Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be alarmed by vaccine passports

415 replies

Loustew12 · 17/11/2021 07:14

Am I the only person who find the proposed extension of this alarming, given what's happening in Austria, where police are out checking the unvaccinated are hiding among the vaccinated? Gibraltar has 100% vaccination rate and cases are through the roof. So clearly being vaccinated doesn't 'stop the spread'. Therefore, there is no logical or justification for segregating society. It's surely a slippery slope to go down?

OP posts:
Thatsthewaytis · 17/11/2021 19:05

Another reason could also be that Ireland is only now starting to use antigen tests. We’ve been very slow on that front. So I guess cases caught by weekly testing in U.K. wouldn’t be caught here and those people would be out mixing and spreading.

PAFMO · 17/11/2021 19:03

[quote JollyJoon]@PAFMO
Are you going to respond to my point?[/quote]
If you make a relevant one.

MarbleQueen · 17/11/2021 19:02

Do people really believe the covid pass will not be used for other purposes?

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/927547/GOS_The_Future_of_Citizen_Data_Systems_Report__2_.pdf

Thatsthewaytis · 17/11/2021 18:58

@MarshaBradyo I said it was stupid to say cases in Ireland are high because the vaccine cert isn’t working. We have no way of knowing how high cases would be if the cert wasn’t in place so it’s a stupid point to make. For all we know without the pass the country would be back in a hard lockdown due to overwhelmed hospitals.

I would hazard a guess that cases in Ireland are very high as Ireland didn’t have a lot of immunity. There was an interesting article on Waterford which has currently one of the highest rates of covid but had the lowest rate and escaped all covid waves during lockdowns. As we all now know vaccines don’t stop you getting covid.

Also testing and extent of testing is likely important. High levels of testing are ongoing in Ireland. Maybe not the same in U.K.

There could be other reasons too. But saying oh look high cases mean vaccine certs don’t work is pure idiocy.

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 18:56

@PAFMO
Are you going to respond to my point?

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 17/11/2021 18:52

Unvaccinated under 65 year olds are protected in the large majority by virtue of their age. Why haven’t people still acknowledged the fact that covid does not cause the same level of risk to all demographics?

If it was your child/ parent / sibling who turned out not to be protected 'in the large' you might think differently

PAFMO · 17/11/2021 18:47

@JollyJoon

In france you cant even take a train without a pass. Do you think it's normal that an abused woman, say, would not be able to leave her home and get on a train to stay with a member of her family, because she doesnt have the pass?

What about a man who is prevented from visiting his fathers death bed?

Or what about a minor from a neglectful household who can no longer get on a bus to school?

Or an immigrant who just wants to go home but cant get on a plane back?

Because this is what we are talking about here. It's not all about who is allowed to go out for cocktails, and how you feel so much safer sitting at the bar with other people like you.

Think you just won the Whataboutery award of the day.
Geamhradh · 17/11/2021 18:45

@Lostinacloud

It’s not the green pass that’s allowing schools to be open though *@Geamhradh*, it’s the italien government, who could have looked at the science and opened schools long ago. It’s not the unvaccinated, it’s not the vaccine passports yet to be put into place or in full swing, who aren’t returning people’s normal lives, it’s the governments. And you want to give them even more direct control by locking you into a contract controlling your own bodily autonomy?
And you know all this how? Are you an expert on Italy now too?

I've got an EU pass. Everyone I know has one. We're happy to have it. Can't wait to get our boosters. Looking forward to a normal Christmas. Looking forward to our kids having an undisrupted school year.
I didn't have to have the vaccine. Nobody dragged me there. Nobody made me get DD vaccinated.
My bodily autonomy is just fine ta.

gogohm · 17/11/2021 17:44

It's also alarming how many people here are unable to understand simple statistics ... if 90% of a town is vaccinated and the local hospital has 40% unvaccinated patients ... who is more likely to be hospitalised??? Clue it's not the vaccinated ones! Back to maths class anti vax lot, you might learn something useful

Chasingaftermidnight · 17/11/2021 17:42

Forcing a trial vaccine on the masses and anyone daring not to take the vaccine will lose their jobs and in some countries their liberties, it all sounds familiar no?

No it doesn’t sound familiar at all. What are you comparing it to?

Lostinacloud · 17/11/2021 17:41

Those at risk have the vaccine available and as many boosters as they like. The rest dont need to be scapegoated or segregated from society.

Lostinacloud · 17/11/2021 17:40

Unvaccinated under 65 year olds are protected in the large majority by virtue of their age. Why haven’t people still acknowledged the fact that covid does not cause the same level of risk to all demographics? Blanket saying the unvaccinated are more likely…. doesn’t take into their health, their age, whether they’ve been previously infected etc

gogohm · 17/11/2021 17:39

Vaccinated people are far less likely to get sick, if they do show symptoms they clear up quicker. Intensive care units across Europe are filled with mostly unvaccinated people who typically are sicker and require longer stays, they are far more likely to die.

I'm on holiday currently, only fully vaccinated over 12's can enter the complex (3-11's must have a pcr test within 72 hours of arrival, under 3's exempt). In return for this there are very few restrictions beyond sensible mask wearing inside when not seated

alborana · 17/11/2021 17:37

Before the vaccine was available I knew several people who were very ill with covid, including friends who were hospitalised and in intensive care. Since people have been vaccinated I've known people catch covid but no-one has been very unwell. The vaccines work.

I have no time for unvaccinated people who may take up hospital beds needed by people with other serious illnesses. We all need to do our bit as a society.

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 17:34

@Thatsthewaytis
Why does Ireland have such a high rate?

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2021 17:33

@Thatsthewaytis

Unvaccinated are more likely to catch covid. Unvaccinated are more likely to spread covid. Unvaccinated are more likely to end up in ICU

You are more likely to catch covid in a crowded indoor setting.

As unvaccinated people have zero interest in protecting themselves or reducing spread to others quite simply not letting them in reduces risk for them and for others.

It’s quite simple.

Also Ireland have had covid passes in place since came out of lockdown. You cant say the passes aren’t working because cases are going up. It’s likely cases would be even higher without the pass in place so it’s a stupid argument to say they’re not doing anything.

But then the anti vaxxers love to make up their own ‘alternative facts’ rather than use logic.

As I said I’m pro vaccine but no it’s not stupid to look at what’s happening in countries with passes and high cases. It’s silly to be aggressive if some one does.

What do you think is happening to cause higher cases in Ireland v U.K.?

Thatsthewaytis · 17/11/2021 17:28

Unvaccinated are more likely to catch covid. Unvaccinated are more likely to spread covid. Unvaccinated are more likely to end up in ICU

You are more likely to catch covid in a crowded indoor setting.

As unvaccinated people have zero interest in protecting themselves or reducing spread to others quite simply not letting them in reduces risk for them and for others.

It’s quite simple.

Also Ireland have had covid passes in place since came out of lockdown. You cant say the passes aren’t working because cases are going up. It’s likely cases would be even higher without the pass in place so it’s a stupid argument to say they’re not doing anything.

But then the anti vaxxers love to make up their own ‘alternative facts’ rather than use logic.

Lostinacloud · 17/11/2021 17:26

It’s true @JollyJoon, the news said today that tests have dropped by 60% since they became payable as well.
School kids don’t test and to be honest I don’t know anyone who’s tested themselves or their families for months because it’s just not on anybody’s mind anymore to do that. I get the sense that most of the fear of covid is gone and so even if people suspect they may have it, they still don’t generally test or stop going to school or work.

JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 17:23

@ConcernedAuntie

But that's because theres practically no testing in France whereas everyone I know in the UK seems to have boxes of lateral flow tests at the ready. Go and look up testing rates and get back to me.

kimsbb · 17/11/2021 17:23

@Lostinacloud
👍👍👍

Why can’t people see this 🤷🏻‍♀️

ConcernedAuntie · 17/11/2021 17:21

Had a visit recently from some friends who live in France. They were here visiting family who they haven't seen for 2 years. They were quite horrified that at the lack of mask wearing here in shops. They also have to show proof of vaccination when they go out to a restaurant in France. Not having given it much thought before, after they had gone I went and had a look at the infection figures. On the latest stats available for the same day the total in France was just over 9,000, in the UK it was nearly 45,000. Now I know they are not so tightly crammed in in France but this is quite a difference for two countries with a similar population.

Lostinacloud · 17/11/2021 17:19

What exactly is their function? They don’t stop spread or fears of saturated hospitals as we are just watching happen in Germany and Austria and Ireland, they don’t return life completely back to normal as promised, as we we are witnessing in many other countries of the world - still with masks and limits on entry to everyday places like libraries and gyms. What is their function? If the vaccine is required due to a person’s risk then there’s no need for coercion. And I thought we all left coercion for medical treatments back in 1945.

Lostinacloud · 17/11/2021 17:15

It’s not the green pass that’s allowing schools to be open though @Geamhradh, it’s the italien government, who could have looked at the science and opened schools long ago. It’s not the unvaccinated, it’s not the vaccine passports yet to be put into place or in full swing, who aren’t returning people’s normal lives, it’s the governments. And you want to give them even more direct control by locking you into a contract controlling your own bodily autonomy?

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2021 17:05

This is the chart and map

The dark green countries still feature in the sharp incline higher rates which I found interesting

to be alarmed by vaccine passports
to be alarmed by vaccine passports
JollyJoon · 17/11/2021 17:04

Yeah what's going on with Ireland? Why is it such a shit show over there?