Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a bit sad when my mum rewrites history? Anyone else have this?

135 replies

dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn · 18/11/2021 00:44

I'm feeling sad tonight, not sure why. I saw my family this weekend and we were swapping the old stories etc, then one of my sisters mentions my nephew lost his pe kit and she was annoyed by it, and my mum immediately jumps in with

'Oh yea we had that all of year 7 and onwards with dont, lost her pe kit regularly, lost £10 for the bus, got the wrong bus repeatedly, lost things constantly' everyone laughed at how forgetful I was etc

Yes I did all of those things and a lot more, I once forgot to get the bus home on parents evening and waited for my parents to finish but they left whilst I was wandering round the school and they had to come back to the school to get me. It's not neglectful because I didn't tell them I was still at school and my phone was dead.

However!! I wish she would remind my family of the context! I had undiagnosed adhd and dyspraxia, my dad was having chemo and we were driving 2 hours to see him every night in hospital I was doing my homework on the floor of the hospital room or in the back of the car, I was tired and my siblings were older, then he died and we were moving across the country but I only had 2 weeks between him passing away and starting year 8..

When we moved house I started in a smaller school and flourished, got my diagnoses and got the help I needed. I'm now an ODP and I can take patients myself in icu, I've have 2 masters. But yet when I'm with my family I'm relegated to that bumbling child when I was 11!

Grr!!!

OP posts:
PinkArt · 18/11/2021 09:20

There's a thing with memory where over time what you are remembering isn't the original memory itself but a memory of a memory. And then a memory of a memory of a memory. Which I think I can see in my dad's version of let's make up the past. No history of abuse in our family, and my heart goes out to those here who have lived through that, but he still tells me stuff about my childhood that isn't true. But if you say the wrong thing once, that becomes the new memory the next time it comes up.
I'm not explaining well but it's an interesting but of neuroscience!

LittleMysSister · 18/11/2021 09:18

Yes my mum does this.

Not on purpose or maliciously, but she will quite often invent whole conversations/parts of conversations that never happened, but she genuinely believes they did and won't accept that they didn't, even when other people were there too.

Eg, when we were younger a frequent thing was she wouldn't be able to find something in the house, and she would ask one of us where it was because "you said you were going to lend it to your friend", or she'd accuse my dad of having given it away because she reckons he mentioned that.

She also mentioned recently that when she, my dad and my sister went to meet our family dog for the first time (rehoming), his previous owner said he had used sedatives on him as he's hyper. My dad didn't pick her up on it as it's not worth the row, but he shook his head and looked bemused...it has never ever been mentioned before, it just didn't happen. But if we'd have questioned it, she'd have aggressively argued that it 100% was said and got pissed off with us for denying it.

It's weird because she's not someone who would purposely lie at all, but this happens quite a lot and always has. She just genuinely believes these things. Maybe she spends a lot of time dreaming or daydreaming and just confuses it with reality?!?! Who knows.

Pinkgorrilaz · 18/11/2021 09:17

Sorry, to be clear, the first bit is to @shouldistop and the last two paras to the OP.

Pinkgorrilaz · 18/11/2021 09:16

@shouldistop

My mum was also the perfect parent. She likes to criticise parents 'these days' for their kids diets and activities. I cheerfully remind her that my play piece at school used to be iced gems and I lived on a diet of pasta with grated cheese and toast for years. We were never encouraged to do sports really.

What annoys me most is that she completely forgets how differently she has treated my brother and I. When I was 18 I worked full time and attended college on a day release from work, they paid for the diploma. I was offered a better paid job not long after graduating so I had to pay the cost of the course back. I didn't have the £1500 so my mum paid it and I paid her back £100 a month for 15 months. I didn't go to my graduation as I couldn't afford a nice outfit and hiring of a gown.

My mum has since supported my brother through various college courses etc, funded trips to Australia and South Africa, bought him a house that he pays minimal rent on.

