Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think TV licensing are complete bullies?

366 replies

dabbydeedoo · 18/11/2021 09:24

I went online and said I didn't need a TV licence because I don't watch live TV (I don't). I then received a letter telling me someone would be round to check, and they could apply for a search warrant from the court if I didn't let them in.

Is it just me or is this absolutely ludicrous? We're in a pandemic and I have absolutely no intention of letting someone into my flat. And even if I did, what exactly are they going to do? I have a TV connected to my laptop that I use for watching streaming services and YouTube. Completely legal, but how on earth can they prove I don't watch TV on it?

It feels so bullying and scammy!

OP posts:
dabbydeedoo · 18/11/2021 17:58

@Tumbleweed101

I've never had a TV licence, genuinely don't use a TV and live services but it's got harder over the years to prove now we have computers and mobile phones.

Had one visit about 20 years ago which we let them in to see as it was easy then. No TV. No service lol.

Generally you up date them every few years and you get the threatening letters until you do the next update. They say they may visit. Which is fine if you aren't using the services but I have to triple check these days we are still eligible.

That's the thing, what's even the point of someone coming in? Yes, there's a TV, so what? Can't prove I use it to watch live TV on, can they?
OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 18/11/2021 17:50

I've never had a TV licence, genuinely don't use a TV and live services but it's got harder over the years to prove now we have computers and mobile phones.

Had one visit about 20 years ago which we let them in to see as it was easy then. No TV. No service lol.

Generally you up date them every few years and you get the threatening letters until you do the next update. They say they may visit. Which is fine if you aren't using the services but I have to triple check these days we are still eligible.

Snoozer11 · 18/11/2021 17:42

When I was a student we bought a licence as we did watch TV.

For the whole year, we received threatening letters telling us we needed a licence, despite having the paperwork to prove that in fact, we DID have one.

They are awful.

dabbydeedoo · 18/11/2021 17:18

I never open the door to people unless I'm expecting something or someone. I peer through the spyhole and see who it is but I don't open it. I don't think it's rude not to answer. I think it's more rude to turn up announced at someone's home! I have a lot of online meetings for work and I'm not always able to answer the door and chat to someone.

OP posts:
ColinTheKoala · 18/11/2021 17:11

@KeflavikAirport

This is a feminist issue. Women are more likely to be at home during the day and are socialised to open the door and let inspectors in, so women are massively over-represented in fines and prosecutions. In 2019, 73% of all prosecutions for TV licence fee evasion were against women, despite women only accounting for 49% of licence holders and around 1/3 of all women's convictions are for TV licence evasion.
Yeah well we need to stop oversocialising women to open doors to strangers.

There are a lot of people (women) on here who think it's rude and strange not to open doors to people.

I had to tell my mum and MIL to stop being so polite to doorstep callers and phone callers - that's when you get scammed.

KeflavikAirport · 18/11/2021 16:56

This is a feminist issue. Women are more likely to be at home during the day and are socialised to open the door and let inspectors in, so women are massively over-represented in fines and prosecutions. In 2019, 73% of all prosecutions for TV licence fee evasion were against women, despite women only accounting for 49% of licence holders and around 1/3 of all women's convictions are for TV licence evasion.

CounsellorTroi · 18/11/2021 16:56

Springwatch and Autumn watch are a nature programme with live coverage of birds nests, badger setts etc. They are quite popular.

Have to admit we don’t watch THAT much live TV but we do like our rugby and football, Strictly, David Attenborough, and make use of IPlayer to watch things like Pointless and QI.

JunoMcDuff · 18/11/2021 16:17

@CounsellorTroi

Finding it hard to believe none of you watch live sport... No football, tennis or Olympics? Or news?

No Royal weddings/funerals? No six nations rugby? No parliamentary coverage? No Springwatch/Autumnwatch?

No.

I like the royals, but do not enjoy weddings of anyone. I have no interest in funerals of people I do not know.

I don't like sport. Any sport.

I get extremely irritated and stressed by any parliamentary coverage so avoid it at all costs.

What springwatch/ autumwatch? I've never seen it but it doesn't sound like something that would interest me.

I watch very little. I prefer browsing the internet, reading and playing board games. When we do watch, its box sets and films, and we have Netflix for that.

We have a TV licence, but I honestly cannot tell you when I last watched live TV. We watch bake off on catch up. We don't have any TVs hooked up to aeriels.

