Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win Bake off!!!

281 replies

Rizzoli123 · 17/11/2021 08:04

I am team chiggs all the way but feel like they will give it to crystelle. I think he has had a fantastic year and sort of deserves it more. I know that might be wrong to say.

What are your thoughts

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 19/11/2021 12:15

I don’t consider her loud at all and if she’s the best baker in the final she will deserve to win.
I just find a person (of any sex) half collapsing on the floor because a man shook their hand a bit dramatic.
It’s personal preference, I enjoyed Jurgens quiet but confident reactions much more.

Kikkomam · 19/11/2021 12:02

I think it's fair enough to say her reactions are a bit over the top! She's a great baker but I'm a bit worried that she might actually collapse if she wins.

Cofifeefee · 19/11/2021 11:59

over the top reactions

What is the definition of over the top reactions? How should the woman change herself in order to get people to like her and judge her on her baking skills on a baking show? Her reaction has nothing to do with her skills but yet people don't want her to win because they consider her too loud.

Hoppinggreen · 19/11/2021 11:54

@Cofifeefee

It does no good to expect women to unconditionally like/support ALL other women

Nobody is saying you need to support all women but you're judging a woman on her personality (her edited for tv personality at that) when the men just get judged on their baking skills.

I don't see how anybody can decide she's fake - you don't know her! As for "amateur dramatics"? What does that mean? She's not meek enough for you? She shouldn't show her happiness, should keep herself quiet and not draw attention to herself? But sure, it's not about misogyny.

As myself and others have said they would find a man doing the same over the top reactions to everything equally annoying then you are correct it’s not about misogyny
Cofifeefee · 19/11/2021 11:51

It does no good to expect women to unconditionally like/support ALL other women

Nobody is saying you need to support all women but you're judging a woman on her personality (her edited for tv personality at that) when the men just get judged on their baking skills.

I don't see how anybody can decide she's fake - you don't know her! As for "amateur dramatics"? What does that mean? She's not meek enough for you? She shouldn't show her happiness, should keep herself quiet and not draw attention to herself? But sure, it's not about misogyny.

Kikkomam · 19/11/2021 11:51

No worries! I've been ruminating far more than I should have about Paul H bullying Jergen and Prus wet comment about the handshake

WhatHoMarjorie · 19/11/2021 11:50

The 'comedy' intros make me clench my sphincter so hard.

Mezza Bezza would never.

Innocenta · 19/11/2021 11:44

@Kikkomam Everyone's personal taste in humour is different! Sorry if I came off as saying it was wrong to be amused by it - that wasn't really what I meant. Was just talking about my own reaction Smile

Kikkomam · 19/11/2021 11:34

I thought the Freddie/Bowie/elvis bit was funny.

JadeTrinket · 19/11/2021 11:13

@Laiste

A confident white male flapping and falling about and shrieking down the phone would put me off me too Hmm I wouldn't care if they were brown, black orange or bloody purple, from London or from Mars - all the face pulling and dramatic performance for the cameras is annoying!

It's nothing to do with ethnicity or sex. I've got 4 daughters (3 in their 20s) and i'm well aware of what misogyny is and i rage against it all the time. If one of my DDs were behaving like Chrystelle does i'd happily tell them they were being bloody irritating and to reign it in too!

It does no good to expect women to unconditionally like/support ALL other women and then accuse them of racism and sexism if they don't. I'm a woman - am i not allowed to say what i think now for fear of being called sexist?! Fuck that.

Sorry but this really pisses me off.

But she’s a contestant on a tv show that shoots hundreds of hours of footage and edits according to a fairly cartoonish vision of what each contestant/judge/presenter is ‘like’ — maybe Crystelle is actually a melodramatic person, or maybe she’s edited to focus on that aspect, and the hours when she’s quietly getting in with stuff don’t figure. Just like Lizzie was ‘zany’, Maggie was ‘trad older WI type’ etc. I mean, they’re cast by the producers for that stuff as well as their baking abilities.

