Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a bit sad when my mum rewrites history? Anyone else have this?

135 replies

dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn · 18/11/2021 00:44

I'm feeling sad tonight, not sure why. I saw my family this weekend and we were swapping the old stories etc, then one of my sisters mentions my nephew lost his pe kit and she was annoyed by it, and my mum immediately jumps in with

'Oh yea we had that all of year 7 and onwards with dont, lost her pe kit regularly, lost £10 for the bus, got the wrong bus repeatedly, lost things constantly' everyone laughed at how forgetful I was etc

Yes I did all of those things and a lot more, I once forgot to get the bus home on parents evening and waited for my parents to finish but they left whilst I was wandering round the school and they had to come back to the school to get me. It's not neglectful because I didn't tell them I was still at school and my phone was dead.

However!! I wish she would remind my family of the context! I had undiagnosed adhd and dyspraxia, my dad was having chemo and we were driving 2 hours to see him every night in hospital I was doing my homework on the floor of the hospital room or in the back of the car, I was tired and my siblings were older, then he died and we were moving across the country but I only had 2 weeks between him passing away and starting year 8..

When we moved house I started in a smaller school and flourished, got my diagnoses and got the help I needed. I'm now an ODP and I can take patients myself in icu, I've have 2 masters. But yet when I'm with my family I'm relegated to that bumbling child when I was 11!

Grr!!!

OP posts:
ssd · 18/11/2021 08:08

And BTW @dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn, you weren't a "bumbling child of 11". That's your mum speaking there, not you. You were a young girl with a very poorly dad who was trying to navigate her life without much direction. And it sounds like you coped very well under very difficult circumstances.
So replace "bumbling" with "courageous"

dottiedodah · 18/11/2021 08:07

Often I think they do remember the past ,but it suits them to rewrite it! They feel embarrassed and like to paint themselves in a good light!

Franca123 · 18/11/2021 08:04

This is just families. Snap back a bit and they'll soon get the message. I'm the youngest so I know.

dottiedodah · 18/11/2021 08:04

Silvershroud That sounds dreadful! Sorry you had such a bad time .

Mellowyellow222 · 18/11/2021 08:02

When I started big school my mum went to work full time. We got ourselves home from school and had to have dinner on the table for her getting home from work. I can still remeber the time her car would come down the driveway and the panic to get everything tidy and sorted.

She now denies that we made dinner when sylhet talks about being a working mum. Her grandchildren are that age now and she says there is no way we were cooking every night - claims she did it😂.

It does irritate me because it was so stressful and she got really angry if the house wasn’t today and dinner wasn’t ready or nearly ready.

Peppaismyrolemodel · 18/11/2021 08:01

@MarleneDietrichsSmile

It’s a kind of gaslighting really, a power trip in a way?

I think it’s horrible

It is sometimes. Sometimes it simply is a imperfect, perhaps unpleasant, parent retelling history so they look better. It’s still not right, and causes implant and sometimes damage. Adequate parents do it too though-
5zeds · 18/11/2021 08:01

Yes this happens in my family too. I find it really distressing.

ssd · 18/11/2021 08:00

I noticed when i met dh, his mother did this too. She constantly had little digs for him, which made him sound daft, like he couldn't do anything for himself. Yet he was the only one out of her 3 kids who left home and made a life for himself. He could cook and clean and iron and anything else needed. By contrast, his siblings either lived at home well into their 30s or never married and visited their mother every weekend.
I often thought she wanted to punish dh for being independent and not needing her as much as the others.

I wonder if its the same with you @dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn?

You sound like you've done well. Maybe she resents this? Or. As in dhs case, she wishes her favourite child had done as well as you, presuming you have siblings? Sorry not rtft yet

WholeClassKeptIn · 18/11/2021 07:59

I think lots of parents minimise children's pain and experiences (physical or otherwise) if it doesn't tally with what they see. We often see it on here - school issues or emotions which are big for kids minimised as not life threatening. Or kids punished harshly for what could be misunderstanding and miscommunication.

