Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think secondary schools could scrap the tutor period?

164 replies

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 08:39

I think most schools are like the one I work in, with a twenty / thirty minute tutor period either in the middle of the day or first thing. Once a week assembly.

Ours is currently first thing, and once a week we don’t have it and finish twenty minutes early.

Do we need it at all? Once a week assembly for each year group, so once a week in a bit earlier.

Maybe in my naive utopia I’m thinking it would reduce school traffic a bit with staggered starts, give teachers a bit more time (yes teacher bashers, we do need it) and reduce another layer of stress.

Perhaps I’m being naive.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 18/11/2021 14:49

I can’t see tutor time going anywhere but I must admit it isn’t my favourite part of the day and is a bit of a pointless pain at the moment. Time is very precious

So essentially you want to ditch it because you dislike it and you've got better things to do... I do get it - having a difficult tutor group is bloody hard-going and thankless. And you're busy. All teachers are busy. But many of them recognise the importance of tutor time. And lots of them enjoy it!

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:45

But (I’m not meaning to be argumentative, I promise!) if you have to deliver a pastoral curriculum in that time, your attention is diverted just the same, surely?

OP posts:
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:45

Grin I’m sure we could have a great discussion on which historical periods should be studied.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 18/11/2021 14:44

It’s interesting people think it’s a child protection issue. I am not sure what would be picked up there that wouldn’t be in lessons, unless as I’ve said the child happens to have a good relationship with that teacher.

It is pretty common for a competent teacher to be able to pick up on issues whether the child has a good relationship with them or not. I have flagged up concerns about or had a quick chat with a student who seemed worried/exhausted/on edge etc many times, sometimes even in a class I don't know and am covering.

So yes, subject teachers do sometimes pick up on things, but it's easier to do that in a scenario where you're not focused on teaching them and 28 other kids algebra or the Imperfect Tense. And where they know that dealing with their welfare and issues is your actual focus during that time.

DPotter · 18/11/2021 14:42

I clicked on to argue with you about how important the Tudor period was for British history.

Clearly I really need to book that optician's appointment....

ArianaDumbledore · 18/11/2021 14:42

Most travel by bus to DS2s secondary so staggered starts won't work there. His mentor is the most complained about teacher, and is definitely not the nurturing sort.
DS2 does grumble that the mentor room is inconvenient with his timetable and doesn't always have time to get a word processor for his first lesson.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:40

None of the examples have proved that it’s essential, @crochetmonkey74. You think it is: that’s fine, I don’t. I genuinely have no idea why you’ve been such an arse on this thread. It’s interesting hearing how different schools do things even if we all still don’t agree.

OP posts:
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:38

It’s more relaxed, certainly. Perhaps that is the key difference. I can’t see tutor time going anywhere but I must admit it isn’t my favourite part of the day and is a bit of a pointless pain at the moment. Time is very precious!

OP posts:
crochetmonkey74 · 18/11/2021 14:38

@padthehallways

It’s interesting people think it’s a child protection issue. I am not sure what would be picked up there that wouldn’t be in lessons, unless as I’ve said the child happens to have a good relationship with that teacher.
There have been lots of clear examples on this thread, and if, as a teacher you really can't see it- I actually do think you need to ask for more training (not being snarky, I think there are some real gaps in your understanding of a tutor role)
lazylinguist · 18/11/2021 14:38

I see your point in some ways OP, but maybe what needs to change is the content of tutor time and assemblies, rather than getting rid of them altogether. I've been a form tutor for many years in
my career but am not now. The school where I currently do supply only has 15 mins tutor time, which I think is fine tbh.

Younger year groups benefit from tutor time most imo. It's useful tine for dealing with any issues, talking about behaviour, organisational issues etc. Quizzes etc are a waste of time, and give the students the impression that there isno real purpose to them being there.

JustLyra · 18/11/2021 14:36

@padthehallways

It’s interesting people think it’s a child protection issue. I am not sure what would be picked up there that wouldn’t be in lessons, unless as I’ve said the child happens to have a good relationship with that teacher.
I’m really surprised you say that.

It’s a totally different relationship with a child to one you teach a specific lesson to.

You have a more relaxed time, you see them out of class time and when they’re either relaxed or have the chance to worry.

In every school I’ve ever worked in the tutor time has been seen as vital for pupil well being and safeguarding.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:34

It’s interesting people think it’s a child protection issue. I am not sure what would be picked up there that wouldn’t be in lessons, unless as I’ve said the child happens to have a good relationship with that teacher.

