Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 16:59

No one is suggesting unvaccinated people will be banned from school or healthcare, but if they choose not to be vaccinated for ideological reasons they will have to accept that they can't access parts of society

That’s not the case in England though, so not everyone has to accept this.

It may not happen. It seems we are less keen than other countries so it hasn’t been implemented yet

visitingagain · 18/11/2021 16:56

What an unbelievable thread this is.
For a long, long time children in many countries including the US have been unable to access school if they are unvaccinated.
(That's why there is such a growth in homeschooling and also why homeschoolers as a group particularly in the US have really high rates of measles, a horrible and completely avoidable disease which can cause blindness and occasionally death in children. )
That is not what's being proposed here at all.
No one is suggesting unvaccinated people will be banned from school or healthcare, but if they choose not to be vaccinated for ideological reasons they will have to accept that they can't access parts of society that might be risky for people with long term conditions or actual needle phobia who don't have the luxury of that choice.
You still have the freedom to choose not to be vaccinated. Stop complaining.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 16:48

@SencosRshit

Cats - keep speaking up. We have to. I’m not in anyone’s camp. No one should pigeon hole anyone. Each one of us is different with our different set of circumstances.

And nobody should be silenced.

This attempt to claim people are being silenced because it’s pointed out that it’s offensive to draw a comparison to the Holocaust is not very convincing.

No one is silencing you. No one is asking you not to argue your case, about which you clearly feel passionately.

They’re just saying please stop using the Holocaust for your agenda.

Make your case on its merits. Argue it well. People will engage.

It’s almost as if you know bringing the Holocaust into it is going to cause people to become upset and ask you to stop, and then you can claim you’re being oppressed and silenced.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 16:44

defending creeping totalitarianism is grossly offensive. Vaccine IDs are on the table and not sure how long England can hold out.

I am not arguing that. Either for or against.

I am arguing very strongly that the attempts to draw a comparison between this measure and the destruction of European Jews grounded in centuries of persecution and discrimination is ignorant and offensive. Many, many Jews have asked people to stop appropriating this tragedy to further their own agenda.

Why don’t you let you arguments stand on their own merits? If you think it’s grossly offensive, make that case.

SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 16:42

Cats - keep speaking up. We have to. I’m not in anyone’s camp. No one should pigeon hole anyone. Each one of us is different with our different set of circumstances.

And nobody should be silenced.

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 16:38

is also offensive to be flippant about people's medical concerns re vaccinations.

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 16:27

grossly offensive comparison

defending creeping totalitarianism is grossly offensive. Vaccine IDs are on the table and not sure how long England can hold out.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 16:16

Two weeks to flatten the curve... but here we are.

Time limits have been enshrined in law on Covid public health measures in England. Parliament has voted to extend them and the powers of government to act within those frameworks.

Even without the time limits, it is an ahistorical and grossly offensive comparison.

CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 16:06

proven government scientific advice

plenty of scientists disagree on the safety side. and government... always only wants whats best for us, right?

ilovesooty · 18/11/2021 16:05

@Lisa2008

I find it so upsetting that there are actually people out there that think passports are a good idea. Our ancestors would be turning in their grave ! Have people actually forgot what hitler done? How all those people lost their freedom to work eat sleep or simply walk where they wanted ! It’s sick to the core and the masses of people that comply and play along with this tyranny are as equal to blame as the government ( who btw couldn’t give a dogs dump about your health )
More hyperbole.
CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 16:01

time-limited public health measures.

Two weeks to flatten the curve... but here we are.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 15:56

I was always of the impression that Germany were the gold standard. Must have dreamt it!

I think they had a good early pandemic (and let’s face it, the UK had a very poor one.)

I think on the ‘trace’ side we’re still quite wobbly. But we do a fuckload of tests and arguably have a much better picture of the state of infections here.

ConcernedAuntie · 18/11/2021 15:49

@JassyRadlett

Have I misunderstood? Are we really better at testing?

We are much, much better at testing and have been for a long while now.

For a while, we’ve done between 10 and 15 tests per thousand per day. The last time we dropped below 10 was in the early spring.

France is currently between 3 and 5. There was a period in August when they broke through 19 but it was short lived, it’s stayed below 5 for the last month.

France is a lot better than eg Germany, which hasn’t gone above 2 since early May.

Many thanks for this Jassy and also the link. Very interesting. Perhaps the UK does have a 'gold' standard for testing after all.

I was always of the impression that Germany were the gold standard. Must have dreamt it!