Its hard to take a kids-eye perspective as an adult. Worth trying to and keeping listening though.

Suprima · 18/11/2021 07:58

My DM is non toxic and means well but as a few stories she tells to her friends and acquaintances which make them look like saintly parents and me very useless

What she said 1: they bought me a car and offered to pay for my driving lessons but I was too lazy

What happened: My dad came home with a car from a mate for me to ‘learn to drive in’ but was never mine. He never taught me to drive in it and I was told I had to pay for all lessons myself. I had no savings and no job until I left for uni, at which point ‘my car’ wasn’t there any more.

What she said 2: I was terrible with money and they frequently had to send me take aways when I was at uni because I spent all my money

What happened: once my card was cloned and I had to freeze all of my accounts. I had no shopping in bar a loaf of bread and some jam so my dad offered to send me a Chinese takeaway where I could use the leftovers.

I frequently pull them up when these stories are rattled off. She’s a lovely woman but loves the drama and any opportunity for a ‘kids, who’d have em?’ conversation

BettyBag · 18/11/2021 07:58

@bumblingbovine49

You know what I thought my change in attitude towards my mums memory gaps regarding my teen years happened as I matured but reading that I realise it was when my kids were old enough to challenge my memories of events.

I've handled it like you have (acknowledging what they are saying even though I don't remember it the same way).

There is mixed bag on this thread some stories that are awful and indicate abusive parents some that are just Hmm maybe the latter group will think differently when their kids are older.

Peppaismyrolemodel · 18/11/2021 07:58

It does grate OP, particularly if you have kids- everything good my son does is bc he is ‘so like your sister’

I’m always reminded of that will & grace scene where she gets her ‘mum shield’ out when visiting
It helps to tell someone else the real version so I don’t feel I’m going mad!

bumblingbovine49 · 18/11/2021 07:52

@MarchXX

Yes, its bizarre. My example below is trivial compared to yours, OP, I'm so sorry you had such a bad time but glad you rose above it and flourished. What can you do? Rise above it again, I'm afraid. She won't change Sad.

When I was growing up in the 60s we had a dog. In those days we didn't walk the dog, we let it out to run about the streets and he came home when he'd finished his adventures, scratching on the front door to be let in. That was completely normal to me.

Today, mum (now well into her 80s) denies any such thing ever happened! But it bloody did!

The thing is memories are very tricky things, they are more strongly affected by how we felt at the time than what actually happened

DS upset me the other day by claiming they his dad and I left him to struggle with a very hurt leg when he was younger . His explanation is that he kept telling us his leg hurt and we ignored him for months! I have a vague recollection than he fell while ice skating once and had a bruise and occasionally complained of pain for a few days but seemed to be walking fine and then it seemed to pass..

The truth is probably somewhere in between me being a completely negligent parent ignoring an almost broken leg ( as DS put it) and my recollection of a minor childhood bump that got better within a week

I did apologise to DS for not having paid better attention to his needs at the time but I genuinely do not recall it the way he does.

Seasonschange · 18/11/2021 07:49

My family joke about how I didn’t do any work at school. I wasn’t lazy I was severely bullied with issues at home and suicidal . As a teen I was devastated with my results but as an adult im bloody proud and if they try and gas light me now I push back.

BettyBag · 18/11/2021 07:49

Is all imperfect human behaviour narcissism now? Can't it just be people misunderstanding how something relatively harmless makes some people feel shitty? I know narc mothers exist (my grandma is text book) and maybe ops mum is one but from the limited information we have I am not seeing anything even bordering on narcissism.

What happened to just getting a fucking grip and letting stuff go?

