Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a bit sad when my mum rewrites history? Anyone else have this?

135 replies

dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn · 18/11/2021 00:44

I'm feeling sad tonight, not sure why. I saw my family this weekend and we were swapping the old stories etc, then one of my sisters mentions my nephew lost his pe kit and she was annoyed by it, and my mum immediately jumps in with

'Oh yea we had that all of year 7 and onwards with dont, lost her pe kit regularly, lost £10 for the bus, got the wrong bus repeatedly, lost things constantly' everyone laughed at how forgetful I was etc

Yes I did all of those things and a lot more, I once forgot to get the bus home on parents evening and waited for my parents to finish but they left whilst I was wandering round the school and they had to come back to the school to get me. It's not neglectful because I didn't tell them I was still at school and my phone was dead.

However!! I wish she would remind my family of the context! I had undiagnosed adhd and dyspraxia, my dad was having chemo and we were driving 2 hours to see him every night in hospital I was doing my homework on the floor of the hospital room or in the back of the car, I was tired and my siblings were older, then he died and we were moving across the country but I only had 2 weeks between him passing away and starting year 8..

When we moved house I started in a smaller school and flourished, got my diagnoses and got the help I needed. I'm now an ODP and I can take patients myself in icu, I've have 2 masters. But yet when I'm with my family I'm relegated to that bumbling child when I was 11!

Grr!!!

OP posts:
BashfulClam · 18/11/2021 10:46

@Animood

Oh fucking hell tell me about it.

You say or do one thing when you're like, 5, then it gets brought up repeatedly for the next 30 years.

It is so very very dull. I don't get why people are stuck in the past going over and over old bloody stories like broken records.

Talk about something interesting ffs.

Yes! This! If she isn’t making things up she tells a really unfunny story from 35 years ago. I was cooking bacon for the first time in the grill when I was about 8. I asked ‘how do I know when It’s cooked enough?’ My brother said ‘well if it’s black with Smoke you’ll know’. She thinks that is hilarious 🤷🏻‍♀️ and re-tells it all the time.
Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 18/11/2021 10:29

I feel you entirely OP.

My Dad died at the same age your did and my mum became ill a few years later.

Any struggles of mine have been white washed over the years and it's all focussed on how hard it was for her.

I was similarly undiagnosed with ADHD and OCD and all of the struggles I had with that are recalled cacklingly.

It hurts but they'll never be told. I think it eases their pain to ignore the struggles we went through. It's not your fault.

3scape · 18/11/2021 10:28

My parents indulge in gaslighting for sympathy and laughs too. If you were to talk to my parents you'd be told I had to be taken off them for my appalling behaviour, that I was a wild child. Not neglect or abuse or their drinking. Abusers externalise all blame and responsibility and don't even blink.

notacooldad · 18/11/2021 10:24

Mum you know it’s rude to mock someone in front of others don’t you” is all you need to say.

I've very tried that. Mum mocks my choices to my friends ( e.g. If we are at a gathering at my house or a party) things like ' oh cool dad, has to be different with all this vegetarian nonsense ' I tell her she is being rude and she retorts to my friends that I've always been oversenitive and ' is she like this with you' cue lots of eye rolling!

Animood · 18/11/2021 10:23

Oh fucking hell tell me about it.

You say or do one thing when you're like, 5, then it gets brought up repeatedly for the next 30 years.

It is so very very dull. I don't get why people are stuck in the past going over and over old bloody stories like broken records.

Talk about something interesting ffs.

Wellarentyouacleverdick · 18/11/2021 10:13

Oh @dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn I feel your pain.

In my family, I'm the 'naughty' one. There are small children (2 mine, 2 my cousins) in our family now and every family event if one of them starts kicking off a bit or is a bit defiant as small children are all I hear is 'well, she's nowhere near as bad a you were! Wow do you remember when X threw that tantrum here, and there, and blah blah blah blah' on and on about how I was the naughtiest child in the world.

I was undiagnosed autistic. I recently had my diagnosis at age 37 and I only realised that I was autistic when I became a mum and my daughter was diagnosed at 3. She is me and it became very clear to me very quickly that all those things over the years that I struggled with weren't me just being crap, rude, blunt, or an awkward arsehole. Just autistic. I also suspect I actually have ADHD too but am still waiting on assessment for that one.

My directness is useful now though, because I interrupt and say 'well yes mother/aunt I did do all of those things but we know why now, don't we? Look at how much support DD has with her disability. I had none!' That shuts it down pretty quickly.

I don't blame my parents for now knowing - it was the 80s there's no way they could have. I did well academically, and I mask like a pro, evidently I did so from a very young age. But I do get pissed off that they don't view the past with a slightly different lense these days.

Augustbirthdays · 18/11/2021 10:11

My grandparents do this, especially my grandmother, in their case, they describe the life they wish they'd given their children not the life they actually did.

When they are sober, the reality of what they did is too much for them to bare. Primarily, because without alcohol they are kind, caring, loyal and generous. They would give you their last £1 and never complain about it.

However, when drunk, they are not.

Their children grew up in extreme poverty and violence and livid in squalor.

They say their children had everything they ever wanted. They absolutely did not.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 18/11/2021 10:10

It is one thing if individuals remember things differently or a child's distress at a sore leg etc is misinterpreted, but, it is another to deny what was clearly neglectful parenting. I'm not just talking about kids of the 80's going off for the day in the summer hols, but the real stuff - hitting, name calling, belittling, abuse (all brushed under the carpet and denied).

My mum forgets how abusive my dad was and only refers to after he left and paints a picture of supportive, straight talking parenting with lots of happy days. What I remember is his physical abuse, and even after he left walking on eggshells, being terrified of putting a foot wrong, her playing down things that were important to me and our lives revolving around her new partners needs.

My chin hit the floor yesterday when I was talking to her about my DC's experience of starting uni. She said she didn't think she could cope with that stress all over again. At 18 she wouldn't let me go to uni, said I wasn't clever enough. I put myself through uni in my 30's and even then when I invited her to my graduation (thinking she might be proud) she said no and why did I want to do it anyway.
And now in old age, she manipulates and twists the truth to make me look like a neglectful daughter.

nokidshere · 18/11/2021 10:02

Memories are rarely the same as reality though. Everyone remembers things slightly differently and there are a whole host of reasons some people rewrite their stories.

My mum left home when I was 8 leaving us (6 girls) behind. That was 50+yrs ago but she 'remembers' things now and tells anecdotes about stuff she wasn't even with us for. We don't bother correcting her these days. If me and my sisters talk about our childhood we all have different versions of events as we remember them.

I'm pretty sure I've read somewhere that there are scientific reasons our brains do this.

thecatsthecats · 18/11/2021 09:58

My mum has the opposite - twee, overblown recollections of our childhood (not dissimilar to Anthony Martin in the Just William books).

Actually we were and remain quite disfunctional, but to her it's all sepia toned. Including rewriting things I've told her as "memories" of mine.

(e.g. I remember say, a toy from a holiday when I was five. She now insists that it was wrong, and it must have been a memory from a different holiday when I was EIGHTEEN MONTHS OLD. Which is a) untrue - I remember the other holiday and the toy distinctly, and b) just stupid. It's so embarrassing to have this prodigious feat of memory trotted out all the time as if I actually have a claim to it.)

SarahAndQuack · 18/11/2021 09:52

I am going to share a very trivial example of this too, which is very silly but really pushes my buttons. When my first niece was on the way, I started doing some knitting for her, as you do. A few weeks later my mum started crocheting something similar. I thought this was fine, but she got in touch to say she was worried her gift would steal my thunder so she'd tell DB and SIL it was to be kept at her house for when they visited. Again, fine.

I, my dad, DB and SIL all remember this conversation the same way; DB has an email mum wrote to him telling him this was what she'd decided (though god knows why it merited a formal decision).

Ever since, every single time she sees the blanket lying around her her house, she sighs tragically. 'Oh ... I made this for DNiece ... but it was left behind ...'

DNiece is ten. I don't think I have managed a single visit to my mum's house since, without hearing the tragic tale of how she made something for her first grandchild and it was cruelly rejected. It's like she set herself up to have something to be a martyr about.

number87inthequeue · 18/11/2021 09:49

As a child, I was very compliant/well behaved, worked hard at school and had good academic achievements. My brother was a nasty piece of work from a young age (including violence towards me, mum and later girlfriends/wife and loads of manipulation) and didn't achieve as much. I cut contact with him when my first child was born- my mother is well aware of this and my reasons.

Yet my mother attributes anything positive either of my children do to being like him.

Eg- Doing well in a maths test. DM- Oh, you get that from [brother] he was always the mathematical one in the family (despite me getting far better grades in maths and studying it at a higher level)

  • DD getting good grades in A level drama/performing in plays etc. DM- She's just like [brother], he stole the show every time. (He once had 2 lines in the junior school nativity and she has memorised them)
  • DD does well in singing exams. DM- I'm not surprised, [brother] was always musical. (No idea where she gets this from, he never played an instrument and only ever sang, very badly, if totally pissed. Whereas I was in to music.)

Less positive behaviour is attributed to me. If either of my DC ever refuse to do what they are asked we are all reminded of the one time that I went out when she had told me I should stay in. They don't mention that I was 18 and went to my Saturday job. They were away for the weekend and arsehole brother had gone out on the Friday night without his keys and was threatening to kick the door down if I wasn't there to let him in.

SunsetSmartmeter · 18/11/2021 09:45

I've experienced this a lot over the years. It's been a long process to see it for the gaslighting that it is, largely because the claims are subtle, insidious and generally centre on things that appear inconsequential. It's only when you build them together that they form part of a picture which reveals itself to be essentially a form of abuse - their narrative is dominant and The Truth, you are either silenced or positioned in ways that make you appear silly/hard work/the problem.

As my eyes have been opened to all this I've become more confident in calling it out. I don't do head tilt/tinkly laugh, or respond with a comic re-telling of the anecdote to my version - that would be to sink to their level and play their game. I quietly and calmly put the story right. I'm strong enough now to deal with any responses to this, which have ranged from anger to defensiveness to waterworks and more. And that in itself is revealing of how that person was indeed intentionally trying to manipulate and hurt me in the first place.

Or rather, I did do that until I realised that you can't reason with toxicity and cut all but essential contact. I'm sad but psychologically so much healthier for it. My view is I'd never behave like this to my children and I would be livid if anyone else tried to do it to them so I shouldn't tolerate being treated like this myself. Finally in my mid forties I have a high bar for treatment and will only have people in my life who are emotionally well regulated, mature and decent.

LittleMysSister · 18/11/2021 09:45

@speakout

*LittleMysSister Also agree re misremembering their own parenting - my mum will swear down that she never smacked us, but she definitely did! And I don't even know why she denies it because most children still got smacked back.*

Exactly the same here!! My mother swears she never smacked but she certainly did! In fact I remember the last time she smacked me- I was 14, wash day ( as they had back in the day) it was summer , I was wearing shorts- she slapped me hard across the thigh. I turned around and slapped her across the face. It was the only time I had ever slapped back, but I decided that was enough.
I will never forget the look in her face- shocked and stunned- she never slapped me again.
But I remember many times being slapped as a younge child- as you say it was common place- police would give kids a cuff around the ear, teachers would use a leather belt, all my friends were slapped by their parents- it was the done thing.

My mother flaty denies it- and gets angry if I even mention it- telling me I am nasty to make up such wicked lies.

That's so funny that you say that @speakout, because I almost added the exact same thing to my original post!!

I remember the last time too, and it was the first time I smacked my mum back. She swiped at my arm as I was walking away from her out of the living room, and I turned around and did the same to her. Never happened again. I must have been about 14 too.

I guess people just don't feel comfortable admitting they used to hit their children as it's obviously now seen as completely unacceptable, but it's really frustrating when it comes up in conversation and they get pissed off and accuse you of lying, when they must know they are not telling the truth. Just own it and admit it was different times then, I'm not accusing you of abuse mum!!

Summerfun54321 · 18/11/2021 09:42

“Mum you know it’s rude to mock someone in front of others don’t you” is all you need to say.

SarahAndQuack · 18/11/2021 09:42

I was coming along to say the same sort of thing, @LondonWolf. I find it really fascinating (in a weird way) how different recollections can be. I have an older brother who claims he can't remember almost anything from our childhood. I remember fairly seriously unpleasant stuff. And my youngest brother really doesn't. It took me ages to figure out that it's a combination of two things - one is that because I had such a horrible experience, I'm very anti hitting and smacking children, whereas DB honestly believes that smacking a child is fine (he doesn't have children). So he naturally thinks 'hmm, Sarah is a bit of a snowflake about this'.

The other thing is that he's only a few years younger, but it's enough that his experience was quite different. My mum had an accident that made it really hard for her to get about for quite a while, my dad's job was precarious for a long time then he got a new one, and they move a couple of hundred miles and lost a lot of value from their house for various reasons - all of that happened when he was too young to remember, and by the time he was older, things had stabilised again. But for me, it must have been a really formative bit of my childhood.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 18/11/2021 09:42

@ssd

And BTW *@dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn*, you weren't a "bumbling child of 11". That's your mum speaking there, not you. You were a young girl with a very poorly dad who was trying to navigate her life without much direction. And it sounds like you coped very well under very difficult circumstances. So replace "bumbling" with "courageous"
Brilliantly said!!!!!!!!
Chocolatewheatos · 18/11/2021 09:40

You should have said that I think.
Everyone used to take the piss out of me in a similar way, although I didn't have any of the extra stuff you had going on, I can't believe anyone would joke about what a "mess" a child was when their dad was dying, sounds like a really tough time.
Since I was diagnosed as autistic though its like people don't bring it up anymore. Because it's no longer funny, it's signs they clearly spotted but didn't realise it meant I was autistic.

