Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
ddl1 · 18/11/2021 12:22

. If you are vaccinated you are well protected. Not completely; though if most people are vaccinated, then there is good protection. You could argue that your paranoia is impinging on another's freedom. What paranoia? The question is: why is your right to impinge on others freedoms greater than an unvaccinated person's? Why is theirs greater than mine? Why is either of ours greater than that of a chronically ill elderly person? The difference between me and (some) unvaccinated people is that I don't claim that I'm Refusing to Comply with the Evil Government out of an ideological belief in Absolute Freedom.

godmum56 · 18/11/2021 12:11

I have had a vaccine "passport" for years and also needed to be vaccinated about certain things to work in the NHS

travelhealthpro.org.uk/news/521/updated-guide-on-the-international-certificate-of-vaccination-or-prophylaxis-icvp

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 11:57

You still haven’t defined who these ‘globalist handlers’ are yet.

China? Pfizer? Is it my job to define? Why is economy "global", technology "global", but corruption and shady dealings can be... only local?

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 11:55

@JollyJoon

Or at least, if they do, they should accept that they are impinging on other people's freedom

But they arent impinging on another persons freedom. If you are vaccinated you are well protected. Stepping out of the house comes with risks. You could catch all sorts of things. You could catch the flu. If you have been double vaccinated and are therefore fairly well protected, and you decide to go to a bar, that's your problem. Your risk assessment, your risk and your responsibility. You could argue that your paranoia is impinging on another's freedom. The question is: why is your right to impinge on others freedoms greater than an unvaccinated person's? Why and who has decided that and what gives them the right to make that call?
[Note: I'm using "you" generally, not specifically aimed at you!]

Yes this is articulating how I feel on that too
JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 11:51

Or at least, if they do, they should accept that they are impinging on other people's freedom

But they arent impinging on another persons freedom. If you are vaccinated you are well protected. Stepping out of the house comes with risks. You could catch all sorts of things. You could catch the flu. If you have been double vaccinated and are therefore fairly well protected, and you decide to go to a bar, that's your problem. Your risk assessment, your risk and your responsibility. You could argue that your paranoia is impinging on another's freedom. The question is: why is your right to impinge on others freedoms greater than an unvaccinated person's? Why and who has decided that and what gives them the right to make that call?
[Note: I'm using "you" generally, not specifically aimed at you!]

DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 11:50

@CatsArePeople

And you may be denying everyone the right, if you cause us to go back into lockdown!

It will happen. And it will be not just the unvaxxed, but unboosted to blame. Your initial compliance will mean nothing.

You still haven’t defined who these ‘globalist handlers’ are yet.
ddl1 · 18/11/2021 11:46

it was the phrasing of someone trumping another so they must agree to vaccination. Not for their own risk but someone else’s put me off for some reason.

'Trumping' is not actually an expression that I usually use - I was responding to another poster's argument that the rights of people to be safe from Covid don't trump other people's freedom.

I don't think that anyone MUST agree to vaccination. Rather that people who don't agree to vaccination (or proof of a negative test) should not attend extremely crowded events, or travel in circumstances where they may be in close contact with others for a long period. Or at least, if they do, they should accept that they are impinging on other people's freedom.

SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 11:41

I'm double vaxxed. Not going to get boosted though.

I'm done for now.

Am I a drunk - or a semi drunk driver?

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 11:41

No I don’t think it will happen.

I’d prefer if all the SM noise was that we don’t want it to also.

We won’t comply etc

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 11:39

And you may be denying everyone the right, if you cause us to go back into lockdown!

It will happen. And it will be not just the unvaxxed, but unboosted to blame. Your initial compliance will mean nothing.

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 11:33

Well sure not me as I’m vaccinated and will get booster

I do understand the frustration around vaccine decisions esp when I think of healthcare workers who are under strain, or restrictions which I fear, but it was the phrasing of someone trumping another so they must agree to vaccination. Not for their own risk but someone else’s put me off for some reason.

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 11:27

And you may be denying everyone the right, if you cause us to go back into lockdown! ('You' here means vaccine refusers, not you personally as an individual.)

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 11:27

Testing and masks I’d say are a bit different for me.

I’ve worn masks where required and I’m vaccinated so no test but can see it could be asked for

I was on the fence re Covid pass but I think that post / justification just put me off. Not having a go just something about the idea that one group trumps the other in that way

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 11:24

Yes the right to attend events should trump it by remaining an individual decision

I assume you mean the right to attend events without vaccination (and without masks or testing?) So long as you accept that you are thereby denying the vulnerable people the right to attend the same events!

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 11:21

You divide society into the "clean" and the "unclean". You blame the "unclean" for whatever has gone wrong and whip up fear over the danger they pose. You restrict their freedom or outright persecute them. And sometimes you say - well if they just convert from their belief system they wouldn't be subject to this treatment so it's their choice.

Let's change this just slightly:
"You divide society into the "sober drivers and the "drunk drivers". You blame the "drunk drivers" for whatever has gone wrong and whip up fear over the danger they pose. You restrict their freedom to drive or outright persecute them by arresting them And sometimes you say - well if they just stop driving when drunk they wouldn't be subject to this treatment so it's their choice"

Still sounds reasonable?

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 11:19

@ddl1

The treatment of disabled and elderly has been appaling in this country for quite a while now. Why do you think it won't get worse.

Indeed. And that's one of the main reasons I don't vote Tory!!!!

But I think that the attitude 'My freedom to travel and attend events without being vaccinated (and other precautions) should trump elderly and disabled people's freedom, at best to travel and attend events because of an unacceptable risk of exposure, at worst to live at all or to avoid worse disability and chronic illness!' is a very strong endorsement of, and increase in, our society's existing ageism and ableism.

I’m pro vaccination and think it’s the way out of this but this makes me uncomfortable

Yes the right to attend events should trump it by remaining an individual decision

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 11:17

The treatment of disabled and elderly has been appaling in this country for quite a while now. Why do you think it won't get worse.

Indeed. And that's one of the main reasons I don't vote Tory!!!!

But I think that the attitude 'My freedom to travel and attend events without being vaccinated (and other precautions) should trump elderly and disabled people's freedom, at best to travel and attend events because of an unacceptable risk of exposure, at worst to live at all or to avoid worse disability and chronic illness!' is a very strong endorsement of, and increase in, our society's existing ageism and ableism.

SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 11:13

Let's talk about witch hunts instead of Nazis:

*I find it incredibly depressing to see history repeating itself like this. It feels like no moral progress has been made since witches were burnt at the stake.

You divide society into the "clean" and the "unclean". You blame the "unclean" for whatever has gone wrong and whip up fear over the danger they pose. You restrict their freedom or outright persecute them. And sometimes you say - well if they just convert from their belief system they wouldn't be subject to this treatment so it's their choice.

The rationale seems stronger to people this time because it's "science" based and not religion based but I think it's exactly the same mentality behind it. People get scared and acquiesce in their government scapegoating a particular group and because they are not personally affected by the measures that group is subjected to and they do not agree with their beliefs they can shrug and go on with their lives.*

Is this a better comparison?

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 11:10

Do I think that prioritizing the freedom of the non-vulnerable to do as they please over protecting the vulnerable will lead us down the same path as Nazi Germany? No!

The treatment of disabled and elderly has been appaling in this country for quite a while now. Why do you think it won't get worse.

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 11:08

There is no "greater good" in totalitarianism, it only leads to mass atrocities.

Health and safety rules to protect the potentially vulnerable are not totalitarianism, FFS! Do you also think it's totalitarian to ban speeding and drunk driving?

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 11:05

My gut feeling tells me that the vaccine passport/segregation is dangerous because it could be the beginnings of something much more serious.

More than the segregation between people who do and don't have driving licenses? Or actual passports? Or citizenship from birth versus acquired citizenship versus long-term residency versus being a 'migrant'? Or who have money to afford travel and attendance at events and other luxuries and indeed necessities, versus those who don't? - perhaps the biggest segregation at the moment. Why is it worse for people to be unable to access certain things if they don't get vaccinated, than to be unable to access these things if they don't have the money? It is practically very difficult for people with large families to do a wide variety of things that are easier for people who fit the current convention of small families- why is it better to 'segregate' large families than to 'segregate' those who will not get the vaccination?

If we ARE going to bring up the Nazis, let us note that a lot of their atrocities began with rating the fit and healthy above those with health problems and disabilities that might need accommodation ('useless eaters'). Do I think that prioritizing the freedom of the non-vulnerable to do as they please over protecting the vulnerable will lead us down the same path as Nazi Germany? No! But it's just as (un)reasonable to suggest this, as to suggest that having rules about vaccines will lead us down the same path as Nazi Germany.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 10:58

Aw, thanks @PAFMO! It is sometimes so discouraging and hard to stick to the boundaries I’ve set myself of ‘just the facts, ma’am’.

(And obviously I give myself exemptions, like on this thread. The idea that by asking people not to make inaccurate, offensive and potentially damaging comparisons to the Holocaust you are somehow silencing debate is so strange.)

PAFMO · 18/11/2021 10:53

@JassyRadlett
I do heave a sigh of relief when I see your name (here and in other more spaggy places Wink)
Power to your elbow. Brew

DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 10:49

left vs. right is an outdated discourse. Conservatism or liberalism also drifted too far from original meaning.
Only ideals that "speak" universally are power and money. Do you think tories are going to stand up to their corporate/globalist handlers?

Who are these ‘globalist handlers?’ (I wonder) How are they relevant to your communism theory?

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 10:49

We haven’t introduced covid passports yet, in England at least

Whereas many other countries have

So we are slightly removed from what others are doing