Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 14:47

I don't feel restricted by this, in fact, i like it as it gives me a certain amount of comfort to think that all the people around me are also vaccinated

This is kind of the worst, sorry. They are human beings, not disease vectors.

sirfredfredgeorge · 17/11/2021 14:45

There's no limits on the number of people in the shop in England (some still have numbers from when there was a voluntary system, but that was just a shop decision)

In Estonia, all large shops require vaccine passports.
Small shops have the choice, limit customers inside to extremely small numbers (1 per 20sq m if I remember rightly) or require vaccine passports.

The result is that even though the law requiring vaccine passports is only limited to larger shops, small shops are pretty much forced into it as otherwise they have to so limit entry that they can no longer trade. So you do need a vaccine passport to shop for food.

UniBallEye · 17/11/2021 14:41

I don't understand all the worry and concern to be honest.
In France and Ireland we've had these restrictions since the vaccine was rolled out.
Restaurants etc will check and scan your vaccine as you enter, same with travelling. Your vaccine / PCR will be checked as you leave and enter countries.

I don't feel restricted by this, in fact, i like it as it gives me a certain amount of comfort to think that all the people around me are also vaccinated.

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 14:37

I think there's a weird thing at play where a sizeable section of the vaccinated population are secretly pleased at the idea of the unvaccinated being cut off, not for any real health reasons, just a bit of bog standard schadenfreude.

sourcherie · 17/11/2021 14:32

@Worldgonecrazy

Having the vaccine reduces the chance of hospitalisation and serious illness.

So does not being fat.

One makes money for pharmaceutical and health industries.

One doesn’t. One also has long term additional benefits for the NHS.

Amazing that only one method is being promoted.

If, instead of vaccine passports, we had BMI passports there would be an outcry. And before someone points out BMI measurements aren’t perfect measurements of fitness, I would point out that vaccination status is not a perfect measure of either immunity or contagious status.

Oh come on - you think the public would respond better to a ‘lose weight’ campaign? Quite apart from the fact that it would take considerably longer for people to lose weight than to just GO AND GET THE ARSING VACCINATION, the “nanny state” frothing would be off the scale, remember the fury directed at Jamie Oliver for trying to get the schools to offer more healthy food. Give me a break.
Europilgrim · 17/11/2021 14:32

You know the Vaccine Passport in Estonia at least restricts access to food shops too - some food shops can choose not to use it if they limit capacity such that there's a very low limit on occupancy.

Sorry, can you explain? Are you saying that there are limits on the number of people in a shop at one time? Isn't that the same as the UK?

sourcherie · 17/11/2021 14:24

@HarrietsChariot

I think Covid passports are a good thing. Sure, some people will have their freedoms restricted, but so what? Individual freedoms are restricted all the time in countless ways, that is a price we pay for living in a (so-called) civilized society.

I can't own a gun because my freedom to do so is restricted due to laws put in place because some people would use them irresponsibly. If I decide to join the army or set up a clay pigeon shooting club then perhaps I will be able to have a gun. It's the same with vaccine passports, people may have their freedoms restricted but have options if they want them to be restored.

You might say "blah blah bah you don't need to own a gun blah blah blah" but that applies to the vaccine passport system too: all it would do is restrict people from certain activities that are not strictly necessary, like going to the cinema or a restaurant. They'll still be allowed to go to the shop for food.

You might say "it's the thin end of the fucking wedge though, who knows what they will restrict next it'll be Nazi Germany all over again before we know it." Bollocks. By that logic banning drink-driving is the forerunner to banning drinking altogether. By lowering the age of consent to 16 they will soon lower it to 12, then 8. Just because there is a restriction put in place, doesn't automatically mean that restriction will be tightened in future. When the Le Mans 24 hour race banned female drivers on safety grounds in the 1950s, it didn't lead to female drivers being banned from driving on the road.

Completely agree - particularly with your last paragraph. I just can’t understand why people are being so obtuse. And to all those railing against the vaccine - if it were up to you, if you were in charge, what would you do when your hospitals had no beds for stroke / heart attack / road accident / meningitis etc etc patients? Seriously - what would you do? With corpses piling up in the hallways? As is happening now in Austria, despite 18 months of varying levels of restrictions. What is your suggestion?
sirfredfredgeorge · 17/11/2021 14:10

They'll still be allowed to go to the shop for food

You know the Vaccine Passport in Estonia at least restricts access to food shops too - some food shops can choose not to use it if they limit capacity such that there's a very low limit on occupancy.

