Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think TV licensing are complete bullies?

366 replies

dabbydeedoo · 18/11/2021 09:24

I went online and said I didn't need a TV licence because I don't watch live TV (I don't). I then received a letter telling me someone would be round to check, and they could apply for a search warrant from the court if I didn't let them in.

Is it just me or is this absolutely ludicrous? We're in a pandemic and I have absolutely no intention of letting someone into my flat. And even if I did, what exactly are they going to do? I have a TV connected to my laptop that I use for watching streaming services and YouTube. Completely legal, but how on earth can they prove I don't watch TV on it?

It feels so bullying and scammy!

OP posts:
gildalily · 18/11/2021 11:14

My DSat uni has had the same OP. Made me really cross as the letter was unpleasant and threatening. He doesn't watch anything you need a licence for. It's outrageous that they treat you as guilty and need you to prove yourself innocent.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/11/2021 11:14

I think it's incredible that they can even get a warrant. They're allowed to enter my home, in a pandemic, at a time when I'm limiting interactions with people, to check I don't watch TV?

They'd never get a warrant from any Magistrate who actually did their job.

How would they even check anyway? I have a TV. It was here when I moved in and it belongs to the landlord. That doesn't mean I watch live TV or am obliged to pay for a licence. I also have a separate larger TV I use for streaming Netflix, watching Youtube channels and also as a monitor for big work meetings. None of this means I have to pay for a licence.

They mostly try to get in and then ask leading and or intimidating questions, tell lies and browbeat people to admit to stuff, whether they have done it or not. Sadly there are some poor and ill-informed people who are taken in by this.

I am not condoning people not having a licence who should do - but the tactics Crapita are always questionable at best.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/11/2021 11:09

@DontBeCatty

I don’t get why people find the letters so ‘threatening’. If you know you don’t need a license then just ignore them. I don’t understand the outrage. 🤷🏻‍♀️ There are loads of people who don’t pay their tv licenses so it’s not surprising that the tv licence people want to catch them. It’s similar to seeing ‘shoplifters will be prosecuted’ signs in shops. I know I’m not a shoplifter so I just ignore them.
Yeah but Tesco doesn't write to me threatening to come round and look in my fridge for stolen items that "they know I have". It's not the same and it's inexcusable that they act as if everyone is guilty. The tone is off.

I am sure if the checkout staff and security at shops continually accused you of shoplifting, you'd eventually feel it was unreasonable.

dabbydeedoo · 18/11/2021 11:04

@HarrietsChariot

They have to prove you guilty, you don't have to prove yourself innocent. They use bullying tactics like this because the only way they can prove you are watching TV without a licence is to catch you in the act or if you admit it.

If they turn up, don't let them in. Sure they can waste licence-payers' money getting a warrant, in which case you have to let them in. But unless you're watching live TV or using iPlayer at the time, they can't prove anything.

Remember you need a licence if you watch live streaming programmes. The TV Licensing website is deliberately vague about what this means. I understand if I watch a live stream of something that is also being broadcast I need a licence, but what if it's a live Youtube stream that is live on Youtube only and not a simulcast of a television channel? My interpretation is that it's not "live TV" therefore a licence isn't needed.

I think it's incredible that they can even get a warrant. They're allowed to enter my home, in a pandemic, at a time when I'm limiting interactions with people, to check I don't watch TV?

How would they even check anyway? I have a TV. It was here when I moved in and it belongs to the landlord. That doesn't mean I watch live TV or am obliged to pay for a licence. I also have a separate larger TV I use for streaming Netflix, watching Youtube channels and also as a monitor for big work meetings. None of this means I have to pay for a licence.

OP posts:
SpiderinaWingMirror · 18/11/2021 11:03

Presumably everything they issue letters, more people get a tv licence!

HarrietsChariot · 18/11/2021 11:01

They have to prove you guilty, you don't have to prove yourself innocent. They use bullying tactics like this because the only way they can prove you are watching TV without a licence is to catch you in the act or if you admit it.

If they turn up, don't let them in. Sure they can waste licence-payers' money getting a warrant, in which case you have to let them in. But unless you're watching live TV or using iPlayer at the time, they can't prove anything.

Remember you need a licence if you watch live streaming programmes. The TV Licensing website is deliberately vague about what this means. I understand if I watch a live stream of something that is also being broadcast I need a licence, but what if it's a live Youtube stream that is live on Youtube only and not a simulcast of a television channel? My interpretation is that it's not "live TV" therefore a licence isn't needed.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/11/2021 11:00

Imagine content creators wanting to be paid for their time and effort

Nobody's suggesting they shouldn't; if you use the service you pay for it, simple as that

But OP doesn't use it ...

DaisyNGO · 18/11/2021 10:57

@Namechangetimes100

What? The Mother f*ckers! I was told I needed one for Prime and Netflix which is literally all we watch. I couldn’t tell you the last time we put broadcast TV on or even tried to sign into I player…. Rage
No, that's rubbish. Did someone tell you that on the phone?

We deleted our iplayer login which probably helps.

Think of it as "no live TV allowed".

dabbydeedoo · 18/11/2021 10:57

@Platax so? That's my choice. They don't send me threatening letters about sending people round to enter my home if I choose not to subscribe to them. As it happens I don't subscribe to them - I use my partner's Netflix account.

Do you not think it's very entitled to bully people into paying for services they don't want?

OP posts:
nosyupnorth · 18/11/2021 10:56

It's madness.

TV licensing seems to be an area of this country where the foundational legal principal of 'innocent unless proven guilty' goes right out the window. I had letters from them recently, there's no "You don't have a license can you confirm if you need one or not" they go directly to accusing you of watching TV illegally and threatening to send their 'enforcement officers' around, like some sort of TV mafia.

