Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think secondary schools could scrap the tutor period?

164 replies

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 08:39

I think most schools are like the one I work in, with a twenty / thirty minute tutor period either in the middle of the day or first thing. Once a week assembly.

Ours is currently first thing, and once a week we don’t have it and finish twenty minutes early.

Do we need it at all? Once a week assembly for each year group, so once a week in a bit earlier.

Maybe in my naive utopia I’m thinking it would reduce school traffic a bit with staggered starts, give teachers a bit more time (yes teacher bashers, we do need it) and reduce another layer of stress.

Perhaps I’m being naive.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 18/11/2021 16:41

If you're not teaching PSHE during tutor time, then I wonder what you are expected to do.

Dragging my tutor group through a powerpoint about Equality before 9am isn't my idea of a great time but if I didn't have that powerpoint, there wouldn't really be much else to do apart from nag them about their shirts and blazers.

Postdatedpandemic · 18/11/2021 16:41

Europe does have similar but different tutor times. Czech Republic has vertical forms in some schools and a simple bit of research would reveal the concept is quite common across the planet
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeroom

QueenofLouisiana · 18/11/2021 16:34

Sure it’s been mentioned, but I think it’s important for safeguarding purposes. Someone who sees the children and knows what is normal for that child. So DS looks like he never brushes his hair (he does!) but clearly is wearing clean clothes, has been in the shower, has everything he needs snd would be able to talk about life at home. Looking at him and chatting daily, his tutor knows everything is ok but a twice a week teacher might look in horror at the mad hair and think there’s an issue.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 16:34

It’s not really about disliking it. It’s a nuisance and it’s pointless, but I don’t actually hate it. In any event, I’ve never been given a choice!

OP posts:
JustLyra · 18/11/2021 16:32

I’m surprised given your clear dislike of it that you have a form group rather than something else.

It doesn’t suit every teacher, just as it doesn’t suit every single child.

JustLyra · 18/11/2021 16:31

@padthehallways

I’m not sure, I think it is. If the raison d’etre for tutor groups and form time is to stay with one member of staff for five years, but without any guarantees that the member of staff will stay for five years (or even for one, or two) then the whole thing is redundant quite quickly.
Well it’s not really. The point is to have a consistent member of staff that knows the pupil well. Hopefully that’s the whole way through school, but even if it’s two teachers or three that’s still a consistency out of lesson time that can’t be offered by other staff members.
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 16:28

I used to work at a school that finished an hour early on a Friday - it was lovely! Grin

It would be interesting to see how British schools compared to ones elsewhere in Europe.

OP posts:
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 16:27

I’m not sure, I think it is. If the raison d’etre for tutor groups and form time is to stay with one member of staff for five years, but without any guarantees that the member of staff will stay for five years (or even for one, or two) then the whole thing is redundant quite quickly.

OP posts:
converseandjeans · 18/11/2021 16:24

It's a very British thing. Schools in Europe have no such thing. I think some students find being in tutor groups stressful - lots ask to move groups because of friendship issues.

The suggestion that you need a support plan because you have asked if it's a good use of time is quite ridiculous. Surely we all have things in our jobs that seem like a waste of time.

I agree that students will just talk to who they find easiest they're not going to start disclosing things in tutor time.

I don't know how other countries manage pastoral side of things - however I do think parents in UK expect schools to mop up lots of things that parents would deal with in other countries (online issues, bullying, exam stress).

With an extra 30 mins a day the students could have an afternoon a week off if you added it all together. I think they would benefit more from that. They could either go home or spend time with mates. Or a shorter school day.

JustLyra · 18/11/2021 16:23

@padthehallways

It isn’t a given a teacher will stay for five years, though.
It’s not, children may also move, but many do so that’s not a reason to disregard it as a pointless exercise.
JustLyra · 18/11/2021 16:22

@tttigress

Isn't the idea that a tutor can see how a child is developing over 5 or 7 years, this may help to flag up issues if there are unexpected changes if behaviour.
That’s a major part of it.
padthehallways · 18/11/2021 16:22

It isn’t a given a teacher will stay for five years, though.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 18/11/2021 16:21

@padthehallways

I think it’s pointless because it’s highly unlikely someone would confide in tutor time about domestic violence. They might confide in their form tutor if they feel they have a good relationship but this isn’t a given and as I’ve said, I’ve had children in my form confide in different members of staff and I’ve had children not in my form talk to me. It just depends.
In 15 years in education the vast majority of time that a child confided something it was to their tutor. That daily interaction builds trust easier than the vast majority of class teachers.

Yes some pupils will disclose to other teachers, obviously that happens, but the idea that having one person as a constant daily/multi weekly contact throughout your time in the school is pointless is very random.

tttigress · 18/11/2021 15:55

Isn't the idea that a tutor can see how a child is developing over 5 or 7 years, this may help to flag up issues if there are unexpected changes if behaviour.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 15:54

That’s lovely Smile

OP posts:
Change123today · 18/11/2021 15:53

At my daughters school they have 3 x 20 min & a PHSE lesson every other week with tutor. The tutor time is split between topics and even spelling tests. Or just general free chat for all to be involved in.

Maybe it’s more helpful in yr7/8? As it’s one constant with that transition from primary to have one teacher that could be trusted?

It’s a point of initial contact for us to engage with the school. The year group is huge so it helps!

My eldest has left school now but she had a very good relationship with her tutor they listened and when she needed that support during y10 & y11 just being there if needed was enough. As the teachers often changed in subjects or if the child moved sets they try to keep the same tutor for the duration of that cohort (in my daughters case it was the same from y9-y11) it was invaluable for her especially during exam time. She left 3 years ago and still talks of her tutor teacher in a positive way!

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 15:49

Some schools don’t have it at the start of the day, though. It was always the period before lunch at my last school, although it’s first thing now.

OP posts:
Snoozer11 · 18/11/2021 15:48

I think it's helpful for kids to start the day in the same place every day. As long as it's only 10 or 15 minutes then it's not a huge part of the day.

Also it stops any latecomers or stragglers from missing the first 5 minutes of a lesson.

Some pastoral tutors are terrible though. I had an absolute dragon for a tutor when I was in year 8 and 9. We had to spend that time sat in silence reading and there was no way I ever would have approached her with any personal issues.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 15:40

Well, yes. It’s not so surprising really - they do five hours of lessons a day in most schools, with a twenty or thirty minute tutor period.

OP posts:
QuiteQuaint · 18/11/2021 15:38

So do you suggest that kids literally just do lessons at school with maybe 1 assembly per week?

My sons college do similar, you attend for lessons only but with one coaching/tutor session per week but obviously he is older. Even he has said, there’s not much sense of belonging. He hasn’t got to know the kids in his tutor group very well god he hardly sees them. He’s with different kids for each A level subject (much like my daughter is with different children for different lessons at school) so he very much feel likes he goes their to learn but there’s no ‘community’. He’s ok with it cos he’s older but younger kids really need that sense of belonging somewhere.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 15:36

Oh, absolutely. We all like different things.

OP posts:
Postdatedpandemic · 18/11/2021 15:34

I think you may have to accept that you will never see the point of tutor time and that you and your tutees will never have more than a satisfactory experience from it.
Lots of teachers try and embed some critical thinking skills into the time, just a suggestion.

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 15:32

I’ve agreed that staggered starts are not a good suggestion Smile

OP posts:
Simonjt · 18/11/2021 15:31

What would you do about school buses with a staggered start/finish?

padthehallways · 18/11/2021 15:29

The ‘arsey’ comment related to the post you quoted, @crochetmonkey74, where you agree that I should be put on an improvement plan. I’m not sure that privately holding an opinion that something isn’t useful or productive is worthy of dismissal.

And while I agree safeguarding is important, I don’t think that it should only be done in tutor time - it’s an ongoing thing, as you know.

OP posts: