Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think secondary schools could scrap the tutor period?

164 replies

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 08:39

I think most schools are like the one I work in, with a twenty / thirty minute tutor period either in the middle of the day or first thing. Once a week assembly.

Ours is currently first thing, and once a week we don’t have it and finish twenty minutes early.

Do we need it at all? Once a week assembly for each year group, so once a week in a bit earlier.

Maybe in my naive utopia I’m thinking it would reduce school traffic a bit with staggered starts, give teachers a bit more time (yes teacher bashers, we do need it) and reduce another layer of stress.

Perhaps I’m being naive.

OP posts:
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:14

I had a mixed age form in my last school. It worked fairly well but using tutor time productively was still a bit of a pain.

OP posts:
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:13

Yes, but safeguarding doesn’t start and end in form time (I know you weren’t suggesting it does but that’s the point, it’s all day every day.)

I am allowed an opinion about my job. I think. Smile

OP posts:
Heyha · 18/11/2021 14:12

I've worked in a vertical system as well and wanted to hate it but in the end found it very good- as long as the tutor was at least ok. The staff that weren't very good at being tutors in a single year group were even more at sea with a vertical group because there was more relationship management, different things going on for different year groups at a time, and so on.

But it can be done really well and I wouldn't be put off by a school that does this, I never in a million years thought I'd advocate for mixed age group forms but here we are!

crochetmonkey74 · 18/11/2021 14:11

The purpose of Tutor period is clearly explained by your school and by many posters on here- it is not an opinion- it is in our job descriptions.

crochetmonkey74 · 18/11/2021 14:09

@padthehallways

I’m not a HOY / HOH though *@crochetmonkey74*, which is what I meant. I don’t pretend to have all the answers. I do know that tutor period is a real pain, and it would be nice not to have it!

I’m all for things like school trips, dances, plays and events, but they have a purpose, even if that purpose is sheer enjoyment, and the tutor period is a drag. It’s nice to hear others enjoy it, though.

ALL teachers have pastoral and safeguarding responsibilty- this is in the Ofsted framework and DfE guidance Your school should have made that clear - it is also part of the teaching standards which you passed to qualify.
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:08

That’s the idea - you wouldn’t have a form.

OP posts:
Musmerian · 18/11/2021 14:08

I’d never see my form if we did this. It’s vital for pastoral care. You’re very wrong about this.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:06

I’m not a HOY / HOH though @crochetmonkey74, which is what I meant. I don’t pretend to have all the answers. I do know that tutor period is a real pain, and it would be nice not to have it!

I’m all for things like school trips, dances, plays and events, but they have a purpose, even if that purpose is sheer enjoyment, and the tutor period is a drag. It’s nice to hear others enjoy it, though.

OP posts:
crochetmonkey74 · 18/11/2021 14:04

@jmp2

I was really surprised to see this suggestion from a teacher.

I’ve always seen my tutor time (have had tutor groups of a variety of ages Y7-Y13) as really important. Relaying messages is obviously one aspect, but in terms of pastoral care I have usually been the ‘go to’ teacher for issues my tutees have been facing. I suppose my thought is without tutors who would be specifically looking out for a child? A head of year wouldn’t be able to have the same depth of relationship with every student that a tutor does, and I just think it would allow so many students to slip through the cracks. Similarly, tutor at the beginning of the day is often a good time to address any issues with equipment/uniform etc which can be rectified before lessons start.

A lot of safeguarding disclosures have come from my tutees over the years; for some students they would not feel comfortable asking their subject teacher during (or after) a lesson so it is an important extra support network for them.

In terms of parents bringing up issues, if tutors were not there then Heads of Year would be inundated with things that could be nipped in the bud by the tutor.

There are so many other reasons I could give but those are the first that come to mind! I think the role of a tutor is so important and I struggle with the idea of it being removed!

Me too, also I love it- We keep the same form group for 5 years so it's a really strong little team
DrWhoNowww · 18/11/2021 14:03

Your year 10s don’t necessarily need to engage with you specifically though to be gaining from form time - like PPs have said it’s an opportunity to catch up with friends who may not be in the same lessons, wake up before the day starts - pick up on home work you might have missed, reminders about meetings, early finishes, after school clubs…

There’s a lot of information shared beyond what the teacher says during tutor (unless your year 10’s are staring at their phones which seems unlikely)

I do think it can often be used better though - I like a PPs school where the year tens swap each term/half term to have form time with a weaker GCSE subject tutor.

I also like the system at my nieces school where the forms are multi- year - it allows for more mixing and building of allies amongst year groups rather than having 30 year 7s wondering the school as a pack!

crochetmonkey74 · 18/11/2021 14:03

I think students are actually crying out for all the normal routine stuff about school- they are sick of the Covid loneliness- ours want school discos, assemblies and form time and I am in a very average comp with a broad demographic- our kids have missed all the tedious things they used to moan about (whole school carol concert for example)

We have to be really careful not to teach children like mini adults- they are not, they need the safety and routine of school now more than ever

jmp2 · 18/11/2021 14:02

I was really surprised to see this suggestion from a teacher.

I’ve always seen my tutor time (have had tutor groups of a variety of ages Y7-Y13) as really important. Relaying messages is obviously one aspect, but in terms of pastoral care I have usually been the ‘go to’ teacher for issues my tutees have been facing. I suppose my thought is without tutors who would be specifically looking out for a child? A head of year wouldn’t be able to have the same depth of relationship with every student that a tutor does, and I just think it would allow so many students to slip through the cracks. Similarly, tutor at the beginning of the day is often a good time to address any issues with equipment/uniform etc which can be rectified before lessons start.

