Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to pay cleaner by bank transfer not cash.

360 replies

Starryskiesinthesky · 18/11/2021 07:41

Cleaner wants paid in cash but I never have cash so would prefer to pay by bank transfer. Fact she wants cash makes me think she’s not declaring it. What do others do and do you care if they are not declaring it? £15 per hour if it makes a difference. Thanks.

OP posts:
TeacupDrama · 18/11/2021 11:36

everyone on mumsnet seems to live in zone 2 or 3 or 30 miinutes from town no one seems to live in Shrewsbury kidderminister ipswich hull or meltom mowbray

I always have some cash as sometimes the card machine in a small shop is down as relying on internet which in some places is slow and the only way to get your bread and milk is cash, sometimes banking websites crash for a day or two
and unfortunately some people do not pay immediately with BT so you have to chase them up. my childminder said this was a constant problem people paying too late sometimes some people just need the money exactly on time to pay bills they simply sdon;t have an extra £200-300 in current account as a cushion for late payers before DD for electric council tax go out of their account

WeRateSquirrels · 18/11/2021 11:35

@Proudboomer

I can’t believe so many people don’t ever have cash on them or in their house. What do you do if your child needs a couple of pound for one of the numerous theme days they do? Do you not give to charity tin rustlers ie buy a poppy, shove lose change in the collection tin for your local hospice or suchlike? Don’t your children ask for a few pound to go to the pictures, bowling alley or just to the corner shop? Don’t you ever what to buy something you don’t want to appear on your bank statement? Don’t you put a fiver in a birthday card for a party your child is attending? Dont you put anything in charity collection envelopes when they come through the door, don’t you give your children your lose change to they can hear their money box rattle when they shake it and learn that they need to save x amount of pennies to buy the comic they want?
Theme days at DS school now only payable online. Rarely go into town so don't see any 'tin rustlers' If DS needs money I do a bank transfer No I don't ever buy anything I don't want to appear on bank statement (?!) We don't get collection envelopes through the door DS well past the money box/money in birthday card stage

Only thing I have cash for is the window cleaner, and that's really irritating!

Exhausteddog · 18/11/2021 11:30

I thought cleaners generally earned £15-20 per hour

Cleaners near me charge £15-16/hour but this might include their own cleaning materials, insurance and other overheads etc so not the same as earning £15/hour.

TeeBee · 18/11/2021 11:28

I've had cleaners who prefer cash and others who don't care. When I had ones who preferred cash, I just drew a load of cash out that would pay them for a month or two and put it in a jar, ready to pay them. Hardly a hardship.

Her tax is her business but it doesn't mean she's not declaring just because she prefers cash.

Proudboomer · 18/11/2021 11:25

I can’t believe so many people don’t ever have cash on them or in their house.
What do you do if your child needs a couple of pound for one of the numerous theme days they do? Do you not give to charity tin rustlers ie buy a poppy, shove lose change in the collection tin for your local hospice or suchlike? Don’t your children ask for a few pound to go to the pictures, bowling alley or just to the corner shop? Don’t you ever what to buy something you don’t want to appear on your bank statement? Don’t you put a fiver in a birthday card for a party your child is attending? Dont you put anything in charity collection envelopes when they come through the door, don’t you give your children your lose change to they can hear their money box rattle when they shake it and learn that they need to save x amount of pennies to buy the comic they want?

notanothertakeaway · 18/11/2021 11:24

Some while ago a family member was caught out paying someone in cash and the tax people said that what he'd paid them was net pay. He ended up being sent a demand to pay the tax and NI which would have been deducted to get to that net pay figure

The person they were "employing" did not have to pay anything extra!

@bestcoffeepot that sounds like your family member was paying an employee in cash, to avoid paying tax, NI etc. That's quite different from paying a self employed contractor, in which case it's the contractor's responsibility to pay tax, NI on their earnings

Takemetothe90s · 18/11/2021 11:23

@malificent7

Why begrudge a cleaner not declaring it when so many rich MPs also dont declare expenses etc?
Exactly, this really pisses me off!! The people begrudging their cleaner cash are probably the same giving to food backs and declaring how awful it is that the working poor need to choose between heating or eating!!
Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 18/11/2021 11:09

Why? Why do you need proof you have paid your cleaner for her weekly clean of, what 2 hours?

I don't have a cleaner but personally I'd like the reassurance that I had paid her. That I hadn't forgotten and she was silently seething or trying to work out how to ask me for the money without making everything awkward.

JurgensCakeBaby · 18/11/2021 11:05

Our gardener wants cash on the day, he had too many people not paying by transfer then had to chase them. Maybe she has an overdraft or credit card debts, maybe she has a partner who tries to control her finances and it's easier for her to squirrel some cash away (as women are often advised to do here). It doesn't automatically mean she's committing tax fraud, using cash is a legitimate payment option.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 18/11/2021 11:04

All the excuses that its so hard for you also mean those same excuses are why its hard for her to then withdraw the cash.

But the vast majority of people aren't paid their wages in cash yet they still manage to pay their bills, spend money etc. What is so different about cleaners?

Oftenithinkaboutit · 18/11/2021 11:02

@StoppinBy

I would pay by Bank Transfer simply so there was a record of making each payment.

Whether they declare it or not I don't care either way but I would like proof that I have paid.

Why? Why do you need proof you have paid your cleaner for her weekly clean of, what 2 hours?
StoppinBy · 18/11/2021 11:01

I would pay by Bank Transfer simply so there was a record of making each payment.

Whether they declare it or not I don't care either way but I would like proof that I have paid.

thebellagio · 18/11/2021 10:58

@Sweetpeasaremadeforbees

People on MN are often a bit patronising about cleaners, like they are all desperate women who can't find another job and have no skills and their job is so godawful and no one would chose to so it so let's be super kind to them. No one suggests this of window cleaners and gardeners, but cleaners seem to inspire pity in people, as if it's a job not worth doing (yet plenty are happy to pay for it!)

