Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To apply for a job without all the 'essential' criteria?

66 replies

EnidSpyton · 17/11/2021 12:10

Looking for experiences of people who applied for jobs they weren't fully qualified for according to the 'essential' JD criteria but still got it anyway...

I've found a job I'd love to apply for and while I know I could do it and have most of the experience and all of the qualifications, there's a pretty essential element I don't have any experience in. I don't personally think it should be a barrier as I feel my experience in other areas makes up for it, but would the org feel the same?!

My usual attitude with work is 'if I were a man, I'd do it anyway' - there's some statistic I've read that says men apply for a job if they meet 60% of the criteria, whereas women will only apply if they meet 100%. I'd say I meet 80% of the essential, and 100% of the desirable for this job. But it's going to take me at least half a day to apply for it, I'm tight on time at the moment, and I don't want to spend the time on the application if I have no chance of getting it. Interested to know what others think and if you'd bother throwing your hat in the ring if you didn't meet 100% of the criteria.

OP posts:
Bigoldhag · 17/11/2021 16:03

Do it!!!
For whoever said that public sector wouldn’t interview you that is utter bollocks.

If we had candidates that filled all criteria, sure they’d be a step ahead but there have been plenty of times where noone has 100% of criteria and the best ones of that get interviewed.

Enb76 · 17/11/2021 15:57

P.S. if you can contact them (telephone/teams not email) and sound them out before applying I would. I always try to speak to the person hiring to chat about the job spec and what they are looking for and it has never let me down, it helps for the application and it helps that they are already looking out for your name. It becomes more and more important the higher I climb up the career ladder.

Adm1010 · 17/11/2021 14:45

The job I’m in now I didn’t meet the essential criteria , however I emailed the lead directly , outlined my experience outside of the criteria and my passion for the job in question . I put an application in alongside this . I got an interview and offered the job .

LakieLady · 17/11/2021 14:38

A lot of organisations value "lived experience" just as much as professional experience, so go for it.

In the additional info/personal statement bit, you can explain about your experience and how it's relevant. That would definitely get you an interview where I work.

dabbydeedoo · 17/11/2021 14:36

I don't understand why you wouldn't. You have nothing to lose here - worst case scenario you don't get it and you're exactly where you are right now. It won't look bad that you applied - if anything it will look good that you went for it and tried. From what you've said, you do sound pretty qualified for the role - who is going to tick every single box?

pandora206 · 17/11/2021 14:34

Trustee of an arts centre here - I'd say go for it OP. You do have relevant experience but not quite in the way they have framed the JD. It's certainly worth sending in an application (maybe with a covering letter acknowledging and explaining).

HarrietsChariot · 17/11/2021 14:33

YABU to use the phrase "if I were a man, I'd do it anyway" because men aren't some homogeneous group - some men feel more confident than others.

But YANBU to apply for the job, the important thing is that you feel you are able to explain to them why you're lack of experience in one area is more than made up for by your abilities in others. You need to be able to explain this on paper first, to get an interview, then face to face. As long as you know why you're a great fit for the role, you shouldn't have a problem.

anniegun · 17/11/2021 14:30

There is no downside to applying, go for it! There are plenty of job descriptions out there that are just a wish list from the employer , who will inevitably compromise when they see the right candidate. Obviously there are a limits , you would want your brain surgeon to have relevant experience, but this doesn't look that type of job. Ultimately if you sincerely believe you would be great in that job then give it a shot. One of the biggest weakness in recruitment is when organisations focus entirely on relevant experience rather than looking for the best person for the job.

tabletennistop · 17/11/2021 14:29

Just read your update. Tbh you sound like a really strong candidate.

c190 · 17/11/2021 14:25

The way I would look at it is - if you don't apply then you definitely won't get it. So apply for it!

I don't think I have ever had 100% of the "stuff" they ask for on the advert - it is a wish list for the ideal candidate and I don't think they expect anyone to be an exact match. That said, they may well "weight" the importance of some requirements over others.

But at the end of the day - if you don't apply, you won't get it. What have you got to lose?!

tabletennistop · 17/11/2021 14:25

@ColinTheKoala

If it's a private sector role, give it a go.

But if it's a public sector role they won't interview you.

This is not true. I have always worked in the public sector and the jobs I got were the ones I thought I was an outsider for, given I could not meet all the criteria. I only once applied for a job where I had everything they asked for, to some degree.
Wilkolampshade · 17/11/2021 14:22

Tbh you sound a pretty good fit! Go for it!

