Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

His choice of engagement ring...

88 replies

surfergrl · 17/11/2021 18:22

DP showed me the ring he’s gonna get, and it’s nice, but it’s not my idea of an engagement ring – it’s silver and topaz. Now this is NOT about the money – I do not expect the ‘month’s salary’ cos that’s diamond company propaganda. But I do love jewellery (I make and sell it) and engagement rings tend to be be a bit more special, and last a long time (topaz is brittle; silver dents easily).

I don’t even mind if we don’t get married for years, but the ring is important to me.

I don’t know if he knows what engagement rings more usually are, and I don’t think he’s trying to be cheap, and it’s a sweet ring. I love that he’s picked it himself too.

Do I tell myself to get a grip, princess, or do I gently say, that’s lovely but I wonder if we could choose something together? Confused

OP posts:
WhatHoMarjorie · 18/11/2021 12:37

I find the idea from some quarters that you’re supposed to wear a ring you dislike just because it was chosen for you by your future spouse to be ridiculous. Speak up now and say ‘that’s not to my taste’. Not great if you can’t be honest with him on these matters.

PeeAche · 18/11/2021 12:35

My first husband bought me a silver ring and it did get all dented up. He told me it was white gold and I believed him Blush (I was young and foolish). I only found out the truth when I went shopping for my wedding ring and the jeweller advised that I don't choose white gold if my ER is silver. Blush

Anyway, we were only married a few years and the ring ended up in storage except for best, because it was so battered up... And then one of the diamonds fell out!

Pheebs2021 · 18/11/2021 12:30

I was given an haribo ring after my proposal and we picked one together, my DH had ideas but really wasn't sure and in fairness to him until I saw my ring I didn't know what I'd want really either. A decade on I adore my ring still.

LaForza101 · 18/11/2021 12:09

Why does the ring need to last forever? I thought it was pretty common for people to upgrade sets or buy new ones to celebrate important anniversaries. I also know of rings not fitting after pregnancy and rather than resizing, the ring is kept to pass to the child years down the line.

Fair enough if you just don't like it and a gentle conversation about it is fair, but I think I would stick to the romance of the choice at least until you reach a new milestone

Socksey · 18/11/2021 12:05

Wandering off the point 🤔😁.... I've never heard anyone describe Topaz as brittle... I can't imagine doing anything to a topaz in normal life that would cause it to chip easily... (I'm a geologist)
My ring is a half eternity with zircons and sapphire

Runningupthecurtains · 18/11/2021 11:54

As they are worn together the wedding band should be the same metal as the engagement ring to limit wear. It might be an 'in' to the conversation to explain that a silver engagement ring means you are also limited to silver for your wedding band (or the harder metal will wear away at the softer one).

FinallyHere · 18/11/2021 11:19

conversations, but it’s never easy or pleasant to tell someone who’s put time, effort and thought into choosing something they think you’ll love that actually you don’t like it.

Fair enough to put time, effort and thought into something h they think you will love. But not so great if they would rather you pretended to love it in order to protect their fragile ego when you just don't love it.

It's really important to me, to be included in the decision making. DH is very clear about that. He loves surprises and I respect that when it's things for him.

Things for me ... not so much

Bear in mind this is going to be the way things are for the rest of your life snd start as you mean to go on.

nomoneytreehere · 18/11/2021 11:02

Surely the silver / topaz is a placeholder until you can get the real one?

mrsm43s · 17/11/2021 20:10

I think its fine to point out the issues with Silver/Topaz, and pick something else in the same price range range. That said, I'm not sure you'll get something much better than Silver/Topaz on a Silver/Topaz budget. The suggestion of vintage is spot on, and with luck you could get something really unique.

Allthesefolks · 17/11/2021 20:10

Yes tell him! DH proposed spontaneously without a ring and I chose and bought my own (I’m incredibly fussy about jewellery and would have hated a solitaire so have an unusual vintage one).

RaisedByPangolins · 17/11/2021 20:10

If he’s shown it to you rather than buy it and present it as a surprise then you absolutely should have a say in what it looks like! If he wanted free reign to buy you whatever he thought then he should have been more romantic about it. This sounds like a weird hybrid of him choosing a ring on your behalf but without the surprise proposal element that makes that a gamble worth taking!

If he’s asking your opinion on it, send him some examples of things you like and say what’s important about it to you so that he has a fighting chance of getting it right!