OP posts:
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:33

I see my tutees three times a week for twenty minutes, so one hour - I see KS4 and 5 every day, KS3 four times a week. I get that I see more of them than some because I’m a core subject but I don’t think that holds as an argument, especially given some students will have two form tutors if they are part time.

OP posts:
Primrosefields · 18/11/2021 14:32

Tutor time at my dcs school is done daily.
This gives an opportunity for child protection and safeguarding issues to be highlighted. They do activities in form time but the children are also more relaxed, so there is opportunity to overhear conversations between peers that could potentially highlight a red flag.
Children tend to open up to their peers about their worries and concerns. They could also mention key phrases that could highlight criminal activities outside of school.
By having this time, there are opportunities to clock something that a subject teacher may not be able to due to focussing on the learning objectives for that lesson.
Many children have been in situations above their heads and the signs have been there for a long time.
Seeing a familiar teacher, especially one that is approachable may be enough to get the support in place or start the ball rolling with safeguarding and child protection concerns.
I am very happy that each day my dc has time with an adult in their school where they are not focussing on the lesson but are concentrating on their wellbeing. The teacher may notice changes in their behaviour that is hidden at home.

crochetmonkey74 · 18/11/2021 14:31

whoever the child feels comfortable with

But some kids never feel comfortable enough to talk and it's their tutor gently encouraging that helps them. Some of my most vulnerable students would be terrified of being late to their next lesson if they stayed behind etc. Also- who would notice when they always arrive in the morning tired , or dishevelled? A subject teacher just doesn't have that day in day out pattern noticing

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:30

Improvement plan because I need to be put on capability, is that the inference?

Is questioning anything about teacher workload something that should lead to dismissal, in your view? Sorry if I have misunderstood something.

OP posts:
crochetmonkey74 · 18/11/2021 14:27

@Postdatedpandemic

Have a discussion with your HOY, HOD or HT. Tell them what you have told us, I'm sure they will sort out an improvement plan for you.
I've been thinking this exact thing!
loveablequalities · 18/11/2021 14:26

We used to have a 10/15 minute registration period every morning where we did stuff like uniform checks, absence notes, general information etc. It was supposed to be pastoral and when it worked it was great. I had some excellent wee teams. We never had any pastoral training though and I felt the lack of that at times - teen pregnancy, gender issues, bullying etc.

They scrapped it to save money and now it's straight into lessons. Assembly is maybe once a term. I think it's pretty rubbish myself.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 14:25

Like I say, the go to person tends to be whoever the child feels comfortable with which may or may not be the tutor.

I mean, if a child tells me they are being bullied, I wouldn’t say ‘sorry, I am your English teacher.’

I don’t think it’s my school. I’ve worked in a few different ones and form time has always been a mix of news / events, revision, behaviour, and so on.

OP posts:
unknownstory · 18/11/2021 14:22

My DC really like form time. Chance to chat about stuff going on. Teacher discusses stuff with them as a group.
I'd be gutted it it went

CryHavoc · 18/11/2021 14:21

My daughter moved schools in yr 8, and the new school has one tutor lesson a week rather than every day. She much prefers this to the system in her last school.

PiddleOfPuppies · 18/11/2021 14:20

DD's school did away with them for the 6th form (because covid) and never brought them back. She now goes in for lessons and that's it - no opportunity to get to know people outside her classes (which is very narrow, she's doing maths, further maths and chemistry, so mostly boys), no teacher who is interested in how she's feeling and no opportunity to discuss issues she might be having in or out of school. She feels like a robot and can't wait to finish.
So no, tutor time is invaluable and should be sacred.

Postdatedpandemic · 18/11/2021 14:19

Have a discussion with your HOY, HOD or HT. Tell them what you have told us, I'm sure they will sort out an improvement plan for you.

SeasonFinale · 18/11/2021 14:18

It is clear from your comments that your school don't run their tutor groups the same way my son's school did, where as well as group sessions they would have one to ones with their tutor and where my son felt comfortable enough to speak about a MH issue he had and which led to successful CBT.

Just because your school (or perhaps you personally ) aren't using this time effectively then it doesn't mean others aren't.

I say you aren't using the time effectively because if you were you would not believe it could be dispensed with.

JustLyra · 18/11/2021 14:18

@padthehallways

That’s the idea - you wouldn’t have a form.
Who would be the go to person for the kids?

Tutor time is invaluable as it’s one person who knows the kids well over their time in the school.
They tend to be the one that notices that Mary’s clothes aren’t as fresh as they used to be, or that Billy has got really quiet, because they are the ones that have the time to focus on the kids rather than a subject.