Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does everyone follow a ‘parenting ideology’?!

36 replies

Scrunchies · 17/11/2021 09:10

Inspired by another thread…. I had not heard of ‘permissive, authoritarian, authoritative’ etc parenting before. I have a 15 month old so up until now haven’t really needed a parenting ‘style’ other than feed, cuddle, clean bum etc. However she is starting to tantrum etc and my husband and I are beginning to disagree on how to manage it. Does anyone just go off instinct or does everyone read, study and follow set theories? Seems very generational and not like something our parents would have bothered with. Do we think this way is ‘better’ or just the new fashion?

No judgement by the way - I have no idea! Just interested in both sides

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Echobelly · 17/11/2021 12:52

Like most parents, muddling through, agreeing on some things, disagreeing on others.

We agree I suppose on a 'free-range' approach as in we think giving kids age-appropriate independence is more important than avoiding all possible risk.

We disagree in that sometimes DH thinks 'punishment' is needed for things that don't merit it and I think learning and making good is both better and more effective.

When they were babies my philosophy, as such, was to go with the flow, encourage them to be able to nap anywhere so we could be more flexible. Luckily they both took to that and for friends and family who really 'timetabled' their babies' naps etc it seemed really restrictive to me, but I also appreciated some babies can't just nap anywhere or may be really difficult to deal with without a routine, so even if it's less flexible, it may be the least tiring or awkward approach. Basically with babies, do what works for you, but don't assume you'll need X or Y approach before you get to really know them.

GTAlogic · 17/11/2021 12:45

I just wing it. I've tried reading the books in the past but just get frustrated when they don't work. I just get on with it and do does do. We know our dc and what does or doesn't work so really I don't think we need the books. Generations past didn't have them!

DaisyWaldron · 17/11/2021 12:41

I started with who I am and what my instincts and values were, and who my children are and what their instincts were and how they responded to the stuff I did. And then then I looked for advice and techniques that worked for us, and tended to find that advice that was appropriate tended to cluster in particular parenting styles.

When DC1 was a baby, I tried a gentle routine for a while, but that made us both stressed and miserable, while a lot of the stuff that fit into attachment parenting worked well for us. But it wasn't a philosophy that I followed wholesale.

Now that my children are at secondary school, I wing it a lot more, because they are able to articulate their troubles and emotions, and they are generally very well-behaved so I don't have to make or enforce rules very often as they just get on with life.

Triffid1 · 17/11/2021 12:27

I've looked at it again and am realising that I'm not really permissive at all. Interesting how my first instinct was to think that I am a bit. Although having said that, I do struggle with the kids and food. Not junk food - that I have no problem saying no to - but more how to tell between when they're genuinely hungry and just using it as an excuse to avoid bed/bath etc.

And I jumped on DH as permissive because he does have this habit of spending lots of time in a sort of "friend" mode with the kids. But actually, he's almost more proactive than me on solution giving.

Mmm, interesting. Really does show how these things are complex.

Rageagainstthebing · 17/11/2021 12:24

I mean I have read books, just not how to raise my child kind of books

Rageagainstthebing · 17/11/2021 12:21

@NuffSaidSam

I wouldn't commit to an ideology, but I would read around child development and make sure you understand what's happening and why and how the various approaches are likely to impact your child.

Your instincts will be based on how you were parented....whether that's a good or bad thing will depend on how you feel about your childhood.

This is what I do/did.

I used to go in all guns blazing when my dd was having a tantrum which made us all feel like shit. Now I've read up a bit about why she might be reacting like she does, I've started to be a lot calmer and will walk away until she's calmed down herself. It's made things a lot easier on us both. Things that I see as small are big to her and she's still learning to understand how the world works and that some things do seem unfair. I won't give in but I also won't punish her for feeling upset.

TikTok gave me a lot of different ideas although according to many on there, if you're not doing gentle parenting at all times you're doing it wrong which I don't agree with. I'm not going to be nice mummy all of the time but I will be kind and pick the battles that need picking. If nobody is going to get hurt or it won't end up costing me time or money I can't afford then generally it's fine.

Other than that I wing it. I've not read any books but my Google history is full of 'why is my child doing this...'. I'm not the best mum but I learn from my kids along the way.

Triffid1 · 17/11/2021 12:20

@toastofthetown that's helpful and interesting thanks. I'd put myself somewhere between authoritative and permissive (my sister would say permissive, my DC would say authoritative! Grin) DH definitely leans more towards permissive.