A lot of safeguarding disclosures have come from my tutees over the years; for some students they would not feel comfortable asking their subject teacher during (or after) a lesson so it is an important extra support network for them.

In terms of parents bringing up issues, if tutors were not there then Heads of Year would be inundated with things that could be nipped in the bud by the tutor.

There are so many other reasons I could give but those are the first that come to mind! I think the role of a tutor is so important and I struggle with the idea of it being removed!

crochetmonkey74 · 18/11/2021 14:01

I’m not a pastoral teacher

Are you in the UK? because if you are- you are a pastoral teacher- we all are. Tutor time is the time to pick up patterns, notice things, talk and do all those important safeguarding 'professional curiosity' things.

It comes down to the old saying we were taught at PGCE-
" What do you teach?"
"Maths"
"No , your subject is Maths, you teach Children"

I do understand your point about disengaged Year 10- are you new or have you had them since Year 7? or in your school does their tutor change each year (unusual and a rubbish system)
When I have students like that- homework is best, but distract and chat whilst they do it, you can normally engage at least one and then others will follow

SisterGabriel · 18/11/2021 14:00

I think turtle (I’m calling it that now) time has to be in the morning to be effective. It’s a good way to start the day and set the pupils up with some positive messages. After lunch or art the end of the day, pupils have had enough and just want to leave.
We have a cake rota in my turtle group - really helps in the afternoon sessions.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:00

You’re right about the staggered starts Smile

Perhaps it is assembly that has had its day!

OP posts:
AChickenCalledDaal · 18/11/2021 13:59

I agree 20 mins the time a week isn't enough to get to know them well. In my daughters' school they have two slightly shorter tutor sessions every day, and the same tutor stays with the class from year 7 to year 11 (unless they leave, obvs)

By the time both my daughters were in year 10 and 11, their tutors knew them really well and were in a great position to support them through the rocky road of GCSEs and all the anxiety inducing stuff that happen around that time. And their tutors were genuinely someone I knew I could always rely on to understand what was going on in the class and keep an eye out when things were difficult.

Lalallama · 18/11/2021 13:57

In my DS2's school they do PSHE in tutor time, so this week they have been doing stuff on anti-bullying, and they'll do sex ed, relationships, have topical conversations, etc. They keep the same tutor group for their whole time at secondary school so the teacher knows them really well and they trust him. It has been really good for DS especially going back after lockdown.

It isn't quite as structured in DS1's, but in years 10 and 11 they move tutor groups to support them with GSCE subjects. So for example he was moved after half term to an English tutor group as he needed support with that subject more than others. I'm not sure whether that is ideal as is feel a bit disruptive to change mid term, but he is happy with it.

Even if you didn't have tutor time, how could you have staggered starts - their first lessons would still begin at the same time? Would they just hang around in the playground for longer?

SirenSays · 18/11/2021 13:56

Tutor in my old school was an absolute waste of time. It just made students grumpy waiting around and I never saw the point of waking up early to sit around for no reason.
I can't say I ever had a good tutor or one that I felt knew me or cared.
I remember I went with a friend to tell the tutor she was being bullied and scared of being assaulted by a gang of girls. The tutor told us this isnt primary school anymore and to stick up for herself. So she did. She was assaulted twice and had to have a head of year walk her to the bus after school every day.

JustLyra · 18/11/2021 13:56

Nine times out of ten tutor time has been when any issues my older three were having came up. That tended to be the teacher they’d speak to about problems, and in one case it was that teacher who spotted the problem.

I think the regular contact with a member of staff who isn’t focussed on teaching a specific subject is important.

Beautiful3 · 18/11/2021 13:56

It's important to have that tutor time, as it's classed as pastoral care. Any problems get picked up and dealt with. I loved tutor time, it made me feel connected, and it provided a base to touch in. It makes you feel like, someone cares about you and the group, and gets to know you all.

Heyha · 18/11/2021 13:56

I bloody love form time and working with my lot even though I tend to be given/collect quite a lot of the tricky customers and they do cause me no end of frustration at times.

Taking a form through is one of the pleasures of teaching in my opinion and I'd hate for it to disappear from my day. That said we are only 20 mins every day with one of those being assembly so it's not a massive chunk of time, plus we have a pretty good pastoral routine that isn't so rigid that we can't do our own thing a bit as well. We have some December rituals that I'm looking forward to new members of the form experiencing with my old hands.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 13:52

I can quite see that re the buses.

We don’t do PSHE in tutor - it’s done in days, one every half term.

OP posts:
StormyCornishSeas · 18/11/2021 13:50

Staggered starts wouldn't really work at my school because of the amount of kids who come in on buses. Like who supervises the kids who start later and where would they go?

Also tutor time is when the pshe curriculum is delivered and intervention

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 13:50

That is a pain @Georgie8

OP posts:
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 13:50

People have said their children like tutor period because they like their tutor. That’s lovely, but it also doesn’t really mean there is anything special happening in that period that makes it essential.

Tbh @Sirzy, I’m not looking for an argument here. I know when I was at school, tutor period was registration and that was fine. We now have electric registration and have done for some two decades so it isn’t quite as essential as it once was. Yet schools hang onto things, I find.

Re pastoral care, I’m not a pastoral teacher so I don’t profess to be an expert but I also don’t think twenty minutes at the start of the day solves all pastoral issues.

OP posts: