Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 17/11/2021 11:25

[quote fungussingstheblues]@gamerchick you can't catch fat from someone, no, but if you're over 30 you're more likely to catch and transmit Covid if you are vaccinated - so what's the point of the passports? To encourage a greater uptake of the vaccine that will make you more likely to catch and transmit Covid if you're over 30?

www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-vaccine-weekly-surveillance-reports[/quote]
This is misinformation.

The data you quoted have very specific caveats that it cannot be used to determine vaccine effectiveness for a wide range of reasons.

The greatest of these is that the NIMS database vastly overinflates population numbers in the under 70s - an effect that gets greater for younger age groups - with the effect that the number of unvaccinated people appears much higher than is in fact the case in the NIMS database.

There are also other potential confounding factors, as the actual surveillance report points out.

As the statistics watchdog has already publicly reprimanded UKHSA for the way they present this data as it is so open to be misused like this, I’m surprised anyone is even trying to stand this up.

Echobelly · 17/11/2021 11:22

I'm not sure if they're that helpful, but I don't think they're a 'slippery slope' either as they are for a very specific thing and I don't think that accepting them means people will accept other 'curbs on their freedom', eg if the government were to say next year 'We're introducing ID for British Muslims', people as a whole wouldn't got 'Sure, we had COVID passports, that's just fine' - other than the kind of people who would think IDs for Muslim people are a great idea who, ironically, are more likely to be the ones who opposed COVID passports (NB OP sure you're not, not a call out, but for many people there will be a correlation)

Wombatstew · 17/11/2021 11:17

We have vaccine passports where I live. I scan a code at the door of a shop for track and trace. Most times especially in small shops (department stores have security guards checking) no one checks to see my vaccination certificate or that I have checked in at all. It relies on staff members to do so. I could have a screen shot of someone else’s cert if I wanted, they don’t check ID. If they’re not bothering now I can’t see it lasting long to be honest. I am double vaccinated, not against them and it bothers me not one bit checking in but I can’t really see how useful they are.
However, DH works with 55 others in a shift, 19 which were unvaccinated (she’ll be right attitude ) until employer said no work next week until first vaccine. All of 19 then got vaccinated.

logsonlogsoff · 17/11/2021 11:12

Just get vaccinated.

Chloemol · 17/11/2021 11:05

@Loustew12

Why are you straying yet another thread when there are millions already

Post on one of those

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 10:43

@MysteryFog60

I have had to produce a vaccination certificate (long before Covid) to enter another country. I don't find this unusual. If you go onto any social media page you can find out all you need to know about anyone. People put their whole lives on Facebook etc and no one is out protesting about that. If the government want to track me - fine. They will be bored within days. I have been to a country that has much, MUCH more control over it's citizens than here. Here is not the worst by a long chalk.
This hasn’t been the case for decades outside certain African countries.
Nietzschethehiker · 17/11/2021 10:39

The only time this argument carried any weight at all is if it comes from someone without an actual passport (given how many checks are enrolled with that ) , doesn't own a mobile phone, doesn't have a driving licence , didn't go to school in the myriad of countries that requires vaccinations in childhood to enrol, doesn't have an alexa etc, disables all cookies on their computer.

I am going to make a reasonably safe bet that at least one of those is the case. We have to confirm everything all the time, we have restrictions based on us all the time on who can do what. Its a silly vapid argument made by those who don't like the vaccine in order to find some basis in their response. The basis isn't there.

We share information all the damn time this is a stupid argument. We are restricted from movement all the sodding time fir a variety of reasons. Find a more justified argument , this one is ridiculous

User135644 · 17/11/2021 10:36

@UsedUpUsername

You said that they said "Once the vaccine came out that would be it" "They" never said that

It’s true they never said that. People just naively hoped it would end if they got the double shot.

Hopefully they will not make this mistake again when it comes to boosters.

It was never going to 'end', it's an endemic virus, but everything has been pretty much open since July. You'd have certainly taken that in Jan-March when most things were still shut and most people hadn't had a vaccine.

Without vaccines we wouldn't have had 4+ months of relative normality from July (and things were opening up before then).

MysteryFog60 · 17/11/2021 10:34

I have had to produce a vaccination certificate (long before Covid) to enter another country. I don't find this unusual. If you go onto any social media page you can find out all you need to know about anyone. People put their whole lives on Facebook etc and no one is out protesting about that. If the government want to track me - fine. They will be bored within days. I have been to a country that has much, MUCH more control over it's citizens than here. Here is not the worst by a long chalk.

Finknottlesnewt · 17/11/2021 10:32

As someone enduring day 6 of so-called mild Covid, caught when a friend came to stay the night. Arrived feeling unwell and only when questioned revealed she was unvaccinated. Tested positive that night. I tested positive 3 days later.

I am immunosuppressed . She knows this. 'But forgot'. Big discussion about why no vax... apparently it's against her human rights. Fuck that. !!! What about MY right to life ?

I can honestly say that I feel absolutely not one jot of guilt in wanting Vaccine passports.