I once raised that she made me pay back the money for my college course and she completely denied it.

If this doesn't confirm the existence of the patriarchy, I don't know what does. So many women of your mother's generation seemed to believe that boys were somehow superior and deserved better treatment. I've seen it so often. My mother didn't have boys and I think she really resented me as the youngest for not being a boy.

Not much consolation for you OP, it's horrible to be gaslit like this. My DF liked to 'pull my leg' about all my shortcomings as a teenager. I was nearly 60 when he died, so you'd have thought he'd have got over it. Besides which I was none of the things I was accused of, if anything I was overly compliant - not drinking much, no drugs, Saturday job that I used my wages to buy my clothes, sensible outfits etc, but you'd think I was some kind of wild child!

It would be mean to keep going on about you losing things even if you didn't have a diagnosis. The fact that you do have one makes it ten times worse. I know I'm just a stranger on the internet but if you were my daughter I'd be so proud of what you've achieved. You've done brilliantly and it's so sad that your mum doesn't focus on that.

malificent7 · 18/11/2021 08:58

Yes...mine do this...otherwise known as gaslighting!

scooterbear · 18/11/2021 08:55

My parents do this all the time. Mostly I can ignore but occasionally they will give their version of a story when the free sloth is something they do wrong casting me badly and it boils me. I've never bitten because it would open a huge can of worms but it is hard!
I think they do it because they don't like the way they behaved in the situation so want to erase it and replace it with the version that's more palatable to them.

sashh · 18/11/2021 08:54

I have to tell you all my relationship with my mother improved after her death.

We had the 'luxury' of her being terminally ill for 2+ years so I decided not to confront her, but knew I'd have to live with that.

She claimed they had to pay for my brother to go to uni (it was a poly and they paid for his digs). He only managed the first year and failed the end of year exams and retakes.

That I used to watch porn with my brother and one of his friends at his friend's house. Because that's who you choose to watch porn with.

I think the worst misremembering was something that happened when I was 17.

I'd taken a day off VI form for tummy ache. My mum went for her afternoon nap (she always had an afternoon nap).

I got something to eat and was about to take the plate back to the kitchen when I got a sudden severe pain that knocked me to my knees.

I couldn't get up and no amount of shouting could wake my mother.

When she did come down I said I needed a Dr because I was in too much pain to move.

She told me to take paracetamol and go to bed, this was about 1.30/2pm.

By the time my dad got home it was about 6pm and I was literally beggging her to call the Dr, I was in too much pain to move to call myself.

My dad came home, asked me if I needed the Dr, and for the first time I can remember went against my mother.

The GP called an ambulance, the ambulance staff comment on my green colour ie jaundice.

Long story short within a couple of hours I was in hospital with a tube up my nose and IV antibiotics.

My gallbladder was badly inflamed, if you have ever had gall stones or an inflamed gall bladder you will know the type of pain.

I actually thought I was going to die with her still telling me to go to bed and take paracetamol.

My mother's recollection is that she was really upset that the GP had called an ambulance.

Melawati · 18/11/2021 08:49

OP I’m sorry you went through such a difficult time and glad that you were able to get your diagnoses and thrive.
I wonder if your mum isn’t saying this to be mean but to have an almost ‘normal family life’ recollection of what must have been an incredibly traumatic time for her too. Your dad being ill, being in hospital 2 hours away, being widowed, moving somewhere new and starting again, and possibly also being aware that her child was struggling and not being able to give you the attention she wanted to with all the other pressures.
If you can, I wouldn’t take it too much to heart and let it fester. If it ever comes up again you could maybe just say ‘that would be my undiagnosed Adhd, good thing we got that sorted!’
Flowers

muddyford · 18/11/2021 08:39

Yep, thoroughly normal!

