Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
Cheerychirpy · 17/11/2021 09:38

I really could not give a shit about the so called ‘rights’ of the unvaccinated. The NHS is on its knees, partly due to us running very few intensive care beds so if just a few beds are taken up by Covid patients things start to fail.

Get the vaccine and you are much much less likely to end up in intensive care, protecting all of society. If locking down all unvaccinated is what it takes for them to see how selfish (and thick!) they are being, so be it.

dudsville · 17/11/2021 09:31

When I was young and travelled there were some countries that required me to get a vaccine in order to visit. I didn't bat an eye.

sirfredfredgeorge · 17/11/2021 09:21

Gib has given 90K vaccines to a 60k population. Given you need two vaccines to be fully vaccinated means half the population are not yet fully vaccinated

Are you including the apes? The population is at least 25,000 less than you say - www.gibraltar.gov.gi/statistics/faqs

Scoobapro · 17/11/2021 09:15

@PAFMO where is the lie?

Our restrictions have been lifted due to the vaccine introduction, so why is it wrong to assume that that was the ‘road to freedom’?

So there isn’t talk of boosters? There’s no talk of vaccine passports?

Struggling to see what I am supposedly fabricating here.

JustLyra · 17/11/2021 09:09

Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof.

What a way to (deliberately?) post a misleading statistic.

Gib has given 90K vaccines to a 60k population. Given you need two vaccines to be fully vaccinated means half the population are not yet fully vaccinated.

Ohsofedupwiththis · 17/11/2021 09:08

@PAFMO

We were told once the vaccine came out that would be it, now we need boosters, now we need vaccine passports.

That's 3 lies in one sentence. Pretty good going.

The unvaccinated aren't being locked down anywhere, as the posters in Austria have confirmed. Unless you consider going out to work, shop and church to be "locked down".

Were we told this though?

I can remember Whitty / Vallance saying that the 1st vaccines wouldn't be the last vaccines. That suggests to me that they expected there to be further variants and requirement for updated vaccines.

I think one advantage the UK has over many others - our CMO / CSO recognise that this will become endemic and that we need to learn to live with it. Other countries are now getting to that point.

The best way to get there is with vaccines, which means the infections you get will hopefully not make you very ill.

There really is such a basic lack of understanding by so many on both sides of the arguments. We are trying to get to the point where we can live with Covid. Will that mean vaccines for vulnerable every year along side Flu - most likely. It will probably become a less serious disease for those who refuse vaccination too in the long term.

But we need to get there 1st - and vaccines make that possible.

SomePosters · 17/11/2021 09:05

@Worldgonecrazy

Having the vaccine reduces the chance of hospitalisation and serious illness.

So does not being fat.

One makes money for pharmaceutical and health industries.

One doesn’t. One also has long term additional benefits for the NHS.

Amazing that only one method is being promoted.

If, instead of vaccine passports, we had BMI passports there would be an outcry. And before someone points out BMI measurements aren’t perfect measurements of fitness, I would point out that vaccination status is not a perfect measure of either immunity or contagious status.

Imagine telling on yourself like that!
AlleZusammen · 17/11/2021 09:03

I thought this graph from a French paper is helpful about admissions to critical care for vaccinated vs unvaccinated

to be alarmed by vaccine passports
Worldgonecrazy · 17/11/2021 09:00

@Platax

The fat people argument is a "Look over there" one. Just because you can point to one risk factor doesn't mean that we should ignore an easy remedy for a much wider risk factor

It seems to me that all arguments against the vaccine fall away when you look at the decrease in death rates in countries which have it.

I would argue that fatness is a wider risk factor than whether someone is vaccinated or not,

A fit and healthy person is extremely unlikely to suffer anything other than a bad cold, if they have any symptoms at all. Fat people are much more at risk of serious illness with or without vaccination.

If it is hospitalisation that matters, rather than cases, then fatness is a major contributory factor to those hospitalisations.

But vaccine passports are not about controlling a virus. That is obvious from how and where they are being implemented.

The unvaccinated are an example of ‘othering’,someone to point a finger of blame at.

The U.K. is a nation of shockingly poor health. We could fix that but choose not to. Why is that?

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 09:00

That makes no sense. You can't catch fat from someone else

www.nytimes.com/2007/07/25/health/25cnd-fat.html

Well, socially contagious anyway 😂

PAFMO · 17/11/2021 09:00

We were told once the vaccine came out that would be it, now we need boosters, now we need vaccine passports.

That's 3 lies in one sentence. Pretty good going.

The unvaccinated aren't being locked down anywhere, as the posters in Austria have confirmed. Unless you consider going out to work, shop and church to be "locked down".

PAFMO · 17/11/2021 08:57

@HeyDugeesCakeBadge

Honestly, why on earth can't people see the bigger picture with vaccine passports? As a previous poster says, once we give up freedoms and allow ourselves to be restricted due to a certain status we are never getting them back - where does that end? I'm actually gobsmacked that so many people are for them, but this is the 'I'm alright jack' attitude that all those that have had the vaccine accuse those who have chosen not to be. You can choose to live in a country where the state restricts freedom due to refusing an invasive medical procedure but I sure don't want that and will fight against it.
If, in the countries with them, you have a pass, then what freedoms are you giving up? I'd argue also that "I'm alright Jack" is pertinent to people who have been saying they won't have the vaccine because they "aren't at risk" or who criticise people for wanting to vaccinate their teenagers. So, all in all, fairly ironic.
Platax · 17/11/2021 08:49

The fat people argument is a "Look over there" one. Just because you can point to one risk factor doesn't mean that we should ignore an easy remedy for a much wider risk factor

It seems to me that all arguments against the vaccine fall away when you look at the decrease in death rates in countries which have it.

