Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a bit sad when my mum rewrites history? Anyone else have this?

135 replies

dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn · 18/11/2021 00:44

I'm feeling sad tonight, not sure why. I saw my family this weekend and we were swapping the old stories etc, then one of my sisters mentions my nephew lost his pe kit and she was annoyed by it, and my mum immediately jumps in with

'Oh yea we had that all of year 7 and onwards with dont, lost her pe kit regularly, lost £10 for the bus, got the wrong bus repeatedly, lost things constantly' everyone laughed at how forgetful I was etc

Yes I did all of those things and a lot more, I once forgot to get the bus home on parents evening and waited for my parents to finish but they left whilst I was wandering round the school and they had to come back to the school to get me. It's not neglectful because I didn't tell them I was still at school and my phone was dead.

However!! I wish she would remind my family of the context! I had undiagnosed adhd and dyspraxia, my dad was having chemo and we were driving 2 hours to see him every night in hospital I was doing my homework on the floor of the hospital room or in the back of the car, I was tired and my siblings were older, then he died and we were moving across the country but I only had 2 weeks between him passing away and starting year 8..

When we moved house I started in a smaller school and flourished, got my diagnoses and got the help I needed. I'm now an ODP and I can take patients myself in icu, I've have 2 masters. But yet when I'm with my family I'm relegated to that bumbling child when I was 11!

Grr!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
powershowerforanhour · 18/11/2021 22:55

I'm annoyed for all of you!

There are a few ways of dealing with it OP. You could try the "Yes it's so lovely to be constantly reminded of one's shortcomings!" But that'll probably result in being told that you are so touchy and can't take a joke.

How about reminding everyone of the context whilst simultaneously painting her in a good light? Eg "Yes, I used to forget things...I was pretty tired...remember we used to do all that travelling to see dad...I remember doing my homework in the back of the car trying to write neatly, I knew all the flat bits on the route where I could write and the twisty bumpy bits where I would stop trying to write and look up so I wasn't sick, funny the things you remember, I used to do some of the homework in that waiting room that smelt of lemon disinfectant and I used a chair as a table..we'd get home at midnight, d'you remember, I was exhausted so you must have been absolutely wrecked!! I don't know how you managed mum, it was amazing how you kept it all together and we were able to see so much of dad. Then when we moved I was so glad you were able to find that new school for me, they were brilliant and getting the diagnoses and help made things so much better, so fab that you were able to find such a good place for me even though you were dealing with all the house move stuff alone...strange times they were... "
Then she gets to be the hero, she gets any retrospective mum guilt assuaged by knowing she was doing pretty much the best she could, but everyone including her gets reminded that it wasn't exactly a cakewalk for you, even though it was nobody's fault.

FinallyHere · 18/11/2021 18:43

@BobbieT1999 😁

BobbieT1999 · 18/11/2021 18:32

Recollections may vary

TexasTyson · 18/11/2021 18:03

My dad did this, but not in the horrible way many PPs have described. It was more that in his head, if you've done something once that's the way it's always been.

For example, when I was 17 I made a cup of tea a bit too close to a driving lesson and didn't finish it . From then on until the day he died if he saw me with a tea he would comment that I "never finish a cuppa". Which is 100% not true, it happened once!

I was also, as everyone is, skint as a student. In his head, that meant I was skint. Fact. Forever. When I was 26ish I mentioned that me and my flatmate were getting virgin installed. He was aghast. "But how can you afford that!?"
"Well, you know how I've been driving to a hospital 4 times a week for the past 5 years and staying for 12 hours at a time? They actually pay me fairly well to do that..."

KT727 · 18/11/2021 17:20

Hi OP,

I'm so sorry for the loss of your Dad and the terrible time you went through in your early teens. I think having a quick chat with your Mum about not trivializing the things that you went through might be a good idea.

I read the title and thought 'yep, that's like my Mum' but really her mis-rememberings aren't terrible. She's 60-something and tends to 'remember' what people have said, by remembering how she felt when they were saying it, so for example if she felt that someone was being difficult, she will use words they would never use when describing what they had said. I no longer take my Mum's reports of what someone has said as fact!

Punfreeusername · 18/11/2021 16:21

My mum, lovely in most ways, was not the best parent I have come to realise as an adult.

Despite her being a primary school teacher, my own educational attainment was shocking, and she didn't seem the least bit interested when I failed all my GCSE's.

Things that I've also thought back to now -

Being a latch key kid from about 8 years old

Being badly bullied at school and by local kids for most of my childhood without her or my father doing a single thing about it.

Not being encouraged to do anything extra curricular - no cubs, scouts, martial arts class, sports clubs etc.

I know they aren't the crimes of the century, but as a parent it's not behaviour I will be repeating.

As for my father, he left when I was a late teenager and I didn't have much to do with him for many years - purely because he had such little impact in my life, at the time I just didn't miss him. We have a good relationship now, but seriously I can't think of any bonding activities we ever did apart from going to the football.

Funny isn't it, not one parent will say ' Oh, well I'm probably not best placed to give advice ' when it comes to our own kids..as far as they are concerned parenting was much better in their day and they know everything so we should follow their every uttered word.

home2012 · 18/11/2021 15:55

My dad does this all the time. He makes up stories and when people call him on it he denies all knowledge that it's made up

At my wedding he have a speech with a completely made up childhood story about me. It was ridiculous

dontletthemugglesgetyoudownn · 18/11/2021 15:13

Thank you! I'm really sorry other people have similar experience though

OP posts:
Stovetopespresso · 18/11/2021 15:02

@Tigger85 that's difficult! interesting...Just occurred to me that the borderline between empathy and having had the exact same experinece is blurred here. its like when toddlers parallel play, rather than play with eachother.
seems to me they're just not able to separate themselves from your suffering, therefore the only way they feel things is if they've actually gone through it themselves.
They've probably never had a chance to reflect on anything much, or just that they're not very bright.Smile

sundaydayisnotmyfundayday · 18/11/2021 14:44

There are 5 of us and my Mum tells stories of when we were young and mixes us up, all of the time. I can't remember what I ate for dinner last night though so I can hardly judge

SockFluffInTheBath · 18/11/2021 14:18

My mum does this all the time. I’m not sure if it’s to make herself feel better or to try to keep me in my place.

LondonWolf · 18/11/2021 14:14

@Tigger85

Oh that’s awful. I’m so sorry for your losses and so sorry you have to listen to that from your mum and sister. They sound really poisonous actually and I would imagine that it’s hard to want to spend any time with them.

LondonWolf · 18/11/2021 14:11

@SarahAndQuack

I am going to share a very trivial example of this too, which is very silly but really pushes my buttons. When my first niece was on the way, I started doing some knitting for her, as you do. A few weeks later my mum started crocheting something similar. I thought this was fine, but she got in touch to say she was worried her gift would steal my thunder so she'd tell DB and SIL it was to be kept at her house for when they visited. Again, fine.

I, my dad, DB and SIL all remember this conversation the same way; DB has an email mum wrote to him telling him this was what she'd decided (though god knows why it merited a formal decision).

Ever since, every single time she sees the blanket lying around her her house, she sighs tragically. 'Oh ... I made this for DNiece ... but it was left behind ...'

DNiece is ten. I don't think I have managed a single visit to my mum's house since, without hearing the tragic tale of how she made something for her first grandchild and it was cruelly rejected. It's like she set herself up to have something to be a martyr about.

I don’t think that is trivial actually. I think it’s annoying as fuck! Angry
Eastridingclub · 18/11/2021 14:01

That's really irritating. You should let her know you're not ok with it. Where is her tact.

Tigger85 · 18/11/2021 13:59

My mother and sister both have these false memories, most of them fairly harmless but they also both completely lie and make things up, they have some weird grief/trauma one upmanship thing. My mother used to say I was perfect when I was born, not a mark on me or any blood, that my sister and brother were a little battered looking because the deliveries were much quicker. My sister's son was a fairly long delivery and they were going to use the ventous but luckily she was then able to push him out before they used the ventous, apparently he kept crowning but going back in but then the midwife caught his head and pulled him out by hand. My mother was my sister's birth partner. I had my D's who has congenital neuro abnormalities and a large head (99th centile) my mother was with me during the birth and she witnessed them use the ventousvon me which failed, then I went round to theatres and had a forceps delivery. My son obviously had a mark on his face from the forceps and a funny shaped head and bruising from the ventous, I also have severe birth injuries causing double incontinence needing surgical repair as a result. After witnessing me go through that her story changed to her having episiotomy and forceps deliveries for all three of us, my sister also immediately claimed that she had a failed ventous delivery then forceps delivery with episiotomy but it was even worse because she was haemorrhaging and there wasn't time to take her to theatres it was done in the normal delivery room by one midwife. Both are complete fabrications, they both had normal deliveries, my sister went home the next morning (delivery at night) and there wasn't a mark on her D's. They made it up to minimise what I went through and to make out they had it worse. I also have had one miscarriage and a late tfmr after having my living D's and my mother now claims to have had two miscarriages, apparently she lost them both down the toilet but at the same time they were both obviously boys which would have made them second trimester losses. Both my father and grandmother have told me that my mother has never had a miscarriage.

I can tolerate them rewriting history about childhood anecdotes but I cannot sit there and listen to them outright lie about the births and fake miscarriages when I actually have gone through what they are pretending they have.

TarpaulinEyes · 18/11/2021 13:29

My aunt lives in a complete fantasy world of her own imagining of events. Her favourite story is about the time my DM dressed up as a snowman complete with pillowcase head and went and stood outside the neighbours house living opposite until they opened their curtains. How they screamed, how hilarious it was, etc. Except it never happened. DM went to a fancy dress party as a snowman and a photograph was taken of her wearing the costume. She will swear black is white on occasion just because..... Minor compared to you OP but annoys me a great deal as my DM is sadly no longer around and I don't want her memory coloured by such nonsense.

SirenSays · 18/11/2021 13:27

Omg OP we have lived really weirdly similar lives it seems!
I confronted my mother about it and let's just say it didn't end well.

I recently caught my DM telling my sister I never stuck with anything and always quit.
My karate - the instructor often didn't show up and then dad would rant about it the whole way home.
My gymnastics - instructors moved away and my parents wouldn't sign me up anywhere else.
My swimming lessons - I was often the only child that showed up, so the instructor would give me some vouchers and send me to the big pool alone.

azimuth299 · 18/11/2021 13:15

My dad loves to rewrite history. He tells this long story about how he caught his partner being violent towards my sibling and threw her out of the house. He paints himself as some kind of amazing hero protecting us. He never mentions that she was back the next day. The violent incidents had gone on for months at that point and continued for many more months before she finally left him. Her being thrown out of the house was because they were arguing, not because of anything she was doing to my sibling.

He likes to tell this story in front of people and wants his children to back him up and publicly thank him for being so heroic. I honestly think that he believes it himself.

RobotValkyrie · 18/11/2021 12:34

This isn't just rewriting history... Your mum's very selective memory mostly seems focused on putting you down, OP! No one deserves that, no wonder you find it upsetting, it's blatantly unfair, and a form of bullying.

I call it Toxic Mum Syndrome. The kind of person who always delights in regaling their audiences with "hilarious" (= embarrassing/humiliating) anecdotes about somebody else (who is typically in the same room at the time: no point humiliating someone if they're not around to witness it!)

My own mum specialises in (greatly exaggerated) medical anecdotes, ideally involving embarrassing bodily functions. Her role in these stories is always "the saviour".

sashh · 18/11/2021 12:18

The autism / ADHD is interesting.

I don't have a diagnosis but enough traits for it to be probable.

I had (still do but not as extreme) thing about starting and finishing things myself. I loved doing jigsaws, so if I left one half complete and went to bed my mum would add a few pieces and laugh at my meltdown when I took 'her' pieces out, and sometimes broke the entire thing up.

Why would you do that? Autistic or not, if you have a child who has something they are sensitive about then why would you deliberately upset them and laugh?

Yes! This! If she isn’t making things up she tells a really unfunny story from 35 years ago. I was cooking bacon for the first time in the grill when I was about 8. I asked ‘how do I know when
It’s cooked enough?’ My brother said ‘well if it’s black with Smoke you’ll know’. She thinks that is hilarious 🤷🏻‍♀️ and re-tells it all the time.

Bloody hell yes.

Like the time I peeled too many potatoes.

I was 7, I came home to an empty house and had to peel potatoes for tea, I didn't know how many to peel and I was terrified of not doing enough.

Does anyone else have that thing where they extract an 'it's all right' or an 'I don't mind' when it isn't all right and you do mind.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 18/11/2021 11:57

@5zeds

She hasn’t seen me for who I am in 20 years, but I love her to pieces. Perfectly put.
God just this.

It can sometimes be they're frightened to acknowledge the adults we became. We're not little and vulnerable, dependant and naive anymore.

Infantilising us prevents them from being able to be challenged, undermined or corrected.

Hodgehog · 18/11/2021 11:56

It’s interesting reading other people’s experiences - my mum too makes things up.

I used to think it was mainly because she’s got a narcissistic streak and can’t accept she doesn’t understand or remember situation as that’s usually when she does it.

I think she really struggles with critical thinking/basic logic so try’s to fill in the gaps in a way that makes sense to her.

Do the people of other parents that did this also have narcissistic tendencies ? Some of these certainly read like that. I’ve posted before about my mum and her style of parenting. I don’t think she was especially good at dealing with a child’s emotional needs. At all really.

Hodgehog · 18/11/2021 11:42

What happens when you point all of that out ?

5zeds · 18/11/2021 11:40

She hasn’t seen me for who I am in 20 years, but I love her to pieces.
Perfectly put.

TakeMeToKernow · 18/11/2021 10:58

My mum has started to do this more and more and I just gently smile and nod as I think this is linked to very long term struggles with anxiety and depression. I think she hangs onto stories and narratives that she’s comfortable with and avoids present challenges. She rewrites them as well, things that have never happened.

My SDCs notice it, it’s so obvious. She’ll relay a 20 yr old (fake) story and laughingly call me a bimbo.

I have a degree, membership of a professional body, leadership role in a PLC and run a lovely home. She hasn’t seen me for who I am in 20 years, but I love her to pieces.