Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Government don't understand where "the north" actually is?

217 replies

AdamRyan · 18/11/2021 08:05

Government have scrapped the Leeds extension of HS2, so it now goes to Manchester. There will be faster trains to Sheffield as well. This apparently is to enable levelling up of "The North"
www.bbc.co.uk/news

AIBU to think Manchester and Sheffield are barely The North in an English context, let alone when you add in Scotland? What exactly does this do for the most deprived communities in the North East and the Lakes?

I'm so annoyed, the North of the UK just constantly gets left behind :(

OP posts:
dropitlikeitsloth · 18/11/2021 12:33

My perception 😂 below the black line is the South, above the blue line is The North and in between the Midlands. Wasn’t sure what to do about Wales tried to get a North/South split but I failed miserably.

No offence meant by the way, purely me having a go at it. Just my opinion.

To think the Government don't understand where "the north" actually is?
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/11/2021 12:28

@Glassofshloer

I don’t think the North will ever be happy, no matter how much is invested in it. It has a bit of a victim mentality. Sorry if that sounds rude but I am prepared to back that up.
Sometimes a "victim mentality" comes form being an actual victim.

Once this country spends as much elsewhere per person on transport and other public services as it does in London we can talk - until then London is getting the lion's share as usual.

Hillarious · 18/11/2021 12:23

@JollyJoon

I'm from Sheffield and I get what you mean, to me Sheffield is only really where the north begins, its not the "deep north". Feel.sorry for Newcastle and co, they always seem to be forgotten.
Also from Sheffield. Definitely this is the north.

Went up to the very north of Scotland this summer. That is a long, long way from Sheffield, let alone London!

RobotValkyrie · 18/11/2021 12:22

Yeah, they seem to think the North = Manchester/Liverpool.
Sure these cities are part of it, but there's quite a lot of room still between there and Scotland!

Not sure where these Londoners get their geography knowledge from, but I suspect it's mostly 60s pop culture, like where did this famous boys band come from, or where did that soap opera get filmed...

dropitlikeitsloth · 18/11/2021 12:21

I’m afraid I don’t know where the North/South divide is, I imagine it’s somewhere either side of Birmingham (being Midlands) Blush I’d class Manchester as North though! I think Manchester upwards is what I’d say. Looks like it is confusing:

loopylindi · 18/11/2021 12:17

Well now...what about the south west? No it's not the same as the South (employment OK, housing OK, social deprivation generally OK) We're beginning to think the South west begins and ends at Bristol. We have 1 main railway line into the whole of Devon and Cornwall which may or may not survive another big storm. We have 1 main motorway for all traffic to Devon and Cornwall (never mind an HS3-4-5) to cut five minutes off the time to Penzance. We have two main hospital hubs in Devon - with several regional hospitals which are miles apart and getting to them on the congested roads (especially in high season) is a nightmare. In addition we have some of the poorest areas with high levels of deprivation in the country. The Barrett formula for working out school finances results in less per capita spending on our children than up t'north. Seaside economies have suffered terribly over the last few years with the trend to shop closures being felt long ago.
Yes we have lovely scenery but man cannot live on fresh air alone.

TheKLF · 18/11/2021 11:59

@BarstewardofNorthstead

'Up north' as defined by the one hit wonders of KLF and Justified Ancients of Mu Mu.....

Bolton,
Barnsley,
Nelson,
Colne,
Burnley
Bradford,
Buxton,
Crewe,
Warrington,
Widnes,
Wigan,
Leeds,
Northwich,
Nantwich,
Knutsford,
Hull,
Sale,
Salford,
Southport,
Leigh,
Derby,
Kearsley
Keighley
Maghull,
Harrogate,
Huddersfield,
Oldham, Lancs,
Grimsby,
Glossop,
Hebden Bridge,

It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North.

Brighouse,
Bootle,
Featherstone,
Speke,
Runcorn,
Rotherham,
Rochdale,
Barrow,
Morecambe,
Macclesfield,
Lytham St. Annes
Clitheroe,
Cleethorpes,
The M62,

It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North.

