Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't drop dog shit in other people's bins?

262 replies

Takedogshithome · 16/11/2021 21:16

My dh thinks that if a house wheelie bin is on the pavement it's fair play to dropped bagged dog shit into it.
I on the other hand think this is socially unacceptable, so I thought I'd ask MN.

Iabu, of course, a bin is a bin, perfectly reasonable to drop shit in it.

Yanbu LTB filthy fucker

OP posts:
Lifewith · 18/11/2021 09:24

@Pigeoninthehouse

If it's properly bagged up, it just waste like anything else. If the bins are out to be emptied don't See the problem. I don't have a dog anymore and have been tempted at times to use someone else's bin, when there are no public ones to use, but know it might upset some precious folk, so haven't done it. I just think it's preferable to it being dumped on pavement, hung from trees etc...
No it's not waste like everything else. It's your dog waste, not mine. Not my dog and not my waste I'm paying to be collected in my bin I paid for. Look after your damn dog with a public bin or your bin. It's not precious to want to use your private bin for your private use.

The dog owners on this thread that think it's ok are really selfish cheeky sods.

AlternativePerspective · 18/11/2021 09:22

Just for clarification, I’ve never put my dog’s crap in someone else’s bin. The advice from guide dogs is actually to put it in the gutter, but I have left it under bushes where people aren’t going to be going and it’s in biodegradable bags.

It certainly doesn’t feel right just to leave it, only exception being if e.g. the grass is exceptionally long and I’ve been unable to find it, but I’m not beyond asking a member of the public just to tell me where it is.

Mouseonmychair · 18/11/2021 09:18

I only do it if people leave their bins out after bin day obstructing the pavement. A nice passive aggressive point.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 18/11/2021 09:14

Nappies are worse.

The odd bag of dog poo vs 14 shitty nappies? Assuming one poo a day from a child?

Know which I’d rather have in my bin. I once had someone change their baby in the boot of their car in front of my house and put the used nappy and wipes in my bin, in my front garden.

And yes, i used cloth as at the time we had bagged waste, not wheelie bins. Even a weeks worth of disposables took a whole bin bag and doubled our waste.

Pigeoninthehouse · 18/11/2021 08:12

If it's properly bagged up, it just waste like anything else.
If the bins are out to be emptied don't
See the problem.
I don't have a dog anymore and have been tempted at times to use someone else's bin, when there are no public ones to use, but know it might upset some precious folk, so haven't done it. I just think it's preferable to it being dumped on pavement, hung from trees etc...

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 18/11/2021 08:09

I own a dog it is a no from me.
It goes in a public dog bin or our own unless there is an extreme exceptional circumstance and then its double bagged.

Lifewith · 18/11/2021 08:08

I really am surprised how many people think someone's private bin can be used as a public bin. Just because they have a dog and don't want to take their crap with them.

There's another thread where some people agreed it was ok to park your car on a neighbours drive just because they didn't use it.

The entitlement of people seems very strong.

Largethighsbadeyes · 18/11/2021 08:08

If my bin was out for collection and someone put a bag of dog poo in it I wouldn't care.

However I wouldn't do it with a bag of my dogs shit and someone else's bin

Lifewith · 18/11/2021 08:04

@AlternativePerspective

Ok slightly alternative scenario.

I am a guide dog owner. Legally, guide dog owners are actually exempt from picking up after their dogs, but `I and most other GDO’s I know do pick up, and it’s not always possible to know where the public bins are, and if you’re e.g. going into town then it’s not possible to keep the bags until you get home.

Now I have never put my dog’s crap in anyone’s bin, but given the choice between leaving it on the grass and putting it in someone’s bin what would people suggest?

I would suggest not putting it in anyone's bin. Don't know how that's any different, it's still dog shit.
KosherDill · 18/11/2021 07:50

@AlternativePerspective

Ok slightly alternative scenario.

I am a guide dog owner. Legally, guide dog owners are actually exempt from picking up after their dogs, but `I and most other GDO’s I know do pick up, and it’s not always possible to know where the public bins are, and if you’re e.g. going into town then it’s not possible to keep the bags until you get home.

Now I have never put my dog’s crap in anyone’s bin, but given the choice between leaving it on the grass and putting it in someone’s bin what would people suggest?

Taking it with you or leaving the sack behind a tree or shrub and retrieving it on your way back? Or, worst case, don't pick it up. At least it will naturally decompose.

The source of the waste doesn't change the smell and mess inside a bin, unfortunately.

kimsbb · 18/11/2021 07:48

@AlternativePerspective that would be a different scenario.

If I saw someone with a guide dog I wouldn't expect them to pick it or find a bin. I also wouldn't offer to pick it.... yuk!!

kimsbb · 18/11/2021 07:44

Errr absolutely not. Someone walked up my drive once to put their bagged dog poo in my wheelie bin.

Bloody cheek!

AlternativePerspective · 18/11/2021 07:39

Ok slightly alternative scenario.

I am a guide dog owner. Legally, guide dog owners are actually exempt from picking up after their dogs, but `I and most other GDO’s I know do pick up, and it’s not always possible to know where the public bins are, and if you’re e.g. going into town then it’s not possible to keep the bags until you get home.

Now I have never put my dog’s crap in anyone’s bin, but given the choice between leaving it on the grass and putting it in someone’s bin what would people suggest?

TangoWhiskyAlphaTango · 18/11/2021 07:30

It made me even more angry when I had a skip on my drive and had at least 10 bags of shit in it. I wouldn't fling shit on to somebody else's drive so why would anybody think this is ok beats me!

TangoWhiskyAlphaTango · 18/11/2021 07:29

I hate this and gave it done to me often. Bins go at the end of a lane and if I haven't bought it in by the end of the day there are bags of shit in there. My bin has to sit near my back door so the stench in the summer is vile especially after 2 weeks Angry

LakieLady · 18/11/2021 07:21

If I lived somewhere where the bin men take the wheelie bin to the truck and tip it up, so that it's empty, I wouldn't have a problem with it. But ours don't, they just lift the rubbish bags out of the bin, so any small stuff not in rubbish bags gets left in the bottom.

The council don't supply bins, either, so everyone buys their own, or just don't bother and leave rubbish out in bags for the foxes to play with in the night.

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 18/11/2021 03:14

Ugh no it’s not ok. And I love dogs.

RainbowMum11 · 18/11/2021 03:07

I would rather it be in a bin than hung in a tree or left at the side of the pavement.

sjxoxo · 18/11/2021 02:54

My husband does this and It mortifies me!! He doesn’t at all think it’s unreasonable. I might show him this thread 🙂

ButterfliesAndDaffodils · 18/11/2021 00:48

I actually can't believe that anyone thinks this is acceptable. Or that the only options are 'sling your dog's shit in a stranger's bin, or leave it on the street'. There are other options, you know. I wonder if the 'it's only dog poo, in a bin' posters would be quite so understanding if I emptied my cats litter tray into a refuse sack and popped it in their bin.

I don't have dogs. I do however, regularly walk my sister's lovely pooch. I plan a route that has dog bins, or carry the bags (and he's a big dog, with big poops) with me until I get back to her house. That's what I sign up for when I walk him, and that's what dog owners sign up for when they get a dog.

Djifunrsn · 18/11/2021 00:18

My bin was emptied today. I would be furious if some lazy sod put their dog shit in it - it would be right at the bottom and then when I put my bin bag in, it would squash the shit, leaving smears over the bottom of the bin. Also, we are on a once a fortnight collection, shortly moving to once every 3 weeks. So no, don't do it - shit sitting in the bin for that length of time is going to smell like hell. I have a dog and I don't put his shit in there. I put it in dog shit bins on walks.

KosherDill · 18/11/2021 00:14

@Childrenofthestones

A totally selfish act and Id hit the roof if I caught somebody putting their dog shit on our bin. Take it home and put it in your own bin as I do. There is a bin next to the local bus stop and lots lazy bastards put their dog shit in it all the time as they walk past rather than take it home. It only gets emptied once a week and in the summer if you are waiting for the bus the stench of shit is overpowering.
Some arsehole put his dog waste in my bin minutes after bin was emptied in the hottest week last summer. Knowing it would fester for a week.

I followed videoing with my phone till he came back and fished it out; otherwise as I told him that vid was going viral. He found another walking route after that.

KosherDill · 18/11/2021 00:12

It is not acceptable. Carry it home.

Magilix · 18/11/2021 00:11

YANBU. That is absolutely revolting. I have a dog but don't put her poo in our bin. I definitely don't want anyone else's in it.

Childrenofthestones · 17/11/2021 23:37

A totally selfish act and Id hit the roof if I caught somebody putting their dog shit on our bin. Take it home and put it in your own bin as I do.
There is a bin next to the local bus stop and lots lazy bastards put their dog shit in it all the time as they walk past rather than take it home.
It only gets emptied once a week and in the summer if you are waiting for the bus the stench of shit is overpowering.