I have a couple of good friends who are cleaners and both are rightly very proud of the business they have built up, and they do treat it like a business. It works well for them because they chose their own hours and where to work, they can fit it around other commitments, and they enjoy it. They aren't destitute or in need of someone's pity because they're 'cleaning skin cells'

This x 1000000. The hourly rate is often more than an ALDI worker. It's middle class MN at it's worst.

Absolutely. I thought cleaners generally earned £15-20 per hour -significantly more than the NMW? Therefore, they earn good money and have the potential to have a thriving business that they can build around their lifestyles. It's absolutely nothing to be sneered at!
RoomOfRequirement · 18/11/2021 10:58

I'd get cash from the supermarket cash back and pay in cash if that's what she prefers and she's a good cleaner. All the excuses that its so hard for you also mean those same excuses are why its hard for her to then withdraw the cash.

MiddleParking · 18/11/2021 10:54

We got a cleaner to take a task away from us, not give us a different task to take on. I wouldn’t bother with one that insisted on cash. I know on MN you have to agree to literally any terms a cleaner might propose or you’ll never find another but in my experience it’s a mutually beneficial arrangement where both parties accommodate each other. And it’s a bit of a stretch to suggest that preferring digital payments makes you responsible for the receiver thereof being unable to flee domestic abuse Hmm

yikerspipers · 18/11/2021 10:50

@Starcaller totally agree. It's bizarre. My cleaner is ridiculously in demand and can pick and choose her clients and moves us all around to suit her schedule and needs etc. She professional and very good at what she does. And I pay her in cash.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 18/11/2021 10:48

People on MN are often a bit patronising about cleaners, like they are all desperate women who can't find another job and have no skills and their job is so godawful and no one would chose to so it so let's be super kind to them. No one suggests this of window cleaners and gardeners, but cleaners seem to inspire pity in people, as if it's a job not worth doing (yet plenty are happy to pay for it!)

I have a couple of good friends who are cleaners and both are rightly very proud of the business they have built up, and they do treat it like a business. It works well for them because they chose their own hours and where to work, they can fit it around other commitments, and they enjoy it. They aren't destitute or in need of someone's pity because they're 'cleaning skin cells'

This x 1000000. The hourly rate is often more than an ALDI worker. It's middle class MN at it's worst.

Peaplant20 · 18/11/2021 10:44

I find it a faff too, especially as it’s never an amount in £10 or £20 denominations.

yikerspipers · 18/11/2021 10:41

@bestcoffeepot because HMRC would need to determine that the cleaner is actually your employee rather than working for herself as a contractor. Unless she is coming everyday or there are other reasons to think she is an "employee", this would never happen.

Starcaller · 18/11/2021 10:40

People on MN are often a bit patronising about cleaners, like they are all desperate women who can't find another job and have no skills and their job is so godawful and no one would chose to so it so let's be super kind to them. No one suggests this of window cleaners and gardeners, but cleaners seem to inspire pity in people, as if it's a job not worth doing (yet plenty are happy to pay for it!)

I have a couple of good friends who are cleaners and both are rightly very proud of the business they have built up, and they do treat it like a business. It works well for them because they chose their own hours and where to work, they can fit it around other commitments, and they enjoy it. They aren't destitute or in need of someone's pity because they're 'cleaning skin cells' Hmm

bestcoffeepot · 18/11/2021 10:39

@yikerspipers

Some while ago a family member was caught out paying someone in cash and the tax people said that what he'd paid them was net pay. He ended up being sent a demand to pay the tax and NI which would have been deducted to get to that net pay figure.

This would be because HMRC deemed this person to be your family member "employee". Would never happen with a cleaner. Don't scaremonger.

Why would it not happen ?
ToastieSnowy · 18/11/2021 10:38

I used to pay in cash each time my cleaner came, until the cleaning agency rang and said I hadn’t paid. In the end I paid again to keep the peace and then cancelled the contract. I wouldn’t pay in cash again.

Jconnais1chansonquivavsenerver · 18/11/2021 10:33

I see the OP has decided to carry on cleaning herself, but here's my tuppence worth anyway! It may be the cleaner doesn't have a bank account for you to transfer the payment to? I agree, having the correct cash ready to pay the cleaner is a complete PITA, but if they are a good cleaner, it is worth making a special trip to a cash point or to get cash back once a month or even once a quarter, to be able to pay them cash in hand if that is what they ask for.

TheChosenTwo · 18/11/2021 10:31

My cleaner accepts both. I have a DD set up to pay her every week on the same day.
My neighbor uses the same cleaner and prefers to pay her cash.
I don’t give a crap what she does with her cash tbh. Declare it or not, she’s bloody brilliant at what she does.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 18/11/2021 10:29

Neither of you are unreasonable, it comes down to if this is a deal breaker for either of you. There could be a number of reasons to want to be paid in cash; from the bad, wanting to not pay taxes or benefit fraud; to the mundane, our cleaner is part of a larger company, it's easier for them to pay the companies cut if they get cash; to survival, needing cash to live off so it's not swallowed up in debt or needing cash so an abusive partner/parent can't control all the money. You don't need to attach a value judgement to people wanting to be paid in cash, you can't know if the reason is nefarious, or mundane or one worthy of support. It's either this is a deal breaker for you, or it isn't. If it is tell the cleaner that you're unable to pay in cash and ask if they'll accept bank transfer. If they won't let you pay by bank transfer, you take your business elsewhere. If on balance you'd rather pay in cash then find a new cleaner, do that and leave the cleaners ethical choices to them.