Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 10:47

So now our right-wing Tory government is secretly communist? For fuck’s sake.

left vs. right is an outdated discourse. Conservatism or liberalism also drifted too far from original meaning.
Only ideals that "speak" universally are power and money. Do you think tories are going to stand up to their corporate/globalist handlers?

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 10:46

@PAFMO

We could try talking about scientific fact? As *@JassyRadlett* has tried to do?
That feels like a distant dream now.
PAFMO · 18/11/2021 10:44

We could try talking about scientific fact?
As @JassyRadlett has tried to do?

DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 10:41

How about not using ridiculous unhistorical examples at all, and try and let your argument stand on its own merits?

DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 10:39

Ok, let's stop about Holocaust. Let's talk about communism - been tried in quite a few places. There is no "greater good" in totalitarianism, it only leads to mass atrocities.

So now our right-wing Tory government is secretly communist? For fuck’s sake.

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 10:38

I would absolutely like people to stop using the Holocaust to try to justify their views on this issue. Or any issue that is not, in fact, the Holocaust.

Ok, let's stop about Holocaust. Let's talk about communism - been tried in quite a few places. There is no "greater good" in totalitarianism, it only leads to mass atrocities.

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 10:33

I agree. I am pro-vaccine, anti-pass, and anti-Holocaust comparaisons. It doesn't do the side any favours.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 10:31

I think if you bang the 'we're downplaying the holocaust' drum too hard - it silences people. It freezes people. Is that what you want? For us to be too scared to discuss?

I would absolutely like people to stop using the Holocaust to try to justify their views on this issue. Or any issue that is not, in fact, the Holocaust.

No one is forcing you to rely on the Holocaust to be able to discuss this issue. Discuss away. It’s a live issue, it should be discussed.

But comparing any choice-based discrimination to racial discrimination is problematic, on first principles. There is agency in the former that is absolutely lacking in the latter. Those choices might be incredibly uncomfortable and make life significantly worse, but conflating them with racial discrimination wipes away the total lack of agency for people to opt out from that discrimination.

But then you do get to questions of scale, and modern impact. On the Holocaust question, Holocaust denial and diminishment is an active component of modern antisemitism.

Who’s stopping you discussing this without talking about yellow stars and ghettoes? Are people saying ‘stop bitching, it’s not the Holocaust?’ Point me in their direction and I’ll tell them they’re being twats and the two aren’t even remotely comparable.

But in the meantime - why can’t this be discussed without bringing the Holocaust into it? If you’re concerned about people like me ‘freezing’ discussion by pointing out how it absolutely downplays the Nazi atrocities from their conception, there’s a real simple solution. Just don’t bloody do it. Don’t co-opt that tragedy for your argument, and the risk of anti-racists criticising the argument totally disappears.

And don’t do it with racial segregation in the South either. Though people don’t seem quite so quick to reach for that one. I can’t think why.

nojudgementhere · 18/11/2021 10:30

@SencosRshit

But the suggestion that there is even anything to compare between the Holocaust and vaccine passports is so staggeringly offensive that I feel compelled to take a side on that one. And it’s not ‘history’. Downplaying the Holocaust is a core element of modern antisemitism.

This is interesting @JassyRadlett

My gut feeling tells me that the vaccine passport/segregation is dangerous because it could be the beginnings of something much more serious.

I don't think it's antisemitic to spot the potential germination of something very worrying.

There are too many people that are ignorant of our history and what happened during the holocaust.

www.theguardian.com/world/2020/sep/16/holocaust-us-adults-study

It is better that people are vigilant rather than ignorant - don't you think? One of the importances of discussing and sharing our history is to prevent similar tragedies from happening again.

I agree with thie 100% @SencosRshit - Thank you for articulating my thoughts so perfectly!
DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 10:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 10:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 10:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 10:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 10:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

Thatsthewaytis · 18/11/2021 10:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 10:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 10:21

@SencosRshit

Sorry JassyR - but I also feel very strongly about this.

I think if you bang the 'we're downplaying the holocaust' drum too hard - it silences people. It freezes people. Is that what you want? For us to be too scared to discuss?

It is only by talking about these things that we can spot patterns and concerns. I think we need to be alert now. And I think trying to shut down this conversation is also very dangerous.

If you don’t like vaccine passports, that’s fine. Make your point. If you use the example of the Holocaust to back it up for reasons of your own hyperbole and paranoia, that’s far from fine. It’s offensive to victims of the Nazis.
SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 10:19

Sorry JassyR - but I also feel very strongly about this.