It's absurd that in an era of many many alternatives to live broadcast television/the BBC they still feel so entitled to our money -- imagine if any other organisation just turned up at your house demanding you let their private goons in to search the place in order to prove your innocence of crimes they have no evidence or good reason to suspect you of, it's an utter violation of our rights to privacy and security in our homes and the presumption of innocence in our legal system.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 18/11/2021 10:55

I don't think it's bullying and I've never had a problem with them until recently.

Several months after moving house I started receiving the threatening letters about court etc as there is 'no TV license at the address'. I've been paying it since the day we moved in so was very pissed off to receive these letters. I've ignored them and nothing has happened but I'm patiently waiting for the day they turn up so I can lose my shit at them.

Platax · 18/11/2021 10:53

[quote dabbydeedoo]@LightDrizzle yes I do disagree. It's biased programming and I have zero interest in watching it. Just because you like it doesn't mean everyone else has to. I pay for content I want to watch, just like you do.[/quote]
The thing is, you also pay for content you don't want to watch with Sky, Prime etc, unless you can really claim that you love every single programme they produce. And you pay much more.

And you pay for a hell of a lot more with the commercial channels, with no element of choice at all, because the costs of advertising are added on to the goods you buy.

Platax · 18/11/2021 10:51

imagine if the content creators produced what they are contracted to do, like non biased programming?

People on all sides of politics accuse the BBC of being biased. That would seem to indicate that it's getting it about right.

lonelyapple · 18/11/2021 10:49

If they knock on your door either don't answer or shut the door in their face. They have no legal powers and work by trying to bully vulnerable people into thinking they have to pay.

Holothane · 18/11/2021 10:46

If it was subscribing I’d not bother it’s crap I only watch Dr who Call the midwife now.

dabbydeedoo · 18/11/2021 10:46

@DontBeCatty

I don’t get why people find the letters so ‘threatening’. If you know you don’t need a license then just ignore them. I don’t understand the outrage. 🤷🏻‍♀️ There are loads of people who don’t pay their tv licenses so it’s not surprising that the tv licence people want to catch them. It’s similar to seeing ‘shoplifters will be prosecuted’ signs in shops. I know I’m not a shoplifter so I just ignore them.
You don't see why intimidating letters telling you they can apply for warrant for a big burly bloke to enter the home you live in alone might be threatening?
OP posts:
girlmom21 · 18/11/2021 10:45

@DontBeCatty

I don’t get why people find the letters so ‘threatening’. If you know you don’t need a license then just ignore them. I don’t understand the outrage. 🤷🏻‍♀️ There are loads of people who don’t pay their tv licenses so it’s not surprising that the tv licence people want to catch them. It’s similar to seeing ‘shoplifters will be prosecuted’ signs in shops. I know I’m not a shoplifter so I just ignore them.
I think they're intentionally vague around the rules for tv licenses which is what worries people.
dabbydeedoo · 18/11/2021 10:44

@LightDrizzle yes I do disagree. It's biased programming and I have zero interest in watching it. Just because you like it doesn't mean everyone else has to. I pay for content I want to watch, just like you do.

OP posts:
Pemba · 18/11/2021 10:43

If the OP doesn't watch or record live TV or use BBC IPlayer then of course she doesn't need a TV licence so why on earth would she get one? Don't understand at all the pp who has a licence despite living abroad. I thought you couldn't access IPlayer outside the UK?

And yes of course people are often bullied or harassed when they legitimately don't need a licence. It's well known.

More and more younger people seem to be not watching broadcast TV. The BBC don't seem to accept this, but they will need to change their business model somehow as in the future they will no longer be able to rely on licence fee income.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 18/11/2021 10:43

No this is absolutely not bullying. It's shameful to suggest it is.

That's crap. Corporate bullying is exactly what it is. "Shameful" is still watching the BBC and allowing these people to carry on as they are.

I cancelled my TV licence 3 years ago and sent in the wanky online form, screenshotted it and then had to repeat the process every six months as they just write to you anyway.

Their letter is worded exactly as if it came from a bunch of cheap and inefficient debt collectors. It's threatening, intimidating and unnecessary.

The BBC is just another corrupt English institution that needs putting out of its misery.

user14943608381 · 18/11/2021 10:42

What? The Mother f*ckers! I was told I needed one for Prime and Netflix which is literally all we watch. I couldn’t tell you the last time we put broadcast TV on or even tried to sign into I player…. Rage

DontBeCatty · 18/11/2021 10:42

I don’t get why people find the letters so ‘threatening’. If you know you don’t need a license then just ignore them. I don’t understand the outrage. 🤷🏻‍♀️ There are loads of people who don’t pay their tv licenses so it’s not surprising that the tv licence people want to catch them.
It’s similar to seeing ‘shoplifters will be prosecuted’ signs in shops. I know I’m not a shoplifter so I just ignore them.

Lougle · 18/11/2021 10:41

"You don’t need a TV Licence to watch videos or clips on demand on YouTube.

But you DO need a TV Licence if you watch TV programmes live on YouTube. An example of this would be watching Sky News live. But it isn’t just live news or sport which needs a licence – it’s any programme which is part of a TV channel, broadcast or transmitted for everyone to watch at the same time."

From their site.

Fluffycloudland77 · 18/11/2021 10:40

We didn’t have one for four years. They sent letters, I rang them once a year to say it’s still the same shite and we don’t watch it. We only got a licence because dh wanted the F1 races.

When we used iplayer again after 4 years the same old programs were still being shown 🙄

LGY1 · 18/11/2021 10:40

I cancelled ours in Feb. Got an email confirmation which says it’s valid for 2 years. Not heard a peep from them apart from that
Do the letters / visits come when you don’t have one / don’t declare you don’t need one?