Pendlebury,
Prestwich,
Preston,
York,
Skipton,
Scunthorpe,
Scarborough-on-Sea,
Chester,
Chorley,
Cheedle Hulme,
Ormskirk,
Accrington Stanley,
and Leigh,
Ossett,
Otley,
Ikley Moor,
Sheffield,
Manchester,
Castleford,
Skem,
Doncaster,
Dewsbury,
Hali-fax,
Bingley,
Bramall,
Are all in the North.

It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North,
It's Grim Up North

👍
TheABC · 18/11/2021 11:39

@HarrietsChariot

The north is the line between the Severn Estuary and The Wash. Leicester, Lincoln, Birmingham and Cardiff are all north. Northampton, Peterborough and Norwich are all south.
Birmingham is the Midlands (we always get overlooked!).

"Northern England" for me is Manchester, York and Newcastle. If it's "Northern UK", the Highlands.

ExceptionalAssurance · 18/11/2021 11:38

Manchester and Sheffield are squarely, unequivocally in the north of England. However, they are only one part of it, and the problem is that this government's idea of assisting the region is just to throw a bit of money at a fairly small geographic percentage of it.

Hospedia · 18/11/2021 11:35

In terms of government spending, "The North" is Manchester and surrounding areas and "The South" is London and surrounding areas. Anyone living in any areas other than this gets some waffle about leveling up, powerhouses, and being proud but no actual investment.

Twas ever thus and ever it shall be.

Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 11:34

@AdamRyan

The North has loads going for it - much cheaper houses, gorgeous countryside, a good network of relatively close large cities meaning it’s easier to get a job & stay close to family at the same time. Cheap houses cos the job opportunities are not so good/wages are depressed If you don't drive its extremely difficult to get between cities, if you do drive it takes ages. They might look close but aren't that easy to get to (have you actually tried traversing Leeds and the ring road?)

I don't live in the North but grew up there, I grew up near Leeds and my grandparents lived in Northumberland near the Scottish border. It was a 2.5 hour drive to see them (100 miles)
My other grandparents lived on the West Coast of the lakes, also a 2.5 hour drive. Nothing has changed to make those journeys easier.

Don't even get me started on the East Coast.

People in those areas can't access higher paying jobs cos transport is shit. So they leave.

Also the same definitely applies to the SW (where I'm based now). I can get to London in 90 minutes. Takes 3.5 hours to Leeds on the train. And the costs are punitive.

Yeah but that means at least houses are more affordable. Here in SW we have biggest gap between wages & house prices. Wages being depressed means less if houses are cheap.
AdamRyan · 18/11/2021 11:26

The North has loads going for it - much cheaper houses, gorgeous countryside, a good network of relatively close large cities meaning it’s easier to get a job & stay close to family at the same time.
Cheap houses cos the job opportunities are not so good/wages are depressed
If you don't drive its extremely difficult to get between cities, if you do drive it takes ages. They might look close but aren't that easy to get to (have you actually tried traversing Leeds and the ring road?)

I don't live in the North but grew up there, I grew up near Leeds and my grandparents lived in Northumberland near the Scottish border. It was a 2.5 hour drive to see them (100 miles)
My other grandparents lived on the West Coast of the lakes, also a 2.5 hour drive. Nothing has changed to make those journeys easier.

Don't even get me started on the East Coast.

People in those areas can't access higher paying jobs cos transport is shit. So they leave.

Also the same definitely applies to the SW (where I'm based now). I can get to London in 90 minutes. Takes 3.5 hours to Leeds on the train. And the costs are punitive.

OP posts:
Hemingwayscats · 18/11/2021 11:25

Major blow to Yorkshire. Leeds is a much bigger, more metropolitan city than Sheffield with lots more business so I’m not quite sure I understand the governments logic here at all. Same goes for everything they do though so unsurprising.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/11/2021 11:24

m.youtube.com/watch?v=ENeCYwms-Cc

Sittingonabench · 18/11/2021 11:20

They do mean England but the north of England is quite big and when they talk about investment in the north they mean the very southern-most point of the north. Used to confuse me as a kid as Manchester is around 3 hrs drive south of where I grew up. It’s all nonsense and one of the reasons there feels like there is such a divide.