Defiantly41 · 18/11/2021 08:38

I found this Instagram post incredibly helpful when attempting to understand others in these circumstances https://www.instagram.com/p/CWQn1vmpCHd/?utmmedium=copyy_link

Reservoir13 · 18/11/2021 08:36

Yes, so much yes of this going on. And it is typically that my mum does it and not my dad.
The telling thing is that everything the way she remembers it was always positive. Me and my siblings were apparently great sleepers, she never had to wake up for us. We never cried or had tantrums. And this is always said (of course) when my kids are acting up, implying somehow that I must do something wrong with raising them. Whenever we have to punish our kids for misbehaving (we take their tablet away or give them a time out) she wants to intervene as she feels we're too harsh. That we were subject to physical punishment, often ran to our rooms to hide out of genuine fear and I was forced to witness my brother being pushed in a cold shower is conveniently forgotten. We live abroad, so I have (literally) taken a lot of distance from her, but it does hurt me. Very occasionally she brings up that our childhood was not ideal but then it is often packaged in a poor-me story and ends up with her accusing me of being distant. I am.

SplodgeWaddler · 18/11/2021 08:30

Agree it’s a way of covering-up their own failings. A strategy for maintaining power and avoiding being exposed by their now adult children who might perhaps by now be realising that something wasn’t quite right about their upbringing. Just crappy parents trying to cover up their own failings by trying to bring you down.

THIS
Robloxdiamonds
“My mum and dad both do this. They think I have a 'role' in my family and are determined to put me back in my place every time I see them. I think both of my parents are completely blind to what I do everyday and my real life. I've always been portrayed by them as naughty and difficult. I'd say they were borderline neglectful and my mum was controlling. I didn't agree with her (like my golden child brother did) so I was difficult.”

AND THIS
MarleneDietrichsSmile
“It’s a kind of gaslighting really, a power trip in a way?”

clarepetal · 18/11/2021 08:29

I remember spending some time with family friends. The mum looked at me and 'I'm sorry, Clarepetal, when I look at you all I can see is that chubby overweight girl you were'.
What the hell can you say to that?! Rise above it, be proud as you sound really successful 👏

Itsjustrenee · 18/11/2021 08:24

Reminds me of my mum completely omitting the fact that her and my dad used to beat the shit out of my older brother and me, whilst my younger brother was spoilt and cosseted.

FinallyHere · 18/11/2021 08:22

My mother did this, it used to infuriate me.

I'm pretty sure she just rewrote anything she found uncomfortable, and did it so much that she just didn't recollect that she had done it.

The only answer is a tinkly laugh and 'we all remember things differently'

I'm not usually much of a royalist, but was glad to see HM use the same 'different recollections' line when there seemed to be some rewriting going on in her family, too.

georgarina · 18/11/2021 08:22

I hate this!

My dad randomly made up a story where I was caught kissing a boy at a charity event - which didn't happen. No bit of it happened. There was no boy, I was there with a girl friend, no one else was doing anything like that either so couldn't have been mistaken for someone else. It was over 10 years later and I was so angry hearing this story when it wasn't true!

Peaseblossum22 · 18/11/2021 08:18

Another one here , my mother has created a completely different narrative to the reality. She was making fun the other day about how indecisive I was as a child , how funny my brother thought it . Was on the tip of my tongue to ask her why she thought I was so terrified to take responsibility but what’s the point . I am her only family practically in the U.K. I just make sure I know inside myself that it’s not true.

notacooldad · 18/11/2021 08:17

I regular get shoted at that I let tbe family down at 18 when I left home and mo ed away while mum was sick and lots of other stuff were going on in tbe family.
Mum forgets or chooses not to remember WHY I left.
Who wants a 10 clock curfew at 18? Who wants to be called a slut and a town bike because she found out I was on the pill with my boyfriend of 3 years etc etc.
I am 56 and .I'm cant believe tbe relationship I have with my two adult sons, I.e. we spend time together, go out for meals and drinks,phone each other up and so on.
History is re written in my family.
My sister had it worse but she tells me that our parents are old now and I should let things go. I cant.

