Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does MIL have the right to veto baby name?

340 replies

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/11/2021 08:58

Context:

Relationship with MIL is at an all time high snd we get on well/she’s good with children but there’s a backstory of her missing our wedding on the day as she didn’t approve of me/not speaking to us for months on end over small things and being generally v difficult.

Here’s the issue:
I’m pregnant with #3. Have used all the baby names we like up for boys on the first 2 (typically 😬). There is one name I absolutely adore but it’s the name of DH’s uncle. MIL does not speak to her brother (or any of that side of the family) and has said we can’t use it as it would make her uncomfortable. There’s is another name with the same nickname we can use but it’s nowhere near as nice. To be clear; her brother has not done anything wrong/I’ve met him he’s a nice man. And the family haven’t done anything “wrong” it’s very much a tit for tat situation and a mixture of difficult characters and no one willing to move forward.

DH says he’s not willing to go to the bat on this, but I’m in 2 minds. I don’t want to be a dick snd I don’t want to wage some sort of war over this but equally I feel a bit pissed off as the baby will be known by a nickname anyway this is just for a beautiful formal name, and does she really have the right to do this?! I wouldn’t mind as much if she had always been loving and supportive or even would appreciate what I feel is a bit of a sacrifice but she hasn’t and she won’t!

Would love everyone’s thoughts please and I’m sorry for the length of this post/don’t know what’s reasonable anymore!

OP posts:
Ileflottante · 18/11/2021 12:14

Use the name. It’s your child. She’s just a nasty hag who actively campaigned to get you ousted from the family for having the audacity to fall in love with her son. She’s crackers.

RobotValkyrie · 18/11/2021 12:13

does she really have the right to do this?!
no

But the real question really is "Who is taking orders from who in this triangular relationship?"

You MIL seems to think she has power over you and your husband. That's bonkers.

You don't accept your MIL as having power over you (quite right!).
Your husband seems to accept his mum as having power over him (bonkers! not healthy)

The next question-mark is: between you and your husband, who has power over the other? This is what's at stake here. This is what needs resolving.
In a healthy relationship, the right answer is: nobody, you're a team of equals, you make decisions together, no one gets to win.
This is what's at stake in this (seemingly innocent) naming decision. How power is distributed in your couple, and whether this power is hander over to a third party.

Your MIL is injecting poison in your relationship by forcing your husband to choose between her and you. That's really nasty, and probably quite deliberate. Nice, sensible people don't do that.

HenryPotter · 18/11/2021 12:11

I would pick another name but then tell tee that’s the last time you are pandering to her behaviour and then distance yourself from her.

Skeumorph · 18/11/2021 12:11

If we don’t use the name I would like him to maybe explain to her that it’s our preferred name we aren’t fucking using despite all the awful shit she’s done…I feel v annoyed about it now; my mother has wound me up a bit. My father was abusive and she said if someone wants to use her name it’s none of her business and MIL is being outrageous.

DH was really on my side when she didn’t come to wedding/ sent round photos of me to family members in a bid to get them on side calling off wedding etc (yes, really).

Although it’s just occurred to me that the preferred name has the same ending as another son’s name so maybe it won’t fit as well with them as the variant.

Use the name.

Seriously, it will probably be the best single thing you EVER do in this 'relationship' (with your MIL).

The moment you draw a fucking big boundary with pathetic, stirring, self-obsessed nasty little bullies, the tone changes.

And you need it to change before your children, who it seems you ideally would want her to have a relationship with, get any older.

Why you want this slice of poison in your life, when it's clear she's actively tried to sabotage your family and her son's happiness, I do not know. But I get it's complicated.

One thing however is not at all complicated.

If after everything this utter cow has done, you carry on appeasing, you'll NEVER have a peaceful time of it. She'll push on parenting, celebrations, everything. She deserved to be cut off for the wedding, you didn't do so. You say you walk on eggshells now. No shit Sherlock!

If you roll over and lose the name you want for YOUR SON because of this woman, you'll end up hating her even more.

If you carry on rolling over on very big issues - she will never ever get easier to manage.

There is only one way to make her easier to manage and that is to stand up to her. No eggshells. A very firm - if you don't like it - there's the door.