I think if you bang the 'we're downplaying the holocaust' drum too hard - it silences people. It freezes people. Is that what you want? For us to be too scared to discuss?

It is only by talking about these things that we can spot patterns and concerns. I think we need to be alert now. And I think trying to shut down this conversation is also very dangerous.

DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 10:17

@SencosRshit

It may seem nonsense to you. That is opinion. Not fact. But I'm sure you already know that, Dismantled.
Read JessyRadlett’s reply. Stop using the holocaust to reinforce your paranoia.
SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 10:15

It may seem nonsense to you. That is opinion. Not fact. But I'm sure you already know that, Dismantled.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 10:14

My gut feeling tells me that the vaccine passport/segregation is dangerous because it could be the beginnings of something much more serious.

I don't think it's antisemitic to spot the potential germination of something very worrying.

No, but downplaying the Holocaust absolutely is. It is encouraging ignorance of the true scale of what was done by conflating it with the concept of exclusion from some public spaces based on vaccine choice.

We’ve seen it on this thread already. The idea that the Holocaust was an opt-in choice based on active religious affiliation. The

The question I would always encourage people to ask themselves is why, when they’re talking about this, it’s the Holocaust they reach for, rather than racial segregation in the US South?

I wouldn’t use either. If you’re worried about segregation or discrimination based on this choice, then great. Argue it on its merits.

Don’t co-opt another tragedy based on an entirely different characteristic to make your argument. Neither US racial segregation or the Holocaust are appropriate comparators. That trauma and grief are not your rhetorical device.

DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 10:13

My gut feeling tells me that the vaccine passport/segregation is dangerous because it could be the beginnings of something much more serious.

This is nonsense, and just another way of using the facile ‘slippery slope’ argument to say that a public health measure will lead to a similar horror to the Holocaust.

SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 10:07

But the suggestion that there is even anything to compare between the Holocaust and vaccine passports is so staggeringly offensive that I feel compelled to take a side on that one. And it’s not ‘history’. Downplaying the Holocaust is a core element of modern antisemitism.

This is interesting @JassyRadlett

My gut feeling tells me that the vaccine passport/segregation is dangerous because it could be the beginnings of something much more serious.

I don't think it's antisemitic to spot the potential germination of something very worrying.

There are too many people that are ignorant of our history and what happened during the holocaust.

www.theguardian.com/world/2020/sep/16/holocaust-us-adults-study

It is better that people are vigilant rather than ignorant - don't you think? One of the importances of discussing and sharing our history is to prevent similar tragedies from happening again.

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 10:06

@JollyJoon

Yes the UK tests much more than France. The UK also has a highly sensitive tracing app. Self testing and isolating are not "a thing" in France. The Tous Anti Covid app doesnt work at all like the NHS app. I had mine activated for 3 months and didnt get a single "cas contact" notification. The French app relies on people inputting data themselves and using bluetooth. In the UK everywhere you go you get tracked.

Its easy for people visiting from France to act "appalled" at non mask wearing in the UK, but in france because their tracing system and testing is shit/low uptake, you dont really have much power over keeping yourself safe.

It comes down to:
Would you rather have freedom but the knowledge (through high testing and good tracing) to shield yourself where necessary? UK
Or limited freedom (compulsory masks, compulsory pass) but lower knowledge? France

This aligns pretty well with the two different political cultures in the countries though. France has quite a paternalistic government, the UK is more hands off.

Interesting question

I prefer U.K. approach, I live here though so obviously I’m influenced by the culture

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 10:05

Yes the UK tests much more than France. The UK also has a highly sensitive tracing app. Self testing and isolating are not "a thing" in France. The Tous Anti Covid app doesnt work at all like the NHS app. I had mine activated for 3 months and didnt get a single "cas contact" notification. The French app relies on people inputting data themselves and using bluetooth. In the UK everywhere you go you get tracked.

Its easy for people visiting from France to act "appalled" at non mask wearing in the UK, but in france because their tracing system and testing is shit/low uptake, you dont really have much power over keeping yourself safe.

It comes down to:
Would you rather have freedom but the knowledge (through high testing and good tracing) to shield yourself where necessary? UK
Or limited freedom (compulsory masks, compulsory pass) but lower knowledge? France

This aligns pretty well with the two different political cultures in the countries though. France has quite a paternalistic government, the UK is more hands off.