Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 13:51

But it’s so simple and effective to get the vaccine. It’s a simple measure. It’s safe. You can’t really compare it to a drug addict taking an overdose fgs!

it's nothing simple when death is listed as side effect. So what if other people inject heroin for the fun of it? I don't.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 13:45

@Cheerychirpy

But it’s so simple and effective to get the vaccine. It’s a simple measure. It’s safe. You can’t really compare it to a drug addict taking an overdose fgs!
It really isn't so simple for some people.
Cheerychirpy · 18/11/2021 13:44

But it’s so simple and effective to get the vaccine. It’s a simple measure. It’s safe. You can’t really compare it to a drug addict taking an overdose fgs!

JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 13:28

Maybe we could create an app you have to scan whenever you order a drink. When a person orders their fourth drink in a 24h period they will be locked out of ordering anymore in any bar across the country. That way we can keep A&E freed up from having to handle drink related cases, we can eradicate drink driving and make sure people stay healthy and safe.

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 13:27

What has killed more people, the vaccine itself, or the strain the unvaccinated are putting on the NHS?

So now its a competition? Or a Russian roulette? what will kill you first?

Sorry, that isn't very reasurring.

ilovesooty · 18/11/2021 13:26

@nojudgementhere

*PAFMO

The irony of someone likening showing a QR code so that they don't risk, y'know, infecting somebody else with something that might kill them to the Holocaust and then having the balls to say it's others doing the name-calling....

I agree. Utterly bizarre.*

You have both spectacularly missed the point here - as I would imagine you realise. People are not complaining about showing a QR code. They are complaining about a whole section of society being shut out of normal life, ridiculed and mistreated for refusing to take a vaccine that they don't feel ready to, and for insisting that they have autonomy over their own bodies. You can downplay it all you like but I would find it hard to think of myself as a decent person if I supported this.

Perhaps you should change your username.

I've no time for people who compare vaccine passport restrictions to the Holocaust.

Lostinacloud · 18/11/2021 13:21

But the British health system doesn’t work like that and rightly so!
Health care workers and hospitals never discriminated between patients before based upon the reason they’d ended up in hospital or taking up an icu bed. It’s the fact this appears to have become ok for people to accept if the patient has covid that’s so scary and is what many of us are trying to illustrate.
A drug taker can choose not to take the drug, why should they have an icu bed? Get it yet?

Cheerychirpy · 18/11/2021 13:16

What has killed more people, the vaccine itself, or the strain the unvaccinated are putting on the NHS?

Thecurliestwurly · 18/11/2021 13:01

@SamosaSammy

Yes it's a slippery slope more focused on control imo.

If vaccine passports are the new norm it's only a matter of time before the vaccine passport becomes a more generalised freedom passport which could have all kinds of other data or conditions linked to it.

I think this is my fear. It becomes the norm to have access to certain things based on passports/credits that has nothing to do with COVID. It's looking more likely now.
CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 12:58

you cannot force people to undergo something that could kill them, and covid vaccines HAVE killed people.

This^

Lostinacloud · 18/11/2021 12:57

Maybe some people won’t think or care about the discrimination problem that vaccine passports bring about until it affects them?

Think about this as an example of what’s going on in France already; just so a teen can go on a school trip to a museum, if not vaccinated, a 25 euro covid test is required. Due to ongoing research and an evolving situation regarding the safety of double vaccinating teens with mRNA vaccines, some parents understandably want to wait before making any final decision.
However, as a result of that wish to have a choice, the whole family can’t easily go out to eat out or go on a day out and the teen can’t go to any sports clubs or scouts groups or meet ups with friends at a cinema without having to be taken for an incredibly uncomfortable nasal test, adding an additional cost of 25 euros. If France follow the example of other European countries, soon there could be the “2g” system where only vaccination or covid recovery counts, no negative test accepted. Doesn’t matter if both parents are vaccinated or that the teen is perfectly healthy or had covid before and suffered no ill effects. They are effectively discriminated against and as a side effect so are their whole family just because of a medical choice. A medical choice that doesn’t stop a vaccinated person’s vaccine from working and a medical choice that may be perfectly reasonable to have made based on risk to benefit.

sirfredfredgeorge · 18/11/2021 12:56

But you should include or negative test for any event

I think this is misunderstanding the reason for unvaccinated to be kept out of events - it's not that they might bring in the virus, it's that they are more likely to become infected from the vaccinated who have not had to test.

If it's genuinely about preventing spread (and not coercion) then it would be a test for everyone upon entry as the way to ensure the event doesn't increase the spread.

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 12:54

For example you have a nightclub full of twenty year olds. At this point most have had Covid maybe they should just be allowed to go

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 12:53

@ddl1

I therefore don't accept your argument that it is the unvaccinated selfishly keeping them at home. It is a horrible and cruel side-effect of the virus itself. To stay safe I mitigate my risks as much as possible by avoiding crowds, staying outside as much as I can and keeping a safe-distance from others. I would imagine other vulnerable people are probably doing the same?

OK, fair enough. I am really arguing with people who have some sort of ideological objection to vaccination conditions under any circumstances. Most vulnerable people won't be attending crowded events. But they may have no alternative to seeking medical care; and there are some people who object to expecting healthcare workers to be vaccinated, and that's my biggest concern.

The main reason for vaccine passports is to reduce the chances of 'superspreader events' causing massive spikes in transmission. I think that in itself is sufficient reason, but can see that some people may not.

But you should include or negative test for any event

Plus how many superspreader events does the average person go to? And what age range are they typically?

You can still go to work or school in Austria so that is where spread will occur

A medical setting is slightly different and I’m still not sure it should be compulsory

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 12:52

Which is why I can accept them for large indoor events where you have several thousand people in a confined space. But not for a casual meal or coffee or swim or visit to a museum.

Well, it is the large indoor events for which they may be required! Unless we get back in lockdown, (because of superspreader events!), they won't be required just to get a coffee.

ColinTheKoala · 18/11/2021 12:51

@ddl1

why is your right to impinge on others freedoms greater than an unvaccinated person's?

Why is my right to be safe from drunk or speeding drivers greater than theirs to drive at speed or when drunk? We restrict the rights of people to endanger others in many situations. How is vaccination different from all of the other situations?

You cannot compare driving while drunk with going out while unvaccinated. There is no downside to driving while sober.

Vaccines are not 100% safe. Therefore it is not reasonable to impose them on people. You hope that the risk assessment comes down on the side of vaccines, especially in this case with long covid, but you cannot force people to undergo something that could kill them, and covid vaccines HAVE killed people.

ColinTheKoala · 18/11/2021 12:49

The main reason for vaccine passports is to reduce the chances of 'superspreader events' causing massive spikes in transmission. I think that in itself is sufficient reason, but can see that some people may not

Which is why I can accept them for large indoor events where you have several thousand people in a confined space. But not for a casual meal or coffee or swim or visit to a museum.

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 12:48

How about I'm not willing to risk my life in a medical experiment on a narrative of "protecting others"?

Because it's not a medical experiment, that's why!

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 12:47

why is your right to impinge on others freedoms greater than an unvaccinated person's?

Why is my right to be safe from drunk or speeding drivers greater than theirs to drive at speed or when drunk? We restrict the rights of people to endanger others in many situations. How is vaccination different from all of the other situations?

ddl1 · 18/11/2021 12:46

I therefore don't accept your argument that it is the unvaccinated selfishly keeping them at home. It is a horrible and cruel side-effect of the virus itself. To stay safe I mitigate my risks as much as possible by avoiding crowds, staying outside as much as I can and keeping a safe-distance from others. I would imagine other vulnerable people are probably doing the same?

OK, fair enough. I am really arguing with people who have some sort of ideological objection to vaccination conditions under any circumstances. Most vulnerable people won't be attending crowded events. But they may have no alternative to seeking medical care; and there are some people who object to expecting healthcare workers to be vaccinated, and that's my biggest concern.

The main reason for vaccine passports is to reduce the chances of 'superspreader events' causing massive spikes in transmission. I think that in itself is sufficient reason, but can see that some people may not.

Lostinacloud · 18/11/2021 12:42

@SencosRshit brilliant post. That is exactly the point I was trying to make but I was instantly labelled a racist antisemite, anti-vaxxer Confused so I didn’t get any further.

nojudgementhere · 18/11/2021 12:41

@ddl1

. If you are vaccinated you are well protected. Not completely; though if most people are vaccinated, then there is good protection. You could argue that your paranoia is impinging on another's freedom. What paranoia? The question is: why is your right to impinge on others freedoms greater than an unvaccinated person's? Why is theirs greater than mine? Why is either of ours greater than that of a chronically ill elderly person? The difference between me and (some) unvaccinated people is that I don't claim that I'm Refusing to Comply with the Evil Government out of an ideological belief in Absolute Freedom.
I find it extremely hard to believe that chronically ill elderly people would willingly be cramming themselves into crowded venues even if all the other people there were double/triple vaccinated. I therefore don't accept your argument that it is the unvaccinated selfishly keeping them at home. It is a horrible and cruel side-effect of the virus itself. To stay safe I mitigate my risks as much as possible by avoiding crowds, staying outside as much as I can and keeping a safe-distance from others. I would imagine other vulnerable people are probably doing the same?
JollyJoon · 18/11/2021 12:32

Why is theirs greater than mine
Sorry, you cant just deflect by throwing the question back at me. It's not up to me to justify the status quo. It's up to you to justify the change you want to see. Until now, the status quo has been that all people have equal access to society. You want to change that, so you explain why.

It's as if I decided that we should ban obese passengers from flying. It wouldn't be up to you to explain why they deserve to fly. It would be up to me to detail why I think they shouldn't.

So again:
"why is your right to impinge on others freedoms greater than an unvaccinated person's? Why and who has decided that and what gives them the right to make that call?"

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 12:31

I'm Refusing to Comply with the Evil Government out of an ideological belief in Absolute Freedom

How about I'm not willing to risk my life in a medical experiment on a narrative of "protecting others"?
Its not essential for me to have a holiday or go to a gig, but where does it end? Lose a job, be refused benefits, have bank account suspended?

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 12:30

@CatsArePeople

You still haven’t defined who these ‘globalist handlers’ are yet.

China? Pfizer? Is it my job to define? Why is economy "global", technology "global", but corruption and shady dealings can be... only local?

If I’d brought up the global economy or global technology in an argument I was making, then yes, I would expect that it was my job to define what I meant if asked.