Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
Thatsthewaytis · 17/11/2021 21:42

@Lostinacloud Well there is that side of the coin, others would argue that vaccines might be causing antibody dependent enhancement in some people and those people are actually experiencing more severe symptoms as a result of vaccination. Who knows?

So true. I mean maybe the vaccinated people in ICU grew another set of lungs from having the vaccine an that’s why their covid symptoms are so much worse. Who knows!!! We just can’t trust actual data.

sirfredfredgeorge · 17/11/2021 21:37

Quite a few countries require a covid pass for shopping - most of them currently accept recent test as an alternative, however that is being limited now in the countries that are growing the most.

If you search for 2g 3g covid, you can read lots of English language European papers on the different covid passes, lots are moving to covid passes not accepting tests (incidently this is actually modelled to prevent the unvaccinated negative test people from catching the virus from the vaccinated positive people and then spread it onwards) the countries which require covid passes for essential shopping is less though (Cyprus, Estonia I'm pretty sure.)

Sadly there isn't a good source for restrictions everywhere, especially as like in the UK they're often highly regional even within a country.

ILoveHuskies · 17/11/2021 21:35

[quote PAFMO]@Jammydodge2
Not linking to your post because I've reported it, but why are you as a "fully vaccinated frontline nurse" against vaccine passes, ergo against vaccines?[/quote]
People can be pro vaccine but against vaccine passports

Is it really that hard to grasp?

DismantledKing · 17/11/2021 21:29

@millymolls

Completely agree with lostinacloud This thread shows most people have zero understanding of respiratory viruses and zero understanding of mRNA technology that there’s no point arguing at all. It’s a truly sad state of affairs that people are prepared to accept these this so easily. Utterly depressing
Luckily for you that you’ve got YouTube, eh?
Draggondragon · 17/11/2021 21:29

Meanwhile the rest of the world has been using ID cards and fingerprint type identifiers for years. I thought the only people who would be alarmed would be the stupid sixth form common room types who think the entire world should exist under their little socialist model.

ILoveHuskies · 17/11/2021 21:29

YANBU

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2021 21:28

There's a massive difference. Mask avoiders are just idiots (if not genuinely exempt). Nobody has died from wearing a mask.

I’d switch that. Masks maybe lower cases not by much, vaccine reduces risk of death and hospitalisation.

I know which I’d choose to have available.

millymolls · 17/11/2021 21:26

Completely agree with lostinacloud
This thread shows most people have zero understanding of respiratory viruses and zero understanding of mRNA technology that there’s no point arguing at all.
It’s a truly sad state of affairs that people are prepared to accept these this so easily. Utterly depressing

ColinTheKoala · 17/11/2021 21:26

@gwenneh

If you want to participate in public life, then you have to take part in public health measures. Whether you agree with the measures or not, and whether they benefit you as an individual or not, makes no difference.
This argument might hold water if vaccines were 100% safe, and 100% effective. They are neither.
thenightsky · 17/11/2021 21:25

@Worldgonecrazy

Having the vaccine reduces the chance of hospitalisation and serious illness.

So does not being fat.

One makes money for pharmaceutical and health industries.

One doesn’t. One also has long term additional benefits for the NHS.

Amazing that only one method is being promoted.

If, instead of vaccine passports, we had BMI passports there would be an outcry. And before someone points out BMI measurements aren’t perfect measurements of fitness, I would point out that vaccination status is not a perfect measure of either immunity or contagious status.

Yes, absolutely this!
ColinTheKoala · 17/11/2021 21:24

@Viviennemary

Bring it on. We've had the mask avoiders. Now its the vaccine avoiders.
There's a massive difference. Mask avoiders are just idiots (if not genuinely exempt). Nobody has died from wearing a mask.

People have died from having the vaccine.

ColinTheKoala · 17/11/2021 21:21

@RockingMyFiftiesNot

Did you have to disclose your yellow fever vaccination status to go into a shop?

Can you link to anything which suggests you will need to disclose your Covid vaccination status to go into a shop?

Someone upthread says that you have to disclose it to go into smaller shops in Estonia.
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 17/11/2021 21:19

Did you have to disclose your yellow fever vaccination status to go into a shop?

Can you link to anything which suggests you will need to disclose your Covid vaccination status to go into a shop?

Lostinacloud · 17/11/2021 21:18

Well there is that side of the coin, others would argue that vaccines might be causing antibody dependent enhancement in some people and those people are actually experiencing more severe symptoms as a result of vaccination. Who knows? You almost can’t trust data on either side of the argument anymore because all of it is manipulated to better represent whichever point you are trying to prove. I saw some stats on mainstream media earlier today quoting Chris Witty. He said that of the 235 pregnant women admitted to icu between 1st Feb and 30th September, 232 were not vaccinated - 98%. Wow, what a high number and what proof that unvaccinated pregnant woman are taking up beds. But then of course most pregnant woman wouldn’t have been eligible for the vaccine in February and they only had a bigger push for vaccinating pregnant women in August so that leaves just one month of data to start taking about real unvaccinated numbers.
And some on here wonder why lots of us are not entirely convinced about the argument and promises we are being sold! Hmm

gofg · 17/11/2021 21:17

I don't believe the state should have any power over who I mingle with and where. I don't believe the state should have the power to exclude people from society based on their decision. And I dont have a problem with unvaccinated people. I dont see them as a greater threat to me and I don't worry about them putting themselves in danger

It's not just about you though is it? There are people who, for medical reasons, can't be vaccinated. There are many people with compromised immune systems. Are they all to remain behind closed doors forever, just because some people find it so difficult to show a vaccine passport Hmm

XenoBitch · 17/11/2021 21:15

@BudrosBudrosGalli

I do not understand the hysteria about vaccination cards/ 'passports', that latter being a really misleading term. As a child living in Africa, we all had a yellow World Health vaccination 'passport' that showed that we were up to date on life-saving vaccinations, such as Yellow Fever etc.
Did you have to disclose your yellow fever vaccination status to go into a shop?
5keletor · 17/11/2021 21:11

I'm not against the vaccine, but I don't like the idea of vaccine passports. I don't disclose my vaccination status to anyone, unless it's needed, for example in a medical setting. It doesn't bother me whether someone else isn't vaccinated, none of my business.

BudrosBudrosGalli · 17/11/2021 21:05

I do not understand the hysteria about vaccination cards/ 'passports', that latter being a really misleading term. As a child living in Africa, we all had a yellow World Health vaccination 'passport' that showed that we were up to date on life-saving vaccinations, such as Yellow Fever etc.

Whyamistilltired · 17/11/2021 20:55

I have a friend who is 50, very obese, and was really unwell with Covid and now long covid. Double vaxxed; instead of assuming the vaccines don't work, my immediate thought is thank god she was vaccinated or she could well be dead by now

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/11/2021 20:49

+Unvaccinated under 65 year olds are protected in the large majority by virtue of their age.*

My sil 44 has been really ill. Still of work 12 weeks later ( fully vaccinated)
Bil 48, had pneumonia and coughing blood ( fully vaccinated)
Friend 38 left deaf in one ear ( fully vaccinated)
Dh’s boss 58, in hospital for 6 days ( fully vaccinated)

Under 65’s don’t get off as easily as you like to thinkConfused

Whyamistilltired · 17/11/2021 20:37

I don't feel restricted by this, in fact, i like it as it gives me a certain amount of comfort to think that all the people around me are also vaccinated

This is kind of the worst, sorry. They are human beings, not disease vectors.

Of course human beings are disease vectors Hmm

Thatsthewaytis · 17/11/2021 19:21

@MarshaBradyo I was responding to a poster who said Ireland was evidence covid passes don’t work. I didn’t even see this chart you posted.

ilovesooty · 17/11/2021 19:09

@PAFMO

The irony of someone likening showing a QR code so that they don't risk, y'know, infecting somebody else with something that might kill them to the Holocaust and then having the balls to say it's others doing the name-calling....
I agree. Utterly bizarre.
MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2021 19:07

[quote Thatsthewaytis]@MarshaBradyo I said it was stupid to say cases in Ireland are high because the vaccine cert isn’t working. We have no way of knowing how high cases would be if the cert wasn’t in place so it’s a stupid point to make. For all we know without the pass the country would be back in a hard lockdown due to overwhelmed hospitals.

I would hazard a guess that cases in Ireland are very high as Ireland didn’t have a lot of immunity. There was an interesting article on Waterford which has currently one of the highest rates of covid but had the lowest rate and escaped all covid waves during lockdowns. As we all now know vaccines don’t stop you getting covid.

Also testing and extent of testing is likely important. High levels of testing are ongoing in Ireland. Maybe not the same in U.K.

There could be other reasons too. But saying oh look high cases mean vaccine certs don’t work is pure idiocy.[/quote]
Did anyone say not working? Maybe someone else did

I just said I found the two images interesting with darker green and higher rates in some cases

It’s very hard to know what impact they have as perhaps even higher without.

I do think too that higher immunity could be part of the picture, I’m hoping it’s the case for U.K.

I’d be interested to know re testing as I thought U.K. was high

Viviennemary · 17/11/2021 19:06

Bring it on. We've had the mask avoiders. Now its the vaccine avoiders.