Scoobapro · 17/11/2021 08:49

The issue is we are now living in a society where the frog in the boiling water analogy is in full effect.
We have said yes and conformed to things in so many stages that a lot of people are oblivious to how crazy this idea actually is.
When will enough be enough? We were told once the vaccine came out that would be it, now we need boosters, now we need vaccine passports.

We don’t have measles vaccination passports, HIV negative passports, STI free passports. The virus will spread and continue to spread despite the vaccine being taken up. I understand that it’s ‘less deadly’ once your vaccinated but surely that just needs to be enough now.

The idea of the unvaccinated having to lockdown in other countries is terrifying to me.

I have chosen not to be vaccinated. I have also chosen not to be obese and to take care of my mental and physical health as best as I can personally control.

There are so many issues that put a strain on our NHS that are simply not addressed or challenged due to fear of triggering or offending people, but many people don’t give a shit about trampling over peoples personal and free will when it comes to the vaccine. Whether people like it or not, obesity is a massive contribution. I am not fat shaming here, but these are simply facts. If I am selfish or not being responsible for choosing not to take a vaccine for this virus, I will challenge why people are able to live such sedentary and unhealthy lifestyles that increase their risk of serious illness tenfold and rely on science and free healthcare to pick up the pieces.

Everyone has a choice and vaccination is no different.

Yes, you can’t catch fat from someone, but our whole society suffers at the hands of obese people who need treatment for the health implications it has. The reason for all these precautions and restrictions is so that our healthcare system doesn’t crumble. There are many other avenues to address before imprisoning those who choose to exercise their right to free will.

Thatsthewaytis · 17/11/2021 08:47

@Worldgonecrazy I’d love to engage with how a fat person isn’t the same as extremely contagious virus that caused the entire world to shut down but I’ve a new rule that I don’t engage once anti vax bingo has been completed. I know now that these people are so far down the conspiracy theory rabbit hole it wools be an absolute waste of my time. It is amusing to read though!

Worldgonecrazy · 17/11/2021 08:41

If the fat people argument is a straw man, please feel free to ice apart.

Fatness makes you more at risk of covid, makes you more likely to use nhs resource both short and long term, and more likely to spread covid if you have it. It’s hardly a straw man argument.

I’m glad you find the ill health of the nation so funny.

I don’t think it’s a laughing matter.

ColinTheKoala · 17/11/2021 08:41

nice straw man argument about fat people

Is it? I don't know, but I'd hazard a guess that obesity-related diseases cost the NHS more to treat than covid (excluding the costs of testing and vaccines - and test and trace).

ColinTheKoala · 17/11/2021 08:39

I am also fully vaccinated and now qualify for a booster so will book it when they open bookings for 40 somethings next week.

But I fundamentally disagree with vaccine passports except maybe for very large indoor events but not for things like cafes and swimming pools. It is wrong to coerce people into having the vaccine.

Other countries have had vaccine passports for months and their infection rates are still increasing massively so they clearly don't help that much. That said, I am in favour of wearing masks in shops and on public transport and the fact that they are still mandated in Scotland and Wales doesn't seem to mean their infection rates are lower than in England, so who knows what the answer is.

Thatsthewaytis · 17/11/2021 08:27

Thanks guys, I enjoyed a good chuckle this morning and some anti vax bingo

  • mainstream media
  • hitler
  • comparing vaccine passports to the Holocaust
  • paranoia about our data (while openly giving away private data online without a care in the world)
  • vaccine passports don’t work
  • nice straw man argument about fat people
  • crazed exaggeration of use of vaccine passports.

It’s the gift that keeps on giving! Keep up the good work guys. Reminds me of that crazy government are out to get us post back in lockdown that ran to like 6 threads. If I remember correctly according to that thread we should all be in internment camps by now

HeyDugeesCakeBadge · 17/11/2021 08:26

Honestly, why on earth can't people see the bigger picture with vaccine passports? As a previous poster says, once we give up freedoms and allow ourselves to be restricted due to a certain status we are never getting them back - where does that end? I'm actually gobsmacked that so many people are for them, but this is the 'I'm alright jack' attitude that all those that have had the vaccine accuse those who have chosen not to be. You can choose to live in a country where the state restricts freedom due to refusing an invasive medical procedure but I sure don't want that and will fight against it.

OrangeIsTheNewRed · 17/11/2021 08:24

@Worldgonecrazy for the record, I'm a triple jabbed slim jim. Very healthy indeed.

I take all necessary steps to be as healthy as possible, including gratefully receiving all recommended vaccines. A member of my family has a compromised immune system due to a long term disease. They are at extra, avoidable risk because of coming into contact with people who are unvaccinated by choice.

Grayskelly · 17/11/2021 08:22

My fear is that a drunk driver will run me over, then, when I get to hospital all the emergency beds will be full of smokers having heart attacks. It might even be my child who needs the bed that the smokers are taking up.
I'm not sure why people think smoking is not worse than being unvaccinated.

PAFMO · 17/11/2021 08:19

@Jammydodge2
Not linking to your post because I've reported it, but why are you as a "fully vaccinated frontline nurse" against vaccine passes, ergo against vaccines?

knittingaddict · 17/11/2021 08:16

@Scarcity20

Fungusingtgeblues you can't catch covid from a healthy person either no matter what msm will have you believe! Common sense went out the window along with our freedoms. It's so nice to see so many people awake on this thread too.
Hmm, define heakthy person for me please? I'm not really sure what you mean.

Also, we need to wake up, do we? Now where have I heard that catch phrase before? Grin

Scarcity20 · 17/11/2021 08:08

Fungusingtgeblues you can't catch covid from a healthy person either no matter what msm will have you believe! Common sense went out the window along with our freedoms.
It's so nice to see so many people awake on this thread too.