sax, which is a heavy instrument that takes a lot of energy.

OP, you have a bright future as a PIP assessor.