TheCheesyBakedBean · 17/11/2021 12:19

Tried a few over the years! I wanted to be a very different parent than the person I am. Turned out I couldn't change myself to fit into a parenting mould, I had to mould my parenting around the person I am. And then I had to adapt that again to fit each child, and each set of life circumstances. So that's my ideology now, to be intuitive and flexible. That's about it

Triffid1 · 17/11/2021 12:16

When DC1 was young I did some reading. But I don't think most people take exclusively from one style because you have to adapt for your own personality, lifestyle and child. And then once the child gets a big bigger and/or you have more children, who has time to do that reading!? Grin

I do generally read around the subject - frankly, just coming on MN gives me lots of tips and insights and makes me think about things differently. Or newspaper/magazine articles etc.

What I struggled with the most is that the child's personality is important. So you adjust and learn with DC1 and then DC2 comes along and it's all different. eg, in our case, there are times when DC1 really does need firm and strong discipline of the "DC, Get moving right now!" persuasion because it jolts him into action. this is particularly true when trying to establish new routines etc as he is not good at that. But for DC2, even the slightest raised voice is almost entirely counter productive except in the most extreme of circumstances, especially when she was younger. So we've had to take slightly different approaches. Which also brings potential resentment etc.

toastofthetown · 17/11/2021 12:15

I think there are two question in the OP. Of course not everyone consciously follows a parenting style, reads books or articles on child raising or seeks any kind of external input. But research has identifies four different parenting styles: authoritarian, authoritative, permissive and uninvolved/neglectful. And everyone's parenting, no matter how researched will fit into these categories. But how you fit yourself into these boxes isn't prescribed. Attachment parenting, pushy parenting, gentle parenting, Montessori, TCS, RIE etc. will sit within those four categories, but are separate

www.verywellfamily.com/types-of-parenting-styles-1095045

ColinTheKoala · 17/11/2021 12:13

@HugeAckmansWife

I'm not really sure when 'parent' became a verb rather than a noun. You ARE a parent. 'doing parenting' seems to imply a method or approach that to me feels like over thinking it. I found mn far more useful because the breadth of experience and approaches allows for a more pick and choose approach. Bit like weaning. I fed my babies. Bit of this, bit of that. I didn't 'do' BLW or spoonfeeding on some kind of principle of what's best.
Exactly this. I am a parent, I don't "parent".
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/11/2021 12:09

Hell no, I just bumble along!

I tend towards the gentler end of the parenting spectrum of things, I guess, but not as an ideology. I try to be fair is the main thing!

VestaTilley · 17/11/2021 12:05

No. I think subscribing to one “way” is rigid and I think your parenting should be tailored (if you can) to what suits your own child’s needs and personality.

I basically do what seems right, instinctive, fair and reasonable. I try and be always loving, warm, responsive and a bit fun where appropriate, but also firm, have routine, instill good values, right from wrong etc, and do gentle discipline (never smacking or getting angry, but very firm if needed).

Scrunchies · 17/11/2021 11:54

Some really fascinating responses so far. I completely agree with @Andante57 - mine was a really difficult newborn and I couldn’t just ‘go with the flow’ like others seemed to - it’s such a chicken and egg situation where the child could be easy because of the parents, or an easy child allows a different type of parenting.

I suppose now some things have been clarified my query is, do most parents read up on child development? I find this quite surprising. I’m starting to read bits here and there but honestly don’t know much about child development, mainly have been learning as I’m going. For those who have done a lot of reading around, what books/ sources would you recommend?

OP posts:
Andante57 · 17/11/2021 10:50

@Fairyliz

No just did whatever was needed to get through the day. As the mother of adult children I’m not really sure difference parenting styles make much difference. They will be who they will be irrespective of what you do.
This. Also it’s easy to blame parents if a child has challenging behaviour, but it’s much easier to be an easy going tolerant parent when one has easy going cooperative children.
Notdoingthis · 17/11/2021 10:41

I worked in a Montessori setting before I had kids and the behaviour was amazing. Calm kids. So I used a lot of these strategies with my own kids. I know my mum thought I was mad but she only saw a snapshot.
When something works and is based on research, it is worth using I think.

NuffSaidSam · 17/11/2021 10:02

I wouldn't commit to an ideology, but I would read around child development and make sure you understand what's happening and why and how the various approaches are likely to impact your child.

Your instincts will be based on how you were parented....whether that's a good or bad thing will depend on how you feel about your childhood.