SplodgeWaddler · 18/11/2021 07:44

My DM does this too. She’s a narcissist and her long-winded retellings usually involve some misdemeanour on my part that just didn’t happen or something amazingly clever that we did that didn’t happen either. I usually just zone out when she starts, it’s so bizarre, as if she doesn’t realise we were actually there too 🤷🏻‍♀️

MarleneDietrichsSmile · 18/11/2021 07:44

It’s a kind of gaslighting really, a power trip in a way?

I think it’s horrible

BettyBag · 18/11/2021 07:40

My Mum does this a lot too OP. Talks about things I used to do when I was a teen as of they were naughty teenage things when actually we were going through an appalling situation with my incredibly abusive father (firstly living with abuse then flight from abuse with stalking).

The thing I have realised as I got older, which I hope you realise too is that she was also going through that trauma. I can't imagine how it was for her. It used to make me angry when I was younger but now I play along.

Your mum suffered the trauma of losing your dad too. She isn't perfect but it sounds like it all turned out okay in the end. Give her a break maybe?

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/11/2021 07:34

Oh I am sorry you have this experience OP. I think it’s something parents often use as a defence mechanism when they realise they haven’t done a great job, or haven’t been able to protect their kids against pain (your Dad dying in your case.) It’s often not conscious. It can turn into scapegoating or even bullying to make themselves feel better - hopefully it isn’t in your case.

As a Pp said, some degree of this is common in families, but for many people it is hurtful, especially if their childhood contained a lot of pain like yours.

As you are finding this hurtful, it would be good to find a calm but firm way of pushing back. Eg ‘ sure mum, but after that I was diagnosed w X, once I had the diagnoses and a small school, it all changed.’ ‘Oh no you were always like this’. ‘ well, no, because after that I got a degree and two masters - you aren’t remembering the full picture mum’

What you probably need are a few stock responses that you repeat very neutrally when this comes up. It will make people feel uncomfortable, but it can help break a family pattern.

If you think pain from childhood is getting in your way you might want to see a therapist. It might not be, but worth considering.

You must be very proud of how well you’ve done!

Magicalwoodlands · 18/11/2021 07:31

These always veer between annoying but harmless to downright sinister.

Carol Ann Duffy’s We Remember Your Childhood Well addresses this, if anyone fancies a read of it.

dudsville · 18/11/2021 07:26

I don't know if there's a perfect outcome. My father freely admits faults, but I don't want to hear it all the time. My mother criticises others parenting, telling me how children learn from parents blah blah blah, and it's so hypocritical, but what does that make me? I don't want her to suffer all her life.

Santaischeckinglists · 18/11/2021 07:25

My now ex ils have a close relationship with adult ds. They regale him with stories of his childhood.
In fact we lived 3 streets away until he was 4 and they never bothered with him until we got divorced and exh dumped them with 3 x dc eow.
Of 3dc only 1 see them.
I bite my tongue.

Robloxdiamonds · 18/11/2021 07:20

My mum and dad both do this. They think I have a 'role' in my family and are determined to put me back in my place every time I see them. I think both of my parents are completely blind to what I do everyday and my real life. I've always been portrayed by them as naughty and difficult. I'd say they were borderline neglectful and my mum was controlling. I didn't agree with her (like my golden child brother did) so I was difficult.

Scoobapro · 18/11/2021 07:18

I empathise with this a lot.
My mum does similar, but she chooses to say how she stayed single over the 14 years that she raised us after my dad left, and conveniently forgets to remember how she was dating my teacher, she dated her own cousin, and a string of around 14 other men that all entered our house and stayed for varying lengths of time.
I can’t stand to hear her say how she put us first for years and didn’t introduce random men.
It’s so very strange.
I wonder why they do this.

stayathomer · 18/11/2021 07:15

I don't want to use the age card thing but my son is only 13 and I'm only 41 but I've already found myself telling stories and then realising the reality was a little different. Sometimes whatever happens was uncomfortable/embarrassing/ horrible and you rewrite it a little, sometimes you forget, sometimes it just comes out like that. It may not be right but you might find yourself telling things differently about different occasions in the future