Crinkle77 · 18/11/2021 08:17

OP your story reminds me of when I was younger and left my PE kit on the bus and once my umbrella. I'm now labelled as being forgetful and always losing things by my mother despite these being the only 2 instances in my 44 years of life that I've left something on the bus. The ironic thing is she's constantly losing things!

JKDinomum · 18/11/2021 08:17

Some of these sound terrible, but there are example where people genuinely remember things differently. I had a thing where I was sure my first car was my granny's old car but then my parents and brother said no, it was him who had my granny's old car, and I had a completely different (old) car!

My 15 year old is currently in the process of rewriting her own history because she now believes she is autistic and trans (neither of which I accept and she has actually been assessed for autism been told she is not). I remember her young childhood very clearly and it is infuriating that she says things like she never had friends or she never played with toys normally, when I was there and remember quite clearly that she did.

Longingforatikihut · 18/11/2021 08:15

My entire extended family did this in a really toxic way just hours after my mother died of terminal cancer. Sat around discussing how nasty and abusive her husband had been and at least now she was free of him. This was after they'd spent all my teens telling me I was making it up and that I just didn't want my mother to be with anyone else every time I asked for help or acted out because home was so horrible. My sister also tried to claim she'd known about my mother's cancer for months before her actual diagnosis, as some kind of infantalisation and oneupmanship. NC was the best thing I ever did.

PinkWednesdays · 18/11/2021 08:14

I think in OP’s case it isn’t really rewriting though is it, as those events did all happen. It seems to be more of a case of the reasons for those events not being included in the story.

So a big question is whether OP’s mum accepts the diagnosis, and that it, along with her dad’s illness, is why all those things happened.

BlooBagoo · 18/11/2021 08:12

Thanks for you OP, in fact Thanks for everyone. I thought it was just my mum who was bad for this.

The same as many others, my brother was the golden child despite him being a troublemaker and me being the quiet one who just got on with stuff. So mum often talks about either a naughty thing he did and says it was me, or something I did, like good marks in my exams, and says it was my brother. She used to always have a go at my gran (her MIL) for telling stories about my cousins and saying it was DB when she did the same thing without realising it.

I was once reminiscing about something that happened at my other gran's house with my mum and we had a lovely time talking about it. Just a few weeks later my brother was around so I started telling him about the memories and my mum denied all knowledge of not only what I was describing but even the conversation we had had about it.

Just the other day she told me she had found photos of me as a teenager and how skinny I was back then. I spent all my teenage years constantly being told I was fat by her. I once walked into a room when I was 15 and she shouted at me to suck in my belly and said I looked 6 months pregnant. Which of course she later denied doing. It's caused a lifetime of issues with my weight for me.

I also didn't tell her I was pregnant with my eldest until I was 6 months along. I was quite young still (just started university but still living at home as the university was close to us) and it had been an accident. She had always told me she would throw me out if I got pregnant so I was too scared to tell her. She eventually worked it out and then told the whole family how awful I was for hiding it from her and denied that she would ever have said such a horrible thing to me. My eldest is now a young adult and that one still hurts me a lot.

Squirrelblanket · 18/11/2021 08:10

My sister does this. We had a pretty ordinary, happy childhood but it's very different to how children experience childhood now. E.g. we were of the generation that pretty much spent the whole of the summer holidays out with our mates building dens etc and barely seeing our parents.

Once my sister became a parent she pretty much seemed to decide that our childhood was awful and borderline neglectful. I just think times were very different in the 80s! We've had to agree not to talk about the past now as we just end up arguing.

IncompleteSenten · 18/11/2021 08:09

Why don't you reply with oh yes, I remember that, it was when that was a tough time for us all wasn't it?

In the case of pp gym and swimming for example "oh yes, I remember. It turned out I had broken 3 fingers in gym class and I had to it was very painful.