Otherwise if this is a ‘placeholder’ as a gesture until you get to choose the one then make sure HE realises thats how you’re seeing it!

Alternatively buy him something for Xmas that’s almost what he wants but not really, watch him squirm trying to explain himself and then let him know that’s how you feel about the ring Grin

magicstar1 · 17/11/2021 20:03

DH proposed to me with a lovely Claddagh ring, and we went to pick out my engagement ring together. He knows me well so it was the right thing. As it turned out I picked a ring I never would have imagjned....he would have had no chance of getting it correct.

Poppy709 · 17/11/2021 20:02

Definitely tell him and you’re not being unreasonable, also second other suggestions on vintage for cost, my engagement ring was under 400 pounds and I look at it every day and think how much I love it which is what you want from a ring!! We also chose it together xx

TotallySuper · 17/11/2021 20:00

Of course YANBU especially since you make and sell jewellery. Who has silver for an engagement ring?!it's supposed to last a lifetime which silver doesn't have the quality to do. Just be honest.

charabanctrip · 17/11/2021 19:57

I have a topaz engagement ring and the stone is still fine, but silver will fade and wear out.

girlmom21 · 17/11/2021 19:56

@scottishnames they ask and then the woman says yeah or no.

Men who are proposing know whether or not the woman they're proposing to is happy for the surprise, most of the time.

scottishnames · 17/11/2021 19:51

girlmom

Fine, that's what they like. But it's not totally up to them, is it? Deciding to get married is a mutual, shared decision. If it's not that, it's pretty pointless, for either the man or the woman.

OK, if a man asks his girlfriend 'I like old-fashioned play-acting, will you play along with me for a proposal?' and she agrees, then 100% all well and good. That's lovely for them both.

But otherwise ...

thisplaceisweird · 17/11/2021 19:47

The engagement and the ring should be a joint conversation and decision. The proposal can be a surprise if that's what you need.

girlmom21 · 17/11/2021 19:43

To 1forAll87 for heaven's sake, why didn't they just ask the women concerned? Who are they to 'bestow' their taste on others?

A lot of men like to propose as a surprise. Almost all of them will try to pick something their girlfriend will like.

For some women, nothing is ever good enough.
For some women, it's just not to their taste.
For some women, it's perfect.

Camembear · 17/11/2021 19:42

Congratulations!

An engagement ring needs to be more hard wearing than that, just be honest with him in a very gentle way.

scottishnames · 17/11/2021 19:35

OP Sorry about typos. Am waiting for new spectacles!

scottishnames · 17/11/2021 19:33

OP many congratulations. It sounds as if you are vv happy to want to get married to your DP.

But - even to people who like jewellery (me included) - a ring is really nothing significant. What's important is that you and DP decide TOGETHER what you want for your futures.

If you would like a ring, then - because you're the expert, you can do this without hurting his feelings - talk about what might be nice, hard-wearing, long-lastinge etc. As PP has said, second-hand/vintage/antique is VASTLY better value. A ring is just a token of intent,, after all.

Also - I'm old and probably early feminist generation - but all sorts of important decisions about my life (and husband's life) have been made by calm, loving, caring discussions with my husband. No waiting for him to propose etc (we just mutually agreed) ; no game-playing/sulky disappointments by me. So much more respectful; so much easier.

To 1forAll87 for heaven's sake, why didn't they just ask the women concerned? Who are they to 'bestow' their taste on others?

katseyes7 · 17/11/2021 19:31

You really need to tell him about the fragility of the one he's chosen, and suggest an alternative. You don't want him wasting money on something that could damage easily. He should understand, you being a jeweller, you know what you're talking about.
When l got engaged to the love of my life, he proposed and said "I haven't got you a ring, love, you're going to wear it for the rest of your life, so l want you to have something you love."
He tied a broken guitar string round my ring finger (he was a musician) and l tied a bit round his wrist.
It was so romantic and sweet. We both chose our jewellery together, l got a beautiful ring and he got a torque necklace and bracelet.

surfergrl · 17/11/2021 19:29

Ah thanks everyone - I think I'm overthinking it!! I will revisit the convo. I love vintage so that's defo an option.

I wouldn't mind putting some money in, not that he's asked.

OP posts:
Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 17/11/2021 19:22

Perhaps suggest you and he design something special and make it yourself. It will be unique (just like you two) Wink