Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Government don't understand where "the north" actually is?

217 replies

AdamRyan · 18/11/2021 08:05

Government have scrapped the Leeds extension of HS2, so it now goes to Manchester. There will be faster trains to Sheffield as well. This apparently is to enable levelling up of "The North"
www.bbc.co.uk/news

AIBU to think Manchester and Sheffield are barely The North in an English context, let alone when you add in Scotland? What exactly does this do for the most deprived communities in the North East and the Lakes?

I'm so annoyed, the North of the UK just constantly gets left behind :(

OP posts:
Itsnotallaboutyoubaby · 18/11/2021 09:29

I live in the midlands. Family from London consider us to live in the North… I consider the North, Yorkshire and upward. I actually love the North.

Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 09:23

@itchypoopark

I think there is 'London' and the rest. Parts of 'the South' are equally as deprived as parts of 'the North' and of course parts of 'London' are equally deprived. 'Levelling up' does not and should not mean seeking equality between regions. It should mean a more even distribution of wealth and the end to poverty in all areas. However, the government would be loathe to spit out those sentiments because people would accuse them of treading on Labour's turf.
The West Country is more deprived than the North. Fact:
Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 09:18

Try living in the West Country if you want to feel ‘ignored’

I remember one Covid briefing where all the region stats appeared apart from ours 😂

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/11/2021 09:17

@JollyJoon

WFH might be a blessing in disguise for the north as southerners flock northwards. The downside of this though is you can expect to see massive house price increases
How would being overrun by Southern refugees be a blessing? Are they bringing their organic free range Quinoa?
JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 09:08

WFH might be a blessing in disguise for the north as southerners flock northwards. The downside of this though is you can expect to see massive house price increases

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 18/11/2021 09:07

To clarify - that's how I think the government sees it!!! NOT how I see it.

itchypoopark · 18/11/2021 09:06

I think there is 'London' and the rest. Parts of 'the South' are equally as deprived as parts of 'the North' and of course parts of 'London' are equally deprived. 'Levelling up' does not and should not mean seeking equality between regions. It should mean a more even distribution of wealth and the end to poverty in all areas. However, the government would be loathe to spit out those sentiments because people would accuse them of treading on Labour's turf.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 18/11/2021 09:06

@Havanananana

What do you expect from a Government that hardly knows what goes on outside of the M25?

Johnson confused Edinburgh with Glasgow at COP26 - Nov 2021
Sunak thought he was in “world famous Burnley market” when he was in fact in Bury. – Oct 2021
Raab struggled to find Dover and didn’t understand why 10,000 trucks a day passing through the area was vital to UK-EU trade.

It's like Game of Thrones, I think. The M25 is 'the wall' (as anyone who's ever been stuck on it will testify) and beyond that it's basically just wildlings.
Havanananana · 18/11/2021 09:01

What do you expect from a Government that hardly knows what goes on outside of the M25?

Johnson confused Edinburgh with Glasgow at COP26 - Nov 2021
Sunak thought he was in “world famous Burnley market” when he was in fact in Bury. – Oct 2021
Raab struggled to find Dover and didn’t understand why 10,000 trucks a day passing through the area was vital to UK-EU trade.

RobinPenguins · 18/11/2021 08:59

@SickAndTiredAgain

Well YANBU to find the ignoring of other areas a problem. But I think generally speaking Manchester is widely considered to be in the North. The problem isn’t that Manchester is considered to be in the North, but that it’s almost seen as the entire North - in the sense that politicians seem to think “well this benefits Manchester, so it benefits The North so we’ve really done our bit there”
As someone who lives in the NE of England I agree with this.

The NW, particularly Greater Manchester, has done much better at organising themselves, lobbying and electing an effective mayor.

Improvements between Manchester and Leeds will have some knock on benefits to the NE, but they’re more likely to increase inward investment and the competitiveness of Greater Manchester and West Yorkshire at the expense of the NE because we’re still stuck with the lack of capacity on the East Coast Mainline which constrains all attempts to improve things.

PinkWednesdays · 18/11/2021 08:58

The north is always north England. It’s never ever meant to be Scotland. You’d even hear the North and Scotland, because they’re two different things.

DoormatBob · 18/11/2021 08:58

I'm in Cumbria and I can't support this idea of a Northern Assembly as I believe that will just focus money into Manchester/Liverpool.

I just think to myself life could be worse. I could live in Manchester, Liverpool or London!

DdraigGoch · 18/11/2021 08:58

@Ifailed

Officially, the North of England is made up of: Cheshire, Cumbria, County Durham, East Riding of Yorkshire, Greater Manchester, Lancashire, Merseyside, Northumberland, North Yorkshire, South Yorkshire, Tyne and Wear and West Yorkshire, plus the unitary authority areas of North Lincolnshire and North East Lincolnshire.
So with the remaining project confined to Cheshire, Greater Manchester, and South Yorkshire; there's not a lot of the North still benefitting after all of these cutbacks (assuming that all of the rumours turn out true).

Originally HS2 was supposed to run directly to Leeds with upgrades to the line to York, thus benefitting Newcastle too. It was also supposed to directly link Wigan and so speed up the trains to Preston, Lancaster and Scotland - rumour has it that this section has been cut back to Crewe so while there will still be improvements in journey times to Scotland, they won't be as good as originally planned and therefore won't do as much to compete against air travel. Then HSN was planned to provide a faster line with more capacity between Liverpool, Manchester, Leeds and beyond which would also have given Liverpool direct HS2 trains. Beat in mind that many freight trains across the Pennines have to go via the Midlands or Carlisle because there isn't enough capacity on more direct routes.

COP26, what COP26? It's almost as if the government doesn't care about the environment and wants people to continue to fly and get stuck in traffic jams instead.

wombat1a · 18/11/2021 08:57

Current scheme is madness, if they were going to do it then they should have at least connected London to Edinburgh and then routed that via Brum and Mancs. This current scheme they have is hardly worth doing, do it once and do it properly.

RainCloude · 18/11/2021 08:57

The Home Counties are the counties surrounding London. Norfolk is not one of the Home Counties?

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 18/11/2021 08:55

Its simple.

Theres the South South. Like Cornwall and Devon. Where no one lives but people holiday.

Then there's the South.. London and surrounding counties where People Live

Then there's the Country... the home counties, Norfolk etc where you have your Second Home.

Then there's the Midlands. Mills, mines etc.

Yorkshire. A country in its own right.

Finally The North. Think there's dragons?

Disfordarkchocolate · 18/11/2021 08:55

We shall have to agree to disagree @JollyJoon. To me they are far to far from the Scottish border to be in the North.

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 08:51

@Disfordarkchocolate

Confused Of course Manchester and liverpool are northern. Are you from the countryside? Those two cities are much bigger and livelier than leeds so you might just have felt they dont feel northern because they are much more metropolitan and "globalised" than Leeds, which still.feels like a market town that got big.

YesILikeItToo · 18/11/2021 08:47

As a Scot, I understood that ‘the North West’ didn’t mean the highlands, but it wasn’t until the pandemic that I understood it didn’t mean Cumbria either - seems to mean greater Manchester.

Disfordarkchocolate · 18/11/2021 08:46

To those of us close to Newcastle, Manchester is hours away and not North. Leeds 'feels' Northern when you visit so I think of it as the lowest North there is. Liverpool, definitely not North.

There is no intention of 'levelling up' just a wider area for low paid jobs to support companies based in London.

PussyCatEatingPigsInBlankets · 18/11/2021 08:44

wikipedia suggests this:

"Writer and journalist Stuart Maconie argues that "there is no south of England... There's a bottom half of England... but there isn't a south in the same way that there's a north". He goes on to state that "there's no conception of the south comparable to the north. Good or bad, 'the north' means something to all English people wherever they hail from... [to southerns] it means desolation, arctic temperatures, mushy peas, a cultural wasteland with limited shopping opportunities and populated by aggressive trolls. To northerners it means home, truth, beauty, valour, romance, warm and characterful people, real beer and decent chip shops. And in this we are undoubtedly biased, of course". This suggests that all people in England have biased views regarding the north–south divide. Maconie says regarding on where the North starts that "Crewe is surely the gateway to the North", suggesting that Crewe is the most southern part of the north of England."

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 08:43

@BethAfra
That's not true. Northerners know they are northern. Its only southerners who really struggle with the boundary.

Jennalong · 18/11/2021 08:42

I've just had a quick a-z route check on my post code to Manchester . We live another 137 miles ' north ' of it . I don't really feel like I'm still in the North if we go to Manchester but I guess it's all relative to where you live .
We live approx 30-35 miles to the border of Scotland , so I can definitely call myself a northerner.

TrampolineForMrKite · 18/11/2021 08:41

As a Londoner I’m convinced that the North begins around Luton. Derbyshire and Notts. must be the North because of their predisposition for putting gravy on their chips. I’m pretty sure that’s how this government are working out where the North is too, due to their similar cluelessness. That’s why it might be good to have a couple of people in the Cabinet not from London or the Home Counties, I guess. But then there’s lots of things that I wish this Cabinet had that it doesn’t.... like a Prime Minister who isn’t a lying gimp or a chancellor who hasn’t got better hair than ideas.

SpinsForGin · 18/11/2021 08:41

I'm guessing if I moved to Manchester it would change again.

It wouldn't. Mancunians definitely consider themselves northern.