Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2021 17:02

I don’t feel that strongly as I’m double vaccinated and will get booster when available

But I understand why people don’t want to go down that road and why they feel strongly about it.

I’ve been looking at vaccination rates / Covid passes and some countries seem to still have higher cases than us - eg Ireland which is interesting as they are both high on vaccination / passes and case rates

Geamhradh · 17/11/2021 17:01

@Lostinacloud

Schools haven’t been closed in France since May 2020 *@Geamhradh* apart from one week only in March this year. You have the green pass and I know from other threads that you are a fan but where’s your normal life? Still masked up inside, showing your pass every time you want to go out to eat and threatened with further restrictions once winter sets in.
I didn't say schools had been closed in France, did I? But they WERE closed here, for 18 months. The vaccine + green pass means they now don't have to be. If wearing a paper mask and showing a QR code keeps them (and businesses etc) open, then great. It's no hardship. Italy will keep its restrictions tighter than many other countries for longer I imagine. The price was too high in March 2020 to ever think of letting it happen again, even on a much smaller scale. And the price we pay now (QR code and a mask) is not too high for that.
XenoBitch · 17/11/2021 17:00

YANBU, it is alarming.
It is all very well saying it is not an issue and should just be tolerated, because that seems to come from people who happily skipped to the vaccine centre and virtue signalled all over FB that they were jabbed.
For some, there is a huge mental barrier in the way that is stopping them getting the vaccine, and this talk of vaccine passports etc is frightening as hell. That mental barrier wont drop away because there is a threat that the life you took for granted is getting restricted.
Yeah, great if you are ok with getting the vaccine now. Next time, it could be something you struggle with.

Lostinacloud · 17/11/2021 16:57

Schools haven’t been closed in France since May 2020 @Geamhradh apart from one week only in March this year.
You have the green pass and I know from other threads that you are a fan but where’s your normal life? Still masked up inside, showing your pass every time you want to go out to eat and threatened with further restrictions once winter sets in.

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 16:56

In france you cant even take a train without a pass. Do you think it's normal that an abused woman, say, would not be able to leave her home and get on a train to stay with a member of her family, because she doesnt have the pass?

What about a man who is prevented from visiting his fathers death bed?

Or what about a minor from a neglectful household who can no longer get on a bus to school?

Or an immigrant who just wants to go home but cant get on a plane back?

Because this is what we are talking about here. It's not all about who is allowed to go out for cocktails, and how you feel so much safer sitting at the bar with other people like you.

Geamhradh · 17/11/2021 16:53

I'm in Italy and am here to tell you we've had vaccine passes since 1st July. I'm here to tell you that where our schools were closed, they're now open, almost all our 12+ kids are double vaxxed, so in classes where everyone is vaccinated, they don't need to wear masks.
Nightclubs are open, with no restrictions on numbers, same with theatres and public transport etc.
Restrictions may need to be tightened up again, 66% of Italians are in favour of the passes, 18% don't care one way or the other.
Booster rollout is underway, so all regions staying "white" for now.
Cases are rising, but not giving cause for concern nationally.
S'all good.

Platax · 17/11/2021 16:50

I would argue that fatness is a wider risk factor than whether someone is vaccinated or not

Define risk. Yes, it's a greater risk to the fat person, but no-one else will catch that risk from them just by virtue of being near them. By contrast, having covid may be a relatively small risk to the individual, but there is a greater risk of passing it on if you are unvaccinated and you then potentially impose a massive risk on others.

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 16:50

@Lostinacloud
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

wasthataburp · 17/11/2021 16:49

@MistyFrequencies

I'm worried about this too. FWIW I'm fully vaccinnated. I just don't know what the answer is.
The issue is how long will you be deemed to be fully vaccinated?
Lostinacloud · 17/11/2021 16:48

I am in France, we’ve had vaccine passports since 23rd July and I am here to politely inform you that their introduction does fuck all to give you back your freedom and normal life!

My DC from age 6 upwards still sit in masks all day at school, there are masks for everywhere indoors and covid tests cost most people about £20 per test. If you don’t have the pass you can’t even leave the country without an essential reason.
The daily news is full of headlines about 5th waves and mass boostering. No sign of an end to the passport as they just passed a law extending its use to at least the end of July 2022. No sign of the promised payback of unmasking our poor kids or letting us get on with our lives without the threat of non entry to everyday tasks or further lockdowns and closures/curfews.

So, let’s just recap….the government brought the passports in so that more would be vaccinated and we could avoid any further lockdowns and get back to some kind of normal life. Just over 3 months later, over 76% of over 12’s are vaccinated and yet restrictions are tightening up again and the passports are threatened to be switched off if you don’t comply and get the booster.

The only thing that vaccine passports do is lock you into an unofficial one sided contract with your government to ensure that you agree from now on to get a vaccine every 6 months. Break the “contract” and you get even less freedom and normality than apparently we have earned up to now by doing what they have already asked us to do.

Seriously, they do nothing, they are discriminatory, make no scientific sense and contribute to more loss of personal freedom than bloody lockdowns!

SAY NO while you still have the chance.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 17/11/2021 16:41

@gwenneh

If you want to participate in public life, then you have to take part in public health measures. Whether you agree with the measures or not, and whether they benefit you as an individual or not, makes no difference.
Totally agree. I'm not alarmed at all.

Am struggling to understand the comment re HIV and STD passports.... as far as I know you can't catch those from sitting next to someone on a flight, or by drinking/dancing next to them in a club.

Re measles, although vaccination rates are falling, they are still incredibly high. So measles is no longer as 'out there' in the same way as COVID,

ddl1 · 17/11/2021 16:35

*Well not driving massively decreases death rates but the solution isnt to ban cars as that would be ridiculous because people rely on them.

Being vaccinated massively decreases death rates but the solution isnt to ban access to society for people as they rely on it.

I dont see the difference.*

There isn't a difference. People CAN'T drive if they don't have a license! And getting a driver's license requires training and passing a test - which costs them time and money. And people with certain medical conditions and disabilities may be unable to get a driver's license for no fault of their own.

Requiring vaccination before travel or attending certain events is probably LESS restrictive than requiring a driving license before you can drive.

The only real difference is that almost no one thinks that they should be able to drive without a license, while some people do think that they should be able to go anywhere risking infecting people, without doing what they can do reduce the risks.

Wilkolampshade · 17/11/2021 16:35

These are victims of persecution and holocaust @Annoymouser2. Not quite the same is it?

HIVpos · 17/11/2021 16:35

We don’t have measles vaccination passports, HIV negative passports, STI free passports

Irrelevant since the vast majority of people living with HIV in the UK are unable to pass it on due to being on effective medication.

STI passports would be similarly pointless, as given window periods any test done is only good for a general timeframe of about 3 months previous.

gwenneh · 17/11/2021 16:29

If you want to participate in public life, then you have to take part in public health measures. Whether you agree with the measures or not, and whether they benefit you as an individual or not, makes no difference.

SarahBellam · 17/11/2021 16:28

I am a mega fan of vaccine passports. Anything that helps us to move on and get back to normal is fine by me. There’s no point in this anti vax wittering - all you’re doing is prolonging it for everyone and putting other people and yourself at higher risk.

ddl1 · 17/11/2021 16:26

They are human beings, not disease vectors.

It's possible to be both.

ddl1 · 17/11/2021 16:22

Who is anyone to dictate what others do with their bodies and what they put into it?

But if you go next to people unvaccinated (especially if you don't have regular tests), then you may be dictating to them that they put YOUR germs into their bodies!

ddl1 · 17/11/2021 16:19

Ive had both vaccines, know wjat im doin just now, sitting on my couch with covid. So again dont tell others what to do with their bodies when it comes to vaccines. Im all for free choice, i dont tell people to not smoke, dont drink, not eat etc because you know, its none of my business, just like its not yours.

Hope you are better soon. But maybe you hadn't had the jabs you wouldn't be sitting on your couch with Covid, you might be in ITU with it.

And people are not told not to smoke or drink, but they ARE told to smoke in indoor public places, and not to drink just before driving! It's the same with vaccine passports - you don't have to have the jab, but you may need to have it if you want to go to crowded indoor public events, or travel on potentially crowded public transport (which are also settings where you aren't allowed to smoke!)

ddl1 · 17/11/2021 16:12

*Having the vaccine reduces the chance of hospitalisation and serious illness.

So does not being fat.*

But sitting next to a fat person at an event or on a train or plane does not put you at risk of becoming fat. Sitting next to someone with Covid does put you at risk of catching Covid. THAT'S why people have vaccine passports!

JassyRadlett · 17/11/2021 16:11

Seeing as its a trial drug the governments should actually wait to find out the longterm side affects before they force anyone to have it.

This is also total misinformation. None of the vaccines we’re using, in the way they’re being used, are in trial.

DismantledKing · 17/11/2021 16:07

@JollyJoon

Look it's not about the medical data.

It's about the morality of it.

The morality of people being too selfish or foolish to be immunised?
Thatsthewaytis · 17/11/2021 15:59

@DismantledKing agreed. it’s disgusting equating anything to do with covid to the suffering of the Holocaust.

JassyRadlett · 17/11/2021 15:58

@Annoymouser2

Slippery slope indeed, yellow stars and ghettos in the war era spring to mind.
Conflating an evidence-based time-bound public health measure to protect specific groups with the Nazi persecution of Jews in the Holocaust is frankly disgusting. It minimises that horror by trying to draw such a comparison.

Jews have asked for it to stop. Minimising the Holocaust actively feeds anti-Semitism.

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 15:58

Look it's not about the medical data.

It's about the morality of it.