So, how exactly can you assert that they won't be required for food?

HarrietsChariot · 17/11/2021 14:02

I think Covid passports are a good thing. Sure, some people will have their freedoms restricted, but so what? Individual freedoms are restricted all the time in countless ways, that is a price we pay for living in a (so-called) civilized society.

I can't own a gun because my freedom to do so is restricted due to laws put in place because some people would use them irresponsibly. If I decide to join the army or set up a clay pigeon shooting club then perhaps I will be able to have a gun. It's the same with vaccine passports, people may have their freedoms restricted but have options if they want them to be restored.

You might say "blah blah bah you don't need to own a gun blah blah blah" but that applies to the vaccine passport system too: all it would do is restrict people from certain activities that are not strictly necessary, like going to the cinema or a restaurant. They'll still be allowed to go to the shop for food.

You might say "it's the thin end of the fucking wedge though, who knows what they will restrict next it'll be Nazi Germany all over again before we know it." Bollocks. By that logic banning drink-driving is the forerunner to banning drinking altogether. By lowering the age of consent to 16 they will soon lower it to 12, then 8. Just because there is a restriction put in place, doesn't automatically mean that restriction will be tightened in future. When the Le Mans 24 hour race banned female drivers on safety grounds in the 1950s, it didn't lead to female drivers being banned from driving on the road.

UsedUpUsername · 17/11/2021 13:48

@alborana

I've just come back from holiday and while there I met an elderly man who walked with a stick. He told me he contracted polio when he was 5 years old and had walked with a stick ever since. He also told me he couldn't read, as he had missed years of schooling as a child due to illness.

Vaccines have changed our lives. I cannot understand people who refuse to accept that and make some of the small sacrifices required to get normal life back.

Children are missing years of schooling in the States right now ironically because of panic-driven restrictions.

Vaccines are wonderful things, but it’s more complex than you’d think.

Here’s one about polio vaccination in developing
countries, where the vaccine-derived virus is often causing more problems than the wild virus: www.statnews.com/2019/09/13/the-switch-polio-eradication-quandary/

And then the scandal in the Philippines over the dengue vaccine—this one caused families to lose faith in other vaccines, like the MMR, which sadly led to a lot of unnecessary measles death among children.

Now you have to have actually had dengue fever in the past before they give it to children—otherwise it can trigger a deadly reaction if you give it to a immunologically naive child, and they then go on to contract dengue again.

All to say it’s complicated

Changer123 · 17/11/2021 13:37

Fully vaccinated ( although as boris says, the definition of fully vaccinated will evolve over time, so I guess I'm not fully vaccinated anymore Confused ) very very concerned by vaccine passports, it is a slippery slope & definitely government over reach. The people who are all for them are kidding themselves that they will stop at the covid vaccine, they have already moved the goal posts for how many doses is fully vaxxed, I dont doubt that lots of other requirements will be added on. Also I believe in medical freedom, body autonomy and informed consent, vaccine passports will over ride every single one of them. Scary times indeed

Mamiamamia · 17/11/2021 13:25

@Worldgonecrazy

Having the vaccine reduces the chance of hospitalisation and serious illness.

So does not being fat.

One makes money for pharmaceutical and health industries.

One doesn’t. One also has long term additional benefits for the NHS.

Amazing that only one method is being promoted.

If, instead of vaccine passports, we had BMI passports there would be an outcry. And before someone points out BMI measurements aren’t perfect measurements of fitness, I would point out that vaccination status is not a perfect measure of either immunity or contagious status.

The best reply I have read since this whole thing began, couldn’t agree more!
Wallywobbles · 17/11/2021 13:12

We've had them since the beginning in France. There's some cheating going on but they are easy and effective. Doesn't feel like a conspiracy. It's just no big deal to ordinary people here.

What exactly are you worried about? Cos from here it really seems like worrying about vaccine passports is a bit mad.

DismantledKing · 17/11/2021 13:09

‘Oh no, if it isn’t the consequences of my own actions’ moan the ‘doing my my own research’ types, when they realise that not having the vaccine may cause them inconvenience.

EsmesRedPetticoat · 17/11/2021 12:53

I am constantly amazed at some people’s eagerness to fat bash on the flimsiest of excuses. This thread is a case in point!

Thehop · 17/11/2021 12:25

@Worldgonecrazy

Having the vaccine reduces the chance of hospitalisation and serious illness.

