Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are there toxic parents on mumsnet?

85 replies

kavalkada · 17/11/2021 05:41

It is something that always troubles me on mumsnet.

I had very abusive parents, both in different ways. My father was a gambler who made our lives a living hell, and I know my mother had a terrible life with him. She was only 20 when she married him, he was 30. She was pregnant with me. I don't know if she would've married him if she wasn't pregnant with me. Mabye yes, mabye no.

I have younger brother. Unlike me, my mother adored him from the moment he came to this world. He was the apple of her eye and there were always cuddles, kisses, hugs for him. You can see it on our family photographs.

As long as I remember, my mother (and father) never kissed me, never hugged me, never cuddled with me. I remember my father holding my hand once during winter olympics, and that was it.

But there was always a belt and a cane in the kitchen if I get naughty. And I did. I haven't eaten lunch - cane over my hands and back, something fell from my hand and broke, belt, I said something I shouldn't (I was four when it started), cane. You get the picture.
Nobody ever shouted and hit my brother.

I was a house maild, ever since I was 6, washing and cleaning like a proper adult. I was 8 when I started ironing saturdays, for hours, because my parents had uniforms and there were lot of them. My brother never made his bed.

Until I met my husband 10 years ago, I didn't know how happy a family life can be. I have two children now, a boy and a girl, and looking at them for the life of me I can not see why my parents made such a difference between me and my brother.

My father was a crap father in every way, but ne never beat me (well, it happened once).

I now live in the other party of my country. I am not NC from them, but I said to myself that I will never ever in my life be alone with them, only if my husband was there. This happened two years ago after spending a week alone with my mother and my children, and she started abusing me again, not with cane, but every other way.

But this is my question. If my mother had a mumsnet in her day, she would come here and write about her hard life. And it was hard. Very poor, no clothes in the winter, alcoholic father, gambler husband, nobody to help her with two little children. She was in hell most of the time. The only thing she had was her job she loved and without it we would be hungry.

She would write all that, probably skipping the part about daily beating her older child, and everybody would jump to tell her not to be so hard on herself, and that she is doing best for her children and that her children love her no matter what.

I see posters coming and asking if they're a terrible parent all the time. Sometimes, they're really not, just too hard on themselves, you want to hug them and tell them, but sometimes, they're not. You can see that even from the things they write, and they probably do not write the whole story. And they're always said they're good parents, doing their best.

So my question is, why on mumsnet it is not allowed to say mother is sometines awful mother? I'm saying mother, because we have threads about crap fathers on daily base and nobody is defending them.

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 17/11/2021 08:16

Are there toxic parents on mumsnet?

Doubtless you are right, there will be loads.

So my question is, why on mumsnet it is not allowed to say mother is sometines awful mother?

The awful mothers don't admit it on here. I think there are lots of threads where it's obvious that the OP is not being honest and is blaming everyone but themselves. Many posters do challenge this but there are always some who jump in with 'be kind' or insist that the other party is bullying them.

The ones that upset me most are the social services/school/police picking on me threads because I know that a large proportion of those OP will be bullshitting and the reality is often that they are terrible parents.

Grabmygran · 17/11/2021 08:16

OP sending so much love.

I think this is an important topic.. perhaps Mumsnet could speak to some experts and abuse survivors about some of these signs you see in posts and come up with some wording to be put in a response to any posts that have these signs?

AlleZusammen · 17/11/2021 08:15

I think sometimes people reveal themselves to be toxic on mumsnet when they are responding to someone struggling with an angry, unhappy child's behaviour. The op will detail trauma the child has experienced and someone will come on and say "I wouldn't put up with that behaviour in this house. They then go on to describe how they'd heap on severe, quite degrading punishments and tell everyone repeatedly what an awful child they'd been. Just a really shit approach to parenting that doesn't help and would just increase the child's anger.

Hodgehog · 17/11/2021 08:11

I agree with the points from PP - one that people are only able to go on the OP and their own personal life experiences and also that I have seen bad parenting to the extent it’s abuse called out on her. I remember the one about the child being washed in cold water and remember another with a teenager - the mother had found a text “claiming” they they were abusive sent to a friend.

She then went on to admit they were physically violent to him in the same breath and this was picked up on and she was told she was abusive.

My mother was …I’m told it’s abuse even if that’s not what they intended.

But my mother I don’t think ever understood the emotional demands of raising a child and that that child would be dependant on her and she wasn’t really able to fulfil that. To the point of being quite cruel to me although she wouldn’t see it that way.

I remember being ill once - vomiting a lot and she literally couldn’t not understand why I wanted her with me when I was being sick. I’d have been about 7. She said so too. Ideally she could have just left me to it to do whatever it was she was doing instead.

I kept going looking for her in the house dragging the bucket with me.

DrBlackbird · 17/11/2021 08:04

A friend of mine recently tried to defend the abusive husband I was leaving by saying he was just acting on his insecurities

When my DH said to me "it doesn’t matter why someone has a boot on your head, all that matters is that they have a boot on your head!" was my wake up call to stop making excuses for people’s shitty/bad behaviour.

Worldwide2 · 17/11/2021 07:59

Your post brings back alot of how i was treated as a child mainly by my mother. Alot of violence (only me) and so much favouritism which is still very much in place nowadays. I have confronted my mother over her treatment of me but she either shuts down completely or will say she has no memory of such things. Growing up myself and now having children it magnifys what happened to me as a child. If ss had known I would definitely been removed. Lots of the family witnessed the violence and treatment but did nothing. Which is astounding really. Makes me angry no one stood up for me. So understand completely when you say no one stands up for children but there is full support for the mother. However on here we only see that mothers point of view and we can only go on that really. I do think nowadays there is alot more support for children and safeguarding is massive. Obviously child abuse is missed all the time but I think the world has gotten better at recognising the signs. Just wanted to say I really understand how you feel 💐

OryxAndCrake11 · 17/11/2021 07:54

I think Mumsnetters do call out abusive behaviour when they see it. I remember once where a poster said she punished her child for toiletting accidents by spraying her with cold water in the bath, and another where her child had to eat cold leftovers in the dark if they were hungry having not eaten dinner. In both cases everyone came down on them like a ton of bricks. Posters who admit to taking their unhappiness out on kids are always called out on it too - just yesterday a woman said she was snappy with her kids due to an unhappy marriage, and was told she has to leave.

I don't think assuming most posters who come here worried that they're messing up parenting are toxic is the right way forward. Parenting is hard, most of us are doing our best, and sometimes posters just need support to make changes.

That said, I am so sorry for what you went through OP.

Lollyneenah · 17/11/2021 07:52

I agree with you OP. The problem I see fairly often is a failure to safeguard- ie the husband is abusive/a drunk/a bully and the poster is wringing their hands about starting all over again 🙄
I had a difficult childhood due to my mum being abusive to me and an alcoholic, except I had a wonderful dad. It was a bizarre feeling g when I realised that my dad could have left her and taken me away from it

Pinkgorrilaz · 17/11/2021 07:48

@DrSbaitso

Every parent swears they haven't got a favourite child, or if they have, they hide it perfectly and nobody would ever know.

But plenty of kids say there was a clear favourite.

I'm pretty sure there's a fair amount of misalignment.

My mum said this to me when she was terminally ill: well at least I treated you all equally. She really, really didn't and I was the scapegoat but at that stage there was no point in challenging her.

I'm so sorry you had such a bad experience with your mum. I do think that a lot of people on mumsnet have had normal parents, who occasionally got things wrong or had a few flaws. They don't understand the difference between that and truly toxic parents, and therefore often insist that you need to honour your mum, you only get one mum, etc.

crankysaurus · 17/11/2021 07:48

I think you're right, op, there are threads on here sometimes that make the hair on the back of my neck stand up, especially the ones where someone's older kids are going LC/NC with them. I do tend to think regularly that we're just hearing the poster's view point only, but never that of the partner or the kids.

Elodeastar · 17/11/2021 07:46

@kavalkada

It is something that always troubles me on mumsnet.

I had very abusive parents, both in different ways. My father was a gambler who made our lives a living hell, and I know my mother had a terrible life with him. She was only 20 when she married him, he was 30. She was pregnant with me. I don't know if she would've married him if she wasn't pregnant with me. Mabye yes, mabye no.

I have younger brother. Unlike me, my mother adored him from the moment he came to this world. He was the apple of her eye and there were always cuddles, kisses, hugs for him. You can see it on our family photographs.

As long as I remember, my mother (and father) never kissed me, never hugged me, never cuddled with me. I remember my father holding my hand once during winter olympics, and that was it.

But there was always a belt and a cane in the kitchen if I get naughty. And I did. I haven't eaten lunch - cane over my hands and back, something fell from my hand and broke, belt, I said something I shouldn't (I was four when it started), cane. You get the picture.
Nobody ever shouted and hit my brother.

I was a house maild, ever since I was 6, washing and cleaning like a proper adult. I was 8 when I started ironing saturdays, for hours, because my parents had uniforms and there were lot of them. My brother never made his bed.

Until I met my husband 10 years ago, I didn't know how happy a family life can be. I have two children now, a boy and a girl, and looking at them for the life of me I can not see why my parents made such a difference between me and my brother.

My father was a crap father in every way, but ne never beat me (well, it happened once).

I now live in the other party of my country. I am not NC from them, but I said to myself that I will never ever in my life be alone with them, only if my husband was there. This happened two years ago after spending a week alone with my mother and my children, and she started abusing me again, not with cane, but every other way.

But this is my question. If my mother had a mumsnet in her day, she would come here and write about her hard life. And it was hard. Very poor, no clothes in the winter, alcoholic father, gambler husband, nobody to help her with two little children. She was in hell most of the time. The only thing she had was her job she loved and without it we would be hungry.

She would write all that, probably skipping the part about daily beating her older child, and everybody would jump to tell her not to be so hard on herself, and that she is doing best for her children and that her children love her no matter what.

I see posters coming and asking if they're a terrible parent all the time. Sometimes, they're really not, just too hard on themselves, you want to hug them and tell them, but sometimes, they're not. You can see that even from the things they write, and they probably do not write the whole story. And they're always said they're good parents, doing their best.

So my question is, why on mumsnet it is not allowed to say mother is sometines awful mother? I'm saying mother, because we have threads about crap fathers on daily base and nobody is defending them.

Firstly OP, sorry for what you went through, that sounds really, really hard. In answer to your question, I think there are toxic mothers everywhere, so some will eventually find their way on here too, and I think also that some are (blissfully) unaware how toxic their behaviour is to their children (and others too). None of use are perfect parents, or would suggest that we are, but there is a difference between trying our hardest but sometimes messing up a little, and an actual abusive situation. Of course abuse comes in many forms too, all are harmful in the short and long term. Wishing you and your family well going forward.
JadeTrinket · 17/11/2021 07:45

Sympathies, OP. Keep away from them.

workwoes123 · 17/11/2021 07:45

I’ve wondered the same OP. It’s an incredibly complex subject.

On Mumsnet we only ever get one side of the story, and because all we have to go on are the words on the page everything can seem very black and white. So 1. We can never entirely trust what is written (we are all capable of being unreliable narrators in our own stories) and 2. As your mums story tells us, it’s not black and white: abusers were often abused in their turn and it’s an incredibly difficult cycle to get out of. We learn how to be men / women / dad / mums / people from our parents (or whoever we were with in early life). Your mum could easily have come here with a tale of woe, and got all the sympathy and validation and reassurance she wanted - if she presented her story in a certain way.

So yes, there are undoubtedly “toxic” parents on MN just as there are everywhere.

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/11/2021 07:44

@kavalkada Firstly I’m so sorry for what you went through Flowers.

I think Nyxly is making a good point. Many of us view what we are reading through a kind of filter based on our own personal experiences. We can project our own experiences onto others. Especially when our experiences have been significant or traumatic in some way.

I am well aware of my own projections, so I try to give the benefit of the doubt. Especially, because I don’t have enough information to really, actually know.

Many parents make mistakes, or become overwhelmed by stress or burnt out but are not abusive parents. They are doing their best, love their children and want to do better and need support. With the right support, they turn things around and do better.

It is amazing how the right kind of support and how building someone up can turn things around and have a positive ripple affect on the parent and then the kids.

Judgment and criticism can have a negative ripple affect on the parent and then the kids.

I don’t want abusers enabled but I also don’t want a parent trying to do their best being torn down and trampled either. That’s not healthy for them or their kids.

So, unless I know with absolute certainty based on enough evidence and facts that a parent is an abuser, I am going to try to be supportive and helpful.

Also, abusers can’t be reasoned with, will not take on board any constructive criticism, or acknowledge their wrong doing or seek to actually change for the better. They simply don’t care. Posting a comment to try to hold them accountable will probably achieve nothing.

Tryagainplease · 17/11/2021 07:43

Ah OP, you poor thing. That is heartbreaking to read. I hope you know you don’t deserve to be treated that way and I hope you know she is completely wrong in everything she has said and done. You are so remarkably brave for dealing with all of that.

You should have had a safe space to just be a child when you were little. Your parents did not provide that. They failed you Flowers

kavalkada · 17/11/2021 07:40

@Gingerkittykat

So my question is, why on mumsnet it is not allowed to say mother is sometines awful mother? I'm saying mother, because we have threads about crap fathers on daily base and nobody is defending them

Your mother was an awful mother.

The sheer volume of people on here means there are probably some abusers amongst the posters but the vast majority are people who love their kids and want to do what is best for them.

It sounds like you have done brilliantly creating your own family unit and I hope you can continue to protect yourself from your mother.

I agree with you, I think most parents do their best and try to be good parents.

But I'm sad that when that is not the case, nobody speaks for children.

OP posts:
JadeTrinket · 17/11/2021 07:40

This is an anonymous net rent forum. People only have what an OP says to go on. Of course there are dreadful parents on here.

kavalkada · 17/11/2021 07:37

@Tryagainplease

We talked last few years about the abuse and one time I asked her why she did it, she answered me that she was miserable, and I was the only person who was not going to turn against her, no matter what she did

How did that make you feel? Did you believe her?
There are no excuses for abusive behaviour, IMO.
A friend of mine recently tried to defend the abusive husband I was leaving by saying he was just acting on his insecurities…

Now I tend to think very few people are genuinely sociopathic enough to abuse for sport. So there will always be an excuse or a reason… but as I pointed out to my friend - I have insecurities too. Many of them so won’t don’t I treat people that way? There has to be another layer there - and I genuinely think it is pure entitlement. The abuser doesn’t deal with his/her insecurities in a healthy way - they feel entitled to punish others for how they feel.

I have only recently left abusive relationship so am still trying to process a lot of it. But no way would STBX admit that his behaviour was unfair. He just comes up with excuse after excuse. I used to believe his excuses… I don’t anymore.

I guess I always knew that, and I didn't feel anything. I was numb, you know, when you finally hear something you knew all your life.

That summer, two years ago. My husband returned home to work, and I stayed for a week, alone with her. And it has been ten years since I was alone with my parents, and I forgot.

And then it all came back, in a flash.

I was feeding my little girl, she is hard to feed in the best of days. But she is calmer when I sing to her. And I started to sing.

And then my mother came, who always complains that I can't take care of my children, and screamed. "Shut up, shut up, I can't hear you singing, you disguist me".

And whole week of that.

And her screaming that she has to take medicines to calm her, because I'm ruining her.

I spent week in my room shaking and holding my chidren next to me, afraid to say a word, afraid to move. It all came back.

I forgot. My home, home I have now is so different.

She doesn't like my husband, and she hates when I say that with him I have found out what love is, what means to love and not to be afraid.

Sorry, it is hard to write this and I have started to cry. I'll be better. I will not let them hurt me again.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 17/11/2021 07:32

I think there's a mixture of not wanting to upset a mother who is potentially just having a bad time and believing totally that what the op wrote is totally true from all sides.

I've seen many times where people post something contradictory and anyone who points this out is slammed by other posters for not being supportive.

I've also seen where a poster has posted something and people have responded with cheerleading remarks when there actually is no evidence.
And the other way.
It often seems to follow the tone of the first replies.

But I also think that we tend to empathise with bad moments. I know over the last 20 years there's parenting moments I'm not proud of. But most of the time hasn't been like that.
But if someone posts a "having a tough time" you mentally see it, like you, a single incident. What you're not allowing for is that this isn't a bad moment, it's always like that.
That is very different.

Gingerkittykat · 17/11/2021 07:31

So my question is, why on mumsnet it is not allowed to say mother is sometines awful mother? I'm saying mother, because we have threads about crap fathers on daily base and nobody is defending them

Your mother was an awful mother.

The sheer volume of people on here means there are probably some abusers amongst the posters but the vast majority are people who love their kids and want to do what is best for them.

It sounds like you have done brilliantly creating your own family unit and I hope you can continue to protect yourself from your mother.

Tryagainplease · 17/11/2021 07:24

We talked last few years about the abuse and one time I asked her why she did it, she answered me that she was miserable, and I was the only person who was not going to turn against her, no matter what she did

How did that make you feel? Did you believe her?
There are no excuses for abusive behaviour, IMO.
A friend of mine recently tried to defend the abusive husband I was leaving by saying he was just acting on his insecurities…

Now I tend to think very few people are genuinely sociopathic enough to abuse for sport. So there will always be an excuse or a reason… but as I pointed out to my friend - I have insecurities too. Many of them so won’t don’t I treat people that way? There has to be another layer there - and I genuinely think it is pure entitlement. The abuser doesn’t deal with his/her insecurities in a healthy way - they feel entitled to punish others for how they feel.

I have only recently left abusive relationship so am still trying to process a lot of it. But no way would STBX admit that his behaviour was unfair. He just comes up with excuse after excuse. I used to believe his excuses… I don’t anymore.

DroopyClematis · 17/11/2021 07:17

Your last paragraph, in particular, is spot on @Nyxly

kavalkada · 17/11/2021 07:16

@Tryagainplease

I’m so sorry for what you experienced OP Flowers

I often wonder what goes through the head of abusers and what causes them to behave the way they do. Entitlement? Lack of empathy? Either way, they aren’t traits that would compel someone to admit they are abusive. Very few people do.

I had a talk with my mother the other day. She asked me to come and visit her with children on my days off. I had to tell her that I can't, because I'm afraid of what she'll do to me.

She still doesn't understand why.

We talked last few years about the abuse and one time I asked her why she did it, she answered me that she was miserable, and I was the only person who was not going to turn against her, no matter what she did.

I'm better now, my new family helped me a lot. I'll never be healthy like I should have been, but I'm better.

OP posts:
Nyxly · 17/11/2021 07:14

I think its just the nature of people and Internet forums.

There are toxic parents on here. I personally have seen posts from them.

And yes they get sympathy. But I also get why. Firstly they are telling their sides of the story, so it's never going to be the whole story.

But also, people tend to judge people by their own character. Lots of us have had times where we feel we haven't been the best parents and are overly hard on ourselves.

My oldest is an adult, so I can look on my parenting. I know I made mistakes, we all do. But I also know that mistakes I made aren't the end of the world, like I thought they were at the time. So I think posters tend to assume that other mothers who are posting how terrible they have been, are just being hard on themselves. Or have pnd or something similar. Especially, if they suffered depression themselves.

I also think people like to think that women abuse children less often than they do.

In my 10 years here, I have only seen one long term poster claim women never abuse their children. Despite posters sharing their stories of that exact situation, the poster just kept insisting it doesn't happen. Essentially calling other posters liars. But I think that pov is rare.

I do also think that alot of posters here, by giving support, often enable abuse. But their brain hasn't made the connection, because they haven't experienced it. It's outside their frame of reference, so it doesn't enter their heads .

DrSbaitso · 17/11/2021 07:13

Every parent swears they haven't got a favourite child, or if they have, they hide it perfectly and nobody would ever know.

But plenty of kids say there was a clear favourite.

I'm pretty sure there's a fair amount of misalignment.