I am terrified. It is a hugely debilitating disease, even in it mildest form. I am attached to an oxygen meter..it's 94. at 92 I have to be admitted.

I am so angry at people Who feel their 'right' is not to do all in their power to reduce the spread of this disease . As their 'right' affects MY LIFE !!

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 10:28

You said that they said
"Once the vaccine came out that would be it"
"They" never said that

It’s true they never said that. People just naively hoped it would end if they got the double shot.

Hopefully they will not make this mistake again when it comes to boosters.

User135644 · 17/11/2021 10:25

Don't really care but don't see the point.

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 10:24

@Europilgrim

We don’t have measles vaccination passports, HIV negative passports, STI free passports All of those are either not easily transmissible just by being in the same room or fairly rare because most people are vaccinated. Pretty poor example!

Where I live we have vaccine passports and most people are in favour because we have had enough of this now! I'm in favour.

Lol maybe nightclubs could use STI passports 😂🙃
JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 10:22

I am fully vaccinated and strongly disagree with this.

I don't believe the state should have any power over who I mingle with and where. I don't believe the state should have the power to exclude people from society based on their decision. And I dont have a problem with unvaccinated people. I dont see them as a greater threat to me and I don't worry about them putting themselves in danger

PAFMO · 17/11/2021 10:14

[quote Scoobapro]@PAFMO where is the lie?

Our restrictions have been lifted due to the vaccine introduction, so why is it wrong to assume that that was the ‘road to freedom’?

So there isn’t talk of boosters? There’s no talk of vaccine passports?

Struggling to see what I am supposedly fabricating here.[/quote]
You said that they said:
"Once the vaccine came out that would be it"
"They" never said that.
You said that they said:
"Now we need boosters" (ok, I'll give you this one as a misinterpretation, but how did people think they wouldn't? You need boosters for childhood immunization, you need tetanus boosters, etc)
You said that they said
"We need vaccine passports"
Who has said that? Who?

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 10:14

I honestly can’t fathom how people genuinely find it easier to believe that vaccines and vaccine passports are some globally orchestrated scheme to curtail people’s freedoms

I wouldn’t say orchestrated.

It’s like security theatre in airports. You know and I know that throwing away bottled water in airports and getting your shoes examined by security does nothing to stop terrorism. But we have to comply.

Once America did it, many other countries followed suit. No one asked for proof they did anything to stop terrorists. And here we are, dumping our water, emptying our pockets and taking out our laptops over twenty years later.

Now we are threatened with a health security state, again no proof any of their measures work.

You have to push back against dumb government.

DumplingsAndStew · 17/11/2021 10:10

*ruining

Although maybe there's something else in that.... 🤔

DumplingsAndStew · 17/11/2021 10:10

Fat people are running the planet.

True fact

Europilgrim · 17/11/2021 10:09

We don’t have measles vaccination passports, HIV negative passports, STI free passports
All of those are either not easily transmissible just by being in the same room or fairly rare because most people are vaccinated. Pretty poor example!

Where I live we have vaccine passports and most people are in favour because we have had enough of this now! I'm in favour.

Xmasprrssiehelp · 17/11/2021 10:02

I honestly can’t fathom how people genuinely find it easier to believe that vaccines and vaccine passports are some globally orchestrated scheme to curtail people’s freedoms. Or that governments are purposely injuring its citizens with a dodgy vaccine.

Over, we have a novel virus that has killed millions globally and countries are trying to protect their citizens and health care institutions.

Who is orchestrating this master plan? What are they going to gain? It’s utter bollocks - just get vaccinated like the billions of other people on the planet, so we can put an end to this madness. The same way we have with over highly infectious diseases.

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 10:00

I am totally fed up of having my freedoms curtailed because of the willfully stupid

It’s the government taking away your freedom, not an unvaccinated 20-year-old. Sooner you realise this, the sooner we can get back to normal.

In my home country, compliance has only led to further restriction. It’s sad to see

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 09:56

If locking down all unvaccinated is what it takes for them to see how selfish (and thick!) they are being, so be it

All it does is show how cruel and stupid those in power are.

DoctorWhoTardis · 17/11/2021 09:55

I agree with the obesity comments. They cost the country a lot more long term with Heath problems, PIP/dla payments, there's even people who get cleaners paid by the council because they are to obese to clean their own homes (true fact check it out.)
If people don't want the vaccine then fair play to them they have their reasons, them not having the vaccine doesn't put you at any more risk of being poorly.

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 09:54

@dudsville

When I was young and travelled there were some countries that required me to get a vaccine in order to visit. I didn't bat an eye.
Unless you travelled around Africa, this is pretty unlikely. Most places have dropped these requirements for tourists for several decades ago at this point.

There are RECOMMENDED vaccines, which is different. I got the rabies series and Japanese encephalitis due to recommendations, they weren’t an entry requirement. It’s a big difference.

amillionmenonmars · 17/11/2021 09:50

Excellent. Maybe now I will be able to visit restaurants, cinemas and pubs and feel (and be) a lot safer.

I am totally fed up of having my freedoms curtailed because of the willfully stupid.