Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to pay cleaner by bank transfer not cash.

360 replies

Starryskiesinthesky · 18/11/2021 07:41

Cleaner wants paid in cash but I never have cash so would prefer to pay by bank transfer. Fact she wants cash makes me think she’s not declaring it. What do others do and do you care if they are not declaring it? £15 per hour if it makes a difference. Thanks.

OP posts:
yikerspipers · 20/11/2021 18:31

@stevalnamechanger

Well if she isn't declaring it , is she insured ? Is she DBS checked?

If I had proof of that wouldn't mind paying cash

My cleaner is neither DBS checked nor insured. Why would that matter to your paying cash?
thebellagio · 20/11/2021 18:29

Interesting how many people are still adamant it’s a tax avoidance thing rather than a making sure she gets paid thing despite many of us self employed people explaining why she probably wants cash.

I doubt many people will be avoiding making their earnings legit after realising how crucial it was for the SEISS grants over the past few years….

MLMshouldbeillegal · 20/11/2021 18:24

@stevalnamechanger

Well if she isn't declaring it , is she insured ? Is she DBS checked?

If I had proof of that wouldn't mind paying cash

Another person who doesn't know what they're talking about.

Why would you need a DBS check for cleaning?

Offmyfence · 20/11/2021 17:59

@PearlclutchersInc

My cleaner charges £13 an hour. I dont believe for a minute she's declaring it. If she did she'd probably charge a lot more.

malificent has a point, why pick on these people when the upper echelons are avoiding paying tax left, right and centre.

At that rate your cleaner would need to work 18.5 hours a week for 52 weeks of the year.

I can't think they do much more than that! So after allowable expenses etc, I think it would be sod all to declare.

Meanwhile...... MPs, Amazon etc

PearlclutchersInc · 20/11/2021 17:52

My cleaner charges £13 an hour. I dont believe for a minute she's declaring it. If she did she'd probably charge a lot more.

malificent has a point, why pick on these people when the upper echelons are avoiding paying tax left, right and centre.

Oftenithinkaboutit · 20/11/2021 17:37

@JustLyra

Oh she doesn’t work for the HMRC! Grin

JustLyra · 20/11/2021 16:56

@Bejaysus767

I would try to avoid paying in cash too! And whether she pays her taxes is actually a matter for me because I work for HMRC! I have a duty to report any suspected tax avoidance or evasion Wink
Why would you think you have a duty to report suspected tax avoidance when it’s not remotely illegal?
Oftenithinkaboutit · 20/11/2021 16:51

@Bejaysus767

Yes, sure you are. And you name changed just to make that point Grin

MrsDThomas · 20/11/2021 16:24

@Bejaysus767 you sound like a right jobsworth. Bet you’re fun.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 15:49

@NeverDropYourMooncup

Why don't tradespeople carry cash for change

Because people want them to take bank transfers so that the state is protected from losing the heady sum of about (assuming they've passed the tax free allowance by working over 16 hours a week at £15/h) about a fiver a week.

It's the important thing. Beth who fits in two cleaning jobs a day and has to be told to make sure that the tassels on the rug all lay straight after she's vacuumed and Fred who cuts the grass once a month need to make up for everything that Amazon avoids. They're the ones who really, really matter.

You've missed the point. I don't care about tax (and disagree with the OP's premise that the cleaner wants cash because she isn't paying tax, none of OP's business). But the discussion then veered into how much of a faff paying with cash is.

Surely tradespeople carrying change would reduce said faff because one of the problems with cash is the lack of exact change and make people want to pay in cash.

stevalnamechanger · 20/11/2021 15:38

Well if she isn't declaring it , is she insured ?
Is she DBS checked?

If I had proof of that wouldn't mind paying cash

BirdyBirdyTweetTweet · 20/11/2021 15:34

I'd prefer to pay via bank as I don't visit cash points.

BUTTTT I also think she should be able to not declare a clean here and there.

Offmyfence · 20/11/2021 15:25

@Bejaysus767

I would try to avoid paying in cash too! And whether she pays her taxes is actually a matter for me because I work for HMRC! I have a duty to report any suspected tax avoidance or evasion Wink
When did tax avoidance become illegal?
Oftenithinkaboutit · 20/11/2021 12:59

@C8H10N4O2

* Its interesting that its never the older or less well off clients who do this, its always middle class clients who are just so terribly busy that little things like paying the staff slip their self centred minds.*

Surely the definition of middle class is having a cleaner! Grin

Oftenithinkaboutit · 20/11/2021 12:56

The reason why your private consultant doesn’t accept cash is because presumably he’s charging hundreds of pounds

My cleaner? £14 an hour for 2 hours a week

So your analogy is daft to say the least

C8H10N4O2 · 20/11/2021 12:45

@Bejaysus767

I would try to avoid paying in cash too! And whether she pays her taxes is actually a matter for me because I work for HMRC! I have a duty to report any suspected tax avoidance or evasion Wink
But again why is your assumption that someone lower end is fiddling tax rather than dealing with the very commonplace problem of employers not paying on time?