Tommika · 18/11/2021 16:03

@DriftingBlue

As an outsider, it boggles my mind that tv licenses make more sense than just wrapping the payment into the general tax. So much money is being wasted on licensing and enforcement. Wouldn’t it be easier and cheaper all around to just make it a line item in the government budget and possibly raise everyone’s taxes by an infinitesimal amount in the process.
Then you get more complaints of “I don’t watch so why should I” pay for others

And government being responsible again - after they offloaded TV licence collection to the BBC
It becomes the nasty government again instead of the nasty BBC & Capita for the contract to do it

Tommika · 18/11/2021 15:57

@TurnUpTurnip

Oh ok i thought it flagged you up on the system for a visit as whilst I still get letters I don’t get visits anymore. another thing I remember but we are going back years but did you use to have to prove you had a license before buying a tv? I remember when I first left home and Argos wouldn’t sell me a tv unless I gave them my address to prove I had a license, I gave them my mums address but I had just moved out and didn’t have one as I only bought the tv to play PlayStation on.
This didn’t prove to Argos that you had a licence, but they had to collect the data for the licensing service. If that address didn’t have a licence and you purchased equipment capable of receiving TV transmissions then they would know
ElephantOfRisk · 18/11/2021 15:57

Isn't an element of it to also provide the infrastructure in terms of analogue signals which other stations would/could use? Regardless of whether they watch bbc, people watching other terrestrial channels (and freeview?) via their aerial will still need access to a infrastructure?

I mean I rarely watch bbc, I don't believe that they are as impartial as they used to be in their reporting etc however I do have a licence.

What I object to is the tone and hounding from the licence people.

Tommika · 18/11/2021 15:51

@SirenSays

Maybe this is a daft question. Can someone explain why and how the BBC are entitled to this money? If its about BBC content creators being paid fairly that's fine, but if I watch a show from ITV why would BBC creators be entitled to anything?

If I watched live sports or news on YouTube, amazon prime..and it's not being shown on a BBC channel, how are they entitled to any of that cash?

The BBCs licence to operate and under their charter are required to provide certain types of content - and also to not place commercial advertising in between programmes

Channel 4 was funded via the licence fee and also was required to provide similar content. It had a balance of advertising and public funding. They eventually opted to withdraw from public funding to remove the obligations

S4C still takes public funding from the licence fee, and also has obligations from that funding

LazyDragonTooth · 18/11/2021 15:47

I haven't had a licence in years, always declared online. Ever since I lived a year abroad and didn't miss live TV for a second. I own a TV though, attached to my PS4 and nothing else. I'm not sure how to get it on live TV! I realise now I've never set up a TV to watch, always lived in places with it set up until I stopped paying the licence.

I watch Amazon, get Netflix for a month twice a year or so just for a change. Watch DVDs on the PS4 or laptop, youtube, Twitch. So many other places to watch than just the BBC. I do wish Netflix was better in the UK though, it's rough finding anything on it to watch.

My big fuss was daring to a buy a TV after years of declaring not needing a licence. I got it for the PS4! Suddenly started getting a letter a week for ages, you declared you don't need a licence but you have a TV! How dare you! You must be watching TV! Give us money! Nope, nothing changed, I'm still not paying for something I don't use.

BeaucoupFish · 18/11/2021 15:46

@Cowpad
Well put 😂

Tommika · 18/11/2021 15:36

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

  • I don't have to write to DVLA to tell them I don't need a driving licence

Though you do have to write to DVLA telling them that you don’t use your car on the road

romdowa · 18/11/2021 15:20

They spent months writing me threatening letters when I actually had a tv license 🤣🤣 it was the last one I bought too. Every time a letter would arrive , I would call them and tell them that I had a valid license. It seemed that they just enjoyed wasting time and money sending these letters.

BertramLacey · 18/11/2021 15:14

Then you'll fall out of your own mind to know I didn't watch a second of dead Prince Philip coverage.

Spoiler alert - he's still dead.

Cowpad · 18/11/2021 15:08

Ignore the fuckers.they are nothing but insulting bullies.what annoys me most with their attitude is,they think nobody can live without watching telly.absolute assholes.just ignore their disgusting tactics.

girlmom21 · 18/11/2021 15:06

@TheCourse

They move the date, too. So if you pay your DD on 10th of the month, for example, that'll be fine for a while, then they move the 'payment due' date to 7th. So suddenly your payments are late, and they send scary letters. It's diabolical. I work with vulnerable elderly people, and this happens all the time.
I've paid via direct debit for 5 years and have never had this issue.
JustJustWhy · 18/11/2021 15:03

@SnackSizeRaisin

Finding it hard to believe none of you watch live sport... No football, tennis or Olympics? Or news?

Anyway the reason you have to pay it of you are watching anything live is because it's the law. It doesn't matter if you hate the BBC, if you watch (e.g.) live tennis on Eurosport, you need the licence.

I think they should get rid of the licence and take the cost from tax. The BBC is too important to lose. I would drop a lot of the entertainment stuff though and just keep radio 3 and 4 and the news, documentaries etc. I wouldn't be paying huge wages to celebrity presenters

Then you'll fall out of your own mind to know I didn't watch a second of dead Prince Philip coverage.
BertramLacey · 18/11/2021 14:53

Being pro-woke and socially liberal isn’t the same as not having a right wing/centre-right bias. The BBC’s coverage of Labour under Corbyn was found to be the right of ITV, to the right of Channel 4 and to the right of Sky News (yes, Rupert Murdoch of all people provided more balanced airtime coverage of Corbyn than the BBC). Also check out studies examining BBC’s coverage of the Middle East. Again, significantly to the right of Sky News etc. The BBC isn’t explicitly anti everything left, but it is pro British Establishment, which of course puts it at loggerheads with anyone to the right of Tony Blair. Objective it most certainly isn’t.

I think what people often forget about the BBC is that it is a very large organisation and that it doesn't operate entirely in one way. Much of its arts programming is quite liberal, at times heading into being more radical. Its news programmes are entirely different. If you look at the mess that is the Today Programme it's very clearly right wing. The BBC is part of the establishment and so some sections of it will not wish to bite the hand that feeds it.

I stopped watching and paying the licence fee when they decided that balance meant giving large amounts of air time to Farage, without actually making any attempt to question his outlook.

BertramLacey · 18/11/2021 14:44

Imagine content creators wanting to be paid for their time and effort. How about you pay the licence for using the service and then they won’t have to waste everyone’s time chasing you?

Imagine reading the OP properly.

I don't watch live TV or iPlayer. I get my news from newspapers, both print and online. I prefer European and American newspapers at the moment as they give more accurate information about the joy and delight that is Brexit and will happily show Johnson as the tremendous fuck up he actually is.

I have no need for any royal events as I'm a republican. I can't imagine anything more eye-wateringly boring than watching football or rugby. Granted some of the Olympics maybe, but since that's every four years I find it's not really worth the licence fee and I can just not watch.

And I find the pheasants in my back garden more informative than whatever the fuck it is MPs are up to, and rather less depressing.

I do pay for Netflix though. If the BBC moved to a model where you had to pay to get a log on they could ditch the whole licence palaver.

supermoonrising · 18/11/2021 14:44

People on all sides of politics accuse the BBC of being biased. That would seem to indicate that it's getting it about right.

Wrong. Being pro-woke and socially liberal isn’t the same as not having a right wing/centre-right bias. The BBC’s coverage of Labour under Corbyn was found to be the right of ITV, to the right of Channel 4 and to the right of Sky News (yes, Rupert Murdoch of all people provided more balanced airtime coverage of Corbyn than the BBC). Also check out studies examining BBC’s coverage of the Middle East. Again, significantly to the right of Sky News etc. The BBC isn’t explicitly anti everything left, but it is pro British Establishment, which of course puts it at loggerheads with anyone to the right of Tony Blair. Objective it most certainly isn’t.

Of course it’s also trying to ram wokeness and social liberalism down everyone’s throats. But having several separate agendas doesn’t equate to “balance”. It just means it’s as self-interested and unreliable as any other news broadcaster - good for them by the way. But don’t expect people to pay for it.

IncompleteSenten · 18/11/2021 14:30

It really should be an optional subscription like all the others. I really don't understand the BBC worship thing people have got going on.

Cam77 · 18/11/2021 14:28

@araiwa
Why are people bashing the BBC?
They don't do anything about chasing TV licenses- all done by capita, a private company

Why are people bashing the Mafia bosses? They don't whack people, it's just their hired goons.