She won't use the door, because she wants to be in your lives. That's YOUR GIFT - take that power. And use it to shut her up.

Use the name. Tell your H that she's lucky she wasn't cut off over the wedding, you've forgiven that, tell her now will be her turn to get over something. He goes in to bat. You have the name you love. And MIL can learn, finally, that you don't create good family relationships through bullying.

AmyDudley · 18/11/2021 12:11

The focus is being put on how MIL will feel if you use this name.
The focus should be put on how YOU will feel if you don't use it. Will you always wish you had chosen it, will you feel that a 'second choice name' is exactly that, how will you feel if when your MIL inevitably falls out with you over some other triviality and you have given in to her over a name you love?

This is a woman with form for falling out with people, that is her character - she's not going to change, She didn't come to your wedding because she didn't approve of you - that is hugely disrespectful, why should you respect her now?
The name will not affect her 'mental health' as a PP has suggested - she is simply throwing a wobbly because she can't get her own way. And people walk on eggshells round her because she throws wobblies to get what she wants.

If you pander to people like this they think they get to have a say in things that are your life and your choices, When in fact it is absolutely none of their business. What other life choice will she decide she gets to dictate over - where you live, where you children go to school, what job you have, etc etc. ?

You have considered her feelings and decided that they don't trump your feelings. And that is what you tell her. She then has a choice of how she reacts. It is up to her whether she flounces off, never speaks to you again, or is unkind to your child. You haven't made that choice for her. She can be silly or she can get over herself, and your future choices about whether to include her in your life will take account of her reaction on this occasion.

This woman will fall out with you at some point whether you chose this name or not, it is certain. People who have constant fall outs do it for the drama, they thrive on that conflict and drama and if there is none they will invent it. She has shown her true character in the past, she has to decide whether getting the hump over a name is worth her losing her relationship with her grandchildren. How she behaves is not your responsibility it it hers. Your responsibility is to give your children as much love and care as is humanly possible and that includes giving them a name that you feel is perfect.

You don't negotiate with people who threaten bad behaviour if they don't get their way.

HikingforScenery · 18/11/2021 12:08

So you want to give your child a name that their grandparent has very negative feelings about? Accept that you might not know the full story as you weren’t there.
It’s your child . Make them whatever you want bunt understand it might impact the kind of relationship they will have.
What’s the point of the backstory if you’ve all made up? Is it so we can see how unreasonable she is?
Come on, there’s bound to be an alternative name

pigsDOfly · 18/11/2021 12:07

She sounds really difficult and unpleasant tbh and no she has no right to veto your children's names. Why would you give her that power.

She didn't come to your wedding because she disapproved of you, she doesn't speak to a whole part of the family. She might at some point in the future decide she doesn't approve of you again. or something you've done or one of your children and stop speaking to your family.

Just give your child the name you want, obviously your DH can veto the name and there's not a lot you can do about that if he does, but, in your shoes, I'd be very reluctant to bow to this woman's opinion.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/11/2021 12:05

I don’t think I would feel comfortable lying to her btw. I just couldn’t I wouldn’t feel right and she would definitely find out another way.

@RosiePosieDozy

Please read my previous posts

OP posts:
RosiePosieDozy · 18/11/2021 12:03

I'm normally all for calling your baby what you want. It's your choice.

In this situation, I don't agree though. You don't know what's happened between your MIL and her brother and to call your baby the name of the brother would be cruel. Whether she went to your wedding or not, I would not do this.

cookiemonster2468 · 18/11/2021 12:03

Well she doesn't have the "right" to veto it, of course.

But I think it would be a bit unkind to use it in these circumstances and would probably only provoke more difficult dynamics. If it were me, I wouldn't. It's not worth it.

There are so many names you can choose from, there must be another that would work.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/11/2021 12:01

It would be weird to name him the same would it not?

I genuinely don’t see why.

Does she take her spats with you out on the kids?

No but she goes AWOL for long periods. DS1 was too young to remember last time but I think if she did it again it would really hurt him snd that would be it for us.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 18/11/2021 12:01

Will she ever see the birth certificate? Just tell her you have called him by the nickname/short version you have chosen for example a friend of mine called her daughter "beth" (not real name) most people assume its short for Elizabeth it's actually not her birth certificate states Beth

Greenrubber · 18/11/2021 11:55

Just name him what you want call him the nickname in front of her it's not like she will look at his birth certificate
Just say you have went for Ben and that's that
My mum said she hated the name I picked for my DD whilst we were still in the deciding stage i just ignored her I also learnt not to tell anyone what you have decided to call your baby as everyone has an opinion

Morgan12 · 18/11/2021 11:55

Don't use it. Your DHs uncle is already using it. It would be weird to name him the same would it not?

CSJobseeker · 18/11/2021 11:52

Your MIL obviously can't veto, but your DH can, for whatever reason he chooses.

Of all the names in all the world - does it really have to be this one?

diddl · 18/11/2021 11:51

"but I think it’s nice for DH and the children and for her"

Really?

I mean it depends how often it spills over & affects the kids.

Does she take her spats with you out on the kids?

Keeping her at arms length might be a good idea if she's unpredictable.

tara66 · 18/11/2021 11:48

How rich is MIL? I think it's relevant this case.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/11/2021 11:46

If you would be okay with some future DIL giving a child your brother’s name, YANBU

I would be absolutely fine with it!

I’m not a horrible controlling spouse she’s just difficult and DH was the golden child and she was livid someone dared “take him away”. That’s it. I’ve really bent over backwards to be kind and a lot of people wouldn’t see her after the things she’s done but I think it’s nice for DH and the children and for her 🤷🏻‍♀️ But this feels like a step too far because it’s important to me

OP posts:
SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 18/11/2021 11:43

So MIL is NC with her brother.
And YOU mention you’re NC with your own brother.
You have 2, soon 3, sons.
If you would be okay with some future DIL giving a child your brother’s name, YANBU.
If you would ask her not to, YABU.
Because otherwise, we really know shite about any of these relationships. Whether MIL is a “bad guy” or you’re some horrible, controlling spouse she has reason to dislike (I mean, hopefully not, but you might be). So just go by the rule of not being a hypocrite.

lockdownalli · 18/11/2021 11:43

Oh, and a good friend of mine facing this level of drama over her baby DDs name ended up telling her MIL "Don't worry MIL, you will be dead soon so you won't have to deal with it for long." Grin

Not saying you should do that of course but she was driven to it (huge back story)

lockdownalli · 18/11/2021 11:42

Of course she cannot veto it. You know this, and you know you have a DH problem as it sounds like he doesn't have your back?

Tell him that is what the baby will be called. If MIL says anything tell her not to worry, if she doesn't want to see her GC because of a name she can fuck off.

Seriously what is wrong with these people?

I do agree with PP that this is why you NEVER NEVER discuss baby names before announcing them as a done and dusted deal. Too late for you OP but might help other posters reading this.

Peony15 · 18/11/2021 11:39

When I was pregnant with both DS I wanted a peaceful atmosphere around me and be calm within myself as I believe the yet to be born baby absorbs the energy and feels/hears what goes on around you. To think he is already surrounded by stress and negative energy before being born over his future name would make me hit that issue straight on the head for his well being. There must be another name that is equally beautiful and creates none of this drama. Not saying it's your fault OP but the baby doesn't deserve any negative energy whatsover that can be avoided, especially whilst he's growing.

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 18/11/2021 11:32

It doesn’t matter - it’s not a courtroom and we don’t always think to include everything that might be relevant in the OP...you’ve had lots of comments from every perspective and you’ll be able to evaluate those and decide on what you think is right for you. 🙂

Ozanj · 18/11/2021 11:31

I think it depends how serious you are in improving the relationship with your mil. Ultimately you might think you know why she doesn’t talk to her brother but you can’t know for sure - for example DB and I usually fall out / don’t communicate over seemingly tiny things but it started because he used to beat me (he’s a lot younger and this started when he turned 14 because he could). Once he even threw me down the stairs. No way would I tell my DS or DN about that though.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/11/2021 11:29

Now that you have cleared up that it is, in fact, down to a petty disagreement and not a horrible back story between them (at least as far as you know) my advice would be that if you really love the name then you absolutely should still go for it

I wish I had been clearer in the OP

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread