Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
nojudgementhere · 18/11/2021 09:11

@JassyRadlett

Thank you for confirming that *@JassyRadlett*. I haven't seen any real evidence that introducing vaccine passports will save lives either.

To be fair, I haven’t looked for it, and just as for any other NPIs it’s going to be very hard to be unequivocal and precise.

You could say much the same about lockdowns, capacity restrictions, school closures, mask wearing, or hand washing. There are too many uncontrollable factors to get a clear evidence base on the precise impact of on any of these measures.

The one thing we do have evidence on is the level to which vaccination will change how many of a particular group are likely to be infected at a particular time. A group that is fully vaccinated will, on average, have a significantly lower number of infected people, and the rest of the group will be better protected against catching it from them.

Surely this is exactly the kind of evidence we should be asking for though before introducing something as controversial and potentially damaging as vaccine passports? Just crossing our fingers and hoping it will work seems a little unscientific to me and having seen the damage earlier NPIs have created (10,000 non-Covid excess deaths in the last four months alone) I'm a little bit wary of another one being introduced.
Lostinacloud · 18/11/2021 09:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 09:10

@nojudgementhere

I have never equated vaccine passports with the Holocaust as I would not want to hurt or offend anyone and I in no way feel the two things are on the same level of atrocity. I doubt whether people who do compare the two are deliberately trying to cause harm or controversy though. I think they are genuinely terrified by the fact that whole sections of populations are all of a sudden being treated as 'unclean' or 'too dangerous to be part of society' and feel unable to adequaely express this. Maybe we should be looking at addressing these points rather than shutting them down?
I’ll be very frank - your recent post reads as justifying those who are doing this and making excuses for them. It’s something I find frankly abhorrent.

I do also question their expectation to be treated with kid gloves when they consistently refuse to show basic respect to others who also have significant cause for fear in modern society.

I have also spent months on these threads avoiding name calling, not taking sides, trying to share the evidence and dispel misinformation in a measured, calm, factual way.

I don’t doubt some are afraid. I do doubt that they all are, and I absolutely don’t accept that anyone who has taken five minutes to inform themselves about the Holocaust can still turn around and in good faith compare the potential consequences of what most claim to be a short term choice (aren’t most saying they just want longer term data? And most of these public health measures are time limited in law anyway) to the systematic racist excision from society of millions based on their birth, not their choices.

Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 09:07

@nojudgementhere

I have never equated vaccine passports with the Holocaust as I would not want to hurt or offend anyone and I in no way feel the two things are on the same level of atrocity. I doubt whether people who do compare the two are deliberately trying to cause harm or controversy though. I think they are genuinely terrified by the fact that whole sections of populations are all of a sudden being treated as 'unclean' or 'too dangerous to be part of society' and feel unable to adequaely express this. Maybe we should be looking at addressing these points rather than shutting them down?
Factually, people who are unvaccinated are more likely to spread covid to others. They are more likely to catch covid too so being around them is a higher risk in general. They are more likely to be hospitalised using up valuable hospital resources at a time when those resources are limited. People who are unvaccinated have refused to listen to actual experts in the area who have explained time and time again that the vaccine is safe.

We are in the middle of a pandemic. They are statistically more dangerous to be around. They are statistically more likely to infect other people around them. This is the whole rationale for vaccine certs. They are not randomly being singled out. There are valid reasons.

Hope that has addressed those points for you.

Also clearly people who are unvaccinated couldn’t care less about those around them or those who genuinely can’t get the vaccine so I have zero sympathy for their ‘fears’ unless those fears have come about from being engulfed in a conspiracy theory in which case I hope they get psychological help.

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 09:06

On the topic of whether Covid passes work you could ask

Do they increase uptake?

Which groups and how much does higher vaccine take up there help?

Do they work seems quite complex so maybe breaking it down is helpful

In other ways if not above

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 09:05

@RandomLondoner

On the subject of fatness re. covid...

The doubling time for the unfettered spread of Covid is a few days, maybe 3? (Can't be arsed to google.) The doubling time for clinical obesity is, I guess, something like 50 years.

These times mean that with no preventative action, it would take at most a few weeks for NHS to be overwhelmed by Covid. It would take a few centuries for fat to cause the same problem, and you'd have to assume that in the time the NHS wouldn't expand to cope, nor anyone invent a method of preventing it.

This doesn’t quite follow to me

Aren’t you better off looking at how to reduce obesity not just in the duration of this pandemic but future ones

RandomLondoner · 18/11/2021 09:02

On the subject of fatness re. covid...

The doubling time for the unfettered spread of Covid is a few days, maybe 3? (Can't be arsed to google.) The doubling time for clinical obesity is, I guess, something like 50 years.

These times mean that with no preventative action, it would take at most a few weeks for NHS to be overwhelmed by Covid. It would take a few centuries for fat to cause the same problem, and you'd have to assume that in the time the NHS wouldn't expand to cope, nor anyone invent a method of preventing it.

nojudgementhere · 18/11/2021 09:00

I have never equated vaccine passports with the Holocaust as I would not want to hurt or offend anyone and I in no way feel the two things are on the same level of atrocity. I doubt whether people who do compare the two are deliberately trying to cause harm or controversy though. I think they are genuinely terrified by the fact that whole sections of populations are all of a sudden being treated as 'unclean' or 'too dangerous to be part of society' and feel unable to adequaely express this. Maybe we should be looking at addressing these points rather than shutting them down?

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 08:59

Thank you for confirming that @JassyRadlett. I haven't seen any real evidence that introducing vaccine passports will save lives either.

To be fair, I haven’t looked for it, and just as for any other NPIs it’s going to be very hard to be unequivocal and precise.

You could say much the same about lockdowns, capacity restrictions, school closures, mask wearing, or hand washing. There are too many uncontrollable factors to get a clear evidence base on the precise impact of on any of these measures.

The one thing we do have evidence on is the level to which vaccination will change how many of a particular group are likely to be infected at a particular time. A group that is fully vaccinated will, on average, have a significantly lower number of infected people, and the rest of the group will be better protected against catching it from them.

Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 08:53

@nojudgementhere to be fair the ridicule is justified! The absolute nonsense being trotted out on mumsnet alone about the vaccine. All based on pure speculation or fake news. What do you expect people to do?

Oh yes you are so right. We don’t know the effects of the vaccine. It’s only been given to 7 billion people. Of course you are right to be cautious Confused

Oh yes it’s definitely possible it will have no effect on your now and 20 years down the line it will have a huge effect.

Oh yes of course the government are out to get you. Totally understandable not to get the vaccine.

Ah yes your concern there will be a 5 G chip in your brain so bill gates can monitor you

Ah yes I totally get you feel like you are being persecuted similar to Jewish people in the holocaust Confused

Oh the vaccine is going to cause infertility! You’re definitely right about that despite zero plausible mechanism.

I’ve never heard a valid argument against the vaccine. It’s all sheer nonsense.

nojudgementhere · 18/11/2021 08:49

Thank you for confirming that @JassyRadlett. I haven't seen any real evidence that introducing vaccine passports will save lives either. What I do know is that they are causing a real division in society and making us turn on one another rather than the government who have over the last ten years run our hospitals into the ground.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 08:44

The one thing I will express a very clear opinion about on this thread is that equating vaccine passports as they are currently used in any country with the Holocaust, or excusing or downplaying the same, is disgusting.

Jews have repeatedly explained why it’s so offensive and asked for it to stop. Downplaying the racial annihilation of the Holocaust helps to feed anti-semitism.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 08:39

Do you have any evidence that vaccine passports do make a significant difference to infection rates then?

No, but then I’ve made no claims about them one way or another.

I simply asked for the evidence supporting an apparent statement of fact. The onus tends to be on the person making the statement to provide evidence to support it.

nojudgementhere · 18/11/2021 08:37

*PAFMO

The irony of someone likening showing a QR code so that they don't risk, y'know, infecting somebody else with something that might kill them to the Holocaust and then having the balls to say it's others doing the name-calling....

I agree. Utterly bizarre.*

You have both spectacularly missed the point here - as I would imagine you realise. People are not complaining about showing a QR code. They are complaining about a whole section of society being shut out of normal life, ridiculed and mistreated for refusing to take a vaccine that they don't feel ready to, and for insisting that they have autonomy over their own bodies. You can downplay it all you like but I would find it hard to think of myself as a decent person if I supported this.

nojudgementhere · 18/11/2021 08:24

@JessyRadlett - Do you have any evidence that vaccine passports do make a significant difference to infection rates then?

Surely if we are going to support a hugely discriminatory policy like this, that will have a major impact on people's lives, happiness and freedom, then we should have concrete evidence of how many lives it will save.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 08:11

Well we do know that infection rates are not significantly lower in Scotland and Wales than in England despite having vaccine passports.

Absent all other factors - including weather, school terms, earlier infection dynamics etc being controlled, that’s not really evidence and certainly not strong enough for ‘we know they don’t reduce infection rates.’

Lostinacloud · 18/11/2021 08:09

@Thatsthewaytis you know nothing about me but thanks for the biscuit for my tea Brew

Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 08:06

@ColinTheKoala awhhh I am playing the worlds tiniest violin just for you.

ColinTheKoala · 18/11/2021 07:56

@JassyRadlett

We know vaccine passports don’t reduce infection rates, don’t reduce NHS pressure, and don’t encourage more than a very small increase in uptake.

Could you share the evidence on this, please? Really interested to see it.

Well we do know that infection rates are not significantly lower in Scotland and Wales than in England despite having vaccine passports.

And yet NI has just decided to introduce them. That's my alternative birthday plan gone* Sad

*was planning a trip to Berlin next March but if there are still vaccine passports was going to go to Belfast instead. Now need to find an alternative alternative!

ColinTheKoala · 18/11/2021 07:54

@UsedUpUsername

There's a massive difference. Mask avoiders are just idiots (if not genuinely exempt). Nobody has died from wearing a mask

A kid in China genuinely died during PE from exercising in a mask. And yet, many kids in America still have to wear them when they exercise. It’s really dumb.

Because masks don’t work. At least not the ones worn by the general population

I didn't know that and I agree that is genuinely dumb!
JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 07:33

What I’m trying to get across is the old adage of ‘lies, damned lies and statistics’

Data can be easily manipulated to support an argument/restrictions no matter what the actual situation.

Which is again why I come back to the importance of primary data and sources - and yet you object to that data being published too?

It’s also why we’re fortunate in this country to have a robust statistics regulator who can (and have) raised issues and reprimanded politicians and public bodies for misusing statistics to support their preferred positions, and ensures high standards of probity for our official statistics in the UK.

Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 07:32

@BurntO

It’s almost like we’re in a once in a century pandemic and no one has a fucking clue what they’re doing but they are hoping to reduce those suffering long term health issues or death
Well said. It amazing how many would rather believe a vast conspiracy against them. It’s worrying.
Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 07:30

@Lostinacloud we all know what you’re trying to get across! I’ve seen you on these threads before and it’s certainly nothing to do with facts or statistics! Biscuit

Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 07:29

@HeyDugeesCakeBadge maybe you should go back on Facebook if you want a vacuum of ‘altnerate facts’

@UsedUpUsername I suppose I dismiss it because it’s nonsense and not backed up by any kind of facts or data?

Lostinacloud · 18/11/2021 07:27

What I’m trying to get across is the old adage of ‘lies, damned lies and statistics’

Data can be easily manipulated to support an argument/restrictions no matter what the actual situation.