Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you shouldn't be claiming benefits if you've just bought a house outright?

115 replies

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 12:39

I've posted about this before- ex paid noting in CM for years then about £140ish per month for a couple of years and has them about 3 nights per fortnight but buys them NOTHING. Two dc.

He recently inherited enough to buy a £200k house in cash. There may well be more money, I don't know though it couldn't be that much more don't think. I have to pay him £10k as marriage equity in about 10 years.

I just got a letter to say his CM contributions will now be nil as he's on benefits??? I just can't believe it. I feel sick. I don't rely on the money but how much of a kick in the teeth can it be? and surely he shouldn't be able to claim benefits with that money?

I've rung CM and because he's on benefits and has them at least 52 nights per year there's nothing they can do. He has arrears too which he could have paid.

Can I report him somewhere? He's ignoring my messages. I want to email him mum or something. I'm off work with stress and this has tipped me over.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nancybotwinbloom · 19/11/2021 18:30

Why isn't it law that inheritance is only released if CMS arrests are cleared from said inheritance. Surely that's an easy step for probate to include?

whynotwhatknot · 19/11/2021 18:01

i would look into it op as a secondary residence even if it is to see the dc it could be argues he could just take them back to hs main residence once a fortnight instead

its an extra asset that hes probably not declaring to the cms or hmrc

Lettucebegin · 19/11/2021 08:26

He is a disabled man. Presumably knows his own limits as to whether he can work or not, and it's not your place or anybody else's to assume he can. Having MS can make even the simplest task hard, and it can often take days to recover from having one single busy day. It's also largely invisible. You aren't going to see any pain/fatigue/weakness he may be struggling with. Comparing him to others with MS is unreasonable and unfair.
You're his EX. You aren't going to see his daily struggles and nor should he have to justify to you for you to make your judgements on what he should/shouldn't do.
Disabled people are also allowed to enjoy themselves/have a social life. That doesn't mean he's capable of holding down a full time job. You've said yourself you're currently off work with stress. I'm not sure why you can see that it's necessary for you but assume somebody with a constant physical disability should work.

That being said, yes he should pay for his children and hopefully you can come to some sort of fair arrangement. Everything else you've said is very unreasonable.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 18/11/2021 20:46

@Malibuismysecrethome

Sorry but your ex has MS, presumably multiple sclerosis. I don’t know how you can say he is unaffected. He is probably claiming benefits for ill health. I don’t know if it is still the case but insurers used to pay out life assurance if you had the diagnosis of MS.
Yes - MS tends to count as a ‘critical illness’ for the purposes of Income Protection insurance
coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 20:27

He's had it 20 years and people are affected differently, plus there are some pretty effective ways of managing it now which seem to be working well for him. Gigs every week, holidays, plans to move abroad - he's not incapable.

OP posts:
Malibuismysecrethome · 18/11/2021 20:14

Sorry but your ex has MS, presumably multiple sclerosis. I don’t know how you can say he is unaffected. He is probably claiming benefits for ill health. I don’t know if it is still the case but insurers used to pay out life assurance if you had the diagnosis of MS.

coffeerevelsrock · 18/11/2021 20:09

This is what I don't know. If he is actually his sister's carer then I can't see that changing so he will still mainly live in the other city. I believe he keeps a house in my city so that he can have a base here to see the dc. But he's never there apart from when the dc are here (about 3-4 nights per fortnight, less over the summer). Buying this house saves him having to rent somewhere here and means he keeps his money safe. He is utterly shit with money and were it not tied up in a house it would be pissed up the wall in months - or a few short years. He knows this hence buying the house, saving on rent, and keeping the money safe until he needs it in a few years when he plans to move abroad. I don't know this for a fact but I'm pretty certain.

The thing is, I wouldn't want to shop him (if he has done wrong)- him having a base here is good for the dc and for me. He's shit but he's their dad and it least it gives me a break. Also, if he's his sister's carer - fair enough. What isn't fair is him making no contribution financially to the dc and me effectively subsidising his life choices. He could tell me not to worry about the £10k I 'owe', or he could make a contribution. Instead he's having his cake and eating it while telling me I'm the selfish one!

OP posts:
bakebeans · 18/11/2021 19:59

@ClitorisAllsorts actually, there are different types of MS. Progressive, secondary progressive, and some which are not debilitating. Some affect mood, eyesight, and others is physical. They have actually done autopsies on people who never knew they had it and found it.

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 19:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Udouhun · 18/11/2021 19:37

Give the authorities all the info and let them deal with it. It doesn't sound above board.

whynotwhatknot · 18/11/2021 19:34

wait he bought a house he doesnt live in?

so its a secondary resdicence-surely thats classed as an asset because hes already got somewhere to live

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 19:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Pigsears · 18/11/2021 19:24

He has form for 'outsourcing' the financial responsibility of his children to you.

This is unfair. But nothing you do will change this. He is solely focussing on him and his needs- whereas you are focussing on the children and you. You are doing more.

You mentioned you were on stress leave from your job- and that you had to keep in full time employment. Focus on you and your mental health- you need to be selfish here. Being annoyed with him isnt going to change him and it seems to be causing more frustration with you.

Be proud of where you are now and where you can go from here. You will succeed.

PinkMochi · 18/11/2021 19:01

@Kebabandchipsplease So what if someone already owns a house outright, then gets made redundant. Should they not be allowed to claim benefits as they own a house? Of course they should, and this is the same situation.

It is different if you are already a homeowner and suddenly need to claim benefits. That’s a change in circumstances. I think OP’s ex was already on benefits when he had over £200k in his bank?

Prestel · 18/11/2021 18:59

Although I agree with many posters that people should be allowed to use a windfall to buy a house within reason without it affecting benefits am I really in the minority in thinking a father who has £200,000 should pay the child maintenance he owes before spending money on himself? The OP is left with funding more than her fair share of the cost of raising their children out of her wages while he gets the full benefit of his £200,000 income. Whether within the rules or not, it doesn't seem right he can get out of his financial obligations to his children and keep all this money for himself. The OP really isn't being unreasonable to feel it's not fair on her, it's not like she can similarly spend more of her income on a bigger house as a nest egg for herself and then ask the state to pay child tax credits because she no longer has enough left over to feed her kids and yet this is kind of what the father is doing - leaving her or the state to pay for his children so he can keep all of his windfall for himself.

MurielSpriggs · 18/11/2021 18:44

Home owners are eligible for benefits.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 18:43

[quote PinkMochi]@XenoBitch unfortunately many younger people who work full time can’t afford a mortgage, let alone buy a £200k house outright. He could’ve bought a significant cheaper house so he could continue to provide for his dc.[/quote]
It depends where he lives. In some areas, a £200k house is the cheapest.

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 18:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

JKDinomum · 18/11/2021 18:42

Those saying the kids will get the house, only if he doesn't remarry or have more kids later on, or make a will leaving it to his best mate etc. If he can't be arsed to pay for his children now what makes you think he would plan to support them in death?

Kebabandchipsplease · 18/11/2021 18:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PinkMochi · 18/11/2021 18:33

@XenoBitch unfortunately many younger people who work full time can’t afford a mortgage, let alone buy a £200k house outright. He could’ve bought a significant cheaper house so he could continue to provide for his dc.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 18:24

[quote PinkMochi]@Kebabandchipsplease hmm comments about benefit fraud seem to have struck a nerve with you. He didn’t have to buy a £200k house outright. He should not be entitled to tax payer money if he had over £200k lying in his bank account![/quote]
So, people on benefits should never be allowed to buy property? They have to rely on shaky rental contracts and housing benefit until the day they drop?

CazY777 · 18/11/2021 18:18

We inherited some money whilst claiming housing benefit, it was disregarded for 6 months but we had to put it in a bond which we couldn't touch. We managed to buy a house outright, 300 miles away in the north (as it wasn't a lot of money). The woman at the council was so pleased that we'd done it! Obviously, we were no longer in need of housing benefit or social housing. If we'd stayed where we were and used it to live on it would be gone by now. As it happens, my DH's health has since deteriorated and we now claim other benefits, but we're still claiming a lot less than we would if we needed to claim the housing element.

PinkMochi · 18/11/2021 18:18

@Kebabandchipsplease hmm comments about benefit fraud seem to have struck a nerve with you. He didn’t have to buy a £200k house outright. He should not be entitled to tax payer money if he had over £200k lying in his bank account!

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 18:14

@Thecathouse

Universal credit - if he was given inheritance money then used it to purchase a home then they will see this as him using income that should have been used in lieu of benefits. Once you have that money you use it for living expenses and stop claiming benefits until the money dries up, univers credit are very strict on this. If they find out he has done so they will treat it as if the money is still there and remove his entitlement to benefit anyway.

He would only be allowed to use the money to purchase property If he was on non means tested benefit (PIP / DLA/ contributions based job seekers, contributions based ESA) and not claiming any means tested benefits

While he had the money, he wouldn't have been entitled to any means-tested benefits, but using the money to buy a home would not count as deprivation of capital and he would be entitled to means-tested benefits again (if he had lost entitlement) once he had bought the property, assuming that he had less than £16k left.
Swipe left for the next trending thread