Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents are expected to be much involved in our kids education than our parents

28 replies

Notagoodtime · 17/11/2021 09:22

Right from the get go when my kids started school, we have been heavily encouraged to take a big part in helping our kids read, times tables etc. I’m happy to do this but appreciate that not all parents have the time. When I first started school 40 years ago, I never brought a reading book home but I could always read well.

Now my kids are at secondary school, I feel that the demands are even more. We are required to log onto our child’s homework daily and I get regular updates if my child even forgets a bloody rubber! I’ve just got an email this Morning to say that my daughter has 3 days to finish her maths homework and try and encourage her to finish the 50% she had started. I feel all the responsibility is on us and I feel that kids are slowly loosing the ability to be responsible for their own work. My parents never knew what homework I had but we all survived!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MintJulia · 17/11/2021 15:09

Our school isn't like that. Ds 13 has a homework diary which shows ds what homework he has on which nights and what is required. It's also available on MS Teams.

I'm supposed to check ds has done his work each night and then sign the diary. But no pressure to get more involved. Ds is expected to sort himself out.

I help with food tech and occasionally French/German.

BogRollBOGOF · 17/11/2021 15:01

@Athrawes

Schools do this because kids no longer take personal responsibility for their own success or failure and teachers are blamed for the latter. Parents complain if they weren't told that Josephine hadn't done her assignment and so is failing her course and what have we, the teachers, done to ensure that this doesn't happen. The world is a different place. Kids used to fail and get a job anyway. Now there aren't jobs to fall into at 16 so there is more pressure on schools to ensure that kids pass exams. All the evidence tells us that actually it's is families who have greatest impact on the academic success of a child. So we ask you to be involved.
Children don't learn personal responsibility because it bounces between school and the parents. It is the government/ OFSTED culture that puts ridiculous pressure on schools and they then spoon feed children and pass the buck to parents.

Then we wonder why many teenagers flounder when they reach the point of having be responsible for themselves.

Eastridingclub · 17/11/2021 14:56

I think it depends on the parents. There was an expectation that a good parent would do all the things-and my parents certainly did reading, homework, board of governors etc- but also an acceptance that some parents wouldn't do any of those things and probably couldn't. Now, establishments are much pushier and unrealistic in their expectations of parents with everyone expected to provide the same support as someone with time/education/inclination. I know they're trying to change generational trends but it does come across as bossy and demanding. If the child has additional needs or there are problems at home, I believe some parents think it did be easier to pull them out of school and take things at a slower pace due to pressure.

thesockfairydidit · 17/11/2021 14:51

My child’s school has purposely taken the approach that they take their own responsibility so it’s old fashioned homework diaries and no parent log in as a school policy. I’m very happy with this way and my child has done well so far….

thewhatsit · 17/11/2021 12:30

It must all start earlier than it did. I can’t imagine I would have done my homework of my own accord and practised independently for my spelling test at age 4 or 5..

thewhatsit · 17/11/2021 12:26

I was thinking about this recently because I don’t think my parents were ever even aware what homework I had, when it was for etc.
Granted mine is only in primary (and Y1 at that) but it’s a lot - reading book every day, spelling test, weekly homework. I don’t mind doing it but I don’t recall my parents doing all that with me every day.

Hillarious · 17/11/2021 12:24

League tables! Parents are their own worst enemy sometimes.

middleager · 17/11/2021 12:12

I agree OP.

My parents only interacted at school for parents' evening.

Both were focused on work. My mother worked days and evening shifts and I was left to get on with my work.

Sockwomble · 17/11/2021 12:08

Try being the parent of a child with SEND. Many of our children only get an education because of what we do / have done to get it.

dreamingbohemian · 17/11/2021 12:06

I have mixed feelings about it

Personally I like being able to see what DS is up to because he still struggles with instructions/organisation, I am helping him improve with this but it will take a while longer.

But I get the sense some of his teachers are assuming all students have lots of parental help, some of the homework would be extremely difficult to do without it. That's not really fair, because not all students have that.

Alicetheowl · 17/11/2021 11:57

I'm early 50s and my parents didn't get involved. I was very self motivated and the first in my family to go to university. The present crop of parents are part of a generation when 40% of people went to university. They are probably more able to help. My parents left school at 15. My Dad became a carpenter, my Mum was what would now probably be classed as a care assistant in a hospital. Unless you got into a grammar school, that is what working class people did.

I did three languages at O Level (last year before it changed to GCSE). No way in a million years my parents got a sniff at a language, so no help there. They weren't going to help me understand Romeo and Juliet. Today's pupils are not being brought up by people who left school at 15 and were largely encouraged to do practical subjects.

My parents were intelligent, loved documentaries and history, by the way.

Also, people weren't so angsty about education because it didn't matter so much. CSE typing and reasonable English, you could get a job as a junior secretary at 16, end up being promoted, end up as PA to the MD of a multinational company after a few job changes and promotions. No qualifications? Plenty of manual jobs where you could work your way to foreman or higher.

Also, if your parents left school at that age, you were responsible for yourself at the same age., so studying hard to get out of a rural backwater with few exciting career options, or not, was my decision. My parents didn't guide me in the same way as now.

Coronawireless · 17/11/2021 11:48

My parents never knew what homework we had. Just expected us to get on with it. I always did well at school and was a self-starter academically. So that was great for me and my parents.

DSis however as an adult says that she always had difficulties and could have done with some help.

I help one of the DC a lot and leave the other to it. The important thing is that if the child can’t do it on their own and the teacher has 30 children to look after, that someone is checking in with them. Too many parents expect this checking in to be done by “someone else” (not them).

LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 11:45

It's a different world.
When I sat my GCSEs it was expected that we attended school, worked in lessons, did our homework, revised and sat our exams. Those who didn't were given sanctions and those who wanted extra help got extra help.

Now it's not uncommon for parents to get annoyed at teachers because their child hasn't done well in their mock exams, demanding teachers get their child a particular grade even if their child isn't working hard, outright lie to teachers in front of their children, defend their child and say 'my child wouldn't lie' even when there's a class of witnesses for a situation, complain to the Head of Department because their child 'didn't know' they had homework, and if all else fails blame the teacher for assorted issues.

By making parents aware, or at the very least making information available to parents should they want to look, it closes down a lot of the issues.

ComDummings · 17/11/2021 11:42

Than*

ComDummings · 17/11/2021 11:42

I think parenting in general is much more intensive that it has been in the past.

thecatsthecats · 17/11/2021 11:40

It does grind my gears to see both the sheer volume of "this should be on the curriculum" posts but also the "parents should be be engaged with x school stuff" posts.

Especially as you can bet your bottom dollar that the mental load falls on women.

The answer isn't straightforward as some kids really do need the pastoral support, but then I'd always see my job as to provide experiences/resources that complement and support education, not to get involved with the actual education.

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 11:37

You could also say schools now are being required to care for/raise children to a much greater extent than previous generations

SarahAndQuack · 17/11/2021 11:34

Schools do this because kids no longer take personal responsibility for their own success or failure and teachers are blamed for the latter.

I am sorry but this is hilarious.

arethereanyleftatall · 17/11/2021 11:22

Goodness, I'd hate that.
Our secondary isn't like that at all.
I have no idea what homework dd has or does (apart from her annual report) and I much prefer it that way.
From year 7, I think it's as important that they actually learn to self discipline/be independent, as the quality of the homework itself.

gingerbiscuits · 17/11/2021 11:18

@Athrawes

Schools do this because kids no longer take personal responsibility for their own success or failure and teachers are blamed for the latter. Parents complain if they weren't told that Josephine hadn't done her assignment and so is failing her course and what have we, the teachers, done to ensure that this doesn't happen. The world is a different place. Kids used to fail and get a job anyway. Now there aren't jobs to fall into at 16 so there is more pressure on schools to ensure that kids pass exams. All the evidence tells us that actually it's is families who have greatest impact on the academic success of a child. So we ask you to be involved.
Absolutely spot on!! ⬆️

Schools can't do right for doing wrong these days. I'm sick to the back teeth of being blamed for this, that & the other by parents; especially considering the huge amounts of risk I've exposed myself & my family to, over the past 2yrs.

It amazes me how much we're expected to cram into a mere 6hr school day; with a max. of 4.5hrs of that being actual teaching time.

Increasingly, over recent years, we're having 4yr olds begin school who are not even properly toilet trained, can't use cutlery, never open a book at home, can't count in the slightest, can't hold a pencil, etc. & we're being faced with a parental attitude of, "But that's your job." Seriously??

This also then goes on to be their attitude towards EVERYTHING: homework, reading & their children's understanding of even the very basics about the world around them.

They're also the same parents who are SO quick to confront, blame & demand about every little thing (often loudly & inappropriately, in front of their children & others); always defending their children without being in possession of the ACTUAL facts; it's ALWAYS OUR fault.

We are seeing an increasing proportion of children who are disengaged from their learning, want everything to be spoon fed, are completely disorganised, don't take responsibility for anything & blatantly have the attitude that if we 'tell them off' they don't care because their parents will come in & deny that they could possibly be anything other than a little angel & will yell back at us!

The amount of times we hear, "My mum/dad said I don't need to be able to 'do maths' or spell because I can just use my phone to look stuff up!"

It's no wonder that teachers are leaving the profession in droves.

blobby10 · 17/11/2021 10:23

I'm 52 and my parents only interacted with secondary school (80s) with parents evenings when they heard how well/badly I was doing and with choosing options. My mum was a SAHM and taught me and my younger siblings to read basic words before we started school (aged 5) and write our names - we were in a very small village school and this was the norm but I do realise it would be considered very privileged compared to others even in those days.

Wannakisstheteacher · 17/11/2021 09:46

I’ve had this discussion with DH. At 13 my parents had no idea what subjects I was doing, who my teachers were or what homework I was doing. DS is 13 and I know all of the above - as the school expects that I do. There is a huge amount of pressure on parents to be engaging with their child’s education way after it ever was for us.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/11/2021 09:44

YABU and extrapolating your own experiences.

I am 59 - my parents taught me to read when I was about 5 because I wasn't "getting" it at school. I can remember resenting them for it as I found it hard going and I wondered why they were torturing me.

DD didn't need the same level of help, but I have helped her.

JadeTrinket · 17/11/2021 09:42

Mine's only nine, so I know nothing about secondary, but yes, I think it's true, though I have nothing to compare it with -- my parents weren't literate when I was in primary school myself, so I never had any homework help, and always wished I had. It can be a real drag on school nights when we're all tired, but actually I do also like to keep an eye on what's being taught and what he's making of it.

Athrawes · 17/11/2021 09:38

Schools do this because kids no longer take personal responsibility for their own success or failure and teachers are blamed for the latter.
Parents complain if they weren't told that Josephine hadn't done her assignment and so is failing her course and what have we, the teachers, done to ensure that this doesn't happen.
The world is a different place. Kids used to fail and get a job anyway. Now there aren't jobs to fall into at 16 so there is more pressure on schools to ensure that kids pass exams. All the evidence tells us that actually it's is families who have greatest impact on the academic success of a child. So we ask you to be involved.