Also. Your parents left you at parents evening, that's 100% on them isn't it?

MrsPatmoresPinny · 18/11/2021 09:37

Oh and she also said to me recently “I used to bake all our biscuits and cakes myself”.

I’ve never laughed so hard inside my own mouth in my life!

I was bought up on fish fingers and Alphabites. There was never any elaborate cooking or baking going on in our house. She even told me herself about three years ago that she’d decided to finally have a go at learning how to bake as she’d never done it before. Confused

speakout · 18/11/2021 09:35

LittleMysSister
Also agree re misremembering their own parenting - my mum will swear down that she never smacked us, but she definitely did! And I don't even know why she denies it because most children still got smacked back.

Exactly the same here!! My mother swears she never smacked but she certainly did! In fact I remember the last time she smacked me- I was 14, wash day ( as they had back in the day) it was summer , I was wearing shorts- she slapped me hard across the thigh. I turned around and slapped her across the face. It was the only time I had ever slapped back, but I decided that was enough.
I will never forget the look in her face- shocked and stunned- she never slapped me again.
But I remember many times being slapped as a younge child- as you say it was common place- police would give kids a cuff around the ear, teachers would use a leather belt, all my friends were slapped by their parents- it was the done thing.

My mother flaty denies it- and gets angry if I even mention it- telling me I am nasty to make up such wicked lies.

Interrobanger · 18/11/2021 09:33

This is very interesting about memories. I wonder if it also works in the other direction?

I don’t have any examples as extreme as some on this thread. But I’ve had a step child for 12 years - I first met them when they were 3. Over the years they’ve insisted that when they were little they came to my house (before me and their father lived together) and that I had a pink bathroom. As in pink toilet and sink, etc. They swear they remember this from the first time they met me.

But it’s absolutely not true. I’ve never ever lived anywhere with a pink bathroom. Yet this is baked in their memory as fact! It’s weird because DSC must perceive that I am the one remembering it wrong, or rewriting the history. But the truth is, it just didn’t happen at all.

I wonder if sometimes that’s the case in these other examples. There’s the perceptions of the two people and then the truth in between.

LondonWolf · 18/11/2021 09:30

@Squirrelblanket

My sister does this. We had a pretty ordinary, happy childhood but it's very different to how children experience childhood now. E.g. we were of the generation that pretty much spent the whole of the summer holidays out with our mates building dens etc and barely seeing our parents.

Once my sister became a parent she pretty much seemed to decide that our childhood was awful and borderline neglectful. I just think times were very different in the 80s! We've had to agree not to talk about the past now as we just end up arguing.

Maybe her childhood was different to yours though. I studied child psychology and one of the discussion points was that all children have a totally different childhood, even from their siblings. Any difference in the family dynamic as a whole will impact on how individual children are treated and what they experience as they come along. So many different things influence that dynamic and your sisters recollections will be entirely different to yours even if the bare bones of the family are the same starting point. For example I am divorced, but my first child had five years of his parents being together and remembers those times and his Dad being part of the family clearly, my second child has never known anything but living in a lone parent family with a fairly absent Dad as we split when she was so young.
BashfulClam · 18/11/2021 09:29

My mum actually makes things up which is a pain when you know she’s wrong.

MrsPatmoresPinny · 18/11/2021 09:24

Wow, this has been an eye-opener. I thought it was just my strange and cruel mother that did this but it seems it’s quite a facet of human nature, which is comforting in a way.

One petty and frustrating incident for me was when my husband had been on a road trip and got back shortly before I needed the car to pick up my mother. When I arrived I apologised for needing to clear out the snack packets and work paraphernalia from the front seat and she made a very snarky comment, not at all jokey, about how my car was always a complete tip so she’s used to it. I’m in my 40s and she’s talking about the time when I was 17 and living between home and my boyfriend’s house for a couple of months, keeping my belongings in my car. It just felt so awful for that one particular time in my youth to be remembered over everything else.

On the other end of the spectrum, the worst and most hurtful one is that she has no recollection of an incredibly tragic incident that occurred at my boarding school where a girl was killed and many injured.

I was 10 years old. We were all in danger and away from home. I just can’t believe she has no memories of perhaps being worried for my safety, trying to get through to the school, having to collect me whilst the school closed for investigations, about my recovery or how she felt about me returning to school afterwards. Nada.

It’s a real illustration of our relationship in truth.

LittleMysSister · 18/11/2021 09:21

Also agree re misremembering their own parenting - my mum will swear down that she never smacked us, but she definitely did! And I don't even know why she denies it because most children still got smacked back.