So does not being fat.

One makes money for pharmaceutical and health industries.

One doesn’t. One also has long term additional benefits for the NHS.

Amazing that only one method is being promoted.

If, instead of vaccine passports, we had BMI passports there would be an outcry. And before someone points out BMI measurements aren’t perfect measurements of fitness, I would point out that vaccination status is not a perfect measure of either immunity or contagious status.

Couldn’t agree with this more, albeit not something I’d dare say in public!

3 of us in a household of 5 are losing weight since covid.it’S a scary risk.

DismantledKing · 17/11/2021 12:24

Nope, not bothered. Just get vaccinated.

kimsbb · 17/11/2021 12:21

You're right, you should be alarmed.

@SamosaSammy
exactly, where does it stop? once the freedom passports are implemented we won't be allowed to work, travel, vote unless we do as we're told.

People are so distracted and divided over the vaccinated/unvaccinated they seem oblivious to what's happening.

alborana · 17/11/2021 11:59

I've just come back from holiday and while there I met an elderly man who walked with a stick. He told me he contracted polio when he was 5 years old and had walked with a stick ever since. He also told me he couldn't read, as he had missed years of schooling as a child due to illness.

Vaccines have changed our lives. I cannot understand people who refuse to accept that and make some of the small sacrifices required to get normal life back.

JassyRadlett · 17/11/2021 11:56

It’s funny, isn’t it.

When you quote trial data, it’s criticised for not being in the real world (Pfizer trials showed relative efficacy of a booster dose at 95.6% compared to two doses.)

When you quote surveillance data, it can’t be trusted as it’s not an RCT.

When they align, people look for other reasons the data couldn’t possibly be right.

JassyRadlett · 17/11/2021 11:46

And remember there's huge confounding facts on "boosters" the people most likely to get their booster, are individuals most likely to also take other mitigations (and while masks don't do much, staying at home sure does) the data you're quoting is not RCT's it's surveillance, and that is always made difficult with confounding factors.

The ONS adjusts for core demographic variables like those you suggest, though of course not for the confounding factors - though their reports do also look at a number of those factors so you are able to see the individual impact of those confounding factors.

The top value of the ONS is as a time series.

JassyRadlett · 17/11/2021 11:41

@JollyJoon

Well not driving massively decreases death rates but the solution isnt to ban cars as that would be ridiculous because people rely on them.

Being vaccinated massively decreases death rates but the solution isnt to ban access to society for people as they rely on it.

I dont see the difference.

We do have restrictions on how you can use your car to reduce the death rate - speed limits, seatbelts, blood alcohol limits, traffic measures, roads that are one way, or only open to certain kinds of traffic, or have time of day restrictions.

But the quantum of deaths is also quite different - around 1700 road deaths in the UK in a normal year, versus more than 140k in less than two years with Covid.

So driving couldn’t save more than 2000 lives a year, even if it stopped entirely. Vaccines have prevented around 127,000 deaths up to the end of September, according to UKHSA and the University of Cambridge.

sirfredfredgeorge · 17/11/2021 11:35

"Not vaccinated" is quite a different group to the others. The majority of "not vaccinated" in this country are under 18... And a 60 year old at random is 10 times less likely to be infected than a 15 year old one?

And remember there's huge confounding facts on "boosters" the people most likely to get their booster, are individuals most likely to also take other mitigations (and while masks don't do much, staying at home sure does) the data you're quoting is not RCT's it's surveillance, and that is always made difficult with confounding factors.

That's not to say it's wrong, but you cannot be so dogmatic about the conclusions. The conclusions from similar reports in March, would not have had the boosters being required now...

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 11:32

Well not driving massively decreases death rates but the solution isnt to ban cars as that would be ridiculous because people rely on them.

Being vaccinated massively decreases death rates but the solution isnt to ban access to society for people as they rely on it.

I dont see the difference.

JassyRadlett · 17/11/2021 11:29

The data is very clear that vaccines reduce the risk of transmission significantly.

With delta and waning, a double dose of AZ drops a little below 50% protection. All other full vaccine courses prevent the majority of infections. So that’s already halving transmission.

And boosters are bloody magnificent. They take protection way beyond even the early days of a double dose of Pfizer. A booster dose will cut your chance of being infected by 7x-9x versus being double vaccinated.

(Graph is from the ONS today.)

to be alarmed by vaccine passports