Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my DCs' primary school would stop putting on Newsround every day?

188 replies

minkfondant · 16/11/2021 18:20

Every class at my DCs' school seems to watch Newsround on a daily basis. Today my 8yo came home excitedly saying "A taxi blew up! It was so cool."

On previous occasions, they've come home telling me about things like George Floyd's murder including graphic details of how he was killed and North Korea possibly having nuclear weapons. 10yo asked if I think we'll have WW3 caused by North Korea.

We deliberately avoid watching news with them around, because so much of it is alarming for people who haven't yet got adult perspective on things. News TV is deliberately curated to make it as arresting and attention-grabbing as possible, and obviously concentrates more on the bad stuff than anything else.

Can't they just have a childhood before they're confronted with the dark sides of human nature?

AIBU to wish the school would leave Newsround out of the lesson plans?

OP posts:
Grida · 16/11/2021 21:36

@rrhuth how would you teach current affairs in a better way? Bearing in mind the people who make newsround spend their working day researching and producing their content so that it is interesting and appropriate for primary age children. It takes up 7-8mins of class time. Planning and preparation has to take less time than the actual teaching otherwise teachers wouldn’t have time to be in the classroom. I don’t think I could do it better than Newsround.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:34

I don't know about in other schools but we have it on at snack time.

My view is that having background TV news instead of just space to chat to your friends is a step backwards for kids.

Bellfor · 16/11/2021 21:32

[quote rrhuth]@Bellfor How long is the discussion afterwards - I missed that.

I was understanding thsi was going on instead of a teacher-led lesson. Because to watch Newsround is quite a chunk each day, do they have time for that + discussion every day?[/quote]

I actually eye rolled. I think I might need a deep sigh too.

How on earth would I know how long the discussion is? Newsround is not 'quite a chunk' of time, its a few minutes at the end of the day. I would find it impossible not to discuss after watching, the very nature of the program prompts discussion. Some schools actually value the educating of children as well rounded individuals rather than churning out arithmetic and script writing robots.

(FYI, I teach ks1 so no, I don't use newsround. It's not age appropriate for my class. But we do discuss news stories as and when)

Hodgehog · 16/11/2021 21:32

Even on things that are upsetting - life is sometimes upsetting and learning to deal with that is a vital part of growing up.

I do not think it is beneficial to children to be shielded from reality in that way so YABU.

OrangeSamphire · 16/11/2021 21:32

I think Newsround is ok although would expect the teachers to encourage discussion and guide the children in their interpretation of what they are being shown.

In my experience schools aren’t always great at doing that, especially for neurodivergent kids who may take things literally, eg climate change, where the narrative in schools was frankly terrifying for my autistic daughter and it left her feeling quite scared for the future and distrustful of adults. (Since she is now homeschooled we’ve worked through this)

fourminutestosavetheworld · 16/11/2021 21:30

I watch it with my class most days. They tackle stories that are potentially upsetting in a very sensitive way, focus on the positive and always have at least one good news story. I like it. If your ds thinks a man on fire in a taxi is cool then Newsround is the least of your worries tbh - saw that story, definitely wasn't presented as cool.

ShaneTheThird · 16/11/2021 21:25

Newsround doesn't need to be vetted by a teacher first it's literally designed for children in an age appropriate way. As pp said teachers then discuss the events after watching and sometimes work is done based off stories. I used to be a ta and loved newsround discussions. Children are a lot more astute than people seem to think they are.

Cuwins · 16/11/2021 21:24

[quote ADreadedSunnyDay]@Tilltheend99
I have no problem kids learning about current affairs but private schools do this in a more structured way through projects etc not by sticking on newsround. My other problem is that the school day is so limited anyway this is time away from core literacy and numeracy skills. over a third of kids in DS class are needing extra support with reading and i would much prefer all the kids got more supported time than watched newsround.[/quote]
I don't know about in other schools but we have it on at snack time. So it's not instead of anything. The show lasts 8mins so hardly a massive chunk of time

nitsandwormsdodger · 16/11/2021 21:23

They will hear about in the playground but maybe in inaccurate or inappropriate way

He wasn’t traumatised at all so what’s your issue exactly?

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:22

@Bellfor How long is the discussion afterwards - I missed that.

I was understanding thsi was going on instead of a teacher-led lesson. Because to watch Newsround is quite a chunk each day, do they have time for that + discussion every day?

AntiMaskersAreTwats · 16/11/2021 21:21

My children came home and asked me about the Liverpool bomb today. They are 9 and 7. We talked about it for about an hour, covering topics such as mental health, bravery, religious extremism and terrorism. My 2 could hold their own in any conversation about current affairs from the troubles in Ireland to the Holocaust to whether we should always trust the government. They aren’t quivering wrecks. They are kind and full of empathy, always looking at both sides of the story. I’m proud of that.

Cam77 · 16/11/2021 21:17

A big part of what’s wrong with the modern world is we’re obsessed with Big Stuff that’s happening 1000s of miles away and which the vast majority of us have virtually zero understanding of the complexities and context: Israel/Palestine, gun crime in the US, the war on drugs, the rise of China, poverty in Africa, etc etc. Aside from a shake of the head and a “how terrible” this stuff is meaningless to 90% of adults and 10x meaningless to children. We need people to start thinking locally and understanding and connecting with issues in our own towns and country first. That’s what primary school should be for - not worrying about North Korean nukes, global meltdown and the middle east.

Bellfor · 16/11/2021 21:13

@rrhuth

Of course kids should learn about the world and deal with upsetting things - but just putting on the Newsround every day is not, IMO, good practice and it is not teaching.

But the discussion afterwards is.

ADreadedSunnyDay · 16/11/2021 21:09

@Tilltheend99
I have no problem kids learning about current affairs but private schools do this in a more structured way through projects etc not by sticking on newsround. My other problem is that the school day is so limited anyway this is time away from core literacy and numeracy skills. over a third of kids in DS class are needing extra support with reading and i would much prefer all the kids got more supported time than watched newsround.

moita · 16/11/2021 21:05

I loved Newsround as a youngster.

Kids are living in war zones and under other appalling conditions. Let's educate our privileged children in an age apporiate way

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:03

Of course kids should learn about the world and deal with upsetting things - but just putting on the Newsround every day is not, IMO, good practice and it is not teaching.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:02

@ShaneTheThird

The difference is that teachers plan the history lessons, so they prep the materials.

If they are putting on Newsround without pre-viewing, that is poor practice.

If they are putting it on after pre-viewing, it may be OK - but I doubt they are.

ShaneTheThird · 16/11/2021 21:00

@rrhuth

I have no problem with Newsround itself, it is aimed at children, but in a school it is problematic to show things that could set off a bad response in a child, and you never know which thing would set off which child.

So I am surprised by it being shown daily and think it is a poor approach by the school.

If you are unhappy - make your views known to the Head in a calm way. They may or may not take your views on board.

This is ridiculous. So should schools avoid teaching history as some kids might get upset? Should they avoid geography because there's a lot of upsetting facts about nature? Or English as some books even aimed at children can be upsetting?

Children need to know what's happening in the world. It's best they get taught it early on rather than giving them a fantasy view of the world and they then grow up and find out actually the world is a scary and dangerous place.

BoredZelda · 16/11/2021 21:00

Yes, yes they should. They should sit in silence.

😆😆😆

MrsSkylerWhite · 16/11/2021 20:46

SpinsForGin

I think it's fabulous that schools do this. It's great to get young people interested in current affairs.“

This.

2389Champ · 16/11/2021 20:45

Interesting post.

My friend’s 9 YO is currently suffering from acute anxiety about climate change. She is struggling to sleep at night, convinced the world is about to die and take all her family with it, and has become obsessed with all things related to global warming. No previous behavioural issues; this has come on in the last six months.

Cam77 · 16/11/2021 20:43

Wouldn’t be too happy with my child being subjected to BBC worldview/propaganda on a daily basis.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 20:43

Should schools avoid nursery rhymes?

Oh

Yes, yes they should. They should sit in silence.

Saracen · 16/11/2021 20:40

Have you seen Newsround, OP?

My eldest was very sensitive and we avoided TV news as it tended to be traumatic. I understand where you are coming from there. Some kids can handle it much younger than others.

However, even my sensitive kid was okay with Newsround from about the age of six. Newsround was about the only form of news which they could handle. It was really well done and I would recommend it.

BoredZelda · 16/11/2021 20:38

I have no problem with Newsround itself, it is aimed at children, but in a school it is problematic to show things that could set off a bad response in a child, and you never know which thing would set off which child.

But that is true of everything they do in schools. The best course of action is to be aware it could be a problem and manage any consequence.

In primary one my daughter was terrified of a specific nursery rhyme character. Had been for a couple of years. They did an exercise on it in class and she had a total meltdown. Her teacher apologised and said they were finishing it off the next day but they would find a fun reason to take her out of class whilst it was happening. Should schools avoid nursery rhymes?