When my cleaner started she took (preferred) cheques from all her clients and was happy to be a bit flexible about specific days/hours if needed.

She now requires cash for the first six months of any new client and contracts a number of hours and notice periods if the service is not required in any one week. This is nothing to do with tax and everything to do with lousy payers and people messing her about which costs her money. Other cleaners she knows now do the same as the problem has become so much worse over the last ten years.

Its interesting that its never the older or less well off clients who do this, its always middle class clients who are just so terribly busy that little things like paying the staff slip their self centred minds.

RecentYears · 20/11/2021 12:44

@RecentYears

Wait, what? you actually think this is a sackable offence? Christ on a bike. So you would sack someone for asking to be paid in cash.

I'd jave to leave if I insisted on being paid cash. Lots of people have been in exactly that position over the years as payroll transferred from little paypackets to direct to bank accounts.

Ultimately, this isn't an employee, it's a contractor. If OP wants to use one who she can pay direct she's entitled to do so, just as cleaner will have to accept she may lose business if she doesn't accept direct payment.

That's not because of the tax issue but because it's easier and less risky for the employer/OP
RecentYears · 20/11/2021 12:43

Wait, what? you actually think this is a sackable offence? Christ on a bike. So you would sack someone for asking to be paid in cash.

I'd jave to leave if I insisted on being paid cash. Lots of people have been in exactly that position over the years as payroll transferred from little paypackets to direct to bank accounts.

Ultimately, this isn't an employee, it's a contractor. If OP wants to use one who she can pay direct she's entitled to do so, just as cleaner will have to accept she may lose business if she doesn't accept direct payment.

maddening · 20/11/2021 12:42

Bejaysus767 - but requiring payment in cash is not grounds for reasonable suspicion and you should know that.

maddening · 20/11/2021 12:40

I don't mind paying cash at all, but I pay a month in advance by bank transfer and my cleaner is fine with this.

How she handles her own finances is non of my business. I also think that accusing people of tax fraud based on no evidence is shitty.

Bejaysus767 · 20/11/2021 12:39

I would try to avoid paying in cash too! And whether she pays her taxes is actually a matter for me because I work for HMRC! I have a duty to report any suspected tax avoidance or evasion Wink

MLMshouldbeillegal · 20/11/2021 12:33

But yet again, you have no idea why she wants cash. And since when has a bank transfer been a cast-iron guarantee of paying taxes?

I've been self-employed for about 15 years. I complete an annual tax return and declare my earnings - all of which come digitally through Paypal or direct transfer into my personal bank account. HMRC have never questioned my return. Never asked to see a bank statement. I could be declaring half my earnings and they wouldn't know.

FreedomFaith · 20/11/2021 12:17

@malificent7

Why begrudge a cleaner not declaring it when so many rich MPs also dont declare expenses etc?
I don't like anyone avoiding paying taxes. Think if you avoid paying taxes and are caught, you take a year out of getting any benefit that you get from paying taxes, like NHS, police, fire service, bin collection etc. If you need help, you get it, but you pay for it. Taxes fund everything we use, not paying into it and yet still being happy to use said services paid for by others is highly selfish and hypocritical. If you don't like paying towards them, then don't use them. Funny though, they won't do that. Happy to take but not give.

Don't care if that's the local shop keeper, a cleaner, an mp or a big corporation. You should be paying your taxes and it is everyone's concern when people don't pay it.

MLMshouldbeillegal · 20/11/2021 12:09

and it is reasonable to say I'll pay be bank transfer as long as you pay regularly and on time

It's also reasonable in that scenario for the cleaner to say cash or nothing and refuse to work for you.

She sets her own terms and conditions. A condition of using her service is that you pay cash. You're not prepared to stick to those conditions, she chooses to work for someone else.

Why is this concept so hard for some people to get their heads around?

WanderleyWagon · 20/11/2021 11:50

For a good (or, tbh, even a satisfactory!) cleaner, I'd make the effort.

I like the idea of getting cash once a month. Maybe you can have a separate tin for the cleaning money, if you already use the tin system!