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 11:04

@AdamRyan

I mean, Manchester is in the North. But only barely. Same with Sheffield. Fucks me right off that the Government constantly say they are investing in the Northern Powerhouse by which they mean Manchester. There needs to be better transport links across the North and into Scotland, not focussed on links into London. The Government need to start focusing on Northern England as a region, and if they conservatives want to appeal to unionists and Scottish voters they need to benefit links between Scotland and England too
I agree with you, and I get infuriated by fellow-southerners who can't see that investment in the north of England and Scotland will benefit the south, too.

If there were better transport links for the North and Scotland it would make relocation of businesses and jobs more attractive and reduce pressure on homes, transport, schools, NHS etc in the south.

It would improve things for the whole country imo.

Courtier · 18/11/2021 11:00

@TrashyPanda

The North = Inverness, Aberdeen etc. The North of England is totally different.
The North refers to the North of England. Aberdeen etc would be referred to as Scotland.

England = North, Midlands, South
Scotland = Highlands, Lowlands, Islands

Courtier · 18/11/2021 10:59

Fucksake. I only needed the Leeds line to visit my family. Well, guess I'll never use HS2 then

NorthSouthcatlady · 18/11/2021 10:54

A lot of people don’t know where the north of England is, disturbing as it’s really not that difficult!!

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 10:52

@DoormatBob

I'm in Cumbria and I can't support this idea of a Northern Assembly as I believe that will just focus money into Manchester/Liverpool.

I just think to myself life could be worse. I could live in Manchester, Liverpool or London!

Funds will always be spent more readily in the more densely populated areas, because that is where the greatest number of people will benefit. However, the old standard spending assessment (the formula central government used to allocate funds to local government) also recognised that it costs more to deliver services in sparsely populated areas and included a low-density element that gave an additional amount to rural areas.

God knows how they do it now, and the central government grant is dwindling year on year, so it probably doesn't affect much.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 18/11/2021 10:51

@Itsnotallaboutyoubaby

I live in the midlands. Family from London consider us to live in the North… I consider the North, Yorkshire and upward. I actually love the North.
I'm in the Midlands. Lost track of the amount of times I've said "I'm not from the North!" or "I'm not from the South!"
Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 10:47

@user0176 I only know a little of the Midlands but from what I can see you’re a bit like us here in SW - totally overlooked in the clash of the titans between London and the North

user0176 · 18/11/2021 10:45

I think the north is above the midlands. So east and west midlands (Birmingham, Nottingham etc) are midlands and anything north of that is 'the north'

This is my opinion, I'm in the midlands and don't identify with the problems touted as southern or northern. I know the midlands aren't really seen as aspirational areas of the UK by any stretch but I really feel like we have the best of both worlds in many respects, easily connected to London and the business benefits that brings whilst benefitting from the cheaper cost of living that comes the more north you go. I can be in London in an hour, but I have a large detached house on a large plot in a nice area for £350k.

Glassofshloer · 18/11/2021 10:43

@LakieLady

Anywhere west of Southampton. We have to keep the gorgeous New Forest!

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 10:41

I think this is a great opportunity for me to shoehorn in my favourite poem. May I?

The Rolling English Road
By G. K. Chesterton

Before the Roman came to Rye or out to Severn strode,
The rolling English drunkard made the rolling English road.
A reeling road, a rolling road, that rambles round the shire,
And after him the parson ran, the sexton and the squire;
A merry road, a mazy road, and such as we did tread
The night we went to Birmingham by way of Beachy Head.

I knew no harm of Bonaparte and plenty of the Squire,
And for to fight the Frenchman I did not much desire;
But I did bash their baggonets because they came arrayed
To straighten out the crooked road an English drunkard made,
Where you and I went down the lane with ale-mugs in our hands,
The night we went to Glastonbury by way of Goodwin Sands.

His sins they were forgiven him; or why do flowers run
Behind him; and the hedges all strengthening in the sun?
The wild thing went from left to right and knew not which was which,
But the wild rose was above him when they found him in the ditch.
God pardon us, nor harden us; we did not see so clear
The night we went to Bannockburn by way of Brighton Pier.

My friends, we will not go again or ape an ancient rage,
Or stretch the folly of our youth to be the shame of age,
But walk with clearer eyes and ears this path that wandereth,
And see undrugged in evening light the decent inn of death;
For there is good news yet to hear and fine things to be seen,
Before we go to Paradise by way of Kensal Green.