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2021 15:48

Please do not underestimate how severe a needle phobia can be. It is not just "being scared".

I think key to understanding is to think of other phobias. More people have claustrophobia or arachnophobia for example. I do so I can apply how I’d feel if it was a necessary event.

If someone has none of these then maybe talk to someone who has to get insight.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 15:42

And again I wonder (not entirely genuinely) why people feel it’s ok to repeatedly reach for the Holocaust here, rather than other instances of racial segregation.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2021 15:41

Have people actually forgot what hitler done? How all those people lost their freedom to work eat sleep or simply walk where they wanted !

Please stop these offensive comparisons between the planned, systematic persecution of Jews, other races and other disadvantaged groups by the Nazi regime with time-limited public health measures.

Regardless of the rights or wrongs of the latter - go ahead and have that debate, but don’t forget to include all the western democracies who currently restrict access to childcare, education and some employment based on vaccination status - it is in no way comparable to the former. Doing so diminishes the enormity of that persecution, ignores the basis of it, is ignorant of the surrounding context and history behind it, and actively benefits modern anti-semites. As has been explained repeatedly on this thread and others.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 15:40

@Cheerychirpy

I don’t have to think of other reasons.

NHS website states that there are very few cases of people who have had very severe allergic reactions to vaccines in the past that Covid vaccines may not be suitable for. So what’s the excuse the rest of the anti vaccine population are giving?

There are very few valid ones. Being scared of needles, feeling faint after getting a tetanus injection once back in 1983, having an IQ too low to be able to tell the difference between anti vaccines conspiracy nut cases and proven government scientific advice are all not (thankfully) valid reasons.

Please do not underestimate how severe a needle phobia can be. It is not just "being scared".
DismantledKing · 18/11/2021 15:07

Have people actually forgot what hitler done?

There’s no hope for some people

Cheerychirpy · 18/11/2021 15:04

I don’t have to think of other reasons.

NHS website states that there are very few cases of people who have had very severe allergic reactions to vaccines in the past that Covid vaccines may not be suitable for. So what’s the excuse the rest of the anti vaccine population are giving?

There are very few valid ones. Being scared of needles, feeling faint after getting a tetanus injection once back in 1983, having an IQ too low to be able to tell the difference between anti vaccines conspiracy nut cases and proven government scientific advice are all not (thankfully) valid reasons.

SunscreenCentral · 18/11/2021 15:02

Here in the Republic of Ireland, 7% of the population (the unvaccinated) are taking up 56% of ICU beds with Covid.
A tiny proportion of that 7% are people who weren't medically viable for vaccination but it's becoming increasingly difficult to have sympathy with those who couldn't be arsed.

Lisa2008 · 18/11/2021 14:57

I find it so upsetting that there are actually people out there that think passports are a good idea. Our ancestors would be turning in their grave ! Have people actually forgot what hitler done? How all those people lost their freedom to work eat sleep or simply walk where they wanted ! It’s sick to the core and the masses of people that comply and play along with this tyranny are as equal to blame as the government ( who btw couldn’t give a dogs dump about your health )

SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 14:39

If it’s not safe for people with certain medical conditions then they ought to get a vaccine passport waiver issued by the hospital consultant they see.

This bit you did come up with yourself. Well done. It isn't easy to get a vaccine passport waiver though. A poster on a different thread (they may be here now) said they had a waiver from their consultant but their government (I think it was Scotland) won't accept it as exemption from the passports.

For others they may have allergic reactions/bad reactions to medicine that make them susceptible and therefore want to avoid these vaccines - but that won't provide them a waiver either.

There are plenty of others in society who will want to avoid these vaccines for all number of reasons - it may not be so simple for them either. Try and think of some other reasons.

SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 14:34

You need to work it out for yourself Cheery.

Cheerychirpy · 18/11/2021 14:12

I don’t know. Tell me who it might not be safe for? If it’s not safe for people with certain medical conditions then they ought to get a vaccine passport waiver issued by the hospital consultant they see. That must be a very very small number of people.

SencosRshit · 18/11/2021 14:02

@Cheerychirpy

But it’s so simple and effective to get the vaccine. It’s a simple measure. It’s safe. You can’t really compare it to a drug addict taking an overdose fgs!
This is very blinkered thinking.

It's not safe for everyone. I won't spell it out for you. Think. Independently. Who might it not be safe for?

It's also not simple just to get the vaccine for everyone. Again. Think . Independently. Who might it not be so easy for?

Is it effective? Is it a simple measure? What does simple measure even mean?