HugeAckmansWife · 17/11/2021 09:58

I'm not really sure when 'parent' became a verb rather than a noun. You ARE a parent. 'doing parenting' seems to imply a method or approach that to me feels like over thinking it. I found mn far more useful because the breadth of experience and approaches allows for a more pick and choose approach. Bit like weaning. I fed my babies. Bit of this, bit of that. I didn't 'do' BLW or spoonfeeding on some kind of principle of what's best.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/11/2021 09:55

The only people I’ve known with an ‘ideology’ that lasted for any length of time, have been those who didn’t yet have kids, but obviously had all the answers.
Some of whom liked offering their expert advice to those of us who were going so sadly wrong. 😂

Twizbe · 17/11/2021 09:54

Nope but mostly because my kids have never read any book on how to be kids, they just are themselves.

I will try techniques from different sources to see what works for them. Sometimes it's the same and sometimes it's different.

What I dislike about a lot of this is the judgement that comes from some parents around this. For example if you do any sleep support you psychologically damaging your child for life or if you co sleep you're turning them into a dependent clingy child 🤷🏼‍♀️

Megan2018 · 17/11/2021 09:52

I am naturally following attachment parenting. But I only know what that is because I studied it at Uni. I haven’t read any books as a parent, but have read a ton of literature whilst studying.

CalamariGames · 17/11/2021 09:51

I think once you start to research parenting, whether it's by reading books or looking at things online, podcasts etc you will soon become aware that there is a risk that what you do as a parent can have lifelong consequences for your dc and your family. Unless you had a wonderful upbringing and don't feel you have any unwanted mental problems then you won't feel confident to just copy your parents in every way, and I think most people realise that doing the opposite to their parents may not work out either so what do they actually do? And of course the world is changing very fast, what is the best way to deal with technology for example, that's something where your instincts and childhood experience may not help much. It's so much easier to get information now than in our parents or grandparents time, which is both a blessing and a curse. You can't just look at the past through rose tinted glasses as a simpler time we know many children were badly treated or abused back then. At the same time I do think there is so much pressure on parents to be perfect and so much, often contradictory advice, that it may have an adverse effect making them lose confidence in themselves and worry too much. Or some people may just give up on taking any advice which would also be a shame as some advice can be helpful.
Overall I would say setting a balanced course in the sea of parenting advice is not easy, especially if you have any kind of mental problems to start with such as a bit of low confidence or anxiety or anything, so you do have to be careful and not let it get to you too much, but not ignore what is helpful.

BunsOfAnarchy · 17/11/2021 09:51

Gosh. I remember feeling like this.
Kids are, on a whole, little shits. Mine still is and I love her.
I just did what came as instinct. Books are great for some but you know your child better than any expert. Do what you feel is right x

Snowisfallinghere · 17/11/2021 09:49

Actually, yes, I would say everyone does have an ideology, whether they realise it or not.

she is starting to tantrum etc and my husband and I are beginning to disagree on how to manage it - and there you have it. If you didn't have different parenting ideologies, you wouldn't disagree. Instead of coming from a book or a blog, your parenting ideology is just the sum total of your values, instincts, temperament, emotions, attitude towards children, your own childhood experiences, your knowledge of child development etc.

And like @TheScenicWay, if we do choose to align ourselves with some established school of thought from books or blogs or classes, we tend to choose one that already reflects our attitude and values. And really, unless you treat it like some kind of strict religion, there's nothing wrong with reading books and arming yourself with a toolkit of techniques to use at difficult moments.

Another part of it is that sometimes we may feel that our instincts are actually not brilliant and there might be things we know we need to do differently. For example, let's say you struggle with your own temper. Your instinct may be to yell at your toddler when they have a tantrum or spill a drink. In that situation it can be quite helpful to have read up on more gentle parenting techniques to help yourself deal with these situations in a calmer way.

Fivebyfive2 · 17/11/2021 09:48

I've part read a couple of books like how to talk so little kids listen etc but to be honest I struggle to get the time to properly focus on them so alot of it is instinct with my almost 2 year old. A friend of mine mentioned in the baby days 'oh you do baby led parenting' and I was like... Do I?

I think a mix of styles depending on the situation works instead of fully going with only 1 way of doing things? So we mix fed, then dropped bottles because I found bf easier than sorting the bottles. No real routine until he dropped to 1 nap! I didn't do 'full' blw but ds was feeding himself with a spoon from the go at 6 months. He was fed to sleep until about 22 months but in his own room from 8 months because Co sleeping didn't suite us.

You'll find your own way op 🙂