PlanDeRaccordement · 17/11/2021 14:19

I’d apply. And if there is any way to include your “lived experience” in arts to be listed as an unpaid volunteer type entry on your CV, do it that way. I did for one job as I was on a board of directors and the treasurer for a charity...unpaid position/purely voluntary...but still was experience in that sector.

GrolliffetheDragon · 17/11/2021 14:14

If the org I work for was looking for someone in that sort of role, already knowing the groups well would absolutely be a major plus that might well get you an interview.

We interview everyone who meets all the criteria, that part is basically tick box, but we can and have interviewed people who haven't if their overall application is good enough.

RobinPenguins · 17/11/2021 14:13

But if it's a public sector role they won't interview you

That’s not true - if the other candidates don’t meet all the essential either then we might choose to interview those who meet the most, or the most essential and desirable overall.

OP I think it depends on what the market is like for this kind of role, I’ve recruited before when we’ve had loads of great candidates to whittle down and no one who didn’t have all the essential criteria would have a hope of an interview. And I’ve recruited recently where we’ve really struggled to get any decent applicants at all because there’s a really shortage of qualified people.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 17/11/2021 14:10

When I've been job hunting in the past I've applied for whatever I felt I would be good at. I might not meet the set criteria but that would never stop me applying.

DH is the opposite and only applies for things that he is an exact fit for.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 17/11/2021 14:04

Go for it!!

I applied for an NHS post that I didn't meet the essential criteria for... But I visited the site, they liked me so was successful! (against 200 other applicants)

I think it's often not about getting the absolute best person, it's about keeping the wrong people out... As they mess up teams and take up loads of time

Kitkat151 · 17/11/2021 13:54

You’ve got nothing to lose...apart from the time it will take to apply

DilemmaDelilah · 17/11/2021 13:48

In my organisation (public sector) your application won't even be sent for shortlisting if you don't meet all the essential criteria - so the people who would be interviewing won't ever get to see it. Our job specifications have a list of criteria, and these are listed as essential or desirable. If you don't have the essential you have no chance at all. If they are just desirable it would be worth applying.

dreamingbohemian · 17/11/2021 12:46

Oh gosh yes in that case I would go for it

Enb76 · 17/11/2021 12:44

You lose nothing by applying.

I have 'lived experience' due to my passion for the art form, and a masters degree in the art form

Big this up, write a fabulous covering letter and remember to try and demonstrate every 'requirement' in your application - lived experience counts.

Pedalpushers · 17/11/2021 12:40

I'd try and stretch some slightly relevant experience into the gap so it looks like you understand why they are saying it's important for the role. It will probably come up at interview and better to have something slightly relevant than nothing at all. I've gotten jobs using that approach to missing experience.

EnidSpyton · 17/11/2021 12:40

Thanks so much for the responses so far everyone - I feel encouraged!

For more info - it's a public arts organisation and the role is about working with particular community groups to develop work for the arts organisation. I have experience with the community groups but not with working in an arts organisation. I would love to move into the arts and blend my interest in the specific community groups I work with and my love for the art form the organisation delivers, but the arts org wants experience in their sector as their main essential criteria.

This is the issue. I have 'lived experience' due to my passion for the art form, and a masters degree in the art form, but no professional experience in the sector whatsoever. At the same time, I know the community groups they're trying to reach out to inside out. If it were a junior role I'd be more confident at going for it, but it's a senior management role. I've got lots of existing management experience and contacts in the community, and am a senior manager currently, so it would be a sideways move pay-wise and responsibility-wise, but not sure the arts org would see it like that!

But judging from what a lot of you lovely people have said - if I write a really strong application and highlight all the things I do have despite what I don't...might be worth a go?!

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 17/11/2021 12:39

I think it really depends what the missing criteria is. Can you say at least generally what it is?

I think within essential criteria, some are properly essential, so I might not apply if you are missing one of those

ShaunaTheSheep · 17/11/2021 12:30

@ColinTheKoala

If it's a private sector role, give it a go.

But if it's a public sector role they won't interview you.

Nonsense. I recruit and will give people a chance to prove themselves at interview. Often it’s about finding someone who is a good ‘fit’ for the role and team. Training can be given for knowledge gaps, but you can’t fix attitude, temperament etc.