Either way, I don’t see how anyone can declare someone ‘fake’ from a tv programme. Of course was you’re seeing on screen is manufactured — just like Big Brother. The cosines shouldn’t blind us to that. Dani, the nice medic from a bunch of series ago, said it well when she said the producers were making a product, and the bakers aren’t it.

clarkie78 · 19/11/2021 11:12

It's a shame Jurgen went as wanted him to win, so probably Guiseppe

Innocenta · 19/11/2021 11:10

@Kikkomam

I thought it was funny. Its a light hearted show, surely - or should be #justiceforjurgen
What did you think was funny?
Kikkomam · 19/11/2021 10:56

I thought it was funny. Its a light hearted show, surely - or should be #justiceforjurgen

Innocenta · 19/11/2021 10:55

@Fifthtimelucky

I was sorry to see Jurgen go, but all four did very well last night and think it must have been incredibly close. I'd have liked them all to go through to the final. I actually like all three remaining competitors and don't really mind who wins now.

Definitely agree with others about how annoying Paul is. Matt is also extremely annoying. That Bowie/Freddie/Elvis bit at the beginning of the show was just stupid. I was glad Prue didn't take part (except to tell them to get on with it )!

I kept thinking how much Freddie would have hated it. He had an eating disorder and was a tiny little man - only suffering bloating and weight changes in relation to his ill health. I really don't like that they had him portrayed that way, it felt too much like mockery.
Innocenta · 19/11/2021 10:53

The hate against Crystelle is wild - going as far as one PP reassigning the dropped sausage roll incident to her, when it was actually Jürgen! She's obviously extremely skilled, and so many women suffer genuine imposter syndrome / anxiety. It's a high pressure situation, too.

Kikkomam · 19/11/2021 10:39

Yes Jurgen was confident and look what happened to him

Exhausteddog · 19/11/2021 10:38

There was a contestant called David a few years ago who i (and it seemed several other MN) found a bit irritating and he came across really smug.
He was male and white.
Someone on MN knew him ,and said that was not at all what he was like in RL.
Maybe we don't like anyone to be confident? Blush

Hoppinggreen · 19/11/2021 10:27

@wtaf37

Amazing how many MNs don't like Crystelle. Is it because she's female (and thus you believe she is there just for PHs delectation) or because she is BAME? It can't be because she is a crap baker because she isn't. And sorry, Lizzie was just not good enough
Can’t speak for anyone else but I find her over the top am dram clutching at the counter and pretending to fall over whenever she does well annoying. Nothing to do with her sex or race, I would find a white man doing the same equally irritating I think she’s a good baker, very creative and if she does feel that she has to pretend not to be any good because of female conditioning I think that’s a shame
Kikkomam · 19/11/2021 10:26

I'd be happy for whoever wins tbh. The magic has gone now anyway #justiceforjurgen

Kikkomam · 19/11/2021 10:25

I like Crystelle but the over top crying grates on me. But as pps have said, people don't like confident women so I can see she's been socialised to do it.

wtaf37 · 19/11/2021 10:19

Amazing how many MNs don't like Crystelle. Is it because she's female (and thus you believe she is there just for PHs delectation) or because she is BAME?
It can't be because she is a crap baker because she isn't.
And sorry, Lizzie was just not good enough

Medievalist · 19/11/2021 08:41

Laiste - spot on.

Why so many posters have to equate a dislike of such overly dramatic behaviour and false modesty with sexism is beyond me.

Exhausteddog · 19/11/2021 08:40

The first week we watched, DH commented that Crystelle was stunning and would probably get to the final , before we even knew what her baking was like.
But she is a good baker and has made some amazing cakes (im sad Freya went out so early as I thought she was also very talented) so I don't think that was the main reason! Although I still don't know how they separated the 4 of them in the end, it seemed there was literally nothing in it (if anything, Chigs technical disaster should have counted against him)
And I still didn't understand why they didn't taste or even critique the centre piece of their show stopper. Why did it even need to be edible (or even there at all) if they weren't going to taste it? I commented that Chigs central biscuit tree might be too simplistic compared to the others but they didn't really mention any of them!

BridesmaidHelp · 19/11/2021 08:23

I find Nadiya quite wholesome, good viewing, less threatening to most women.
It’s a well known fact attractive females get a hard time amongst other females, doubly so if they are ethnic.
I’m not even a Christelle fan, I’m devastated Juergen is out!

lollipoprainbow · 19/11/2021 08:12

@Laiste brilliantly put !!