Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Government don't understand where "the north" actually is?

217 replies

AdamRyan · 18/11/2021 08:05

Government have scrapped the Leeds extension of HS2, so it now goes to Manchester. There will be faster trains to Sheffield as well. This apparently is to enable levelling up of "The North"
www.bbc.co.uk/news

AIBU to think Manchester and Sheffield are barely The North in an English context, let alone when you add in Scotland? What exactly does this do for the most deprived communities in the North East and the Lakes?

I'm so annoyed, the North of the UK just constantly gets left behind :(

OP posts:
HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 18/11/2021 10:41

@LadyCatStark I remember that thread!! So much utter nonsense.

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 10:40

@LakieLady
Urgh, she's just jealous because she comes from the only part of Yorkshire that doesnt have a proper city.

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 10:39

[quote JollyJoon]@BethAfra
That's not true. Northerners know they are northern. Its only southerners who really struggle with the boundary.[/quote]
I don't struggle with it, and I'm a southerner!

I couldn't for the life of me tell you where the south-east becomes the south-west though. Bournemouth, maybe? Dorchester?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/11/2021 10:37

It’s in Westeros isn’t it?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/11/2021 10:36

I think the north is above the midlands. So east and west midlands (Birmingham, Nottingham etc) are midlands and anything north of that is 'the north'

user0176 · 18/11/2021 10:33

I don't understand HS2, it seems so ridiculously expensive for the little it gains, it seems to me it would make sense to use the money upgrading the rail network across the country rather than an arbitrary fast line in very limited locations (that will likely cost the Earth and therefore less tangible benefit to the majority). Leeds and Manchester are already pretty accessible to the south by rail?

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 10:33

@JollyJoon

I'm from Sheffield and I get what you mean, to me Sheffield is only really where the north begins, its not the "deep north". Feel.sorry for Newcastle and co, they always seem to be forgotten.
A colleague of mine thought Scotland started as soon as you got north of Newcastle. He had no idea that there was miles and miles of east coast before you get to the border.

My Yorkshire-born friend maintains that Sheffield only counts as north because it happens to be in Yorkshire, and really it belongs in the Midlands. She comes from what she claims is "proper" Yorkshire, about 10 miles south of Darlington. Shock

Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 10:32

why is your criticism of the Northern regions for trying to make a case for more investment and not of Westminster for not devolving more resources to the SW?

Because the North shouts the loudest & therefore hogs the attentions of Westminster when it comes to the ‘levelling up’ stuff. The North has loads going for it - much cheaper houses, gorgeous countryside, a good network of relatively close large cities meaning it’s easier to get a job & stay close to family at the same time. Wages are low but the money goes further.

But the ‘poor, neglected’ North label has stuck & therefore other places won’t get a look in.

Then you get threads like this complaining about the generic use of ‘North’ but complaining about ‘the South’ like we are a homogenous mass as well 😂

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 10:29

@RobinPenguins

That's true. Good point. On the plus side I just checked train prices for Brighton to London and then Manchester to Liverpool leaving now with no rail cards and the former is much, much more expensive.

RobinPenguins · 18/11/2021 10:28

[quote Glassofshloer]@ColinTheKoala well you call us softies but we’re not the ones on here complaining 😕 I live in the south west & we are more deprived than you are[/quote]
Are you sure you’re not complaining? Because it really sounds like you are. I’m not suggesting you don’t have good cause to (although much of the SW is rural so it’s a different complaint IMO) - but why is your criticism of the Northern regions for trying to make a case for more investment and not of Westminster for not devolving more resources to the SW?

RobinPenguins · 18/11/2021 10:25

@JollyJoon

In fairness though I once saw a documentary, can't remember where it was set, maybe Kent or Essex or somewhere, and was really shocked to see the poverty there. It was people living in basically what looked like caravan parks on the coast, but these were their actual houses. Inside them, it was dismal. Lots of stories of addiction. Normally when we think 'Kent' we think posh manors. Apparently Somerset is really bad too, So maybe just as southerners can be ignorant about the north (you want to see some of the manors in Cheshire...), northerners can be very ignorant about the south too.

I was quite shocked when I went to Brighton too. It basically felt like London in the centre, but you realise that there is no real social mixing in the bars and clubs there. Then when you go out to places like Whitehawk, you realise it's very segregated, and even in places like Sussex, there is poverty everywhere.

I think the difference is that those places exist in northern regions too, but our cities and supposedly affluent areas have nowhere near the level of investment of London and the SE in particular. If the rail links between Brighton and London or Reading and London, for example, were anything like as shit as between Manchester and Liverpool or Manchester and Leeds, for example, there would be outrage. And within regions the public transport investment is a fraction of what other areas benefit from. People who live in Greater London have no idea how much better their public transport options are than for those who live in the northern city regions, and those should be like-for-like comparisons. It’s not like we’re comparing rural backwaters with London and expecting the same, we’re talking about major city regions with developed urban areas.

Wholly agree there’s crushing poverty in poorly-connected coastal areas, but that’s a different issue.

JaceLancs · 18/11/2021 10:24

I’m in Lancashire who would have guessed
We are definitely in the North although I’m usually more specific and say I live in the North west
I’ve also lived and worked in London and the South East there is definitely a big divide financially - access to government funding, poorer services including NHS but I don’t feel like a victim I choose to live here
What we should be discussing is equality I would not expect to receive poorer treatment because I’m female so why should I get it because of where I live

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 10:24

@AlphabetAerobics

YANBU - but this is not just politics - it’s evident enough right here across these forums.

I’m 3 times as far north from Manchester than Manchester is from London. In the last few weeks I’ve been told it’s IMPOSSIBLE it’s getting dark before 4pm. Hmm

Well, you can't reason with stupid, sadly.

If I was 5 miles further south I'd be in the sea, but even I know how quickly sunrise/sunset times vary as you head north, and how the difference is greater at different times of the year.

I used to know someone who grew up on Yell, and she told me that in midsummer it barely gets properly dark and that in midwinter it barely gets properly light.

Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 10:24

I consider the North to be anything above the point of Wales, the Midlands to be anything at the same level as Wales, the South to be anything below Wales

But it’s subjective isn’t it really depending on where you live.

Needdoughnuts · 18/11/2021 10:23

I think England needs autonomy like Wales and Scotland. The assembly should sit in Birmingham. London would make all the decisions about the UK as a whole but Birmingham would make decisions about England, school funding, town planning etc. Disclaimer: I haven't thought this through.

Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 10:23

The south will stop lumping everything above Oxford in as ‘the North’ when the North stops lumping everything else as ‘the South’ 🤷🏼‍♀️

Anordinarymum · 18/11/2021 10:22

If nobody can agree where the bloody North of England is on here then how is Boris going to be able to?

Hilarious

Spedder · 18/11/2021 10:21

YANBU. Manchester is 200 miles north of London. But there are parts of England that are 200 miles north of Manchester!

Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 10:21

@Porcupineintherough no I live in Devon.

Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 10:20

@ColinTheKoala well you call us softies but we’re not the ones on here complaining 😕 I live in the south west & we are more deprived than you are

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 10:20

In fairness though I once saw a documentary, can't remember where it was set, maybe Kent or Essex or somewhere, and was really shocked to see the poverty there. It was people living in basically what looked like caravan parks on the coast, but these were their actual houses. Inside them, it was dismal. Lots of stories of addiction. Normally when we think 'Kent' we think posh manors. Apparently Somerset is really bad too, So maybe just as southerners can be ignorant about the north (you want to see some of the manors in Cheshire...), northerners can be very ignorant about the south too.

I was quite shocked when I went to Brighton too. It basically felt like London in the centre, but you realise that there is no real social mixing in the bars and clubs there. Then when you go out to places like Whitehawk, you realise it's very segregated, and even in places like Sussex, there is poverty everywhere.

BarstewardofNorthstead · 18/11/2021 10:18

'Up north' as defined by the one hit wonders of KLF and Justified Ancients of Mu Mu.....

Bolton,
Barnsley,
Nelson,
Colne,
Burnley
Bradford,
Buxton,
Crewe,
Warrington,
Widnes,
Wigan,
Leeds,
Northwich,
Nantwich,
Knutsford,
Hull,
Sale,
Salford,
Southport,
Leigh,
Derby,
Kearsley
Keighley
Maghull,
Harrogate,
Huddersfield,
Oldham, Lancs,
Grimsby,
Glossop,
Hebden Bridge,

It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North.

Brighouse,
Bootle,
Featherstone,
Speke,
Runcorn,
Rotherham,
Rochdale,
Barrow,
Morecambe,
Macclesfield,
Lytham St. Annes
Clitheroe,
Cleethorpes,
The M62,

It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North.

Pendlebury,
Prestwich,
Preston,
York,
Skipton,
Scunthorpe,
Scarborough-on-Sea,
Chester,
Chorley,
Cheedle Hulme,
Ormskirk,
Accrington Stanley,
and Leigh,
Ossett,
Otley,
Ikley Moor,
Sheffield,
Manchester,
Castleford,
Skem,
Doncaster,
Dewsbury,
Hali-fax,
Bingley,
Bramall,
Are all in the North.

It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North

Porcupineintherough · 18/11/2021 10:17

@Glassofshloer

I don’t think the North will ever be happy, no matter how much is invested in it. It has a bit of a victim mentality. Sorry if that sounds rude but I am prepared to back that up.
How about we test this by distributing government investment more evenly for 30 years or so and see? Oh and come up with a system of government where more people see their votes reflected? Because what you see as a victim mentality is what I see as reasonable complaints about the distribution of wealth and power. Or are you one of those folk in the home counties who hyperventilates at the thought that you may no longer be able to eat all the pie?
LakieLady · 18/11/2021 10:16

@dreamingbohemian

I find this question of where the North begins fascinating (I'm not originally from the UK) OP where would you say it begins? Is Leeds the North?

YANBU to be annoyed, it's really shocking how the government so completely ignore a whole part of the country

For me, the North begins at an imaginary line between the Mersey and the Humber.

Below that line, and above an imaginary line between the Severn and the Wash, is the Midlands.

And I agree that because of our London-centric government and media, the North gets disregarded, but I also recognise that a far greater proportion of the population lives south of the Midlands.

ColinTheKoala · 18/11/2021 10:13

@Glassofshloer

I don’t think the North will ever be happy, no matter how much is invested in it. It has a bit of a victim mentality. Sorry if that sounds rude but I am prepared to back that up.
Softie southerners always say that (especially about Liverpool) and it's rubbish.

The country is orientated towards the south and London in particular. Pointing that out does not imply victimhood (and anyway I live in the south).